"A Right to Know" pro-life brochure

I don't remember my next question but from there we slowly got around to agreeing that a fetus is a "innocent human being" ....

I asked what her beliefs were, and she explained (with some additional questioning) that she believes in original sin.

I'd be interested in how she reconciles these two opposing views.

Sent from my Dell PC using my keyboard.

cullennz, can you turn off that annoying message, please.
 
Last edited:
Good question. I think she would draw a distinction between being guilty under god's laws versus our own laws. So a fetus is guilty of original sin but innocent of any law breaking that would result in a human being just in killing in response.

She got my email and I made a few points so I'll let you know how she responds. I may paste large points so as to not have to retype or rephrase anything. She says she'll think a bit and get back to me
 
Good question. I think she would draw a distinction between being guilty under god's laws versus our own laws. So a fetus is guilty of original sin but innocent of any law breaking that would result in a human being just in killing in response.
Hadn't thought of that "out". Should be interesting. Do you think she has a mentor/preacher/someone else helping her with the heavy lifting?
 
Hadn't thought of that "out". Should be interesting. Do you think she has a mentor/preacher/someone else helping her with the heavy lifting?

Is there much you do think about before you throw your big hay makers?
 
Hadn't thought of that "out". Should be interesting. Do you think she has a mentor/preacher/someone else helping her with the heavy lifting?

As I think I mentioned earlier, she came off as someone who at least is familiar with what her sect believes in (she didn't give me a name or anything, though I didn't ask). Presumably, she's spent a lot of time at church in the last 7-8 years that she says she's been a believer for.

Your question raises some potential other problems, though.

1) If only god determines who and when someone should be killed (how she reconciles the bad stuff in the bible) then what does the "innocent" distinction matter when it comes to abortion (or any) facet of life when "killing an innocent human being"???
2) If our own laws allow for us to kill people (rather than just god's command) then why does god's opinion on murder ever matter?

These are some off-the-cuff thoughts so they might have gaping logical holes in them heh
 
^I decided to email her to continue the conversation. Should be interesting.


I figured I'd take a moment to summarize some of our conversation now:

Because I read the brochure in advance, I started by challenging her position/premise that "killing innocent human beings is morally wrong" by pointing out that if this is true, then how are "medically necessary" (aka non-elective) abortions justified?
Unfortunately I don't really remember her response and should have pushed harder on this point, but I do recall her saying that non-elective abortions are incredibly rare (which I suspect to be true).

What I wanted to do was get her to admit that if she allows for abortions in SOME cases, then she is fine with people making the judgment as to whether or not an abortion (killing an innocent human being) is morally the better choice than not (for example when the life of the mother is threatened).

I don't remember my next question but from there we slowly got around to agreeing that a fetus is a "innocent human being" under their definition and that to me, being human is not sufficient to have rights. I explained that I believe a distinction between humans and persons is necessary to grant rights to people and to evaluate which rights people have.
She simply wouldn't agree with me on this point and appealed several times to "every example in history that people draw a distinction between humans and person it has been in order to oppress them" (jews, blacks, women, etc.). My only counter to this was that I don't care what the historical record is, it has no bearing on the validity of the present of future use of said distinction. I should have pointed out that we don't "oppress" children by giving them less rights.

Ultimately I said that the distinction to me for a person and a human is that a person has some cognitive ability which allows them to think and feel (beyond just simple pain recognition imo). . . though this definition is not set in stone for me. I'm certainly willing to hear what everyone else thinks.
For this reason, I consider the braindead and the unborn (up to a certain stage - which once again I leave undefined because this is not my expertise) to not be "persons". After a fetus reaches said point I think that the issue becomes more of a grey area, though I wouldn't say "NO" to abortions at said point under all circumstances (elective or not).

She then told me that a fetus can "feel pain" between 8-12 weeks and that most abortions take place at this time. I have no idea how true this is though I can't help but doubt it. Once again willing to hear what others know :)

She finished by saying I'm an ageist for my discrimination which I didn't disagree with at the time and I certainly agree with now. Then we moved on to religion as a side topic which is irrelevant mostly so I'll put it in spoilers:

I asked what her beliefs were, and she explained (with some additional questioning) that she believes in original sin and some other stuff. I forgot to ask if she was a young earther since she seemed to take adam and eve fairly literally and placed the blame for our sin on free will (which we have to have in order to love god!).
I challenged the system as unfair and pointed out that it seems like god is responsible for making us this way. I also pointed out that god would know in advance that many of us would fail his test in advance. I had to keep pushing the blame back to god when she tried to say it was Satan's fault (who also had free will) by pointing out that god created satan that way and would know.

I asked her how she reconciles the pro-abortion stuff in the bible and she appealed to the "thou shalt not kill" commandment :rolleyes: and explained that god gets to decide when some of us deserve to die such as the examples in the "old testament". She also says there's "plenty of anti-abortion stuff in the bible" which I personally doubt outweighs the pro-abortion stuff but whatever, I'm not a biblical scholar.

I asked what would happen to me as an unbeliever, and she said that hell was a place "without god" since "god is perfectly good". It wasn't clear to me whether this was some kind of annihilation theory or something but I want to keep questions to a minimum since it had been so long.

Finally, I asked her WHY she believed and she appealed to personal revelation and "further study" after this point. She also said that she believed god intervened in her life (made her look both ways when crossing the street for example). At some point I asked her how god is able to interfere with our free will in some instances (petty things like looking both ways) but not other stuff like making us love him but i don't remember her answer at this point.


Anyway, thanks for reading.. I'm going to bed

It sure sounds like you want this girl to have your abortion.
 
Ya I've been saving this fetus for a special someone. My GF doesn't make the cut, though :o
 
1) If only god determines who and when someone should be killed (how she reconciles the bad stuff in the bible) then what does the "innocent" distinction matter when it comes to abortion (or any) facet of life when "killing an innocent human being"???
This, in turn, raises the issue of miscarriages. If the fetus (baby) is innocent, why does god cause miscarriages?
 
Is there much you do think about before you throw your big hay makers?
Why, thank you, Caper. I've always viewed my posts as mere noise among the gems posted by others. Now I am surprised to learn they are "big hay makers". Wow. I now feel obligated to post even more.
 
This, in turn, raises the issue of miscarriages. If the fetus (baby) is innocent, why does god cause miscarriages?

I try to avoid "gotcha" questions but this is too perfect. I think I'll ask her eventually if religion comes back into the discussion
 
I try to avoid "gotcha" questions but this is too perfect. I think I'll ask her eventually if religion comes back into the discussion

Yes. Too perfect. Because never in the history of religion have religious people pondered the question "why do bad things happen to good people".
 
Yes. Too perfect. Because never in the history of religion have religious people pondered the question "why do bad things happen to good people".

Perfect may be an exaggeration but it's directly applicable to the discussion.
 
Perfect may be an exaggeration but it's directly applicable to the discussion.

What I mean is, if you are looking for some stomping question that's going to make her rethink her position, I don't think that one is it. Babies and infants have been dying forever, as long as the question "why would god let that happen". Yours is just another version of that.
 
Yes. Too perfect. Because never in the history of religion have religious people pondered the question "why do bad things happen to good people".
Why is a miscarriage a bad thing?

ETA: Opps, I think slyjoe beat me to it.
 
Last edited:
What I mean is, if you are looking for some stomping question that's going to make her rethink her position, I don't think that one is it.
Why do you suppose phaphis is looking for a "stomping question". From what little I can glean, he respects this person because she seems to have thought through some of the issues on Christianity so he is probing to see how deep her knowledge is. Maybe she has some insights that will change phaphis' mind.

Wow. There's my latest hay maker, eh, Caper?
 
Why is a miscarriage a bad thing?

I didn't say it was a bad thing.

You said:

If the fetus (baby) is innocent, why does god cause miscarriages?

I took that as a variation of the question of. Why does god let bad things happen to good people? In this case because the woman views the miscarried fetus as a person ((innocent (or good)).

pharphis said.

I try to avoid "gotcha" questions but this is too perfect.

As in your scenario would surely stump her. That is why I answered sarcastically, because I don't think it would.

Maybe I misunderstood.

Wow. There's my latest hay maker, eh, Caper?

The irony is it was... or maybe more of a jab. Either way, I don't think it landed.
 
Last edited:
I try to avoid "gotcha" questions but this is too perfect. I think I'll ask her eventually if religion comes back into the discussion
Most fertilised embryos fail to implant.

Yes. Too perfect. Because never in the history of religion have religious people pondered the question "why do bad things happen to good people".
But they have failed to answer the question.
 
But they have failed to answer the question.

No they haven't. They have failed to answer the question to your satisfaction (and maybe mine). But they have not failed to answer it. Or maybe they have in a literal sense have not answered the question, but they would say they addressed it as to make the question not as important an issue as you may think it is.
 
No they haven't. They have failed to answer the question to your satisfaction (and maybe mine). But they have not failed to answer it. Or maybe they have in a literal sense have not answered the question, but they would say they addressed it as to make the question not as important an issue as you may think it is.

Sorry dude but in English?

Sent from my GT-S6802 using Tapatalk 2
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom