9/11 New information.

To my mind, that makes them untrustworthy. If they are unreliable with the truth, then who are they best serving?

I don't like secrets and lies, especially in positions of authority. I don't care if it's a doctor, a policeman, a journalist, or a politician, I would rather they had some integrity.....

Sorry, I don't know the correct term, but implying it's all or nothing is a fallacy.

The frustrating thing - for many of us here who are trying to help you - is made obvious in the ironic contrast of those two consecutive and contradictory posts.

The recurring theme of your posts is your repeated use of "implying it's all or nothing" demands for perfection. As shown by the first post I quoted above.

So please stop calling on us on "all or nothing" fallacies when it is your own primary base of argument and one you are not prepared to abandon.

You need to make your mind up - none of us can help you clarify your reasoning processes.

And the double irony I will wager is that you cannot see the direct conflict between your two consecutive posts.
 
A lot of the time I don't like the UK and I really can't wait for Scotland to become independent and sever our dependency on the scum and villainy in Westminster.

Good luck with that.................Do you really think this change will create the government you envision? :rolleyes:
 
The frustrating thing - for many of us here who are trying to help you - is made obvious in the ironic contrast of those two consecutive and contradictory posts.

The recurring theme of your posts is your repeated use of "implying it's all or nothing" demands for perfection. As shown by the first post I quoted above.

So please stop calling on us on "all or nothing" fallacies when it is your own primary base of argument and one you are not prepared to abandon.

You need to make your mind up - none of us can help you clarify your reasoning processes.

And the double irony I will wager is that you cannot see the direct conflict between your two consecutive posts.

Nope, I'm obviously too thick for your subtleties. How have I slipped up now and shown my underlying motivations, and let you glimpse the cunning traps I am weaving.

Obviously me failing to spot the difference between full disclosure and honesty has something zionist lizard aliens amongst us!
 
Blew over your head.
Completely - see his response and my intervening post which "crossed in posting".

Unable to process a complex of multiple factors without simplistically reducing it to "me" v "the rest of you" - where "authority'/"government"/"the Man" cops the blame for his inability to process reality.
 
Nope, I'm obviously too thick for your subtleties. How have I slipped up now and shown my underlying motivations, and let you glimpse the cunning traps I am weaving.

Obviously me failing to spot the difference between full disclosure and honesty has something zionist lizard aliens amongst us!
Resorting to word salad will not help. Nor will it influence or irritate me. I am fairly proof against trolling after ~10 years activity on forums. I have a simple "two posts rule" when dealing with members who raise issues. I will explain where I can provided the other person is interested in serious honest debate. If the evasive nonsense or other trickery continues two posts - without a component of honest reasoned discussion - I simply withdraw from the discussion with that person.

You have one more post to become serious.

I repeat the offer - I am willing to help you work through your issues of concern if you ever decide to stop insulting game playing and get serious.
 
Completely - see his response and my intervening post which "crossed in posting".

Unable to process a complex of multiple factors without simplistically reducing it to "me" v "the rest of you" - where "authority'/"government"/"the Man" cops the blame for his inability to process reality.
I didn't miss it...............;)
 
Resorting to word salad will not help. Nor will it influence or irritate me. I am fairly proof against trolling after ~10 years activity on forums. I have a simple "two posts rule" when dealing with members who raise issues. I will explain where I can provided the other person is interested in serious honest debate. If the evasive nonsense or other trickery continues two posts - without a component of honest reasoned discussion - I simply withdraw from the discussion with that person.

You have one more post to become serious.

I repeat the offer - I am willing to help you work through your issues of concern if you ever decide to stop insulting game playing and get serious.

I have no idea what word salad means.

You fail to explain why you think my posts were contradictory. I don't see it. Perhaps you have inferred something from my words incorrectly, that seems to happen a lot here.

Being unreliable with the truth is giving misleading answers or evading questions, and other dirty tricks. The opposite of this is not, as alluded to, the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth. There is the fallacy.

DGM assumed incorrectly that I wanted complete disclosure all of the time, and yet he appears to accept lies as an acceptable answer to a question that he does not need to know the answer to. He is happy for his government to lie to him if they think he doesn't deserve an answer.

I would rather have the truth, even if that truth is "We cannot answer that at this time".
 
DGM assumed incorrectly that I wanted complete disclosure all of the time, and yet he appears to accept lies as an acceptable answer to a question that he does not need to know the answer to. He is happy for his government to lie to him if they think he doesn't deserve an answer.


What makes you think I accept lies? Please show me the lies I have accepted?

You really need to think before you put words in my mouth. I'll wait for you to show the lies I accept.
 
What makes you think I accept lies? Please show me the lies I have accepted?

You really need to think before you put words in my mouth. I'll wait for you to show the lies I accept.

Now who has things blowing over his head. You are willing to accept lies as a filter to the whole truth, or you wouldn't have brought it up.

If that's not what you are trying to say, then you need to back up a few steps and try again. Your stance was that tactical truth is better than the whole truth as if there were no other options.
 
Now who has things blowing over his head. You are willing to accept lies as a filter to the whole truth, or you wouldn't have brought it up.

If that's not what you are trying to say, then you need to back up a few steps and try again. Your stance was that tactical truth is better than the whole truth as if there were no other options.
What lies?

I said there was a filter for need to know information. You assume it has to be lies.

Tell me the lies you claim I believe.
 
I don't like secrets and lies, especially in positions of authority. I don't care if it's a doctor, a policeman, a journalist, or a politician, I would rather they had some integrity.


So you have no problem with your doctor posting your personal medical history in public?

Then you want to journalists to conduct business in a way that insures secrecy as they would not be able to protect anonymous sources, lest they lose their jobs or get murdered depending on their subject matter.

Or are some things best kept secret with limited access? Are some secrets better kept from public view?

I live in a land where Donald Trump might be handed nuclear weapons via a popular election. He is being elected by people who think that the government is "out of control" and "can't be trusted". I wonder where they get that idea?
 
So you have no problem with your doctor posting your personal medical history in public?

Would you rather your doctor wrote what he liked, and told you nothing?

Then you want to journalists to conduct business in a way that insures secrecy as they would not be able to protect anonymous sources, lest they lose their jobs or get murdered depending on their subject matter.

Would you rather no journalism at all? You only learn what you can track down yourself?

Or are some things best kept secret with limited access? Are some secrets better kept from public view?

I live in a land where Donald Trump might be handed nuclear weapons via a popular election. He is being elected by people who think that the government is "out of control" and "can't be trusted". I wonder where they get that idea?

That scares the **** out of me, more than when Reagan was voted in.
 
What lies?

I said there was a filter for need to know information. You assume it has to be lies.

Tell me the lies you claim I believe.

Again, you seem to equate willing to accept with has accepted.

If you aren't, then you need to back up and try a different tack.

Either there are more options or there aren't. You can't have it both ways.

Check your sig about bogging down a debate in bollocks, you are very, very good at it.
 
I have no idea what word salad means.

It means a collection of words that make no sense whatsoever, and barely even form coherent sentences. Maybe a bit of an overstatement, but I think you got a bit lost in the middle of a sentence and ended up not making a lot of sense.

Dave
 
Again, you seem to equate willing to accept with has accepted.

If you aren't, then you need to back up and try a different tack.

Either there are more options or there aren't. You can't have it both ways.

Check your sig about bogging down a debate in bollocks, you are very, very good at it.
You said I accept lies. Give an example.

Do you need me to quote where you said this? My sig portraits exactly what you are doing.

Back-up or retract your claim.
 
It means a collection of words that make no sense whatsoever, and barely even form coherent sentences. Maybe a bit of an overstatement, but I think you got a bit lost in the middle of a sentence and ended up not making a lot of sense.

Dave

I think he got nervous when I mentioned lizards, and now he's wondering what I know, that he knows I know. I have also just watched Pontypool which is a thoroughly decent movie and good fun.
 
You said I accept lies. Give an example.

Do you need me to quote where you said this? My sig portraits exactly what you are doing.

Back-up or retract your claim.

Go on then, knock yourself out, fill your boots. Quote me up baby.
 
Go on then, knock yourself out, fill your boots. Quote me up baby.
I thought so.....................

You do know people can read............

DGM assumed incorrectly that I wanted complete disclosure all of the time, and yet he appears to accept lies as an acceptable answer to a question that he does not need to know the answer to. He is happy for his government to lie to him if they think he doesn't deserve an answer.

Now who has things blowing over his head. You are willing to accept lies as a filter to the whole truth, or you wouldn't have brought it up.

If that's not what you are trying to say, then you need to back up a few steps and try again. Your stance was that tactical truth is better than the whole truth as if there were no other options.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom