"A Right to Know" pro-life brochure

I'm fully aware that in some cases babies have survived after the death of the mother. But if you make that argument, then the point at which the fetus achieves personhood depends on who is around and what level of technology they have available to them. The philosophical issue stills remains.

No. Completely shot down.
 
my short answer to this when people ask is, my body, my choice.
the real reply is that women fought too long not to have to undergo backyard abortions with cost hangers to let others decide what they can do. everyone's choice is different, people have no right to judge.

Why don't I have the right to Judge? We can judge anything we want, no?
 
I think that everybody should read this, regardless of which side you're on. Here's an excerpt:
A very good summary. Logically if a woman can be forced to endanger her life by carrying a fetus to term compulsory blood and organ harvesting is quite reasonable.

It's bad. It's a bad article.
Why? Because it exposes the nonsense at the heart of the "pro-life" arguments?
 
If you are prolife you argue that the fetus has autonomy over their own body.

Even if that were true...so? The rights of the fetus, whatever they may be, don't trump the rights of the woman.

If you are pro-choice.. the fetus is not human deserving of any rights.

Whether or not the fetus is human doesn't enter into the conversation. My argument is its irrelevant.

And a person doesn't have complete body autonomy. If I'm looking after my kids and I watch my kid fall in a kids pool or hit it's head and they die while I sit and watch.... A defense in court cannot be "I exercised my right to do with my body as I saw fit." (in this case nothing).

That has nothing to do with bodily autonomy. The argument's not saying that you should be able to do anything with your body as you see fit. That is clearly ridiculous. It would mean that you could murder, rob, etc., freely ignoring all laws, since you are taking actions "with your body". It says

Bodily autonomy means a person has control over who or what uses their body, for what, and for how long. It’s why you can’t be forced to donate blood, tissue, or organs. Even if you’re dead. Even if you’d save or improve 20 lives. It’s why someone can’t touch you, have sex with you,or use your body in any way without your continuous consent.

Do you think that people should be forced to donate blood, tissue, or organs?

A pro-lifer would argue that when you engage in sex, you have forfeit your right to call a fetus "there by permission". They are there cause they were put there, almost always by the free actions of the woman. That's different. The fetus didn't have a choice not to there. I like a lot of people, think that means something and for me at least some protections should be granted.

Again, the rights of the fetus, whatever they may be, do not trump the rights of the woman. I don't know anybody who is pro-choice who insists that the fetus must die. If the fetus is capable of living outside the woman's body, then steps should be taken to ensure that it survives the abortion.
 
Even if that were true...so? The rights of the fetus, whatever they may be, don't trump the rights of the woman.

Dude. That is what the fight is about. You think they do, a true prolifer thinks they don't. And people like me think in some cases the do.
 
Dude. That is what the fight is about. You think they do, a true prolifer thinks they don't. And people like me think in some cases the do.


While legitimate, such opinion is bordering if not in violation of human rights.

The American Convention on Human Rights is the only international human rights instrument that contemplates the application of the right to life from the moment of conception, though not in an unqualified manner. In 1981, the body that monitors the implementation of the human rights provisions in the American regional system—the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights—was asked to establish whether or not the right-to-life provisions in this convention and in the American Declaration on the Rights and Duties of Man are compatible with a woman’s right to access safe and legal abortions. The commission concluded that they are.

http://www.hrw.org/legacy/backgrounder/americas/argentina0605/

---

Human rights are universal, global, agreed upon, or ought to be so lets say radical pro-life undermines them and poses questions.
 
Do you think that people should be forced to donate blood, tissue, or organs?

I can envision a scenario where they should. If a mother needs to donate, say a pint of blood to save their child and lets say they refuse for some religious reason. Then yeah I have no problem making it happen... No problem at all.

If say someones blood could possibly save millions of people. Like say this guy.
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/art...-babies-half-century-donating-rare-blood.html
Maybe I would be in favor of forcing him to give it up. Maybe I wouldn't... but maybe I would. I'm not principally opposed to the idea. If I can convince myself that it is ok sometimes to drop atomic bombs on innocent civilians for the greater good, then I can probably convince myself to force someone to give blood.
 
Yes it would. I'd imagine they want to change that too.

Is there debate then at all or are there just two sides talking through each other? Well yes, everything is subject to change. Still, education about human rights, in general, should not be harmful.

Like when someone says about other human .. fish food. It can mean many things among them .. this person does not have human rights, and that is immediately problematic, because that is not how it works, how it ought to work.
 
Again, the rights of the fetus, whatever they may be, do not trump the rights of the woman. I don't know anybody who is pro-choice who insists that the fetus must die. If the fetus is capable of living outside the woman's body, then steps should be taken to ensure that it survives the abortion.

Again man, that's what it's about. True pro-life, fetus rights trumps the mothers rights. True pro-choice, they don't.

Or. If you are like me and a great many people, I'd argue the majority of people. The rights of a fetus should sometimes trump those of the mother.
 
Is there debate then at all or are there just two sides talking through each other?

That's kind of what it is. The fact of the matter is you can have a pretty air tight logical case for being prolife or prochoice. If I come on here spouting religious reasons for being prolife, that's not a very logical case, but I think one very well can be made, at least at some point in the pregnancy. Same with being prochoice, you can make a pretty good case for being prochoice... At some point you just have two sides that disagree and simply try to get enough support for their position.
 
Again man, that's what it's about. True pro-life, fetus rights trumps the mothers rights. True pro-choice, they don't.

Or. If you are like me and a great many people, I'd argue the majority of people. The rights of a fetus should sometimes trump those of the mother.

I am not going to exercise moral philosophy, I made my remarks I felt were important, but I come from culture where this is non-issue and I plan to keep it as such. Sometimes .. sometimes its necessary to kill other people. People.
 
I am not going to exercise moral philosophy, I made my remarks I felt were important, but I come from culture where this is non-issue and I plan to keep it as such. Sometimes .. sometimes its necessary to kill other people. People.

Yip, that's your opinion and I can't argue with that.
 
Again man, that's what it's about. True pro-life, fetus rights trumps the mothers rights. True pro-choice, they don't.

Or. If you are like me and a great many people, I'd argue the majority of people. The rights of a fetus should sometimes trump those of the mother.

Why would something that isn't even a fully-developed human being have more rights than a woman does? Something that isn't even born yet? How is that right? Please explain.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom