9/11 New information.

The CIA did not know an attack of that magnitude was going to happen. But they did know something was going to happen, and they knew Nawaf al Hazmi and Khalid al Midhar were involved.

I believe the "agent recruitment" theory holds a lot of weight. Clarke lays it all out in his interview which I will post below.

At the end of it, I firmly believe in the later stages leading up to 9/11, the CIA went into massive arse covering mode rather than prevent 'an attack' of unknown proportion from occurring.

I believe if they knew what the attack was going to be, if they could look in hindsight and see the hijacking of 4 aircraft and the death of 3000 people, they would have acted a lot differently leading up to 9/11 and would have shared any and all information they had with the FBI and the White House.

 
The CIA did not know an attack of that magnitude was going to happen.

I've noticed that lots of people on this forum, not only know what the CIA knew. They also know what the CIA did not know.

In 1998 AQ destroyed two U.S. Embassy Buildings nearly simultaneously, and killed over 200 people. In 2000, they Killed 17 U.S. Navy sailors in an attack on a U.S. Navy destroyer.

The operation of returning the destroyer to the U.S. took six weeks and costed about $4.5 million.
The Navy estimated that the repairs would cost an estimated $240 million

http://www.navysite.de/dd/ddg67.htm

What magnitude would you consider these prior attacks?

But they did know something was going to happen, and they knew Nawaf al Hazmi and Khalid al Midhar were involved.

Yes, but since they didn't know they were going to hijack 4 planes on the morning of 9/11 and fly 2 into the WTC, the third into the pentagon, and the forth into the White house or Capital, there was nothing they could do. Or so I'm told.

I believe the "agent recruitment" theory holds a lot of weight. Clarke lays it all out in his interview which I will post below.

The statement put out by Tenet, Black and Blee say his theory is "unworthy of serious consideration". We have these "theories" because they lie without repercussions, and are promoted instead of being held accountable.

At the end of it, I firmly believe in the later stages leading up to 9/11, the CIA went into massive arse covering mode rather than prevent 'an attack' of unknown proportion from occurring.

Any theories on why they were rewarded/promoted? For this?

I believe if they knew what the attack was going to be, if they could look in hindsight and see the hijacking of 4 aircraft and the death of 3000 people, they would have acted a lot differently leading up to 9/11

LOL! Like I said earlier

and would have shared any and all information they had with the FBI and the White House.

We can see the FBI Agents involved were/are pretty upset by the actions of the CIA.

http://video.newyorker.com/watch/the-new-yorker-presents-the-agent-gibney

The White House on the other hand - quite pleased. Promotions and Medal of Freedom Award. Not sharing information is still going on to this very day. It was the Whitehouse that doesn't want to share information with the citizens of America. The information contained in those 28 pages.

Any theories on why the President was pleased that his Saudi friends supposedly didn't share information with him, and also pleased that supposedly his CIA didn't either?

"The George Bush Center for Intelligence is the headquarters of the Central Intelligence Agency"
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/George_Bush_Center_for_Intelligence
 
Last edited:
Is trust, or lack thereof the biggest influence behind 9/11 conspiracies?

My own personal opinion is that while there are a lot of ordinary people doing ordinary jobs within the government machine, the higher you go in the food chain of all the disparate agencies, and ultimately to the very top, the people involved become less trustworthy.

This is where personal definitions of trustworthy come into play, it can include, but is not limited to:
Lies - Outright falsehoods.
Lies by omission
CYA
Blame someone else.
Half-truths
Spin
Ulterior motives
Conflicts of interest
Fabrication of data
Falsification of evidence
Incompetence
Negligence
Lack of compassion
"Just" Following orders
Understatement
Exaggeration.
Official Secret.

In addition, people have a tendency to categorise and anthropomorphise (not without justification, Roman law in particular helps frame this mindset with corporate entities). John Smith is no longer an individual, he becomes The FBI and/or The Government.

Over the course of history, many actions by individuals (independently or collectively) have cumulatively added to the bad rep of these entities to different degrees within every person. A poll of "How much do you trust <insert here>" would have a very wide answer range, however as with many things, the answer will change depending on the framing of the question. "Do you trust...", "Have you lost trust..", "Has your level of faith and/or trust changed.."

So, when a court of law for example, uses evidence or testimony from "trusted" sources such as the FBI, they are not universally trusted.

Flip that, if you are a trusted source regardless of your conduct, could that influence your behaviour? I'm sure we have all heard that power corrupts.

How I see this in relation to 9/11 is that we have sworn testimony from trusted sources, that have a reputation for being untrustworthy.
We also have unsworn testimony, which is automatically viewed with suspicion by some.
We have testimony behind closed doors.
We have reliable evidence.
We have evidence that has been classified.
We have evidence that cannot be certified as reliable.
We have evidence that it could be possible to fabricate or plant.
We have circumstantial evidence.
We have here say.
We have coincidences by the thousand.
We have theories, probabilities, and likely explanations.
We have unlikely or counter-intuitive explanations

As an individual, presented with a sequence of events that shocks you through sheer magnitude, brutality and complexity, and when offered a narrative by one or more agencies who you do not trust, can you be forgiven for searching out alternative theories?

In other words, are The Government the boy who cried wolf? Have their agents lied, cheated, made stuff up, planted evidence, and generally screwed up so much, and so often, that some people wont believe anything they say?
 
Is trust, or lack thereof the biggest influence behind 9/11 conspiracies?

I'm sure it's always been a major contributor to this and all other similar "alternative" theories, from conspiracy theories to alternative medicine to parapsychology to relativity denial; the idea that there's an all-powerful "them" who tell you what to think.

In other words, are The Government the boy who cried wolf? Have their agents lied, cheated, made stuff up, planted evidence, and generally screwed up so much, and so often, that some people wont believe anything they say?

That appears to be a common starting point, yes. However, the problem starts when people then decide to believe the opposite of what they say, which is no less absurd. The whole "never believe anything until it's been officially denied" mindset is as much a substitute for actual thinking as the "believe everything the government says" that conspiracy theorists suggest the rest of the world suffers from.

It's important, also, to note that journalists are not necessarily part of the government or sympathetic to it, so when journalistic sources agree with government information there is at least a degree of independent confirmation.

Dave
 
All of this needs to be taken in the context of the RESPONSE to 9/11 which was the run up to the war with Iraq where there was clearly a bogus case laced with outright lies made to the public... by the same cast of characters who "explained" 9/11 and presented the official narrative.

It is this LARGER context that has seriously poison the well and nourished the conspiracy theories. They lied their ass off in the run up to the war in Iraq... they failed to get OBL in Tora Bora... These are either the gang who couldn't shoot straight.. or with intent pulling the wool over the eyes of the public.

But.... are they concealing a massive Emperor has No Clothes situation... where a bunch of people we call the national security state has no idea what they are doing and it's all window dressing...Truman Show reality?

I don't see that the USA got much bang for their buck from the CIA over the 60 years they have been funded by congress including black funds. The CIA seems to have morphed from an intel gathering mission to one of covert ops. If they had intel about AQ... they didn't do much with it. Why? If they didn't ... why not?

There is no doubt that all manner of CYA was in play on personal and institutional level post 9/11. And the CIA seems completely on their own...still... no accountability or mission change.

It's time for rational adults and policies with regard to national security.
 
All of this needs to be taken in the context of the RESPONSE to 9/11 which was the run up to the war with Iraq where there was clearly a bogus case laced with outright lies made to the public... by the same cast of characters who "explained" 9/11 and presented the official narrative.

Exactly. And a war with Iraq is impossible when The American people read a report from the Senate And Congress Joint Inquiry. That names Saudi Arabia as a state sponsor of 9-11.

4500 US Patriot soldiers died in Iraq. I know for a fact that some of those that died joined the service after 9/11 in order to go after "the evil doers who hate freedom", just like I did, but unlike them I wasn't sent to my death in Iraq, along with deaths of hundreds of thousand of Iraqis.

“Saddam, this time, will be out, period?” Bandar asked skeptically.

Cheney replied, “Prince Bandar, once we start, Saddam is toast.”

After Bandar had left, Rumsfeld voiced some concern about the “toast” remark. “What was that all about, Dick?”

“I didn’t want to leave any doubt in his mind what we’re planning to do,“ Cheney said.

[The next day, to Bush], Bandar said, ”People are not going to shed tears over Saddam Hussein, but if he’s attacked one more time by America and he stays in power after you’ve finished this, yes, everybody will follow his word.“ The problem would be if Hussein survived. The Saudis needed assurance that Hussein was going to be toast. Bush said, ”The message [from Cheney that] you’re taking is mine, Bandar.“

http://www.ontheissues.org/Archive/Plan_of_Attack_Dick_Cheney.htm

So the Prince couldn't wait for the U.S. bombs to fall.
https://books.google.com/books?id=U...he bombs to fall saddam killed bandar&f=false

Bandar, Thumairy, and Basnan, are three Saudi terrorists named in the 28 pages.

So I have no problem saying Bush was a mass murderer and traitor.
 
What new ones? After 14 years what can top nukes, CD, thermite, and silent explosives.
Dr. Fu Manchu had a substance that weakened steel (as did one of The Spider's antagonists), maybe that was used. Or his invisible fire that could melt steel.
Of course the Devil Doctor also had the Ericksen Ray.
 
Wars of aggression have no justification. FULL STOP. Iraq was not a threat to the USA... Anyone who believes that I have a bridge to sell them.
 
All of this needs to be taken in the context of the RESPONSE to 9/11 which was the run up to the war with Iraq where there was clearly a bogus case laced with outright lies made to the public... by the same cast of characters who "explained" 9/11 and presented the official narrative.

Technically no.

The folks who investigated the 9-11 attacks were not the same people behind the bad intelligence leading to the Iraq invasion.

More important is the fact that the invasion was an act of 9-11 Trutherism. Rumsfeld and others in the NSC didn't believe AQ could pull off the attacks without help, which is understandable considering their white-collar backgrounds.

It is this LARGER context that has seriously poison the well and nourished the conspiracy theories. They lied their ass off in the run up to the war in Iraq...

With Saddam Hussein's help. Remember the USCOM issues. He needed us to believe he had WMDs because he needed his own generals to think he had them...and they did up until nine days into the invasion.

Do you really think the CIA successfully convinced the Republican Guard that they had WMDs?

they failed to get OBL in Tora Bora... These are either the gang who couldn't shoot straight.. or with intent pulling the wool over the eyes of the public.

They failed to shoot straight.

Rumsfeld was incompetent. He micro-managed our military forces and limited our asset projection into Afghanistan because he believed we could fight a war on the cheap. Remember, while we were committed to a war in Afghanistan and elsewhere, Rumsfeld was actively cutting US military forces.

Rumsfeld was an ideological idiot. It cost us.


I don't see that the USA got much bang for their buck from the CIA over the 60 years they have been funded by congress including black funds. The CIA seems to have morphed from an intel gathering mission to one of covert ops.

They have always had an operational directorate. It has waxed and waned depending on the whims of our elected leadership. That's the key point, the CIA is not an autonomous entity, it does the bidding of the Congress and the White House, and its Jekyll & Hyde nature stems from our country's changing political tides.

If they had intel about AQ... they didn't do much with it. Why? If they didn't ... why not?

They had some intel, but the crucial data was stored in NSA servers unread and un-analyzed. The NSA didn't know they had AQ intel until a post-9-11 audit.

All I ever see on this board is "CIA, CIA, CIA" like they're magic. The US has the CIA, NSA, NRO, DIA, the intel commands of each of the military branches, and a secondary Pentagon intelligence unit that was spun up after the Desert Storm and Somalia because the military lost faith in the CIA.

That's a lot of people, a lot of machinery, and a lot of money.

Before 9-11 they rarely talked to each other and horded their intel sharing little. Now we have added the ODNI to facilitate communication between all of these offices.

If you look at Syria - right now - it is clearly failing.

There is no doubt that all manner of CYA was in play on personal and institutional level post 9/11.

No, really?

Could it be that the intelligence community was limited by the executive branch between 1993 and 2001 to the point where priorities had been retasked after the end of the Cold War?

What did Sandy Berger risk prison time to steal from the National Archives and destroy?

Why didn't the House and Senate Intelligence Committees not press harder for accountability?

I'm going to go out on a limb and say their actions or lack of action was based on the knowledge of personal guilt rooted in incompetence.

"Failure of imagination" is just a nice way of saying they were morons.


And the CIA seems completely on their own...still... no accountability or mission change.

They're hardly on their own. And they're only as accountable as their government.

And no, their mission hasn't changed.

It's time for rational adults and policies with regard to national security.

The problem is that it was rational adults who got us into trouble. There is nothing rational or consistent about intelligence, and you never have all the facts in real time. Rational adults expect hard and consistent data, and this is almost always impossible on a good day. There are few good days.

This is why the intelligence services in other countries is kept at arm's length from the political leadership.
 
I've noticed that lots of people on this forum, not only know what the CIA knew. They also know what the CIA did not know.

In 1998 AQ destroyed two U.S. Embassy Buildings nearly simultaneously, and killed over 200 people. In 2000, they Killed 17 U.S. Navy sailors in an attack on a U.S. Navy destroyer.

The operation of returning the destroyer to the U.S. took six weeks and costed about $4.5 million.
The Navy estimated that the repairs would cost an estimated $240 million

http://www.navysite.de/dd/ddg67.htm

What magnitude would you consider these prior attacks?

12 of the 224 people killed in both US Embassy attacks were Americans. We responded with a cruise missile attack on AQ bases in Afghanistan.

The magnitude of these attacks was in order with attacks on US assets and forces going back to Islamic Jihad in Lebanon in the 1980s. Our response back then was similar; a limit air strikes and shelling by the USS New Jersey.

The fact is that up until 2001, Islamic terrorist groups ranked below Marxists rebel and terror cells on the priority list. Our Counter-Terrorism history bears this out. More importantly, this played into the mind-set of both the Clinton and Bush Administrations (prior 9-11).
 
...
My own personal opinion is that while there are a lot of ordinary people doing ordinary jobs within the government machine, the higher you go in the food chain of all the disparate agencies, and ultimately to the very top, the people involved become less trustworthy.
...
This is certainly a major tile in the mosaic of the Truther Mind - and it is mostly false.

There are a number of qualities that take people to the top of organizations, be it politics, corporations, the military, trade unions or NGOs, not all of them are positive, and none apply to all people who move to the top.

There is intelligence, education, people skills, resilience, idealism, hard work, vision.
There is ambition, focus, expectations by family or peers.
There is ruthlessness, wiliness, corruption.

The latter work better in autocratic societies. Democratic and republican societies generally favour cooperative skills.

Anecdotal case in point: When I came home from work today, I made myself a coffee and bowl of cereals and switched on the TV for mere diversion. Zapping channels, I came across a public channel that carried life a debate in our federal parliament, and the current speaker was - Wilfried, a guy formerly in my extended circle of friends (15 years ago, he used to sing in the choir I still sing with). He's our MP now. Not a particularly powerful one, but still. I remember him as a thoroughly decent guy, studied though not obviously brilliant, with conservative but solid and heartfelt values. I had lost contact for many years, but have encountered him a few times recently in semi-official settings, and as best as I can tell, he hasn't changed substantially.

I believe that a solid majority of the leaders of our democratic institutions are genuinly good, or at least well-intentioned people - not better than you or I, but also not worse. They may have developed a, let's say, tactical relationship towards the truth, but are not outright deceptive and dishonest.
At any rate, there are too many good people at the top for any conspiracy to recruit many participans for an utterly evil plot. Doesn't happen. It's a fantasy shared by Conspiracy Theorists that any meetung among the top echelons are essentially the same as Dr. No meeting Goldfinger, Scaramanga and Blofeld. This is a comic rendering of the world.

Let's take Dick Cheney: I don't like the man. I don't share his political views and disagree with some of his values. But he is not evil incarnate, as Truthers see him. He didn't spent his Veep years scheming against the American people every day and thinking up ways how to hurt the world and rob and rape other countries for personal gain. That view would be the silliest nonsense. Even Cheney is true to defendable values most of the time.
 
Last edited:
In other words, are The Government the boy who cried wolf? Have their agents lied, cheated, made stuff up, planted evidence, and generally screwed up so much, and so often, that some people wont believe anything they say?
Part of the problem is the confusion between not believing what they say and denying what they say because if it comes from that source, it must be false.
 
Last edited:
They may have developed a, let's say, tactical relationship towards the truth, but are not outright deceptive and dishonest.
.

To my mind, that makes them untrustworthy. If they are unreliable with the truth, then who are they best serving?

I don't like secrets and lies, especially in positions of authority. I don't care if it's a doctor, a policeman, a journalist, or a politician, I would rather they had some integrity.

I don't know a lot of the personalities over there, but over here we have MPs that are landlords voting on legislation about.... landlords. We have people with vested interests in private healthcare trying to destroy our NHS. We have sexual deviants in league with the police and the press, we have high profile court cases that fade away, with not guilty verdicts whispered while the country wonders what happened. We take money from the poor and give it to one of the richest women on the planet, while sending foreign aid to countries that have nuclear weapons and space programs. It's a big steaming pile of poo.
 
To my mind, that makes them untrustworthy. If they are unreliable with the truth, then who are they best serving?

I don't like secrets and lies, especially in positions of authority. I don't care if it's a doctor, a policeman, a journalist, or a politician, I would rather they had some integrity.

That depends on the level of truth you need. This might be hard for you to understand but, you really don't want to know the whole truth. Would you like the security administration telling us every day every single threat they receive?

Do you think this would be a good and prudent policy for the general population? Yes, there are secrets but, they don't necessarily translate to lies.
 
Last edited:
That depends on the level of truth you need. This might be hard for you to understand but, you really don't want to know the whole truth. Would you like the security administration telling us every day every single threat they receive?

Do you think this would be a good and prudent policy for the general population? Yes, there are secrets but, they don't necessarily translate to lies.

Sorry, I don't know the correct term, but implying it's all or nothing is a fallacy.

Not telling me what Achmed said to his mother is not the same as "I did not have sexual relations with that woman".
 
This is certainly a major tile in the mosaic of the Truther Mind - and it is mostly false.

There are a number of qualities that take people to the top of organizations, be it politics, corporations, the military, trade unions or NGOs, not all of them are positive, and none apply to all people who move to the top.

There is intelligence, education, people skills, resilience, idealism, hard work, vision.
There is ambition, focus, expectations by family or peers.
There is ruthlessness, wiliness, corruption.

The latter work better in autocratic societies. Democratic and republican societies generally favour cooperative skills.

Anecdotal case in point: When I came home from work today, I made myself a coffee and bowl of cereals and switched on the TV for mere diversion. Zapping channels, I came across a public channel that carried life a debate in our federal parliament, and the current speaker was - Wilfried, a guy formerly in my extended circle of friends (15 years ago, he used to sing in the choir I still sing with). He's our MP now. Not a particularly powerful one, but still. I remember him as a thoroughly decent guy, studied though not obviously brilliant, with conservative but solid and heartfelt values. I had lost contact for many years, but have encountered him a few times recently in semi-official settings, and as best as I can tell, he hasn't changed substantially.

I believe that a solid majority of the leaders of our democratic institutions are genuinely good, or at least well-intentioned people - not better than you or I, but also not worse. They may have developed a, let's say, tactical relationship towards the truth, but are not outright deceptive and dishonest.
At any rate, there are too many good people at the top for any conspiracy to recruit many participans for an utterly evil plot. Doesn't happen. It's a fantasy shared by Conspiracy Theorists that any meetung among the top echelons are essentially the same as Dr. No meeting Goldfinger, Scaramanga and Blofeld. This is a comic rendering of the world.

Let's take Dick Cheney: I don't like the man. I don't share his political views and disagree with some of his values. But he is not evil incarnate, as Truthers see him. He didn't spent his Veep years scheming against the American people every day and thinking up ways how to hurt the world and rob and rape other countries for personal gain. That view would be the silliest nonsense. Even Cheney is true to defendable values most of the time.
clap.gif
clap.gif


Very well stated Oystein. As many members know I worked at the level of "big agency" interfacing with "the Government political system" here in AU. Your assessment aligns accurately with my experience in that firing line. Despite possible national cultural differences AU<>DE - the underlying qualities are the same.

The big difficulty for many truthers is that they cannot cope with the reality that these people and the processes they use are mostly well intentioned and correct.

The error or misjudgement proportion is low and the deliberate dishonest bit is even less. And no matter what the actual proportion of "good" to "bad" the truthers look only at the bad -- then blow it out of all proportion by various debating tricks -- commonly false generalising innuendo -- "If I can find one bit wrong THEN the lot is rotten/corrupt/evil". (Try identifying a truther, troll or Poe or any other opponent of the accepted 9/11 narratives who does NOT make that card a main premise of their "argument".)

A big part of that problem is that the opposing clans hold to different ideologies mostly in the areas of political philosophy, societal governance and economic management. Plus a few others.

And the truthers tend to regard legitimate differences of point of view in those areas as "dishonesty" or some other version of malice.

The main problem being that the truthers cannot deal with reality - especially reality involving complex multi factor events where 100% accurate info is not and never will be available in the time frame needed to manage real events in real time.
 
Sorry, I don't know the correct term, but implying it's all or nothing is a fallacy.

Not telling me what Achmed said to his mother is not the same as "I did not have sexual relations with that woman".
Blew over your head.

It's not all or nothing, it's a filter. To what extent does the general public need to know and what would be comfortable to most people. You want complete open but most don't want to know what doesn't effect their normal life directly.

Do you understand the concept of 'need to know' when it comes to national security? You say you don't really like the US, how about the UK, France or Germany (I believe you said (UK) that's where you live)?
 
Last edited:
Blew over your head.

It's not all or nothing, it's a filter. To what extent does the general public need to know and what would be comfortable to most people. You want complete open but most don't want to know what doesn't effect their normal life directly.

Do you understand the concept of 'need to know' when it comes to national security? You say you don't really like the US, how about the UK, France or Germany (I believe you said (UK) that's where you live)?

I know all about filters and the concept of need to know. I'm talking about straight answers to honest questions, not complete 100% transparency and disclosure of everything at all times.

I do not need to know the exact location of our nuclear submarines. But if asked "Was there a leak of radioactive material form one of our submarines?" then an honest, direct answer is my preferred choice every time. I do not want to be protected from the truth any more than I want to be bombarded with it. Unless it's the bit about the frogs, I really want to know the bit about the frogs.

I said I do not love the USA, that is not the same as don't really like. The absence of one does not confer its opposite. Nine times out of ten I can happily just ignore the US. A lot of the time I don't like the UK and I really can't wait for Scotland to become independent and sever our dependency on the scum and villainy in Westminster. France or Germany I can usually ignore. Pretty much everyone outside my door I can ignore most of the time, just not always.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom