Are 4 to 4.5 hour office fire simulations valid?

Let me see if we can get a response ...

How much does a 50-ton press weigh?


(I once had a 5-ton jack in the back of my car, back in the day. Dunno how that car managed to scrape along :D)

Oh oh oh Mr. Cah-teh pick me....
http://www.harborfreight.com/50-ton-hydraulic-shop-press-96188.html
image_11969.jpg

Shipping weight 722 pounds
,, and it does not have the look of something that would survive 110 storeys of office building materials crashing down on it. Its BOLTED together furgawdssak


Here's a 1 ton portable gantry crane
http://www.harborfreight.com/1-ton-Capacity-Telescoping-Gantry-Crane-69513.html
Shipping weight 470 pounds





Mich, HELLO!!! MICH JAVA! Care to acknowledge that your bugaboo about 50 ton press is meaningless?
 
Last edited:
Check out this page: http://www.aquafoam.com/BlastingExplosions.html

Using foam and a tin barrier, they softened the sound of 5 pounds of c4 going off pretty well in that video. The foam is nostalgic of the spray-on fireproofing, too.

If you had bothered to read to the bottom, you might have noticed that they used 800 cu.ft. of foam. That corresponds to a cube with 9.28 ft. edges. Do you think anyone would notice such? :crazy:
 
If you had bothered to read to the bottom, you might have noticed that they used 800 cu.ft. of foam. That corresponds to a cube with 9.28 ft. edges. Do you think anyone would notice such? :crazy:

Reading the final paragraphs it seems the max reduction was 15db per meter of foam.

That would approximately reduce an explosive sound to the level of sound from a jackhammer.
That is significant but hardly what truthers would like it to be.

Of course using more than 1 meter thick foam would work but even if one doesn't notice that 1 meter bump out in the wall that wasn't there before, I am pretty sure a 2, 3, 4 meter bump out in the wall would be noticed. :rolleyes:
 
If you had bothered to read to the bottom, you might have noticed that they used 800 cu.ft. of foam. That corresponds to a cube with 9.28 ft. edges. Do you think anyone would notice such? :crazy:

Consider 9.28 in. edges with nanofoamite.
 
I see Micah made some more idiotic claims and has now run away again. Countdown to his next appearance where he shows up and acts like his posts in this thread don't exist.
 
OK - who around here used Fortran 11 and punched cards??

;)

Me, and yes it was almost 50 years ago (1967). I think we spent a whole 2 weeks on it in General Engineering 101, which was about a week longer than it took to learn everything it could do. Best part: even though it was simple, it encompassed everything a computer can really do; more advanced languages mainly offer programming conveniences and "best practice" things like structured programming and object-oriented design. Worst part: no backspace on a card punch machine. Second worst part: dropping a deck. :)
 
Was just reading a bit more about the One Meridian Plaza fire here: https://www.usfa.fema.gov/downloads/pdf/publications/tr-049.pdf

That office fire, which was vigorously fought, lasted about 15 hours, even though it was contained in only about ten floors of the building (with firefighters staging their triage and support center at the 20th floor to fight the main blaze on the 22nd floor, and the fire damaging up to the 30th floor). Note this passage from the above-linked report:

All interior firefighting efforts were halted after almost 11 hours of uninterrupted fire in the building. Consultation with a structural engineer and structural damage observed by units operating in the building led to the belief that there was a possibility of a pancake structural collapse of the fire damaged floors.​

I guess the FDNY engineers were not the first to worry about a steel framed building collapsing from fire damage...

Anyway, unless Tony has some very specific and documented reason to believe that office fires could not persist in and around a specific area in WTC 7 for 4.5 hours, I think we can pretty much call it based on this counterexample alone that clearly they could have, even if they had been fought vigorously (which they were not).
 
Last edited:
Was just reading a bit more about the One Meridian Plaza fire here: https://www.usfa.fema.gov/downloads/pdf/publications/tr-049.pdf

That office fire, which was vigorously fought, lasted about 15 hours, even though it was contained in only about ten floors of the building (with firefighters staging their triage and support center at the 20th floor to fight the main blaze on the 22nd floor, and the fire damaging up to the 30th floor). Note this passage from the above-linked report:

All interior firefighting efforts were halted after almost 11 hours of uninterrupted fire in the building. Consultation with a structural engineer and structural damage observed by units operating in the building led to the belief that there was a possibility of a pancake structural collapse of the fire damaged floors.​

I guess the FDNY engineers were not the first to worry about a steel framed building collapsing from fire damage...

Anyway, unless Tony has some very specific and documented reason to believe that office fires could not persist in and around a specific area in WTC 7 for 4.5 hours, I think we can pretty much call it based on this counterexample alone that clearly they could have, even if they had been fought vigorously (which they were not).
Also this:
After the loss of three personnel, hours of unsuccessful attack on the fire, with several floors simultaneously involved in fire, and a risk of structural collapse, the Incident Commander withdrew all personnel from the building due to the uncontrollable risk factors.
Seems it's not unusual to pull an operation whenthere is widespread fire, risk of collapse, and the FD has already lost members. There were issues with water pressure as well.

Reading this report just makes one shake their head at the utter stupidity of truther arguments....... Again!
 
Riddle me this: if bright flashes are explosives AND the sound of explosives is dampened by foam and sheet metal, then how in the hell do we see bright flashes AND not hear them?

I don't think the flashes from any hypothetical explosive charge need to be covered up besides the drywall.
 
Was just reading a bit more about the One Meridian Plaza fire here: https://www.usfa.fema.gov/downloads/pdf/publications/tr-049.pdf

That office fire, which was vigorously fought, lasted about 15 hours, even though it was contained in only about ten floors of the building (with firefighters staging their triage and support center at the 20th floor to fight the main blaze on the 22nd floor, and the fire damaging up to the 30th floor). Note this passage from the above-linked report:

All interior firefighting efforts were halted after almost 11 hours of uninterrupted fire in the building. Consultation with a structural engineer and structural damage observed by units operating in the building led to the belief that there was a possibility of a pancake structural collapse of the fire damaged floors.​

I guess the FDNY engineers were not the first to worry about a steel framed building collapsing from fire damage...

Anyway, unless Tony has some very specific and documented reason to believe that office fires could not persist in and around a specific area in WTC 7 for 4.5 hours, I think we can pretty much call it based on this counterexample alone that clearly they could have, even if they had been fought vigorously (which they were not).

One Meridian Plaza is the closest thing you can compare to WTC 7's curious foreknowledge? The engineer at One Meridian Plaza there never stated for a fact that the building was going to collapse, nor did they give any estimate for when to expect a collapse. They only pulled back after three firefighters died and the fire had lasted all day. The building did not collapse.
 
I see Micah made some more idiotic claims and has now run away again. Countdown to his next appearance where he shows up and acts like his posts in this thread don't exist.

I was doing real life things, ProBonoShill.

The hydraulic press meme was obviously a joke. Nobody here is on my ignore list, especially not beachnut, whose rants I occasionally enjoy.

I am also not suggesting 10 feet of nanofoamite per column like the video shows. The point is that technology exists to turn an explosion which sounds like a bolt of lightning into something that sounds more like a rumbling echo.

EDIT: Does anybody have an estimate, with decibels and distances, how loud the collapses were?
 
Last edited:
One Meridian Plaza is the closest thing you can compare to WTC 7's curious foreknowledge? The engineer at One Meridian Plaza there never stated for a fact that the building was going to collapse, nor did they give any estimate for when to expect a collapse. They only pulled back after three firefighters died and the fire had lasted all day. The building did not collapse.

First--this thread isn't about rehashing stupid foreknowledge claims. It's about the validity of a fire simulation that runs for 4.5 hours. So far neither you, nor Tony, nor anyone else, has provided a single reason to believe that such a fire simulation, as was run by WAI's fire expert in their award winning engineering investigation into the collapse of WTC 7, is invalid.

Second--if you read the actual paper I linked, you would find that they did not pull back because those three people died. In fact, they recovered the bodies of the bodies of those three 5 hours prior to evacuating the building.

Third--the engineer on site clearly made the call that he thought the damage to the building from the fires, as observed by himself and his colleagues, left the building at risk of a collapse. It says so right in the report. That the building ultimately did not collapse does not mean he was wrong while the WTC 7 evaluator was right. They were were both right--both buildings were vulnerable to collapse due to fire and posed significant risks to fire fighters that were not worth taking. That's what the evaluators were assessing. And the eventual collapse of WTC 7 ultimately showed that the One Meridian evaluator was shrewd in recognizing such a possibility--which truthers would have us believe is somehow wildly unimaginable. But risk assessment doesn't require certainty and, thankfully, the actual structural engineers who have to evaluate fire damage every day apparently know that. Why don't truthers?

In short, you continue to ignore the point of this thread, invent a stupid lie to serve your nonargument, and completely miss the point anyway. Nice work.
 
Last edited:
I don't think the flashes from any hypothetical explosive charge need to be covered up besides the drywall.


There were no flashes attributed to explosives. Such flashes would have generated an explosive noises as sudden heat comes into contact with the cooler air.
 
Last edited:
First--this thread isn't about rehashing stupid foreknowledge claims. It's about the validity of a fire simulation that runs for 4.5 hours. So far neither you, nor Tony, nor anyone else, has provided a single reason to believe that such a fire simulation, as was run by WAI's fire expert in their award winning engineering investigation into the collapse of WTC 7, is invalid.

Second--if you read the actual paper I linked, you would find that they did not pull back because those three people died. In fact, they recovered the bodies of the bodies of those three 5 hours prior to evacuating the building.

Third--the engineer on site clearly made the call that he thought the damage to the building from the fires, as observed by himself and his colleagues, left the building at risk of a collapse. It says so right in the report. That the building ultimately did not collapse does not mean he was wrong while the WTC 7 evaluator was right. They were were both right--both buildings were vulnerable to collapse due to fire and posed significant risks to fire fighters that were not worth taking. The eventual collapse of WTC 7 showed that the One Meridian evaluator was shrewd in recognizing such a possibility--which truthers would have us believe is somehow wildly unimaginable. But risk assessment doesn't require certainty and, thankfully, the actual structural engineers who have to evaluate fire damage every day know that.

In short, you continue to ignore the point of this thread, invent a stupid lie to serve your nonargument, and completely miss the point anyway. Nice work.

In what world does One Meridian Plaza support WTC 7 fire collapse? The fires in that building spread floor-to-floor via broken windows. You were obviously referencing to the WTC 7 foreknowledge and how it relates to the engineer who warned the fire chiefs.
 
Last edited:
One Meridian Plaza is the closest thing you can compare to WTC 7's curious foreknowledge? The engineer at One Meridian Plaza there never stated for a fact that the building was going to collapse, nor did they give any estimate for when to expect a collapse. They only pulled back after three firefighters died and the fire had lasted all day. The building did not collapse.


WTC 7 sustained massive impact damage and uncontrolled fires for almost 7 hours. Structural buckling and the internal creaking sounds were clear indications that WTC 7 was in danger of collapsing.
 
I am also not suggesting 10 feet of nanofoamite per column like the video shows. The point is that technology exists to turn an explosion which sounds like a bolt of lightning into something that sounds more like a rumbling echo.

It would have been impossible to rig WTC 7 with explosives in secret.
 
In what world does One Meridian Plaza support WTC 7 fire collapse? The fires in that building spread floor-to-floor via broken windows. You were obviously referencing to the WTC 7 foreknowledge and how it relates to the engineer who warned the fire chiefs.

You seriously cannot figure out how the citation of an office fire that lasted 15 hours despite being vigorously fought for 11 of those hours is relevant in a thread dedicated to the question of whether a simulated office fire that lasts 4.5 hours is prima facie invalid?

Seriously?

And do you want to acknowledge your lie about the fire department pulling out due to the deaths? Why did you invent that lie?

Are you now claiming that office fires cannot last 4.5 hours or more unless they expand vertically by lapping between windows? You cannot be this dumb and/or dishonest.
 
Last edited:
WTC 7 sustained massive impact damage and uncontrolled fires for almost 7 hours. Structural buckling and the internal creaking sounds were clear indications that WTC 7 was in danger of collapsing.

skyeagle, the creaking and the "structural buckling" (small, insignificant perimeter deformation, bulge) can NOT account for collapse initiating via thermal expansion. Steel-weakening fires, like One Meridian Plaza, usually just result in parts of the structure slowly and gradually warping (i.e. not a sudden collapse). NIST themselves clearly acknowledged WTC 7 is an odd case in the history of fire and building collapses. It may have worked on the day of 9/11, where confirmation bias can explain WTC 7, but not today when people are trying to figure out ANY specific way it could have collapsed. Any possible building collapse from thermal expansion of girders is completely unpredictable.
 
You seriously cannot figure out how the citation of an office fire that lasted 15 hours despite being vigorously fought for 11 of those hours is relevant in a thread dedicated to the question of whether a simulated office fire that lasts 4.5 hours is prima facie invalid?

Seriously?

And do you want to acknowledge your lie about the fire department pulling out due to the deaths? Why did you invent that lie?

Are you now claiming that office fires cannot last 4.5 hours or more unless they expand vertically by lapping between windows? You cannot be this dumb and/or dishonest.


There was no lie. Three firefighters died in the fire and that may have been a factor in the evacuation. The evacuation of OMP is not comparable to the evacuations of WTC 7. What about the One Meridian Plaza fire relates to computer fire simulations?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom