"A Right to Know" pro-life brochure

The argument in the brochure is spelled out pretty clearly:

Premise 1: Intentionally killing an innocent human being is a serious moral wrong.
Premise 2: Elective abortion kills an innocent human being.
Conclusion: Elective abortion is a serious moral wrong.​

Seems pretty cut and dried.
Not to me. Premise 2 makes a huge assumption, namely, that a fetus is "an innocent human being" which is highly questionable. And there is that loaded word "innocent" again.

The brochure follows up by showing that a fetus is, in the scientifically literal sense:

- an individual: distinct from other living things
- living: characterized by growth, reproduction, metabolism, and response to stimuli
- human: has human DNA a human genetic signature
- an individual being: self-contained, self-integrating living entity with it's own nature​
Actually, in scientifically literal sense, a fetus is a parasite. It meets the very definition of one.

That's what the fight is about. They and I in some cases believe the unborn's right outweigh the adults.
I'd like to hear an example of where a parasite's rights outweigh an adult's rights.
 
Last edited:
I didn't go any further than this statement from the linked site:

That is just plain wrong. Science has not a jot to say about human beings being innocent or when a fetus becomes human. Philosophically, there is much debate on when a fetus is an "innocent human being" so the assertion that it is clear is wrong. They can hold their conviction all they want but their erroneous argument should sway nobody.

In addition, what does including the word "innocent" add to the argument? Innocent of what? What does innocent add to the argument? I think it is just used to be inflammatory for their position.


Yes. Who empowered them to speak for the unborn?
I think "innocent" is used so people don't reject the premise regarding killing (innocent) life. There are obvious exemptions to this if the person you're killing is trying to kill you, for example (in which case they're guilty of a (moral?) crime I guess)
 
But neither does a 1 day old. A 1 day old and a -1 day old are basically the same thing.
You must be joking. A -1 day old is completely dependent on the mother. She dies, it dies. A +1 day old can be completely independent of the mother. She dies but it lives. This is so fundamental I'm surprised it has to be mentioned.
 
One of my thoughts is that they paint "killing an innocent human being" as morally wrong in all cases (I might agree with this - not sure) without talking about how obviously there are other moral implications to abortion - not just the life of the unborn (is it morally wrong to cause mental anguish to someone who doesn't want to carry a child for 9 months?). The focus seems to solely be about right to life rather than minimization of suffering, which was something else I think is troublesome.*
I suggest you ask them to what degree it's acceptable to them to endanger the woman's life.

*Does someone in a vegetative state with no brain function (you know, beyond breathing and whatever) have the "Right to life"? How is this different than an unborn, unthinking and unfeeling fetus (or earlier) state of development?
According to many of the anti-abortion crowd even someone brain dead should be kept alive artificially. Though of course artificially interfering in conception is wrong.

That shady line where morals and medicine collide
Like with the brain dead, organ transplantation, management of limited resources, use of addictive analgesic drugs, assisted suicide, 'pay-for-performance' indices, compelling patients to accept treatment and the whole concept of 'defensive medicine'.
It's not a line, it's a huge expanse.
 
my short answer to this when people ask is, my body, my choice.
the real reply is that women fought too long not to have to undergo backyard abortions with cost hangers to let others decide what they can do. everyone's choice is different, people have no right to judge.
 
I suggest you ask them to what degree it's acceptable to them to endanger the woman's life.


According to many of the anti-abortion crowd even someone brain dead should be kept alive artificially. Though of course artificially interfering in conception is wrong.

I differ on this question. I considering people in a vegetative state to no longer have personhood (I think this is the right term). I know the brochure certainly paints a distinction between personhood and "human being" to be arbitrary but I don't agree with that.

The "clubs day" atmosphere isn't a good place for this kind of question since it's very loud and I'm too lazy to go to their actual club meetings but that is a good question.
 
Well apparently it's still clubs day so I might hop by and pick up whatever else they had and ask some questions now that I'm more prepared and I've slept on it.

I think asking why abortion is EVER acceptable (not just elective) if "killing innocent human beings is ALWAYS morally wrong" is a good idea.

If they're willing to ever concede that abortion can be acceptable then I think their entire argument breaks down because the "innocent human being" as they have defined it is not any different if the mother's life is at risk, it's a "rape baby", or any other number of factors where they might allow for it.
 
You must be joking. A -1 day old is completely dependent on the mother. She dies, it dies. A +1 day old can be completely independent of the mother. She dies but it lives. This is so fundamental I'm surprised it has to be mentioned.

Assuming normal term, a -1 day old can live independent of the mother if she dies. Assuming someone is present to remove it from the mother's body. I believe babies routinely survive when born a couple months early. Occasionally, delivery occurs after the mother dies:


When the doctors gently pulled the tiny newborn from the womb in an emergency caesarean, her mother had already been dead for an hour.

Shayma al-Sheikh Qanan, 23, was eight months pregnant when an Israeli tank shell hit her home in the central Gaza strip town of Deir al-Balah, reducing it to rubble. She was left in a critical condition. Her husband, a local radio journalist, was also badly wounded.

"Her body was brought in after an Israeli shelling at 3am on Friday," said Fadi al-Kharti, a doctor at Deir al-Balah hospital. "We tried to revive her but she had died on the way."

Before paramedics managed to dig her out, she had been stuck under the rubble of her home for an hour. "Then we noticed movement in her stomach, and estimated she was about 36 weeks pregnant," he says. Doctors performed an immediate caesarean and saved the baby, who was named after her late mother.

http://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/jul/28/baby-born-caesarean-gaza-after-mother-dies

Another example:

http://ktla.com/2014/09/01/newborn-boy-recovering-after-his-mothers-tragic-death/

The point is that at some point before birth a baby becomes capable of living outside the womb. Some people think that at this point it is a separate life. Most of the pro-choice people I know (myself included) actually fall into this camp. I'm not sure I know anyone who would say it's perfectly fine to abort seven or eight months into a pregnancy. That does not make them anti-abortion, it means that they believe that the line has been crossed where the fetus is no longer a part of the mother, but is a separate individual.

Of course, hardcore pro-life people feel that this line is crossed at conception. Extreme pro-choice people believe that this line is only crossed at birth. I've found that some people who are really somewhere in between argue from the standpoint of the position they are closest to.
 
You must be joking. A -1 day old is completely dependent on the mother. She dies, it dies. A +1 day old can be completely independent of the mother. She dies but it lives. This is so fundamental I'm surprised it has to be mentioned.

That is the exact same as a 1 day old. Mother dies and no one else is around baby dies. And like Tom says. If some one is around for the -1 day old when the mother dies, they can usually live.

So your fundamental premise is well......... wrong. Nice try.
 
Not to me. Premise 2 makes a huge assumption, namely, that a fetus is "an innocent human being" which is highly questionable. And there is that loaded word "innocent" again.


Actually, in scientifically literal sense, a fetus is a parasite. It meets the very definition of one.

Wow.
 
I wont bother, but focusing on DNA like you do is simply ignorant.

I didn't. In the context I used it, I could have used the word species. It was in reference as to why I put human life ahead of say... a ducks.
 
"A Right To Know" also refers to concept where children have right to know their biological parents. On this bases fathers cannot "abort" a child same way mothers can, fathers cannot refuse to be recorded as fathers. Also this right comes to the debate around the so-called baby boxes. Those to me are more controversial than the right to know from OP. Of course, a right to know, for abortion please consult appropriate case studies.
 
If they're willing to ever concede that abortion can be acceptable then I think their entire argument breaks down because the "innocent human being" as they have defined it is not any different if the mother's life is at risk, it's a "rape baby", or any other number of factors where they might allow for it.

It doesn't break down at all. If they are willing to concede that abortion is sometimes acceptable, then they must be backing off the point that killing an innocent human being is always wrong. Also, their position may take practical sacrifices for the greater good. Allow a rape exception, because you can't win without it. You can still believe in the innocence of the child, but realize you must comprise in order to further your other goals.
 
It doesn't break down at all. If they are willing to concede that abortion is sometimes acceptable, then they must be backing off the point that killing an innocent human being is always wrong. Also, their position may take practical sacrifices for the greater good. Allow a rape exception, because you can't win without it. You can still believe in the innocence of the child, but realize you must comprise in order to further your other goals.

Isn't this contradictory? The premise is that killing innocent human beings is always morally wrong, but the admission that in some circumstances this is allowable is an admission that either 1) it's not always morally wrong or that 2) sometimes this "moral wrong" can be equal or lesser in weight compared to the alternative (eg/ rape baby). This flies in the face of their first premise.


BTW, I did talk to the girl there for about an hour today and got a lot of useful discussion... I'll add more when I'm back from a bus ride, or tomorrow, or something
 
I think that everybody should read this, regardless of which side you're on. Here's an excerpt:

There’s a concept called bodily autonomy. It’s generally considered a human right. Bodily autonomy means a person has control over who or what uses their body, for what, and for how long. It’s why you can’t be forced to donate blood, tissue, or organs. Even if you’re dead. Even if you’d save or improve 20 lives. It’s why someone can’t touch you, have sex with you,or use your body in any way without your continuous consent.
 
Real men chew through it and then stand looking manly with their hands on their hips.

Preferably wearng steel cap boots and a sleeve rolled up to show their tattoo

Sent from my GT-S6802 using Tapatalk 2

Real men wait in the pub across the road from the hospital with a pocket full of cigars (I was determined that any children I had were going to be born on the "1950's Ward")
 
Assuming normal term, a -1 day old can live independent of the mother if she dies. Assuming someone is present to remove it from the mother's body. I believe babies routinely survive when born a couple months early. Occasionally, delivery occurs after the mother dies:

....

The point is that at some point before birth a baby becomes capable of living outside the womb.
I'm fully aware that in some cases babies have survived after the death of the mother. But if you make that argument, then the point at which the fetus achieves personhood depends on who is around and what level of technology they have available to them. The philosophical issue stills remains.
 
I think that everybody should read this, regardless of which side you're on. Here's an excerpt:

You think everybody should read it because... why?

It's bad. It's a bad article.

If you are prolife you argue that the fetus has autonomy over their own body. If you are pro-choice.. the fetus is not human deserving of any rights. The article gets us no where.

And a person doesn't have complete body autonomy. If I'm looking after my kids and I watch my kid fall in a kids pool or hit it's head and they die while I sit and watch.... A defense in court cannot be "I exercised my right to do with my body as I saw fit." (in this case nothing). A pro-lifer would argue that when you engage in sex, you have forfeit your right to call a fetus "there by permission". They are there cause they were put there, almost always by the free actions of the woman. That's different. The fetus didn't have a choice not to there. I like a lot of people, think that means something and for me at least some protections should be granted.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom