9/11 New information.

Seriously? Corners were cut? The union leadership and cement providers would never stand for that. Many of them come from old NY Families.

The implication from Bailey is indeed that corners were cut in that the flutes were not filled with SFRM when they were required to be.

I did say that this was an incomplete theory, it needs a lot of work. It is something that I have only come upon recently and haven't had the chance to fully look into.

Bailey asserts that the vacant flutes played a significant role in the structural integrity of the steel in building 7 when subjected to heat over time.

If true, and if that is in breach of code, then there may be a case to answer.

It really depends on the individuals discussing it in court. It may be true, but deemed irrelevant, or it may be true and it's relevance is dismissed, or it may be false.
 
Probably nothing. And - until AClark or paloalto makes a claim I'm not going looking.

New member AClark is playing "newbie truther' by regurgitating many of the long dead canards - and employing all the standard "truther debating trickery".

AFAICS AClark has not yet played the truther trick of argumentio by youtubium

...so paloalto probably thinks AClark needs help. ;)

...PA is sort of saying "You've played a lot of tricks there AClark - here's one you missed."
Bullseye.

Do we still have any of those truther bingo cards left?
 
The implication from Bailey is indeed that corners were cut in that the flutes were not filled with SFRM when they were required to be.

I did say that this was an incomplete theory, it needs a lot of work. It is something that I have only come upon recently and haven't had the chance to fully look into.

Bailey asserts that the vacant flutes played a significant role in the structural integrity of the steel in building 7 when subjected to heat over time.

If true, and if that is in breach of code, then there may be a case to answer.

It really depends on the individuals discussing it in court. It may be true, but deemed irrelevant, or it may be true and it's relevance is dismissed, or it may be false.

You're in the 9/11 Conspiracies sub forum, please explain what any of this has to do with that.
 
You're in the 9/11 Conspiracies sub forum, please explain what any of this has to do with that.


Think of it as the 9/11 version of the guy who runs a red light and totals your car, and then insists in court that you're partly to blame because you hadn't changed your oil as often as the manufacturer recommended.
 
The implication from Bailey is indeed that corners were cut in that the flutes were not filled with SFRM when they were required to be.

I did say that this was an incomplete theory, it needs a lot of work. It is something that I have only come upon recently and haven't had the chance to fully look into.
Then come back when you can make a legitimate claim in a legitimate setting OR ask for help but please say what you need the help with..

If you need help say so and some of us will probably provide it. BUT keep spraying truther crap and you will not improve your understanding.

Bailey asserts that the vacant flutes played a significant role in the structural integrity of the steel in building 7 when subjected to heat over time.
In what context did he make that assertion? For what purpose? What is your purpose in quoting it here? SPECIFICALLY (yeah - I know - that word again.:( ) what claim are YOU making that relies on Bailey's work and what difference does that detail make to YOUR claim.

If true, and if that is in breach of code, then there may be a case to answer.
MAY? By whom? In what action? Against who? What jurisdiction?
It really depends on the individuals discussing it in court. <<Yes - and that will only arise if someone with standing to do so raises it in a legitimate legal action in the appropriate jurisdiction. AND - probably a surprise to you - >>>> it is past history - it happened and >> It may be true*, but deemed irrelevant*, or it may be true* and it's relevance is dismissed*, or it may be false*. << Yes, yes, yes, yes and "true but the issue of fact wasn't tested in court" -- respectively.
 
Last edited:
The implication from Bailey is indeed that corners were cut in that the flutes were not filled with SFRM when they were required to be.
At best then its a fault in design, perhaps one might just be able to claim an incompetance. It quite obviously has no bearing at all on a conspiracy to bring down WTC 7 let alone any other event on 9/11/01.
(Unless one s making the ridiculous claim that this was all planned several decades ahead of 2001.)

Bailey asserts that the vacant flutes played a significant role in the structural integrity of the steel in building 7 when subjected to heat over time.

If true, and if that is in breach of code, then there may be a case to answer.
Is it a code breach? Was that part of the fire code when the structure was built?
 
I took a look. Unfortunately the Mac I am on has decided it won't play the video. It gets hung up on the preceding advertisement.
Until I manage to get to another computer, could someone tell me how long the video is?
15:36

It is a dramatised LIHOP claim. Theme "9/11 could have been prevented/stopped/avoided". Running off the Cole bombing incident and setting up FBI as the "good guys" and "CIA" as the baddies. With lots of 20/20 hindsight and zero recognition of Intell Operational realities. The content is of little relevant to 9/11 discussion - 9/11 happened so "what if" scenarios are of limited value as hypotheticals.

One sub-theme says - in effect - my words - "If we had killed the 9/11 hijackers earlier they couldn't have flown the planes".

WOW.
 
Last edited:
It's not so much as a LIHOP as much as a what seemed cross purposes... CIA wanting to infiltrate AQ and FBI wanting to snag and try terrorists who had done the Cole for example.
CIA NEEDS an AQ to spy on.... without the "threat" their anti terror mission is without a target. What was the CIA intending to do? It seems that there were leads which might have led to 9/11 being stopped.... but no one was actively pursuing them. But why? CIA bumbling or CIA malfeasance? Both?

And of course CIA uses these proxy guys to cause trouble around the globe when they need it.
 
Last edited:
It's not so much as a LIHOP as much as a what seemed cross purposes... CIA wanting to infiltrate AQ and FBI wanting to snag and try terrorists who had done the Cole for example.

Don't confuse means with ends Sander. (Causes and effects if you prefer those words.)

"we could have stopped 9/11 if we didn't have inter-agency barriers/jealousies/rivalries/conflicts of interest."

So we let it happen.


END (or "effect") - it was LIHOP
MEANS (or "cause") - because the CIA kept info from the FBI
 
Last edited:
Don't confuse means with ends Sander. (Causes and effects if you prefer those words.)

"we could have stopped 9/11 if we didn't have inter-agency barriers/jealousies/rivalries/conflicts of interest."

So we let it happen.


END (or "effect") - it was LIHOP
MEANS (or "cause") - because the CIA kept info from the FBI

let and failed to prevent are different... no?
 
let and failed to prevent are different... no?

How do you fail to prevent secret attacks you have no clue are coming, or how it is coming.

All we knew for sure is UBL promised to kill USA people, when and where he could. He promised, why did we fail? Gee, why do 40,000 to 50,000 die in accident every year, we were warned we could crash, why do 10s of thousands crash when we knew it was going to happen?

lol, it appears to be BS opinion for those who think 911 could be stopped with mind reading, or what ends up being the BS of, could have, should have, would have... with big IFs all over the place.

Why did you fail to stop 911; why did I fail? Next time you are attacked by surprize, who will you blame.

The blame for who let 911 happen, are 19 idiots for UBL. Darn that was easy. Blame the people who did it, not the people who can't imagine idiots rushing the cockpit and cutting pilots throats with small knives...

But go ahead, make up BS about why we blame others for the action of 19.

this is general notes on the BS of stopping 911, because some CIA agents think they could have, should have, and would have, IF


I/or a crew member carried a weapon when we carried PAX... we decided to kill anyone who threatened the cockpit, unless it was a hijacking to RIO...
Boss we had to go, ... yep... he had a gun.... yep
Thus if you hijack my crew, be sure to say we are going to RIO before we shoot you...
 
let and failed to prevent are different... no?

Sure but no need to play word games with me on that. I'm well aware of the difference between LIHOP and LIHOOI - I've been making the point for many years. And getting ignored. How often do we even see LIHOOI discussed when the usual argument is "MIHOP OR LIHOP" (Plus a ruddy big false assumption about the structural taxonomy of the topic....but let that pass... ;))

Organisational incompetence could be LIHOOI

...BUT the main point in the video is that CIA deliberately.....

...and that could be interpreted as active not passive - maybe Making not Letting

BUT given the crudity of logic we see on MIHOP LIHOP on these forums the subtlety of distinction is something you and I can muse on.


So good for you picking the distinction - that makes two of us. :thumbsup:
 
let and failed to prevent are different... no?
How do you fail to prevent secret attacks you have no clue are coming, or how it is coming.
That is the central issue and the problem is even more complicated.

Actually the reality in those situations isn't black or white; yes or no.

Its judging multiple factors and most of them shades of poorly defined grey.

Every one of them a probability based call - not binary yes or no.
 
Does that equal LIHOP? No, it just equals a messed up system that failed to make sure all the information available was in the hands of those that needed it because two agencies were more interested in play politics than working together to ensure the safety of the US.

It's not "a messed up system that failed" it was people. They have names. The only reason we are talking about it is because John O'Neill made sure "the System" had FBI agents in the CIA Bin Ladin unit. If it were not for Doug Miller and Mark Rossini, this CIA secret would remain hidden today.

The good part is they are not saying they let it happen on purpose... the 911 truth conclusion.

Actually, they are saying the information was withheld on purpose. And they don't know why, because The CIA wont tell them.

Lots of LIHOOI must have occurred and near certain bits of LIHOP and MIHOP.

BUT at section/agency/inter-agency levels NOT one overall master plan.

That is what "a messed up system" means.

LIHOOI LIHOP MIHOP ZIHOP I don't care about Internet truther/debunker made up garbage. Although my personal favorite would be the IHOP Pancake theory.

You folks are aware aren't you, that this is a theory. The theory that the reason the CIA withheld this info was to recruit. The CIA says this theory is "baseless, and unworthy of serious consideration."

Joint Statement from George J. Tenet, Cofer Black and Richard Blee

Clarke starts with the presumption that important information on the travel of future hijackers to the United States was intentionally withheld from him in early 2000. It was not.

https://www.scribd.com/doc/62083444/Joint-Statement

See? The CIA says that Clarke is a liar. So is Lawrence Wright...

After September 11th, the C.I.A. claimed that it had divulged Mihdhar’s identity to the F.B.I. in a timely manner; indeed, both George Tenet, the agency’s director, and Cofer Black, the head of its counterterrorism division, testified to Congress that this was the case. Later, the 9/11 Commission concluded that the statements of both were false. The C.I.A. was unable to produce evidence proving that the information had been passed to the bureau.
http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2006/07/10/the-agent

Joint Statement from George J. Tenet, Cofer Black and Richard Blee continued...

The handling of the information in question was exhaustively looked at by the 9/11 Commission, the Congressional Joint Inquiry, the CIA Inspector General and other groups.
https://www.scribd.com/doc/62083444/Joint-Statement

See? The trust worthy CIA is telling the truth.

looked at by the 9/11 Commission:

executive director of the 9/11 Commission: “The FBI is telling the truth,” Philip Zelikow, executive director of the 9/11 Commission, told Newsweek. As for why the CIA not only failed to share pre-9/11 information on Al-Qaeda operatives but forbade the FBI agents in Alec Station from sharing it, Zelikow said, “We don’t know.”
http://www.newsweek.com/2015/01/23/information-could-have-stopped-911-299148.html

Yup it was looked at by the 9/11 Commission

the Congressional Joint Inquiry:

Co-Chairman of the Congressional Joint Inquiry Sen Richard Shelby.....
GWEN IFILL: Senator Shelby let’s talk about accountability. You have been quoted on more than one occasion and again today talking about the CIA, George Tenet, the director of Central Intelligence – saying that more massive failures occurred on his watch than any CIA director in history.


Do you think he should resign?

SEN. RICHARD SHELBY: Well, I have spoken on that before. I would like him to resign. Whether he stays there is up to President Bush.

GWEN IFILL: You call Louis Freeh’s tenure at the FBI catastrophic I think is the word you used.
http://www.pbs.org/newshour/bb/politics-july-dec02-intelligence_12-11/

Yup, just like the statement said, looked at by the Congressional Joint Inquiry

CIA Inspector General:

Agrees with the JI(Joint Inquiry)that IC agencies, including the CIA, did not adequately share relevant information before 9/11.

Critical information related to the 9/11 attacks that was not adequately shared included:
Al-Mihdhar and al-Hazmi,
who had been linked__________________________

http://www.foia.cia.gov/sites/default/files/DOC_0006184107.pdf

Yup, just like the CIA said looked at by the CIA Inspector General.

Joint Statement from George J. Tenet, Cofer Black and Richard Blee continued......

Building on his false notion that information was intentionally withheld, Mr. Clarke went on to speculate--which he admits is based on nothing other than his imagination--that the CIA might have been trying to recruit these two future hijackers as agents.

Mr. Clarke has suddenly invented baseless allegations which are belied by the record and unworthy of serious consideration.

https://www.scribd.com/doc/62083444/Joint-Statement

CIA debunks this silly theory! Actually there are other theories. But they surely will be debunked by these nice honest heroes of 9-11as well.

That is what "a messed up system" means = It means no accountability, because the system was fine. It was people in the system being rewarded for failure that is messed up. This is a recipe for corruption.


Senator Shelby let’s talk about accountability. You have been quoted on more than one occasion and again today talking about the CIA, George Tenet, the director of Central Intelligence – saying that more massive failures occurred on his watch than any CIA director in history.

You call Louis Freeh’s tenure at the FBI catastrophic I think is the word you used.

http://www.pbs.org/newshour/bb/politics-july-dec02-intelligence_12-11/

Why is he so mean? I hope these guys are alright. They are just part of "the messed up system".

The leaders of the CIA and FBI have done pretty good for themselves.

In any fair world Tenet would be tried for criminal incompetence. Instead, he got the Presidential Medal of Freedom and after resigning in 2004 (at which point his agency salary was south of $200,000), he received a $4 million advance to write a memoir.


Tenet has received millions more in his current role as managing director of a privately held New York investment bank and as a board director and advisor to intelligence and military contractors.

When he headed the CIA, Tenet lived in a ranch house in Potomac, Maryland, which he bought in 1986 for $179,000.

Then there’s Louis Freeh, Tenet’s counterpart at the FBI during the run-up to 9/11. (He resigned a few months before the attacks.)Freeh resigned from the FBI two months before 9/11. When he worked there he was making an annual salary of $145,000 and lived “in a heavily mortgaged house in Great Falls, a Virginia suburb,”. He and his wife now own at least four lavish estates worth many millions of dollars, including a residence in Wilmington, Delaware, a six-bedroom summerhouse worth more than $3 million in Vermont, and a beachfront penthouse at 100 Worth Avenue in Palm Beach, Florida, which was bought for $1.4 million and now has an estimated value of $3 million. He also opened up a consulting firm whose clients have included Saudi Arabia’s Prince Bandar.

https://theintercept.com/2014/12/31/winner-war-terror-financed-dream-home-2014-giveaway/

Being the head of the FBI when Bandar was funneling money to what the FBI describes as "an Ardent UBL Supporter" through Riggs Bank Accounts, money that......
....made its way into the hands of hijackers, according to the 9/11 report.
http://www.ibtimes.com/911-link-sau...nment-report-congressmen-push-release-1501202

On October 9, members of the special congressional committee investigating the 9/11 attacks met privately with a key FBI witness.
Several members were "appalled" at what informed sources described as the "explosive" testimony of Special Agent Steven Butler, who recently retired from the FBI after his final posting in the bureau's San Diego field office.


Government officials told U.S. News that Butler disclosed that he had been monitoring a flow of Saudi Arabian money that wound up in the hands of two of the 9/11 hijackers. The two men had rented a room from a man Butler had used as a confidential informant, the sources say. According to officials familiar with his account, Butler said that he had alerted his superiors about the money flows but the warning went nowhere. "Butler is claiming ... that people [in the FBI] didn't follow up," says a congressional source. Adds another: "He saw a pattern, a trail, and he told his supervisors, but it ended there."
https://web.archive.org/web/2002120...ews.com/usnews/news/features/saudi_021129.htm

The Head of the FBI at the time should know how innocent our Saudi friend is, so a logical choice. I hope his fees are reasonable.

Former FBI chief defends flow of money to Saudi ambassador
Freeh, who is now a lawyer and consultant for Bandar, made his comments to the Public Broadcasting Service for a "Frontline" documentary to be broadcast this evening.

http://articles.latimes.com/2009/apr/07/nation/na-freeh7

Frankly I'm glad these guys made out pretty good. I hope it helps heal their wounds for the massive failure of "the system they were in".

The FBI Informant, housing these two hijackers, who is a liar according to the Joint Inquiry, The Joint Inquiry that was not allowed to conduct an investigation on him by orders of Lord Bush. Hopefully feels better after cashing his $100,000 check, after all, it was the system not him who did such a horrible job.

The good news is there are people like Dieter Snell to make sure greedy money grubbing opportunists like the family members of the people murdered on 9-11 don't insult our terrorist friends.

Just before publication of the 9-11 Commission report...

Snell and Zelikow were in the office, rewriting the report. Snell had presented an alternative draft of the chapter and removed virtually all of the most serious allegations against the Saudis. -page 398
http://www.amazon.com/Commission-Un.../ref=tmm_hrd_swatch_0?_encoding=UTF8&qid=&sr=

And I'm glad to. Because it was the enemy of the Sunni Saudis that did 9/11 ---Shiite Iran! Judge Daniels said so......

A federal district court in Manhattan yesterday entered a historic ruling that reveals new facts about Iran's support of al Qaeda in the 9/11 attacks. U.S. District Judge George B. Daniels ruled yesterday that Iran and Hezbollah materially and directly supported al Qaeda in the September 11, 2001 attacks
http://iran911case.com/

An "expert witness" was our friend Dieter Snell. According to his sworn Affidavit...

Although both Binalshibh and KSM denied "any relationship between the hijackers and Hezbollah", based on my experience in reading hundreds of interrogation reports and based on documented instances in which both detainees withheld information and even on occasion engaged in outright prevarication, I do not particularly credit those denials any more than I credit the denials of both Iran and Hezbollah of any complicity in the 9/11 attack.
http://information.iran911case.com/Exhibit_5.pdf

As a 9-11 hero and millionaire once said...."Slam dunk evidence!"

Judge George B. Daniels prevented the greedy opportunists from scamming our Saudi terrorists friends, whose loved ones were murdered by Saudi Arabia's enemy -Iran.

Good thing he had the case.....

Judge dismisses 9/11 charges against Saudi Arabia

U.S. District Judge George Daniels in New York declared that the families had failed to provide enough evidence linking Saudi leaders to the incident, closing one chapter in what has been a years-long legal effort to implicate the kingdom.
http://thehill.com/policy/national-security/255419-judge-dismisses-9-11-charges-against-saudi-arabia

Oh well, families of the 3000 people murdered on 9/11. The evidence is classified, and it was Iran anyway.
The system sucks for you. It's no ones fault. It's a "messed up" system.

Isn't there a pentagon fly under theory that needs "debunking"?
 
... Actually, they are saying the information was withheld on purpose. And they don't know why, because The CIA wont tell them. ...
Really, where did they say that? you are saying they knew these two failed nuts would commit suicide on 77? Where did they say that?
You realize your conclusion is an opinion...

The CIA had no clue 911 was coming... and the video proves it. , and you don't understand why

They got upset when the recognized names they knew, and think they should have, could have, would have, IF... and ... and...

It is neat you have an opinion they let it happen, or made it happen. great

You are allowed to have an opinion, please, your opinion stands, you got one... wow

Now we can say we can predict the future, but only after the event, then we can say, we can predict the future... that makes more sense than your fly below the Pentagon failed personal attack BS dig


did the knives used on 911 cost 2 Billion dollars?
 
Last edited:
Really, where did they say that? you are saying they knew these two failed nuts would commit suicide on 77? Where did they say that?
You realize your conclusion is an opinion...

The CIA had no clue 911 was coming... and the video proves it. , and you don't understand why

They got upset when the recognized names they knew, and think they should have, could have, would have, IF... and ... and...

It is neat you have an opinion they let it happen, or made it happen. great

You are allowed to have an opinion, please, your opinion stands, you got one... wow

Now we can say we can predict the future, but only after the event, then we can say, we can predict the future... that makes more sense than your fly below the Pentagon failed personal attack BS dig


did the knives used on 911 cost 2 Billion dollars?

Or in other words....

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ss2hULhXf04
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom