A taste of our own medicine...perhaps??

With all due respect, for the life of me I can't see how you managed to take that conclusion away from my post. And frankly, I don't believe it requires a great deal of "careful reading" to understand my main point: I don't think a reasonable, and rational, and informed, and honest, and mature, and mentally healthy individual can be a TMer. Do I believe those attributes can arguably be applied to myself? I sure hope so, at least some of the time, but that's not my point. I am not solely defined by a handful of attributes, no one is. Thus you don't have to be me to not be a TMer. But to be a TMer, I honestly feel one must lack one of the crucial traits I mentioned.

You can be reasonable and be a TMer. Or intelligent. Or rational. Or mature, or honest, or any the rest. Thus you're likely to meet reasonable TMers, and ones who are honest, mature, mentally healthy, informed, and so on. But a TMer with the whole package? I haven't seen it yet, and I strongly believe it's simply not possible.
Yeah but you miss one thing. A REASONABLE, RATIONAL, INFORMED, HONEST, MATURE and METALLY HEALTY individual can simply be mistaken can't they or does your qualifications mean they can't?
 
I don't know any personally. I don't move in those kinds of circles. All that I've encountered are on the 'net at LC, pft, etc.

I read posts on those sites just to keep informed. Who else is there?
I didn't ask you that. I asked you to list who you spoke with. You ask me to list who is reasonable yet you can't list who you spoke with?
 
You can also lack one or more of the traits Stellafane listed, and not be a TMer. Put me on the list of those who can't see the us/them mentality in his post either, and tend to agree with it as well.

Oh wait, that is setting up an us/them mentality . . . :boxedin:
 
I agree. What's funny is that he spends a good deal of time debunking the real nutty folks but he still has this belief that what happened at the Pentagon wasn't as published.

Yes, I know. I've never seen him list the reasons why and I don't agree with him in all respects, but from what I've read he will listen to reason and he does have reasonable judgment and analytical skills. Otherwise, he is somewhat of a mystery that I don't quite understand and I would never dismiss his opinions "out of hand".
 
You can also lack one or more of the traits Stellafane listed, and not be a TMer. Put me on the list of those who can't see the us/them mentality in his post either, and tend to agree with it as well.

Oh wait, that is setting up an us/them mentality . . . :boxedin:
Nobody said you can't agree with it or even not see what I did. I just don't understand how any of those qualifications rules out how someone can just be mistaken.
 
I didn't ask you that. I asked you to list who you spoke with. You ask me to list who is reasonable yet you can't list who you spoke with?

Wow! What a way to avoid a simple question. Since it's too complicated for you to list those who are reasonable besides Pickering just forget that I asked. It's not important anyway.
 
You can also lack one or more of the traits Stellafane listed, and not be a TMer. Put me on the list of those who can't see the us/them mentality in his post either, and tend to agree with it as well.

Oh wait, that is setting up an us/them mentality . . . :boxedin:
I lost track somewhere. Am I one of us, or one of them? Is it good to be a them or an us? Which group has cooties?

I don't want to be left out another time!
 
Yeah but you miss one thing. A REASONABLE, RATIONAL, INFORMED, HONEST, MATURE and METALLY HEALTY individual can simply be mistaken can't they or does your qualifications mean they can't?

Wouldn't being mistaken imply being uninformed? And persisting in one's mistakes after being informed is not being reasonable or mature.
 
Nobody said you can't agree with it or even not see what I did. I just don't understand how any of those qualifications rules out how someone can just be mistaken.


I think that if the Honest trait holds true, once your mistake has been pointed out, you would work to correct it. Holding on to a belief shown to be mistaken could be considered dishonest. That's just my opinion though.
 
Nobody said you can't agree with it or even not see what I did. I just don't understand how any of those qualifications rules out how someone can just be mistaken.
IMO being mistaken is pretty much the same as being uninformed, and not admitting a mistake after being informed of the error is being unreasonable and/or immature
 
I just don't understand how any of those qualifications rules out how someone can just be mistaken.

That would probably qualify, in the context in which you appear to mean it, as "uninformed", thus ... Stellafane's post still stands.

I find it difficult to understand how you can misunderstand his post so thoroughly. I really do.
 
Yeah but you miss one thing. A REASONABLE, RATIONAL, INFORMED, HONEST, MATURE and METALLY HEALTY individual can simply be mistaken can't they or does your qualifications mean they can't?

That's where "informed" comes in. Anyone can be mistaken if they lack the facts. But once you're informed of the facts concerning 9/11, I don't believe that anyone in possession of the attributes I mention can come to any other conclusion except what is colloquially called the "official version." Thus a person informed of the facts of 9/11 who continues to believe in the TM is, in my view, lacking in one of those crucial traits.

Anyone can make a mistake, of course. But belief in the TM is not a reasonable mistake. Or a rational one. Or (here it comes again) an informed, or honest, or mature, or mentally healthy one. Something, somewhere must be lacking for a person to make such an illogical mistake of this magnitude, in the face of readily available, abundant, and irrefutable evidence.

Suggesting that those with whom I disagree are somehow lacking is not something I ever enjoy doing; indeed I think I risk looking like I'm resorting to an ad hominem attack and thus am arguing from a weak position. But in this instance, I can honestly see no other conclusion.
 
I lost track somewhere. Am I one of us, or one of them? Is it good to be a them or an us? Which group has cooties?

I don't want to be left out another time!
Yer cool, Cap'n.

For while it is true that you are in fact not MATURE (which on its face steers you towards the sucking tentacles of TMdom), you also happen to be a former SUB DRIVER and that supersedes any civilian classification and categorization system.

I can't believe I'm saying this but yer one of us.
 
Suggesting that those with whom I disagree are somehow lacking is not something I ever enjoy doing; indeed I think I risk looking like I'm resorting to an ad hominem attack and thus am arguing from a weak position. But in this instance, I can honestly see no other conclusion.

I entirely agree with both of your posts. That's the way I see it and it seems to me so does everyone else, except........
 
Wow! What a way to avoid a simple question. Since it's too complicated for you to list those who are reasonable besides Pickering just forget that I asked. It's not important anyway.
I'm avoiding? You tell me noone you spoke to is reasonable yet when I ask who you spoke to you make two posts to me and you don't answer and you accuse me of ignoring the question. You realize where you put yourself right?
 
Yer cool, Cap'n.

For while it is true that you are in fact not MATURE (which on its face steers you towards the sucking tentacles of TMdom), you also happen to be a former SUB DRIVER and that supersedes any civilian classification and categorization system.

I can't believe I'm saying this but yer one of us.
Sorry, but they wouldn't let me drive. I got to push it, not steer it.

Some would say I've always been pushy!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom