Are antioxidants woo?

Zygar

Master Poster
Joined
Oct 3, 2006
Messages
2,606
Yes.

At least according to the Cochrane Collaboration.
No evidence to support antioxidant supplements to prevent mortality in healthy people or patients with various diseases

And according to The American Heart Association.

With regard to the meta-analysis, the lack of efficacy was demonstrated consistently for different doses of various antioxidants in diverse population groups.

And most recently, according to the WAFACS study.

The findings cast further doubt on the role of folic acid and B vitamins in preventing cardiovascular events, despite their effect on homocysteine lowering...

So, why are we focusing all our energy on homeopaths? Why aren't we going after Pom, Emergen-C, and all the other "health drinks" which cost a fortune and do nothing?

Just curious.
 
Good point. I think one reason woo does so well is that mainstream medicine can be really confusing.

Everyone seems to be taking fish oil tablets. Trust me, smell their breathe. Is it really good or not? Let's say that's a LOT of money to take the 3-5 per day.
 
Anti-oxidants work wonders for me.
Especially vitmain B complex.

Since I increased my intake of salt, and cut out suger and wheat almost
completely I have needed less vitamin B,
but if i do not take it, I am lethargic, and a whole other array of
promblems arise, like impaired concentration, mouth ulcers,
and anxiety.

When I give in to my cravings for chelsea buns, I have to increase
my vitamin B intake, or I get bad headaches the following day.

I did drink too much booze in my youth though, which, I guess,
is why I am in this position now.
 
Anti-oxidants work wonders for me.
Especially vitmain B complex.

Since I increased my intake of salt, and cut out suger and wheat almost
completely I have needed less vitamin B,
but if i do not take it, I am lethargic, and a whole other array of
promblems arise, like impaired concentration, mouth ulcers,
and anxiety.

When I give in to my cravings for chelsea buns, I have to increase
my vitamin B intake, or I get bad headaches the following day.

I did drink too much booze in my youth though, which, I guess,
is why I am in this position now.

If you have a vitamin deficiency, sure, it makes sense to take them. And it sounds like what you actually have is an electrolyte deficiency. You could probably do just as well drinking gatorade.
 
So, why are we focusing all our energy on homeopaths? Why aren't we going after Pom, Emergen-C, and all the other "health drinks" which cost a fortune and do nothing?

Just curious.

I think to some extent, where the focus goes depends on how bad the harm is. For example, a homeopath who diverts patients from effective treatment is a bigger harm than a pointless, overpriced fruit drink that wastes money. Pom and similar products by and large aren't sold with claims that would divert people from other treatments. For example, all the Emergen-C ads that I've seen tout it as a prevention for colds. While this could in theory inspire someone to take more risks in exposing themself to sick individuals, it's not nearly as problematic as a person going to a homeopath in preference to a real doctor to care for, say, hypertension. In one case, you've wasted money and maybe picked up an unnecessary cold; in the other case, you may die.

So, it's entirely reasonable to sic the FTC or FCC (as appropriate) on exaggerated claims for preventive health benefits from these products, but if you have to prioritize, those false claims that might out-and-out kill people have to come first.
 
Hmm, I too have wondered this. It's a very dubious claim that appeals to the vanity of people, slowing the aging process. Antioxidants certainly do work regarding mediating certain types of drug induced neurotoxicity though.

Capela JP, Macedo C, Branco PS, Ferreira LM, Lobo AM, Fernandes E, Remião F, Bastos ML, Dirnagl U, Meisel A, Carvalho F.

REQUIMTE (Rede de Química e Tecnologia), Toxicology Department, Faculty of Pharmacy, University of Porto, Rua Aníbal Cunha, 164, 4099-030 Porto, Portugal. [email protected]

3,4-Methylenedioxymethamphetamine (MDMA or "ecstasy"), is a widely abused, psychoactive recreational drug that is known to induce neurotoxic effects. Human and rat hepatic metabolism of MDMA involves N-demethylation to 3,4-methylenedioxyamphetamine (MDA), which is also a drug of abuse. MDMA and MDA are O-demethylenated to N-methyl-alpha-methyldopamine (N-Me-alpha-MeDA) and alpha-methyldopamine (alpha-MeDA), respectively, which are both catechols that can undergo oxidation to the corresponding ortho-quinones. Ortho-quinones may be conjugated with glutathione (GSH) to form glutathionyl adducts, which can be transported into the brain and metabolized to the correspondent N-acetylcysteine (NAC) adducts. In this study we evaluated the neurotoxicity of nine MDMA metabolites, obtained by synthesis: N-Me-alpha-MeDA, alpha-MeDA and their correspondent GSH and NAC adducts. The studies were conducted in rat cortical neuronal cultures, for a 6 h of exposure period, under normal (36.5 degrees C) and hyperthermic (40 degrees C) conditions. Our findings show that thioether MDMA metabolites are strong neurotoxins, significantly more than their correspondent parent catechols. On the other hand, N-Me-alpha-MeDA and alpha-MeDA are more neurotoxic than MDMA. GSH and NAC conjugates of N-Me-alpha-MeDA and alpha-MeDA induced a concentration dependent delayed neuronal death, accompanied by activation of caspase 3, which occurred earlier in hyperthermic conditions. Furthermore, thioether MDMA metabolites time-dependently increased the production of reactive species, concentration-dependently depleted intracellular GSH and increased protein bound quinones. Finally, thioether MDMA metabolites induced neuronal death and oxidative stress was prevented by NAC, an antioxidant and GSH precursor. This study provides new insights into the neurotoxicity mechanisms of thioether MDMA metabolites and highlights their importance in "ecstasy" neurotoxicity.
 
Hmm, I too have wondered this. It's a very dubious claim that appeals to the vanity of people, slowing the aging process. Antioxidants certainly do work regarding mediating certain types of drug induced neurotoxicity though.

This is a problem with many nutritional health products. A cell culture study does not equate with anti-oxidants are good (or bad) for you. Cell studies are useful in pointing to future treatments but are a long way down the research timeline from showing that a product is useful in treatment.
 
This is a problem with many nutritional health products. A cell culture study does not equate with anti-oxidants are good (or bad) for you. Cell studies are useful in pointing to future treatments but are a long way down the research timeline from showing that a product is useful in treatment.

Is there a specific problem in the cell culture methodology that means it cannot be extrapolated to human models?

I know that depending on the tissue metabolite profiles can match the patterns of in vivo studies, but it is limited to qualitative aspects, which I guess reflects your comment about pointing towards future treatments. Metabolism may also differ depending on concentrations used, for example diazepam in excess undergoes 3-hydroxylation instead of N-demethylation as the major metabolic pathway. I guess where pharmacokinetics is concerned, they cannot really say anything.

Thanks for the reply.
 
Is there a specific problem in the cell culture methodology that means it cannot be extrapolated to human models?

<snip>

Yes. The human body is a much more complicated system than any cell culture. Many similar molecules are used in different ways and by different systems. A drug which has the desired effect on cells in a cell culture may do something undesirable in other types of cells in a human.
 
Is there a specific problem in the cell culture methodology that means it cannot be extrapolated to human models?

It often doesn't work. See high dose vitamin C studies to see if it reduced the risk of cancer, the studies were halted as the test group had much higher cancer rates.
 
Is there a specific problem in the cell culture methodology that means it cannot be extrapolated to human models?

I suppose the trite answer is that they are too specific, looking at only a specific cell, under highly unnatural conditions ie in the absence of other cells which may have a controlling effect.
 
What bothers me about these arguments on this website is the background faith in legitimate medical intervention. I don't like woo. really, i don't.

it is often mentioned that some people that eschew legit medical treatment for homeopathy and such waste their money for no benifit; sometimes dying from their stupidity.

What is often ignored is the amount of money and time and pain that people go through in their effort toward legitimate medical treatment. It often fails. Sometimes, catastrophicly. I wish we could address this stuff with some true statistics.

For every child that dies because their parents were a-hole Christian Scientists, or homeopaths, how many die because of crappy hospitals, lousy surgeons, and the poverty that often comes with doing the right thing?

Its like a speck in the eye, all this woo.
meanwhile, there's a log in our collective eye regarding our faith in modern medicine.

Any one here ever have a bad experience with modern medical treatment?
Know anyone that did?

Can we hear from you, please?
 
Any one here ever have a bad experience with modern medical treatment?
Know anyone that did?

Can we hear from you, please?

Sure. I was misdiagnosed once as having strep. I was still rather ill after a week of antibiotics, returned to the hospital, and a different doctor said, "Well, if you're still sick like this after a week of drugs, it's either antibiotic-resistant strep, and I hope it's not, or it's mono. Let's do some cultures for mono, and give you an injection of strong antibiotics in case it's the strep."

Turns out, mono. First doctor got the diagnosis wrong, and I spent a week feeling even ickier than I needed to because the initial strep antibiotics were quite strong.

That said, I have also been successfully treated for bronchitis, shoulder injury, neck injury, all manner of childhood illnesses and so forth. Of course there's an error rate. The guys at the auto shop missed a problem with my car's engine once, too. The point is that homeopathy and similar magical thinking NEVER WORKS.* Medicine, like auto repair, sometimes gets it wrong. Sometimes it gets it badly wrong -- my friend's car went in for service once, and the mechanic didn't properly reattach her fuel line. She smelled gas while driving away, turned around and drove back, and he said, "I'm glad you came back. That could have exploded."

Does that mean she goes to a shaman to pour magic water on her car from now on? No. It just means that even processes and methods that work have a finite failure rate. We try to keep it as low as possible, but it happens. Why trade in a small chance of failure for certain failure?


*And per my earlier post, we focus on things like homoepathy over stuff like antioxidant fruit drinks because people are more likely to forgo their working treatments to use homoepathy, whereas they just tend to blow money on health drinks.
 
Last edited:
Good point. I think one reason woo does so well is that mainstream medicine can be really confusing.

Everyone seems to be taking fish oil tablets. Trust me, smell their breathe. Is it really good or not? Let's say that's a LOT of money to take the 3-5 per day.

I'll say this- I am north of 350lbs but my cholesterol is normal. Of course, on the other hand I rarely eat fried foods. Make of that what you will.
 
I'll say this- I am north of 350lbs but my cholesterol is normal. Of course, on the other hand I rarely eat fried foods. Make of that what you will.

How high your cholesterol is depends in part on genetics. My dad and I have really, really low cholesterol (mine was once measured at 35 total) and my mom and brother both have high total cholesterol. My mom is overweight but my brother is not.
 
How high your cholesterol is depends in part on genetics. My dad and I have really, really low cholesterol (mine was once measured at 35 total) and my mom and brother both have high total cholesterol. My mom is overweight but my brother is not.

My father and all his brothers are all overweight to obese, one has died from heart disease, as has their mother, and all the surviving ones are or have been treated for high cholesterol.

Obesity is far less common on my mother's side, but high colesterol is rampant there too- it specifically killed my small and slender maternal grandmother. Otherwise that side mostly gets cancer.
 
What bothers me about these arguments on this website is the background faith in legitimate medical intervention. I don't like woo. really, i don't.

it is often mentioned that some people that eschew legit medical treatment for homeopathy and such waste their money for no benifit; sometimes dying from their stupidity.

What is often ignored is the amount of money and time and pain that people go through in their effort toward legitimate medical treatment. It often fails. Sometimes, catastrophicly. I wish we could address this stuff with some true statistics.
OK give us some. At the moment, antioxidant success rate is zero, treatment with any old thing has a toxicity ranging from zero to greater than zero. What do you estimate the cure rate over the death rate to be? Please give precise figures.
For every child that dies because their parents were a-hole Christian Scientists, or homeopaths, how many die because of crappy hospitals, lousy surgeons, and the poverty that often comes with doing the right thing?

Its like a speck in the eye, all this woo.
meanwhile, there's a log in our collective eye regarding our faith in modern medicine.

Any one here ever have a bad experience with modern medical treatment?
Know anyone that did?

Can we hear from you, please?

And how many who would have died are now still alive?

Medicine in the end is a cost benefit system. Talking about one end or the other is counter-productive. When you produce the figures asked for you just might have something to discuss.
 
What is often ignored is the amount of money and time and pain that people go through in their effort toward legitimate medical treatment. It often fails. Sometimes, catastrophicly. I wish we could address this stuff with some true statistics.

For every child that dies because their parents were a-hole Christian Scientists, or homeopaths, how many die because of crappy hospitals, lousy surgeons, and the poverty that often comes with doing the right thing?

Its like a speck in the eye, all this woo.
meanwhile, there's a log in our collective eye regarding our faith in modern medicine.
I had always assumed that was why we had medical trials. Presumably almost any write up of a decent trial would tell you how many were helped and how many hurt. If you want a cost/benifit for conventional medicine as a whole, then I should think that would be quite a bit of work.
 
What bothers me about these arguments on this website is the background faith in legitimate medical intervention. I don't like woo. really, i don't.

it is often mentioned that some people that eschew legit medical treatment for homeopathy and such waste their money for no benifit; sometimes dying from their stupidity.

What is often ignored is the amount of money and time and pain that people go through in their effort toward legitimate medical treatment. It often fails. Sometimes, catastrophicly. I wish we could address this stuff with some true statistics.

For every child that dies because their parents were a-hole Christian Scientists, or homeopaths, how many die because of crappy hospitals, lousy surgeons, and the poverty that often comes with doing the right thing?

Its like a speck in the eye, all this woo.
meanwhile, there's a log in our collective eye regarding our faith in modern medicine.

Any one here ever have a bad experience with modern medical treatment?
Know anyone that did?

Can we hear from you, please?

It seems to me that lousy surgeons and crappy hospitals fall into the same category as woo - they all represent a lack of standard medical care. I think it would be more relevant to compare standard medical care with a lack of standard medical care when it comes to assessing our faith in modern medical treatment. What standard is the physician held to vs. that of the woo? Although I do agree that the extent to which physicians are able to achieve that standard is also relevant.

Linda
 
It seems to me that lousy surgeons and crappy hospitals fall into the same category as woo - they all represent a lack of standard medical care.

Depends. In some cases it is simply reaching human limits. Doctors can only be so good. In other cases there are more systematic problems (say surgons in small units trying to complex operations themselves rather than refuring cases to larger units whith better facilities and more experence) which can be identified and fixed. And real medicine does it's best to do this.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom