A taste of our own medicine...perhaps??

Just for the record, I should mention that Pickering really isn't all that reasonable. He's reasonable about some things, sure (flight 77 and the Pentagon, for example), but quite the opposite about others. When he was still posting here he was completely unable to entertain the thought that there were significant fires in WTC7 based solely on the fact that he couldn't see flames licking outside the windows on multiple floors in any of the pictures of the building. In doing so he steadfastly refused to even acknowledge the scores of quotes provided by Gravy from firefighters on the scene which attested the severity of the conflagration, after which he resorted to copying and pasting juvenile "you know you've won the argument when" taunts. This is all the more discouraging when you consider the fact that he once worked with firefighters.

So I would say he still possesses all the basic twoofer qualities, just in a slightly less concentrated form.
 
Just for the record, I should mention that Pickering really isn't all that reasonable. He's reasonable about some things, sure (flight 77 and the Pentagon, for example), but quite the opposite about others. When he was still posting here he was completely unable to entertain the thought that there were significant fires in WTC7 based solely on the fact that he couldn't see flames licking outside the windows on multiple floors in any of the pictures of the building. In doing so he steadfastly refused to even acknowledge the scores of quotes provided by Gravy from firefighters on the scene which attested the severity of the conflagration, after which he resorted to copying and pasting juvenile "you know you've won the argument when" taunts. This is all the more discouraging when you consider the fact that he once worked with firefighters.

So I would say he still possesses all the basic twoofer qualities, just in a slightly less concentrated form.
When was he last here?
 
I'm not sure. The exchange I referred to was months ago, long before I was even a member. It might have been last year, even. I read it quite a while after the fact.
Ok say a year...quite a long time. i haven't talked to him about his beliefs except to know he thinks the flyover is firmly in the guano catagory but beliefs change in a year.

ETA - Before anyone reading starts thinking I am defending anybody - read carefully cause I am not.
 
Last edited:
Ok say a year...quite a long time. i haven't talked to him about his beliefs except to know he thinks the flyover is firmly in the guano catagory but beliefs change in a year.

He never believed in the flyover "theory" (if it can be called that), hence I said he was quite reasonable about flight 77 and the Pentagon. But once you go into WTC7 territory he's as barking mad as the rest.

I'm not sure what his position is on the Twin Towers themselves, though I'm guessing he's in the CD camp.
 
He never believed in the flyover "theory" (if it can be called that), hence I said he was quite reasonable about flight 77 and the Pentagon. But once you go into WTC7 territory he's as barking mad as the rest.

I'm not sure what his position is on the Twin Towers themselves, though I'm guessing he's in the CD camp.
Ok but you are speaking about his position from 1 year ago. Can beliefs change in 1 year?
 
Ok but you are speaking about his position from 1 year ago. Can beliefs change in 1 year?

Yeah, sure. Perhaps he is more reasonable now concerning building 7 than he was then, but I highly doubt it. He's still part of the "Truth" movement, is he not? The CD of building 7 hypothesis is pretty much the last bulwark of MIHOP silliness: if he no longer believes in that then I have no idea why he would still associate with the movement at all.

You still post over at LCF, right? Maybe you could ask him if his opinion has changed concerning the fires in WTC7.
 
But they have cool uniforms :)
True.

Hey these guys just beat the Twins 7-5 by scoring 2 in the ninth to tie, two in the eleventh. 80th win. 7 ahead of the Tigers. Maybe this friggin' Tribe will win (ha) the Series ONCE DURING MY LIFETIME!!!11!one!!1
 
Yeah, sure. Perhaps he is more reasonable now concerning building 7 than he was then, but I highly doubt it. He's still part of the "Truth" movement, is he not? The CD of building 7 hypothesis is pretty much the last bulwark of MIHOP silliness: if he no longer believes in that then I have no idea why he would still associate with the movement at all.

You still post over at LCF, right? Maybe you could ask him if his opinion has changed concerning the fires in WTC7.
You forget that MIHOP isn't the only "HOP" in the truth movement. And yes I post there but I'm not concerned with Russell's belief in WTC 7. If you want, just register, send him a PM and ask.
 
True.

Hey these guys just beat the Twins 7-5 by scoring 2 in the ninth to tie, two in the eleventh. 80th win. 7 ahead of the Tigers. Maybe this friggin' Tribe will win (ha) the Series ONCE DURING MY LIFETIME!!!11!one!!1
They better watch for Detroits claws but it is September...then again as ole Tug used to say "You gotta believe."
 
You forget that MIHOP isn't the only "HOP" in the truth movement. And yes I post there but I'm not concerned with Russell's belief in WTC 7. If you want, just register, send him a PM and ask.

I'm not really all that interested, and besides I've been banned there already. For the sake of absolute candor, however, I will amend my assessment of Pickering's rationality to say that he was at the time of his posting here very unreasonable about the fires in WTC7 when confronted with evidence on this forum.
 
I'm glad you understood why I mentioned physics. A mistake is simply a mistake. The magnitude is a subjective term. In school when I majored in chemistry forgetting where an element was on the periodic table was a grave error or to use your terminology one of great MAGNITUDE. Subjective call though.

Oh, please. Stop it already.

Seriously.
 
Stellafane understood what I meant, why do you have a problem?

I sincerely doubt that Stellafane will appreciate you putting words in his mouth. And as I said before - just above, in fact - stop it already.
 
I sincerely doubt that Stellafane will appreciate you putting words in his mouth. And as I said before - just above, in fact - stop it already.
Not putting words in his mouth and I am not going to stop it. You have a problem then show how the quote of mine you used was wrong.

ETA - the post you quoted was #173...you quoted it in post #192, why?
 
Last edited:
Not putting words in his mouth and I am not going to stop it. You have a problem then show how the quote of mine you used was wrong.

Actually, you are putting words in Stellafane's mouth and you really should stop it.

Given our private communications, I cannot respond publicly to the latter part of your post, as it would of necessity entail writing publicly about things that we have discussed privately, and I take very seriously the sanctity of private communications.

Yeah, I'm funny that way.

(You can thank me later - after next week, that is.)
 
Actually, you are putting words in Stellafane's mouth and you really should stop it.

Given our private communications, I cannot respond publicly to the latter part of your post, as it would of necessity entail writing publicly about things that we have discussed privately, and I take very seriously the sanctity of private communications.

Yeah, I'm funny that way.

(You can thank me later - after next week, that is.)
In your post #192 you quoted my post #173. There were 20 intervening posts and 8 were by me on different subjects yet you bring up a 20 old post and tell me to stop? C'mon...
 
Russell is the ONLY one in the "movement" that is anywhere near remotely reasonable that I've ever encountered. If there are others, please list them.

Heirosis (sp?) is disturbingly rational when it comes to demolishing some of the more far out 'truther' claims over on LCF. But he's definitely a believer. A bit like Russel, he doesn't seem to be able to take that small step of applying his critical thinking skills to his own beliefs.
 
and who do you deem to be conspiracy fantasists?

Those who will not accept that a group of religious fanatics highjacked four planes on 11 Sept 2001 and flew three of them into buildings.

Those who claim that the WTC buildings were demolished with explosives.

Those who implicate (usually without having the courage to state explicitly) that the emergency responders were in on it.

That probably covers most of them.

no it doesnt. Look at the polls. This is the problem with your ilk. You have no idea whho/what you are arguing against


The question of polls seems to have been covered by others. Therefore I will not bother to ask what polls.

What is my "ilk"?

I am "arguing against" thase who make errors in their understanding of events, when, as previously stated, these errors are something that I know about.

I do not make arguments about areas outside my knowledge. Consequently, I do not get involved in the technical discussions regarding, for example, structural engineering. I defer in these areas to those who do have knowledge.

With respect to this, until I retired last year I was employed at the Building Research Establishment in the UK. A representative from NIST came to BRE and gave a presentation to the staff about their WTC investigations. The staff at BRE are some of the foremost in the UK in building science. There were also representatives from other consultancies present (I think Arup were represented). NOT ONE PERSON present questioned the basic premise of the findings presented. On the basis of this I believe that I am justified in accepting the "official version" of the sad events on that day.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom