A taste of our own medicine...perhaps??

T.A.M.

Penultimate Amazing
Joined
Jul 25, 2006
Messages
20,795
I have been noticing as of late, perhaps the last 6-8 months, that the truthers have begun to label certain aspects of the "other side".

examples:

1. The "official" account is now referred to as the "Official Conspiracy Theory"
2. Debunkers here are now referred to as part of the "Debunking Movement"

My first thoughts on this was "so what", but now I am seeing it for what it is, which is an attempt to try and depreciate the effort many of us make here. The official account is referred to as a CT because they know how much contempt we have for CT's as a whole. Our mocking of the "truth movement" has resulted in them labeling what we do as the "Debunking Movement".

As to the motive behind this, the obvious one is anger at us for what we do. We are the thorn in their side, and they know it. It is the reason why the term "JREFer" has become a curse word on truth sites.

But then there is, what I think, a more subtle reason. I think the truthers are trying to trivialize our efforts, so they can rationalize us away, like they do with so many other things. It is much harder for them to accept that their most ardent and adamant opponents on the 9/11 issue are a bunch of educated, ordinary people with NO REWARD, and honesty and truth as their only motives. Much easier, is to try and label us as a group of extremists, who will tolerate only one version of the truth, apologists for the Neocons, etc....

And then, my final thoughts, are concerning how we in fact, treat them the same way. Do we do so for the same reasons? When we call them "truthers" or "Twoofers" or "Denialists", when we call them Kooks, are we doing so to trivialize them? If we do, why do we trivialize them and their cause...is it because it is stupid and trivial? Is it because it is easier to trivialize it than confront it? I dunno?

They are, in fact, doing to us, exactly what a lot of us have done to them. Do we deserve it? I dunno.

What do you think??

TAM:)
 
Last edited:
It reminds me of faith heads refering to atheism as a belief system. It's a kind of tu quoque fallacy.
 
Hmm, TAM, you may have a point. It's certainly worthy of examination. I'd like to think I'm not trivializing, that in fact by caring to study it, I'm actually accepting the notion that there's worth in the topic, even if I ultimately and deeply disagree with the fantasists. I'd like to think that, of all the responses I've ever made, I've never actually trivialized any of the statements, that I've actually treated the subject seriously, even if at times I've ridiculed the opposing side. But, I'm a bit to close to my own statements to be objective in judging them. I'd need someone else to tell me if that's what I've indeed done, either in my rather disdainful replies in blogs like SLC or Conspiracy Smasher, or in my own shorthand (like calling truthers "conspiracy fantasists"). I might have indeed done this.

This is definitely something to think about. I don't think that this reflection reduces the veracity of the information we provide, but it is a double-check on our own behavior. Anyway, self analysis is usually a good thing, especially in the heated circumstances that surround debates on this topic.
 
Hmm, TAM, you may have a point. It's certainly worthy of examination. I'd like to think I'm not trivializing, that in fact by caring to study it, I'm actually accepting the notion that there's worth in the topic, even if I ultimately and deeply disagree with the fantasists. I'd like to think that, of all the responses I've ever made, I've never actually trivialized any of the statements, that I've actually treated the subject seriously, even if at times I've ridiculed the opposing side. But, I'm a bit to close to my own statements to be objective in judging them. I'd need someone else to tell me if that's what I've indeed done, either in my rather disdainful replies in blogs like SLC or Conspiracy Smasher, or in my own shorthand (like calling truthers "conspiracy fantasists"). I might have indeed done this.

This is definitely something to think about. I don't think that this reflection reduces the veracity of the information we provide, but it is a double-check on our own behavior. Anyway, self analysis is usually a good thing, especially in the heated circumstances that surround debates on this topic.

Well said sir, and you have hit the nail on the head wrt why I posted this topic. Self reflection is always good. As well, however, I posted this as a place to analyze this "rhetoric" element of the "duel" if you would call it.

TAM:)
 
I have been noticing as of late, perhaps the last 6-8 months, that the truthers have begun to label certain aspects of the "other side".

examples:

1. The "official" account is now referred to as the "Official Conspiracy Theory"
2. Debunkers here are now referred to as part of the "Debunking Movement"

My first thoughts on this was "so what", but now I am seeing it for what it is, which is an attempt to try and depreciate the effort many of us make here. The official account is referred to as a CT because they know how much contempt we have for CT's as a whole. Our mocking of the "truth movement" has resulted in them labeling what we do as the "Debunking Movement".

As to the motive behind this, the obvious one is anger at us for what we do. We are the thorn in their side, and they know it. It is the reason why the term "JREFer" has become a curse word on truth sites.

But then there is, what I think, a more subtle reason. I think the truthers are trying to trivialize our efforts, so they can rationalize us away, like they do with so many other things. It is much harder for them to accept that their most ardent and adamant opponents on the 9/11 issue are a bunch of educated, ordinary people with NO REWARD, and honesty and truth as their only motives. Much easier, is to try and label us as a group of extremists, who will tolerate only one version of the truth, apologists for the Neocons, etc....

And then, my final thoughts, are concerning how we in fact, treat them the same way. Do we do so for the same reasons? When we call them "truthers" or "Twoofers" or "Denialists", when we call them Kooks, are we doing so to trivialize them? If we do, why do we trivialize them and their cause...is it because it is stupid and trivial? Is it because it is easier to trivialize it than confront it? I dunno?

They are, in fact, doing to us, exactly what a lot of us have done to them. Do we deserve it? I dunno.

What do you think??

TAM:)
A "Movement" can be defined thus:

a diffusely organized or heterogeneous group of people or organizations tending toward or favoring a generalized common goal

Given that you are diffusely organised, you are people, and you favour the goal of spreading your beliefs, you are thus a "movement". "The Debunking Movement" is the suitable epithet.

Let's hear no more quibbles about this please.
 
Opposing groups will always find names for their opposition.

I can't list all of the words that have been used to describe the enemy in wartime, but they are many: Krauts, Jerries, Nips, Gooks.....

Personally, I don't care if they call debunkers "The Poopyhead Movement". It's the argument that counts, not the names we use to refer to each other.

Personally, I don't think "truther" is a particularly hateful moniker to slap on the CT's. How should we refer to them. Likewise, I don't find anything hateful about "OCT's" or "Debunkers". Seems better than Poopyhead Movement :D

It's a non-issue, IMHO.
 
Well said sir, and you have hit the nail on the head wrt why I posted this topic. Self reflection is always good. As well, however, I posted this as a place to analyze this "rhetoric" element of the "duel" if you would call it.

TAM:)


An interesting tangent to this discussion, if you go look at the August 2007 forum statistics Darat posted down in Forum Management, the main keywords that people search on and has taken them to this site were "jref" and "zeitgeist".
 
I guess you could say I am a member of the sceptic movement with a particular interest in religion and conspiracy theories.


Pardalis, you sound as if you have had a particularly hard Labor Day weekend. Your tone is usually more "reserved".

Do you really think they are ALL idiots?

Do you really think they have NOTHING of value to say?

TAM:)


1) Well I suppose some of them may just be confused and misguided.

2) They have nothing of value to say, but it is possible to learn from their mistakes.
 
I personally find it hard not to belittle them myself. Their suggestions, their theories are not only frightening, but they are grossly slanderous. They accuse many men, innocent until proven guilty, of horrible crimes, with little to no evidence.

While I try to be much more reserved here, on JREF, I find more and more I am slipping into name calling and labeling when I post at SLC Blog or other places. Some of it, surely, is falling for the "bait" just like one might with a good old schoolyard taunting, some of it is frustration that I can't make them see the real TRUTH, and yet some more of it is down right anger and contempt.

In the end, I think it is human nature to react to such things in this way, but as others have said, self-reflection is a great way to keep oneself in moral check.

TAM:)
 
I have been noticing as of late, perhaps the last 6-8 months, that the truthers have begun to label certain aspects of the "other side".

examples:

1. The "official" account is now referred to as the "Official Conspiracy Theory"

The official account actually is a conspiracy theory (19 Arab terrorists executing a plan conceived, planned and financed by Al Qaeda). However, I agree with you that by labeling the account that we believe is the most obviously logical explanation for the events of Sep 11, they are trying to trivialize our belief, and make there theory appear as an equally plausible alternative explanation.

2. Debunkers here are now referred to as part of the "Debunking Movement"

My first thoughts on this was "so what", but now I am seeing it for what it is, which is an attempt to try and depreciate the effort many of us make here. The official account is referred to as a CT because they know how much contempt we have for CT's as a whole. Our mocking of the "truth movement" has resulted in them labeling what we do as the "Debunking Movement".

Again, to make us sound like them...to attempt to elevate themselves to the same level that we are at, as if these were two equally valid explanations, backed by equal amounts of evidence.

As to the motive behind this, the obvious one is anger at us for what we do. We are the thorn in their side, and they know it. It is the reason why the term "JREFer" has become a curse word on truth sites.

But then there is, what I think, is a more subtle reason. I think the truthers are trying to trivialize our efforts, so they can rationalize us away, like they do with so many other things. It is much harder for them to accept that their most ardent and adamant opponents on the 9/11 issue are a bunch of educated, ordinary people with NO REWARD, and honesty and truth as their only motives. Much easier, is to try and label us as a group of extremists, who will tolerate only one version of the truth, apologists for the Neocons, etc....

And then, my final thoughts, are concerning how we in fact, treat them the same way. Do we do so for the same reasons? When we call them "truthers" or "Twoofers" or "Denialists", when we call them Kooks, are we doing so to trivialize them? If we do, why do we trivialize them and their cause...is it because it is stupid and trivial? Is it because it is easier to trivialize it than confront it? I dunno?



They are, in fact, doing to us, exactly what a lot of us have done to them. Do we deserve it? I dunno.


What do you think??



TAM:)

I believe that they deserve to be trivialized. We base our beliefs on logic and solid evidence, we know how to weigh different pieces of evidence objectively, to pay attention to the vast body of evidence that is important, and to discount that which is trivial. Truthers arguments are based on emotion and minutiae. They start out with a conclusion. and then cherry pick the only the evidence that tends to look inconsistent with the official story. They say they are only 'asking questions', but then they pay no attention to the answers. They are closed minded (Dylan's response that 'nothing' would make him change his mind). I have been watching this forum for quite some time, and I can't think of a single JREFer that would make a statement like that.

I don't think we owe the truthers an apology for trivializing them, nor should we feel bad about it. They have trivialized themselves by continuing to support a theory that is completely preposterous, and not backed by a single piece of solid evidence.
 
Let's hear no more quibbles about this please.

Sorry, this is a public forum, and last I checked you were neither a mod or admin, so if you do not like the topic, I suggest you simply go find another thread to read.

TAM:)
 
A "Movement" can be defined thus:

a diffusely organized or heterogeneous group of people or organizations tending toward or favoring a generalized common goal

Given that you are diffusely organised, you are people, and you favour the goal of spreading your beliefs, you are thus a "movement". "The Debunking Movement" is the suitable epithet.

Let's hear no more quibbles about this please.
 
A "Movement" can be defined thus:



Given that you are diffusely organised, you are people, and you favour the goal of spreading your beliefs, you are thus a "movement". "The Debunking Movement" is the suitable epithet.

Let's hear no more quibbles about this please.
I was about to say that this would be the first time I agreed with you, mjd, were it not for the part about "favour the goal of spreading your belief", then Pardalis said:
There is a skeptical movement, but not a 9/11 debunking movement per say.(sic)
Which I wholly agree with.

I think there are a few here that actually care about "spreading (their)belief re: 9/11, I think most of us came to this forum as skeptics of all manner of claims, and got wrapped up in the 9/11 part of it. At least that's my story.
 
Whenever they say "we" are the debunking movement, or we support the "official CT" they remind me of Creationists, when they accuse evolution of being a religion.

It's just plain and simple nonsense.
 
A "Movement" can be defined thus:



Given that you are diffusely organised, you are people, and you favour the goal of spreading your beliefs, you are thus a "movement". "The Debunking Movement" is the suitable epithet.

Let's hear no more quibbles about this please.

you have said this twice now. Are your batteries low?

TAM:)
 
I was about to say that this would be the first time I agreed with you, mjd, were it not for the part about "favour the goal of spreading your belief", then Pardalis said:

Which I wholly agree with.

I think there are a few here that actually care about "spreading (their)belief re: 9/11, I think most of us came to this forum as skeptics of all manner of claims, and got wrapped up in the 9/11 part of it. At least that's my story.
I think if your agreeing with Pardalis over me, you have some pretty serious thinking to do!

I should say that if you do not favour the goal of letting people know your beliefs about 911, then why do you propagate them? Or more to the point, if the whole world (or majority) believed what you and your ilk deemed to be the truth about 911 and its CTs, is this something you would favour or tend towards?
 
I think we should remember that, for all the talk about "debate", there really isn't, at the end of the day, any debate about what happened on 9/11, or who made it happen.

What we are trying to do is educate the lurkers, fence-sitters, and those who might have seen "Loose Change" and wondered what all the fuss is about, and might have stumbled across JREF in their search for a balanced view. And, not incidentally, we are trying to expose the intellectual and moral bankruptcy of those who attempt to profit from the tragedy of that day.

That being said, I do believe that a little perspective is important, too. I have noticed, in the last few weeks, an increasing tendency to personalize arguments. Our "Truther" posters are subject to increasingly vitriolic attacks just for questioning our interpretation of events. Are they trolling? Sure. But we should not rise to their bait. The posters here have a wealth of information and ability in a tremendous variety of disciplines. I believe that the cause of JREF is better served by simply presenting information as objectively as possible, without personalizing the presentation.

For example:

Claim: WTC7 fell faster than freefall speed.

Right answer: That is false. See attached. (link to relevant page at 911myths or Gravy's paper)

Wrong answer: Wrong, (rule10)hole. (link to relevant page at 911myths or Gravy's paper)

Now, I understand that civility might be harder to maintain the five-hundredth time you've answered the question... but can't we all strive for it a little more? Do it for the poor, misguided lurkers...
 
Last edited:
The reason I personally post here is to expose the sellers of snake oil, so to speak. The internet, like nothing else in history, save the printing press, has allowed the propagation of lies, mistruths, and conspiracy theories. Some one has to be there to provide the other side. Since the Government has decided to play the "ignore" game with the truth movement, it is up to those of us who dislike the selling of snake oil, to guide fence sitters/newcomers in the direction of evidence, logic, and science.

TAM:)
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom