A taste of our own medicine...perhaps??

Semantics and name-calling aside, I have to confess that at this point, I honestly can't see how any reasonable, rational, informed, honest, mature, and mentally healthy individual can be a member of the TM. I know that sounds quite harsh, but I really don't see any other options here. 9/11 just isn't the sort of issue on which reasonable people can agree to disagree. All the evidence (and it is supremely abundant, reliable, and supported) points in one direction, and none of it points towards the TM. There's really no room for viable alternate theories. Anyone who doubts that 9/11 was the work of 19 Arab terrorists, supported by a terrorist network, must be basing this opinion on something other than logic and reality.

For instance, look at the TMers who come here. Typically, they make some claim that they insist supports their view. When a JREFer points out their claim is irrefutably and demonstrable false, how often does the TMer say "Thank you, I was misinformed?" Has this ever happened? It seems that in every case I can remember, the person ignored counter arguments and doggedly insisted their claim was true, or said the evidence was invalid for some reason, or simply went on to the next completely debunked claim. Is this the way a rational, mature, and healthy intellect works? Most of us would be ashamed to indulge in such behavior, but TMers seem to do nothing else. So how can we take seriously the cause they represent?

I don't believe in UFO's, but I can at least imagine how a reasonable and informed person might. The same is true for most woo topics, including lake monsters, ghosts, and Bigfoot (although the last one may be stretching the limit to its breaking point). But not 9/11. When I learn that someone is a TMer, I invariably suspect that there must be some flaw in their reasoning skills and the way they view the world. Unfortunately, the more I learn about the TM, the more convinced I am that my suspicions are likely correct.
 
no it doesnt. Look at the polls. This is the problem with your ilk. You have no idea whho/what you are arguing against

Like the Scripps poll that shows only 16% in the "strongly agree" Bush etal either planned or allowed 9/11, with only another 20% think this scenario "somewhat likely", and a full 59% thinking the scenario of LIHOP and/or MIHOP "Unlikely".

You mean that poll (a legit poll rather than the cyberbombed online polls)?

TAM:)
 
Semantics and name-calling aside, I have to confess that at this point, I honestly can't see how any reasonable, rational, informed, honest, mature, and mentally healthy individual can be a member of the TM. I know that sounds quite harsh, but I really don't see any other options here. 9/11 just isn't the sort of issue on which reasonable people can agree to disagree. All the evidence (and it is supremely abundant, reliable, and supported) points in one direction, and none of it points towards the TM. There's really no room for viable alternate theories. Anyone who doubts that 9/11 was the work of 19 Arab terrorists, supported by a terrorist network, must be basing this opinion on something other than logic and reality.

For instance, look at the TMers who come here. Typically, they make some claim that they insist supports their view. When a JREFer points out their claim is irrefutably and demonstrable false, how often does the TMer say "Thank you, I was misinformed?" Has this ever happened? It seems that in every case I can remember, the person ignored counter arguments and doggedly insisted their claim was true, or said the evidence was invalid for some reason, or simply went on to the next completely debunked claim. Is this the way a rational, mature, and healthy intellect works? Most of us would be ashamed to indulge in such behavior, but TMers seem to do nothing else. So how can we take seriously the cause they represent?

I don't believe in UFO's, but I can at least imagine how a reasonable and informed person might. The same is true for most woo topics, including lake monsters, ghosts, and Bigfoot (although the last one may be stretching the limit to its breaking point). But not 9/11. When I learn that someone is a TMer, I invariably suspect that there must be some flaw in their reasoning skills and the way they view the world. Unfortunately, the more I learn about the TM, the more convinced I am that my suspicions are likely correct.
Good post but I disagree somewhat. Good people, smart people can have weird beliefs. You (and alot of people) are basing what you believe on the few hardcore fruitloops and guano catagory people that come here. That isn't the entire truth movement. Someone here once mentioned Russell Pickering and said that he was reasonable, do you really believe that there are no others that can be called reasonable?
 
Like the Scripps poll that shows only 16% in the "strongly agree" Bush etal either planned or allowed 9/11, with only another 20% think this scenario "somewhat likely", and a full 59% thinking the scenario of LIHOP and/or MIHOP "Unlikely".

You mean that poll (a legit poll rather than the cyberbombed online polls)?

TAM:)

Even questions like "planned or allowed" combine two different things in order to 'up' the percentage. "Allowed" is worthless to most 9/11 CT's as it accepts the so-called 'Official Story'. Bush couldn't have 'allowed' something to happen unless it happened.

Also, relying on alleged popular support is a tad daft. It doesn't do you any good to believe something if you believe it out of ignorance or due to faulty reasons.
 
Good post but I disagree somewhat. Good people, smart people can have weird beliefs. You (and alot of people) are basing what you believe on the few hardcore fruitloops and guano catagory people that come here. That isn't the entire truth movement. Someone here once mentioned Russell Pickering and said that he was reasonable, do you really believe that there are no others that can be called reasonable?

As I stated in my post, I do not believe that any reasonable, rational, informed, honest, mature, and mentally healthy individual can be a member of the TM. I believe that to be a TMer, you must lack at least one or more of those attributes. Thus a person could in theory be reasonable, but if they are not informed or mentally healthy they may still fall for the TM. I have yet to discover any TMer who possessed all the traits I mentioned, so I stick by my post.
 
no it doesnt. Look at the polls. This is the problem with your ilk. You have no idea whho/what you are arguing against


Yeah, yeah... "Pay attention to the polls. No, no! Don't look outside at the lack of protests! No! Don't look at our dismally minuscule gatherings! Damnit! Stop looking at the lack of professional support! LOOK AT THE POLLS!"

:rolleyes:
 
As I stated in my post, I do not believe that any reasonable, rational, informed, honest, mature, and mentally healthy individual can be a member of the TM. I believe that to be a TMer, you must lack at least one or more of those attributes. Thus a person could in theory be reasonable, but if they are not informed or mentally healthy they may still fall for the TM. I have yet to discover any TMer who possessed all the traits I mentioned, so I stick by my post.
Do you disagree with what Michael Shermer wrote that smart people can believe some weird things?
 
Do you disagree with what Michael Shermer wrote that smart people can believe some weird things?

That is not at all what Stellafane said, enigma. Of course, some smart people can believe some weird things. If you read Stellafane's post again, thoroughly, you will realize that he is not saying "smart people don't believe some weird things". In fact, he has made his post pretty clear, particularly when he responded to your last post and explained it further in his post #125.

I, for one, agree with Stellafane's post.

ETA: Stellafane is not saying that anyone who buys into the TM, even briefly, is a raving lunatic. He has said, quite succinctly, that to be a member of the TM, one must lack at least one of the following traits: reasonable, rational, informed, honest, mature, mentally healthy.

He is right. Some members of the TM (past or present) are probably reasonable, rational, mature, and mentally healthy, but simply uninformed. Similarly, some members of the TM (past or present) are probably reasonable, mature, honest, rational, but mentally unwell. Similarly... well, you get the idea. Stellafane's point is that he has seen no examples of members of the TM meeting all of the criteria that he has set out.

I have not either.
 
Last edited:
That is not at all what Stellafane said, enigma. Of course, some smart people can believe some weird things. If you read Stellafane's post again, thoroughly, you will realize that he is not saying "smart people don't believe some weird things". In fact, he has made his post pretty clear, particularly when he responded to your last post and explained it further in his post #125.

I, for one, agree with Stellafane's post.

ETA: Stellafane is not saying that anyone who buys into the TM, even briefly, is a raving lunatic. He has said, quite succinctly, that to be a member of the TM, one must lack at least one of the following traits: reasonable, rational, informed, honest, mature, mentally healthy.

He is right. Some members of the TM (past or present) are probably reasonable, rational, mature, and mentally healthy, but simply uninformed. Similarly, some members of the TM (past or present) are probably reasonable, mature, honest, rational, but mentally unwell. Similarly... well, you get the idea. Stellafane's point is that he has seen no examples of members of the TM meeting all of the criteria that he has set out.

I have not either.
Then what he said is basically that there are "us" and "them". Or am I misunderstanding?
 
Then what he said is basically that there are "us" and "them". Or am I misunderstanding?

I can't speak for Stellafane, but no, I do not think that is what he has said at all, and yes, I think that you have misunderstood his post entirely.
 
Someone here once mentioned Russell Pickering and said that he was reasonable, do you really believe that there are no others that can be called reasonable?

Russell is the ONLY one in the "movement" that is anywhere near remotely reasonable that I've ever encountered. If there are others, please list them.

I have ZERO respect for someone who ignores FACTS and won't listen to credible knowledgeable reasoning and opinion. The vast majority of these idiots only know what they've read on some "twoofer" site on the Internet. They have expertise in NOTHING except the ability to sit behind their keyboard and type nonsense.

I have no remorse and no hesitation to belittle and mock them since that is EXACTLY what they deserve.
 
Russell is the ONLY one in the "movement" that is anywhere near remotely reasonable that I've ever encountered. If there are others, please list them.

I agree. What's funny is that he spends a good deal of time debunking the real nutty folks but he still has this belief that what happened at the Pentagon wasn't as published. I can't figure him out in that respect. In fact, I have yet to read what HE thinks really happened...:boggled:
 
That is not accurate, enigma. It says no such thing.
Then borrow Gravy's clue bat and beat me about the head because I can't for the life of me see another meaning.

ETA - Be careful though because I might like it :)
 
Yes upon a really carefull reading it basically says they are either me or not me.


With all due respect, for the life of me I can't see how you managed to take that conclusion away from my post. And frankly, I don't believe it requires a great deal of "careful reading" to understand my main point: I don't think a reasonable, and rational, and informed, and honest, and mature, and mentally healthy individual can be a TMer. Do I believe those attributes can arguably be applied to myself? I sure hope so, at least some of the time, but that's not my point. I am not solely defined by a handful of attributes, no one is. Thus you don't have to be me to not be a TMer. But to be a TMer, I honestly feel one must lack one of the crucial traits I mentioned.

You can be reasonable and be a TMer. Or intelligent. Or rational. Or mature, or honest, or any of the rest. Thus you're likely to meet reasonable TMers, and ones who are honest, mature, mentally healthy, informed, and so on. But a TMer with the whole package? I haven't seen it yet, and I strongly believe it's simply not possible.
 
Last edited:
That is the key concept in your statement. But you ask for a list, instead of provideing one let me ask you to list every truther you have spoken to.

I don't know any personally. I don't move in those kinds of circles. All that I've encountered are on the 'net at LC, pft, etc.

I read posts on those sites just to keep informed. Who else is there?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom