3 Cornerstones of the Truther Movement

What I'm saying is that in my opinion there are some lightpoles that are still up that I think would be down given the official flight path. There are no skid marks either.

No, that's not what you said. No downed light poles is what you said. I'm not sure what you're on about missing skid marks, but if I'm any judge of character, you'll likely find some in your shorts.
 
What I'm saying is that in my opinion there are some lightpoles that are still up that I think would be down given the official flight path. There are no skid marks either.
Where and why would there be skid marks?
 
What I'm saying is that in my opinion there are some lightpoles that are still up that I think would be down given the official flight path. There are no skid marks either.
Opinion based on no research. If you researched the flight path, you would not be making failed opinion posts. Good luck, but you are not doing the work, exposing your ignorance.
 
What I'm saying is that in my opinion there are some lightpoles that are still up that I think would be down given the official flight path. There are no skid marks either.

Could you please indicate, perhaps using a map or an aerial view of the area, precisely which poles you'd expect to be downed, and where you'd expect to see skid marks.

Please do also explain WHY you expect those poles to be down, and WHY you expect skid marks there.

We can then check
a) if your expectation is based on facts and reason, or rather made up
b) if that which ou expect happened or not
 
What I'm saying is that in my opinion there are some lightpoles that are still up that I think would be down given the official flight path.

Nobody gives a damn about your opinion. Show your work, however, and people might respond.
 
Could you please indicate, perhaps using a map or an aerial view of the area, precisely which poles you'd expect to be downed, and where you'd expect to see skid marks.

Please do also explain WHY you expect those poles to be down, and WHY you expect skid marks there.

We can then check
a) if your expectation is based on facts and reason, or rather made up
b) if that which ou expect happened or not

I stand corrected. I can not conclusively show that based on the official flight path, any of the light poles in that video that are standing should have fallen. My apologies. As for skid marks I always assumed they would be there somewhere, can you explain why there are none? There is still the biggest problem of all (in terms of the video) the lack of debris. All the videos in the world of someone playing pool isn't going to explain it.
 
I stand corrected. I can not conclusively show that based on the official flight path, any of the light poles in that video that are standing should have fallen. My apologies.
Accepted ;)

As for skid marks I always assumed they would be there somewhere, can you explain why there are none?
It's your assumption. Before we see if we can conform or refute your assumption, I think it is only fair that you explain why you have that assumption in the first place!

There is still the biggest problem of all (in terms of the video) the lack of debris. All the videos in the world of someone playing pool isn't going to explain it.
Again, could you please point ot, on a map maybe or an aerial view, where you would expect to find debris, and explain why you expect that? Then we can check if
a) you reasoning makes sense in terms of physics and engineering
b) whether or not there is debris where some should be expected.
 
Accepted ;)


It's your assumption. Before we see if we can conform or refute your assumption, I think it is only fair that you explain why you have that assumption in the first place!


Again, could you please point ot, on a map maybe or an aerial view, where you would expect to find debris, and explain why you expect that? Then we can check if
a) you reasoning makes sense in terms of physics and engineering
b) whether or not there is debris where some should be expected.

The debris are skid marks are almost one in the same. I would expect them to be somewhat near the impact zone. I believe that video gives us enough of a vantage point that we should see something. Skid marks because it is awfully hard to keep that plane in such a position that it did not bounce and yet the roof did not collapse initially. Even if we believe this is possible I think some of the blow back of parts would cause skid marks, I mean they didn't just land and stay there,they had to be moving. I'm not sure why that would not have left a skid mark.
 
I stand corrected. I can not conclusively show that based on the official flight path, any of the light poles in that video that are standing should have fallen. My apologies. As for skid marks I always assumed they would be there somewhere, can you explain why there are none? There is still the biggest problem of all (in terms of the video) the lack of debris. All the videos in the world of someone playing pool isn't going to explain it.
Assume makes an ass out of u and me.

Now think tmd2_1, try to think. Ignore the pain in your head and the burning smell whilst you try to think. Don't worry this problem can be resolved by thinking for just a couple of seconds so it's not going to hurt for too long.

Now, what would have to happen for an object to leave skid marks on grass?

Easy tmd2_1, we don't want you to fry your synapses by trying too hard. Nope, haven't got it have you. Hmmm, perhaps we'll try a different technique. Maybe have a nice hot bath and perhaps the simple answer will pop into your atrophied brain. Still nothing? Ok I'll tell you the simple answer.

In order for the aircraft to leave skid marks on the grass there would need to be CONTACT between the aircraft and the grass.

Now this is the really, really hard part. Take a break tmd2_1, we don't want to overload you with information. Your brain is in far too delicate a state as it is and I fear a complete melt down isn't too far off if you push yourself too hard as you are going to need all your mental faculties, however little, to process this next bit of information.

If there were no skid marks it means the plane never made contact with the grass.

Do you see how you have it backwards? You expect to see skidmarks and assume there is something wrong when you don't see them. Instead try to look at the evidence and then form your conclusions rather than forming your conclusion first and then questioning the evidence.

Now this is really going to tax you. Do you understand the concept of weight? Do you know about light things and heavy things? Do you know that engineers try to make aeroplanes as light as possible? Now lets see if you can answer a question.

What do engineers try to make aeroplanes from?

a) Heaviest materials possible.
b) Lightest materials possible.

Hint: it's b)

So you see, light things such as the fuselage that is made from light aluminium alloys specifically designed to be strong and light are not going to make skid marks in the grass especially when those pieces are relatively small. Again you are assuming that you know what an explosion will do to light objects and how those objects are going to behave.

tmd2_1? tmd2_1? Quick someone call an ambulance I think he's fried his brain.
 
Last edited:
I lurk here a lot, spend most of my debunking time over on IMDB, but after having experienced a lot of Truther tactics over the past several years, I have come to the conclusion there are 3 cornerstones to the Truther movement. Nearly every exchange between Truthers and Debunkers will include one if not more of the following:

1. ALL loud noises heard at WTC1, 2, or 7, the morning of 9/11, were, WITHOUT question, planted exposives detonating.

2. There is no "fog of war" in the Truther movement. Everything everyone said in conjunction with the attacks on 9/11 was EXACTLY what they meant to say. No one ever makes a mistake or misspeaks due to being in a highly stressful life or death situation.

3. Whenever any Truther is exposed to any evidence that appears to contradict a Truther "theory", then that evidence is, WITHOUT QUESTION, faked.

Any more from anyone?

Hundreds!

But all are just variations of this:

I thought the 3 cornerstones of trutherism was...
1. Ignorance
2. Arrogance
3. Mental illness
 
Assume makes an ass out of u and me.

Now think tmd2_1, try to think. Ignore the pain in your head and the burning smell whilst you try to think. Don't worry this problem can be resolved by thinking for just a couple of seconds so it's not going to hurt for too long.

Now, what would have to happen for an object to leave skid marks on grass?

Easy tmd2_1, we don't want you to fry your synapses by trying too hard. Nope, haven't got it have you. Hmmm, perhaps we'll try a different technique. Maybe have a nice hot bath and perhaps the simple answer will pop into your atrophied brain. Still nothing? Ok I'll tell you the simple answer.

In order for the aircraft to leave skid marks on the grass there would need to be CONTACT between the aircraft and the grass.

Now this is the really, really hard part. Take a break tmd2_1, we don't want to overload you with information. Your brain is in far too delicate a state as it is and I fear a complete melt down isn't too far off if you push yourself too hard as you are going to need all your mental faculties, however little, to process this next bit of information.
If there were no skid marks it means the plane never made contact with the grass.

Do you see how you have it backwards? You expect to see skidmarks and assume there is something wrong when you don't see them. Instead try to look at the evidence and then form your conclusions rather than forming your conclusion first and then questioning the evidence.

Now this is really going to tax you. Do you understand the concept of weight? Do you know about light things and heavy things? Do you know that engineers try to make aeroplanes as light as possible? Now lets see if you can answer a question.

What do engineers try to make aeroplanes from?

a) Heaviest materials possible.
b) Lightest materials possible.

Hint: it's b)

So you see, light things such as the fuselage that is made from light aluminium alloys specifically designed to be strong and light are not going to make skid marks in the grass especially when those pieces are relatively small. Again you are assuming that you know what an explosion will do to light objects and how those objects are going to behave.

tmd2_1? tmd2_1? Quick someone call an ambulance I think he's fried his brain.

This kind of people makes me sick.
 
Last edited:
This kind of people is making me sick.

Yeah just ignore them. They don't even realize they are doing a dis-service to their own "debunking" cause. Anyone with a somewhat open mind reading these threads will see through them.
 
This kind of people makes me sick.

No Marokkaan....you make us sick.

You accuse NIST of either incompetence or fraud.....

Literally HUNDREDS of Engineers (and others as well) worked on that report....spanning across industry, academia, and government.

There have been literally DOZENS of peer reviewed articles in peer reviewed journals that agree with the general conclusions of NIST and DO NOT CONCLUDE CONTROLLED DEMOLITION OF ANY KIND.

EVERY SINGLE professional Engineering Orginization THE WORLD OVER agrees that the buildings fell as a result of structural damage + fires.

And what do you give us as evidence?

Your "opinion"? A "youtube video"? A joke group like AE911 truth with not even 1% of the worlds experts?

You should feel lucky we even bother to take the time to reply to your conspiratorial crap.

No go do some reading....NCSTAR 1A and NCSTAR 1-9 chapter 12.....those are good places to start.
 
Yeah just ignore them. They don't even realize they are doing a dis-service to their own "debunking" cause. Anyone with a somewhat open mind reading these threads will see through them.

I fully agree! You need to have a hole in your head to believe anything out of the truth movement.

The Truth Movement - 10 years of failure and counting!
 
Yeah just ignore them. They don't even realize they are doing a dis-service to their own "debunking" cause. Anyone with a somewhat open mind reading these threads will see through them.

Which of course would not be you. You have raised several issues that are complete non-issues.

1) Time: EVERY measurement system has its own time marker. Those systems can vary not only their value at any given moment in time, but also in the rate they measure time. You want to focus on a DAMAGED analog clock time found in the debris. The operative word is damaged, since it stopped due to an induced shock. Someone posted for you a perfectly valid experiment that demonstrated that such a shock also has the effect of changing the time value on the clock.

You obviously did not read the paper I linked earlier on time normalization. The Citgo security system recorded the impact event at one time, the Doubletree hotel recorded it at another. Even the radar sites recorded phenomenon at completely independent times with one another. The system that recorded exactly the same feeds for NEADS and SEADS also recorded at different times and rates. The broadcast television reports also exhibited different time stamps for the same event(s).

So to determine the time of the event, you can't just take a couple of damaged clocks found among debris to reach a conclusion. You take ALL of the records of the time for the event and correlate them to the same timeline. The study you failed to read did such a correlation to a common timeline, SEADS. Why? Because of all of the time systems involved, SEADS exhibited quantifiable stability using fairly standard statistical techniques.

2) Videos: According to you videos taken within minutes of the event do not record debris or downed poles. That is simply a blatant falsehood. One poster has already shown you in error, and there is also a downed pole (actually fixture) recorded in another. The reason they do no show the other poles or the debris field is simply because the ones you used were recorded to the south of the approach path and impact area and the debris field is to the north of it. In other words, the videos simply are not pointed at either or recording too distant from them to be resolvable. A 5-year old can figure out that you are misrepresenting the videos.

3) Aziz: The guy's account has absolutely nothing to do with anything. A guy who was at the scene goes to a TV station to show off a piece of debris he found lying next to his car and claim his 15 minutes of fame. You presented a photograph which you believe shows the guy at the Navy Annex as proof the guy was not there. Assuming that the guy in the photograph is him (not established in the least), all you have done is proven that the guy actually was there at the time of the event.

So yeah, even a casual reader can make the determination that either you just flat out don't know what you are talking about, or are completely incompetent, and/or intellectually dishonest with yourself and others.
 
There is still the biggest problem of all (in terms of the video) the lack of debris. All the videos in the world of someone playing pool isn't going to explain it.

Why would you watch video to check the amounts of debris?

Have you gone looking for still photos of AA77 debris? There are scores of good stills showing plenty enough to satisfy your curiosity, and people here will post them if you insist.
 
tmd

You've been asked multiple times now why there would be skid marks.


....nevermind. I see you've handwaved that.
 
Last edited:
Which of course would not be you. You have raised several issues that are complete non-issues.

1) Time: EVERY measurement system has its own time marker. Those systems can vary not only their value at any given moment in time, but also in the rate they measure time. You want to focus on a DAMAGED analog clock time found in the debris. The operative word is damaged, since it stopped due to an induced shock. Someone posted for you a perfectly valid experiment that demonstrated that such a shock also has the effect of changing the time value on the clock.

You obviously did not read the paper I linked earlier on time normalization. The Citgo security system recorded the impact event at one time, the Doubletree hotel recorded it at another. Even the radar sites recorded phenomenon at completely independent times with one another. The system that recorded exactly the same feeds for NEADS and SEADS also recorded at different times and rates. The broadcast television reports also exhibited different time stamps for the same event(s).

So to determine the time of the event, you can't just take a couple of damaged clocks found among debris to reach a conclusion. You take ALL of the records of the time for the event and correlate them to the same timeline. The study you failed to read did such a correlation to a common timeline, SEADS. Why? Because of all of the time systems involved, SEADS exhibited quantifiable stability using fairly standard statistical techniques.

2) Videos: According to you videos taken within minutes of the event do not record debris or downed poles. That is simply a blatant falsehood. One poster has already shown you in error, and there is also a downed pole (actually fixture) recorded in another. The reason they do no show the other poles or the debris field is simply because the ones you used were recorded to the south of the approach path and impact area and the debris field is to the north of it. In other words, the videos simply are not pointed at either or recording too distant from them to be resolvable. A 5-year old can figure out that you are misrepresenting the videos.

3) Aziz: The guy's account has absolutely nothing to do with anything. A guy who was at the scene goes to a TV station to show off a piece of debris he found lying next to his car and claim his 15 minutes of fame. You presented a photograph which you believe shows the guy at the Navy Annex as proof the guy was not there. Assuming that the guy in the photograph is him (not established in the least), all you have done is proven that the guy actually was there at the time of the event.

So yeah, even a casual reader can make the determination that either you just flat out don't know what you are talking about, or are completely incompetent, and/or intellectually dishonest with yourself and others.

1.Right so all those clocks that stopped at 9:32 mean nothing? Let's just forget about them. Who cares? You can rationalize it all you want, those clocks are damning. Let me show here are two of the clocks one that hung in the Smithsonian, and another posted on the official Navy website. I think it's good for people to actually see it.

http://www.americanhistory.si.edu/september11/collection/record.asp?ID=19

http://www.navy.mil/view_single.asp?id=2480Pentagonclock_BBC

2. I've conceded that I can't conclusively show any of the light poles standing should have fallen. Sure I'm mis-representing the videos, people watching them will just have to judge for themselves if there should be debris or not. I have a feeling which way they might lean.

3. Aziz our good buddy Aziz. Right so his photo is taken between a half a mile and a mile away from where he said he was. He comes into the TV studio like he has a souvenir from Disneyland, there are no repercussions because removing crime scene evidence is a crime. He's also photographed with John Kerry pictured partying with the mayor of DC. As well as other red carpet events. Let me tell you what that shows. His associating with these people and those type of events make it seem less likely that he is just some nut. They push balance towards him having connections and people wanting him to be there to display his "souvenir."
 
Yeah just ignore them. They don't even realize they are doing a dis-service to their own "debunking" cause. Anyone with a somewhat open mind reading these threads will see through them.

Why are you here if you do not want what you assert to be dissected?

was not the "skid mark" nonsense enough to convince even you that you have a lot more research to do before coming here and wasting your and our time?

If you behave like a fool you will be treated like one.
 
1.Right so all those clocks that stopped at 9:32 mean nothing? Let's just forget about them. Who cares? You can rationalize it all you want, those clocks are damning. Let me show here are two of the clocks one that hung in the Smithsonian, and another posted on the official Navy website. I think it's good for people to actually see it.

http://www.americanhistory.si.edu/september11/collection/record.asp?ID=19

http://www.navy.mil/view_single.asp?id=2480Pentagonclock_BBC


all these clocks??? you show only two and even they are not at the same time........one is at 9:30:39 and the other 9:32:30

Right so you have proven that clocks do not agree with each other....I think we knew that.

2. I've conceded that I can't conclusively show any of the light poles standing should have fallen. Sure I'm mis-representing the videos, people watching them will just have to judge for themselves if there should be debris or not. I have a feeling which way they might lean.

Conclusively?? you haven't even given vague cause!

3. Aziz our good buddy Aziz. Right so his photo is taken between a half a mile and a mile away from where he said he was.

His photo?? you have utterly failed to prove that for a start and people can walk. He doesn't say he wasn't there and its in easy walking distance so wheres the mystery??

He comes into the TV studio like he has a souvenir from Disneyland, there are no repercussions because removing crime scene evidence is a crime. He's also photographed with John Kerry pictured partying with the mayor of DC. As well as other red carpet events. Let me tell you what that shows. His associating with these people and those type of events make it seem less likely that he is just some nut. They push balance towards him having connections and people wanting him to be there to display his "souvenir."


Indeed he should not have picked the part up but as for repercussions what would be the point? What harm had he done. There was no mystery as to what plane it was and why it crashed so a small part of the aircraft is of no interest to the investigation.

After Lockerbie in Scotland some people were charged with taking plane parts but in that case they were looking for evidence of why it crashed.

As for pictures with politicians....This was DC! and my Wife has a picture of her with Princess Anne and I have one of me shaking hands with a British Prime Minister.......I was only 5 at the time but :)
Most People who accomplish something in life get to bump into VIPs and in DC its an occupational hazard!:rolleyes:
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom