Are 4 to 4.5 hour office fire simulations valid?

There was no lie. Three firefighters died in the fire and that may have been a factor in the evacuation. The evacuation of OMP is not comparable to the evacuations of WTC 7. What about the One Meridian Plaza fire relates to computer fire simulations?

You didn't say "may have been a factor" in your original lie. You said:

The engineer at One Meridian Plaza there never stated for a fact that the building was going to collapse, nor did they give any estimate for when to expect a collapse. They only pulled back after three firefighters died and the fire had lasted all day.

This is simply false based on the very report I linked. You made it up. They evacuated 5 hours after the fire fighters who died had been recovered. You lied in a blatant attempt to minimize the structural engineering reason for the evacuation five hours later, which, again, was as follows:

Consultation with a structural engineer and structural damage observed by units operating in the building led to the belief that there was a possibility of a pancake structural collapse of the fire damaged floors.

And if you cannot understand how the well-documented occurrence of a 15 hour office fire shows that a 4.5 hour office fire is not impossible
Edited by Agatha: 
Removed breach of rule 0 and rule 12
 
Last edited by a moderator:
skyeagle, the creaking and the "structural buckling" (small, insignificant perimeter deformation, bulge) can NOT account for collapse initiating via thermal expansion.


Of course it could have because structural buckling and the creaking noises are clear indications the building is about to collapse. The steel structure was redistributing structural loads as uncontrolled fires continue to weaken the structure over time.

the Steel-weakening fires, like One Meridian Plaza, usually just result in parts of the structure slowly and gradually warping (i.e. not a sudden collapse).

You have to understand that particular builidng did not sustained massive inpact damage on the level of WTC 7.
 
You didn't say "may have been a factor" in your original lie. You said:

This is simply false based on the very report I linked. You made it up. They evacuated 5 hours after the fire fighters who died had been recovered. You lied in a blatant attempt to minimize the structural engineering reason for the evacuation five hours later, which, again, was as follows:

Sorry if you interpret my words stupidly. I already knew about the engineer making their judgement on OMP based on danger of collapse.

And if you cannot understand how the well-documented occurrence of a 15 hour office fire shows that a 4.5 hour office fire is not impossible
Edited by Agatha: 
Removed moderated content

Edited by Agatha: 
Removed breach of rule 11
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Of course it could have because structural buckling and the creaking noises are clear indications the building is about to collapse. The steel structure was redistributing structural loads as uncontrolled fires continue to weaken the structure over time.

Only for as long as steel-weakening temperatures can be achieved from a nearby fire. Please explain what this has to do with a random girder failing from low-heat thermal expansion.

You have to understand that particular builidng did not sustained massive inpact damage on the level of WTC 7.

What are you talking about? A few perimeter columns being destroyed is like nothing to a building like that.
 
Only for as long as steel-weakening temperatures can be achieved from a nearby fire. Please explain what this has to do with a random girder failing from low-heat thermal expansion.

Well, let's take a look at what fire can do to steel beams.


Fire Weakens Steel Photo 1

http://i662.photobucket.com/albums/uu347/911conspiracytv/horseshoe_steel.jpg

Fire Weakens Steel Photo 2

http://www.beachymon.com/photo/woodsteelfire.jpg


In case you missed it before.


Kader Toy Factory Fire


At about 4pm on May 10th, 1993, a small fire was discovered on the first floor of part of the E-shaped building. Workers were instructed to keep working as the fire was thought to be minor. The fire alarm in this building did not sound.

The building was reinforced with un-insulated steel girders which quickly weakened and collapsed.

The Kader buildings,...collapsed relatively early in the fire because their structural steel supports lacked the fireproofing that would have allowed them to maintain their strength when exposed to high temperatures. A post-fire review of the debris at the Kader site showed no indication that any of the steel members had been fireproofed.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kader_Toy_Factory_fire
 
One Meridian Plaza is the closest thing you can compare to WTC 7's curious foreknowledge? The engineer at One Meridian Plaza there never stated for a fact that the building was going to collapse, nor did they give any estimate for when to expect a collapse. They only pulled back after three firefighters died and the fire had lasted all day. The building did not collapse.

And the steel did not ...

onemeridiansag.jpg

Three feet of sagging? Which engineer, do you have his name? One Meridian Plaza, the steel sagged how far?

Was One Meridian Plaza used again? No.

Fire totals buildings, and One Meridian Plaza was fought, WTC7 fires, not fought; big difference.

Did One Meridian Plaza suffer damage from expansion due to fire? Yes...

Got some evidence yet? It has been nearly 15 years and you don't have anything but talk.

9/11 truth in action...
standup.jpg
 
Last edited:
Last edited by a moderator:
Edited by jsfisher: 
<snip> Moderated content redacted.
You live in a fantasy world of BS. As predicted, instead of discussing evidence (you don't have), you have talk, zero facts, zero evidence, and no clue how fire did it.

You are a 9/11 truth no evidence expert, you believe what you google from liars in 9/11 truth. Zero evidence, no clue how fire did it. No useful knowledge to explain why you can't find evidence for your CD fantasy.

Where do 9/11 truth believers get silent explosives from? A fantasy explosives store. Got an address for those misfiring dendrites? Why had Tony failed to post evidence? Where is your evidence.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I don't think the flashes from any hypothetical explosive charge need to be covered up besides the drywall.
You'be missed jaydeehess' point. If you can see flashes, it's because there's no foam covering them, therefore they should not be silent. If they are still silent despite not having foam then the flashes can't be explosions.

Here's his question again for reference:
Riddle me this: if bright flashes are explosives AND the sound of explosives is dampened by foam and sheet metal, then how in the hell do we see bright flashes AND not hear them?


The point is that technology exists to turn an explosion which sounds like a bolt of lightning into something that sounds more like a rumbling echo.
No, the point is that there's no proof it was used. The technology to kill someone at a distance (guns) exists, but if a guy falls dead with no bleeding (explosive noise) that doesn't make it any more likely that he was shot.

Show proof that it was actually used and you'll have something.
 
Riddle me this: if bright flashes are explosives AND the sound of explosives is dampened by foam and sheet metal, then how in the hell do we see bright flashes AND not hear them?



What about THE (afaik only one is ever mentioned) 50 ton press?
Its a chunk of metal weighing in at about 500 pounds. What about it?


ETA: perhaps I am on ignore to MJ

I don't think the flashes from any hypothetical explosive charge need to be covered up besides the drywall.

You missed jaydeehess' point. If you can see flashes, it's because there's no foam covering them, therefore they should not be silent. If they are still silent despite not having foam then the flashes can't be explosions.

.

pgimeno is correct MichJava. You either completely missed the point or deliberately ignored it.

YOU are claiming that it would be possible to dampen the sounds of these 1000+ explosives by encasing them in a foam and sheet metal dampener. However, you also claim that flashes, which I contend are moving/shattering glass reflecting sunlight, are from these supposedly FULLY ENCASED explosives.
Reconcile how one can see explosive flashes when they are masked by a meter of foam and sheet metal, OR if the explosive escapes such containment, why it cannot then be heard.
 
9/11 truth, fantasy born in ignorance, evidence is calling people sheep.

It's almost poetic that the last serious attempt by truthers to claim a scientific basis for their objections to the several fulsome, independent professional engineering investigations done of WTC 7 has now come to a close with a lone idiot claiming fire isn't real.
 
Oh oh oh Mr. Cah-teh pick me....
http://www.harborfreight.com/50-ton-hydraulic-shop-press-96188.html
[qimg]http://www.harborfreight.com/media/catalog/product/cache/1/image/9df78eab33525d08d6e5fb8d27136e95/i/m/image_11969.jpg[/qimg]
Shipping weight 722 pounds
,, and it does not have the look of something that would survive 110 storeys of office building materials crashing down on it. Its BOLTED together furgawdssak


Here's a 1 ton portable gantry crane
http://www.harborfreight.com/1-ton-Capacity-Telescoping-Gantry-Crane-69513.html
Shipping weight 470 pounds

Mich, HELLO!!! MICH JAVA! Care to acknowledge that your bugaboo about 50 ton press is meaningless?

pgimeno is correct MichJava. You either completely missed the point or deliberately ignored it.

YOU are claiming that it would be possible to dampen the sounds of these 1000+ explosives by encasing them in a foam and sheet metal dampener. However, you also claim that flashes, which I contend are moving/shattering glass reflecting sunlight, are from these supposedly FULLY ENCASED explosives.
Reconcile how one can see explosive flashes when they are masked by a meter of foam and sheet metal, OR if the explosive escapes such containment, why it cannot then be heard.
Helllloooooooo?<<snipped - guff that would get me in trouble>>
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom