"A Right to Know" pro-life brochure

I didn't say it was a bad thing.

You said:



I took that as a variation of the question of. Why does god let bad things happen to good people? In this case because the woman views the miscarried fetus as a person ((innocent (or good)).

pharphis said.



As in your scenario would surely stump her. That is why I answered sarcastically, because I don't think it would.

Maybe I misunderstood.



The irony is it was... or maybe more of a jab. Either way, I don't think it landed.

No they haven't. They have failed to answer the question to your satisfaction (and maybe mine). But they have not failed to answer it. Or maybe they have in a literal sense have not answered the question, but they would say they addressed it as to make the question not as important an issue as you may think it is.

Fair enough.

I think it's directly implied that a miscarriage is a "bad thing" because under the worldview of someone who believes life and human rights start at conception, that the "death" of the embryo (?) is bad and so in this case god is at least in part responsible, depending on how much one thinks god intervenes in people's lives (didn't stop it, directly caused it, or other...?)
 
Sorry dude but in English?

Sent from my GT-S6802 using Tapatalk 2

He just means to say that they have answers for the problem of "why do bad things happen to good people" but that non-theists generally find them not satisfactory.

Ultimately, I think the appeal will be to "god made us so he can do whatever he wants" in which case I would wonder how that makes a parent's ownership of a child any different. I think they would have to commit special pleading but maybe there are more answers. Perhaps they would argue that because god is perfectly good (or it's his "nature", or whatever they say) that his actions are by definition good whereas a human is fallible and not perfectly good.

I would then ask how they know god is perfectly good and if they appeal to "his word" at all I couldn't help but point out that an evil god would be willing to lie about being perfectly good in order to dupe everyone.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom