Dancing David
Penultimate Amazing
Oh, and one more thing: These arguments, even if they are correct, do not prove that p-zombies and qualia do not exist, merely that the concepts are nonsensical. I have no proof as yet that the universe is required to make sense.
Ture words. There is the universe, maybe, which we apparently percieve. There are thoughts and words used to decribe the universe. In science there is an idea that there are concepts and words which can approxiamate the way the universe appears to behave. In philosophy an attempt is made to deliniate the ways that humans can describe and explore the thought structures of humans. In literature an effort is made to deliniate the nature of experience.
As a nihilist I say that it is all nonsense, it is only which area of possible communication you wish to focus upon that makes the non existant difference.