Are antioxidants woo?

This is similar to the idea that the ends justify the means. What's the danger of making false claims about antioxidants if they get people to eat more fruits and vegetables?

The problem is that you get people claiming to have pills and tonics with "pure" antioxidants in them and marketing them as alternatives to fruits/vegetables/medicine/excercise/etc. Or you get other forms of spinoffs and hybrids that, at best, waste people's money and, at worst, convince them to forgoe effective activities and cures.
I agree that the worst case scenario you've described is bad. However, the majority of things I see labelled with "anti-oxidants" are things that do actualy contain a great deal of nutritional value.

Don't get me wrong. I'm not saying that its GOOD to trick people like that. I'm just saying that its slightly less bad, at this point in time, than homeopathy is.
 
this is a failure of politics though not medicine.

True. But it does explain why some people might turn to woo in desperation.
Toss the placebo effect in there, as well as lying scam artists that use clever adds to lure the very group I speak of, and bogus treatment is more understandable.

Again, I'm not promoting the woo...just trying to understand its hold on people.
 
Richard Dawkins did a television programme investigating what the appeal of alternative medicine/spiritual healing was, called "The Enemies of Reason". He concluded that much of its appeal was the approach of many alternative medicine practitioners/spiritual healers, who would take time to soothe patients and make them feel pampered and cared for, thus de-stressing them.
 
Must... resist... posting in YET ANOTHER anti-antioxidant thread....

Damn, I failed again.

Why, oh why dear JESUS LORD OF THE HEAVENS everyone has to judge the efficacy of the anti-oxidants by whether they reduce mortality ? And why are ALL antioxidants grouped together as if they were not completely different substances with a multitude of properties ?

There is this great site which until recently was kept secret by Buddhist monks but recently they have decided to share it with the Western World: www.pubmed.com People can go there and search for specific antioxidants and see which claims are substantiated and which are not.

Sorry I lapsed again.
 
Like I said, show me a DBRCT for "antioxidant X" that shows it provides ANY HEALTH BENEFIT over an identical tasting/smelling placebo, and I'll pay attention.

I can make 10-15% of the population feel better by giving them a teaspoon of water, and lie to them that it contains Dr DUFUS AMAZING ELIXIR...Called the placebo effect.

TAM:)
 
Richard Dawkins did a television programme investigating what the appeal of alternative medicine/spiritual healing was, called "The Enemies of Reason". He concluded that much of its appeal was the approach of many alternative medicine practitioners/spiritual healers, who would take time to soothe patients and make them feel pampered and cared for, thus de-stressing them.

I think the allure is that it's easier, cheaper and less invasive than your typical, institutional, sterile hospital. Who wouldn't rather spend some meditating and drinking green tea instead of going to a hospital and receiving surgery (if the mediation and green tea actually worked)?
 
Must... resist... posting in YET ANOTHER anti-antioxidant thread....

Damn, I failed again.

Why, oh why dear JESUS LORD OF THE HEAVENS everyone has to judge the efficacy of the anti-oxidants by whether they reduce mortality ? And why are ALL antioxidants grouped together as if they were not completely different substances with a multitude of properties ?

Because we are referring to the woo practice of making recommendations on the basis of inadequate knowledge, or ideas which have already been demonstrated to likely be wrong. And this woo practice involves treating them all the same.

There is this great site which until recently was kept secret by Buddhist monks but recently they have decided to share it with the Western World: www.pubmed.com People can go there and search for specific antioxidants and see which claims are substantiated and which are not.

Sorry I lapsed again.

Which anti-oxidant do you think has had its claims substantiated? (Please note that by substantiated I mean RDBPCTs with relevant clinical outcomes (i.e. the standards used for other substantiated therapies).)

Linda
 
Last edited:
I think to some extent, where the focus goes depends on how bad the harm is. For example, a homeopath who diverts patients from effective treatment is a bigger harm than a pointless, overpriced fruit drink that wastes money.

And besides, Pom is yummy, although there are much cheaper pomegranate juices available.
 
Like I said, show me a DBRCT for "antioxidant X" that shows it provides ANY HEALTH BENEFIT over an identical tasting/smelling placebo, and I'll pay attention.

I can make 10-15% of the population feel better by giving them a teaspoon of water, and lie to them that it contains Dr DUFUS AMAZING ELIXIR...Called the placebo effect.

TAM:)

If you can make 10% of the population feel better, shouldn't you do that?
Or, shouldn't it be understandable that some people would feel justified in doing that?

As far as I know, woo is rarely forced down someone's throat.
The same people that are inclined to bite the woo-bait are the same group that have the best chance of getting the bogus/not so bogus buzz from their twisted belief system.

But, as I've mentioned, there are a lot of people for whom 'alternative' medicine is the only alternative...they simply can't afford the 'good' stuff.

If we ever manage to come up with a global health care system, the woo will fall off, like dead leaves in autumn.
 
Quarky said:
If we ever manage to come up with a global health care system, the woo will fall off, like dead leaves in autumn.

I suspect so - I think it's desperation that drives a lot of this belief in faith healing and this search for alternative cures. People are attracted to such things to some extent because they haven't received satisfaction from conventional medicine, whether that be because the medical advances that could really help them just haven't been made yet, whether they can't afford them or whatever.

A global healthcare system could be a fantastic step forward, or at least improvements in healthcare throughout the world. One example of this is that in the third world, a lot of people blame disease and other misfortune on witchcraft, thinking someone must have cursed them, because they don't realise proper medical care is the solution to their problems. It causes a climate of fear. See a post I wrote in another thread. This would all change if they had adequate healthcare.
 
If you can make 10% of the population feel better, shouldn't you do that?
Or, shouldn't it be understandable that some people would feel justified in doing that?

As far as I know, woo is rarely forced down someone's throat.
The same people that are inclined to bite the woo-bait are the same group that have the best chance of getting the bogus/not so bogus buzz from their twisted belief system.

But, as I've mentioned, there are a lot of people for whom 'alternative' medicine is the only alternative...they simply can't afford the 'good' stuff.

If we ever manage to come up with a global health care system, the woo will fall off, like dead leaves in autumn.

1. Sure, as long as you are not lying to people in order to steal, I mean take their money from them, then yes you should provide such things/services to people. If that is the case, boy have I got some super snake oil to sell you. Only $50 a bottle.

2. We have such a health care system up here...free for all. Woo alternative medicine is a THRIVING business up here, so your theory does not hold true.

3. I have always said, about alternative medicines, (A) if you have the excess cash to afford it, (B) the product causes no harm, and (C) avoiding traditional therapies will not put you at risk, then go ahead, try it. The problem is with those for whom A,B,C do not hold true, but who are still swindled by the snake oil salesmen.

TAM:)
 
TAM said:
2. We have such a health care system up here...free for all. Woo alternative medicine is a THRIVING business up here, so your theory does not hold true.

But do you still have a problem with long waiting lists?

Also, disillusionment because of former bad experiences might play a role, and also dissatisfaction with conventional medicine that isn't curing them. For instance, I know of several people who've been in chronic pain for years that doctors can't seem to help them get rid of.

Maybe if systems improve still further, things will change. But then, I don't suppose it'll get anywhere near eliminating the problem, because there are probably lots of reasons people are attracted to alternative medicine.
 
Tam,

You are likely correct. I'm surprised that woo is as strong in Canada as the U.S.
Do you know of any measurements for this?
 
quarky:

Yes,

1. Regulation. Official standards for the chemical "soups" these people peddle.
2. Scientific evidence to prove their claims are valid, prior to market placement.

TAM:)
 
But do you still have a problem with long waiting lists?

Also, disillusionment because of former bad experiences might play a role, and also dissatisfaction with conventional medicine that isn't curing them. For instance, I know of several people who've been in chronic pain for years that doctors can't seem to help them get rid of.

Maybe if systems improve still further, things will change. But then, I don't suppose it'll get anywhere near eliminating the problem, because there are probably lots of reasons people are attracted to alternative medicine.

1. Yes we still have longer waiting lists, but at least your income level does not determine your placement on that list.

2. I agree that for some it is disillusionment with traditional medicine that makes some people seek elsewhere. Chronic pain, of all the conditions you could use, is certainly a good one, as it is a difficult one to manage, regardless of traditional or alternative.

TAM:)
 
For example, a homeopath who diverts patients from effective treatment is a bigger harm than a pointless, overpriced fruit drink that wastes money.

Is this woo too?

How often does this happen?

Homeopaths that I've met say many of their patients come to them in despair after years of ineffective mainstream medical treatment.
 
Last edited:
quarky:

Yes,

1. Regulation. Official standards for the chemical "soups" these people peddle.
2. Scientific evidence to prove their claims are valid, prior to market placement.

TAM:)

I thought Quarky meant statistics to prove alternative medicine is as popular in Canada as it is in the US.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom