Anyone Heard of the Scent of the Departed?

That's silly . "At the level of my face." If I had a rotting slice of sausage on top of a bookshelf and I smelled it would you say it , the sausage, was at the level of my face when it was eight feet above my face?

The difference being you can trace the scent of the sausage to the sausage and thus know the origin. In your case the most likely source of the scent was the mattress directly below you. That you could also smell flowers elsewhere in the room does not mean the source was elsewhere, just like you have demonstrated with the sausage - just because you can smell the sausage 8 feet away does not mean the sausage it 8 feet away from it actual location.

Unless, of course, you now claim to have followed the scent and found the rotting sausage known as granny.
 
Last edited:
That's silly . "At the level of my face." If I had a rotting slice of sausage on top of a bookshelf and I smelled it would you say it , the sausage, was at the level of my face when it was eight feet above my face?


The position of the sausage may have been 8 ft above, but the particles carrying the scent would have to be at the level of your face or else you would not be able to smell them.

This argument is actually not helping your case at all.
 
Lets try the sausage one more time.

Someone places a frozen rotting sausage under your pillow and you can smell nothing of said sausage. As you sleep the sausage thaws and begins to stink eventually waking you. The smell can now be experienced clear across the room! Tell me where is the sausage?

ETA: This is the dumbest conversation I have had in a long time.
 
Last edited:
The position of the sausage may have been 8 ft above, but the particles carrying the scent would have to be at the level of your face or else you would not be able to smell them.

This argument is actually not helping your case at all.

I'm wondering if Deranged knows how the sense of smell actually works?

Olfaction, along with taste, is a form of chemoreception. The chemicals themselves that activate the olfactory system, in general at very low concentrations, are called odorants.
 
I'm wondering if Deranged knows how the sense of smell actually works?

Of course he does! Its the sense that the dead use to make us smell roses.


I think the most ridiculous idea yet is that there are people out there claiming to know what Jesus' mother smelled like.:boggled:
 
The difference being you can trace the scent of the sausage to the sausage and thus know the origin. In your case the most likely source of the scent was the mattress directly below you. That you could also smell flowers elsewhere in the room does not mean the source was elsewhere, just like you have demonstrated with the sausage - just because you can smell the sausage 8 feet away does not mean the sausage it 8 feet away from it actual location.

Unless, of course, you now claim to have followed the scent and found the rotting sausage known as granny.
The scent was above us. Period. EXACTLY HOW FAR above? Who knows?
 
'Deranged; I don't think anyone necessarily doubts that you and your partner smelled a scent in the night..." Yes, most definitely doubt it happened. Far as "looking for evidence of life after death" I don't do that. Sometimes it seems as if it's finding me.

No one doubts that something so mundane as your smelling something floral. What people doubt is that it was proof of a ghostly presence. Your insistence of binding those two together is what people are having trouble with.

Do you agree that all smells are not the result of a visitor from beyond the grave? Why do you think THIS particular instance is prroof of anything?
 
The position of the sausage may have been 8 ft above, but the particles carrying the scent would have to be at the level of your face or else you would not be able to smell them.

This argument is actually not helping your case at all.
True. Some of the particles were right at our faces but they were experienced as being up above. So I guess they were in both places.
 
The scent was above us. Period. EXACTLY HOW FAR above? Who knows?
That's not how smell works.

True. Some of the particles were right at our faces but they were experienced as being up above. So I guess they were in both places.
Experienced as being above? What? Is this like a smell version of ventriloquism? Instead of throwing her voice, granny threw her smell?
 
No it didn't. Not enough surface area.

Actually in some belief systems bees are able to project a strong smell of grass despite their low surface area. Others do not admit this possibility, but they are cold, dull people who live lives devoid of excitement or wonder.
 
No one doubts that something so mundane as your smelling something floral. What people doubt is that it was proof of a ghostly presence. Your insistence of binding those two together is what people are having trouble with.

Do you agree that all smells are not the result of a visitor from beyond the grave? Why do you think THIS particular instance is prroof of anything?
"Do you agree that all smells are not the result of a visitor from beyond the grave? Why do you think THIS particular instance is prroof of anything?" I love this question. Let me see...it has to do with the strength of the scent , the fact that a lovely scent woke him up then left when he told it to. Then his mother's statement at breakfast that her mother would sleep in that bed when she'd visit. It was an otherworldly, peaceful but exciting thing to happen . You just knew. We knew. Then it happened to me again decades later.
If it happened to you oh , how funny it might have been. You: jumping up and yelling at his mother for spraying our room with flower scented spray in the middle of the night; you: racing to see if the window was down. And you: not being able to sleep after that. lol Next day you: driving home all nervous, remembering what happened and trying to decide if you should tell anyone. Arrival at home: ripping through science books to discredit your suspicions.
 
No one doubts that something so mundane as your smelling something floral. What people doubt is that it was proof of a ghostly presence. Your insistence of binding those two together is what people are having trouble with.

Do you agree that all smells are not the result of a visitor from beyond the grave? Why do you think THIS particular instance is prroof of anything?
"
Do you agree that all smells are not the result of a visitor from beyond the grave?" Um, let me think about this question....
 
The scent was above us. Period. EXACTLY HOW FAR above? Who knows?

NO. PERIOD.

The scent had to be right at the level of your nose or it could not have been smelled by you. It could also be elsewhere but that does not mean the origin was elsewhere.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom