3 Cornerstones of the Truther Movement

USAFMXOfficer

Scholar
Joined
Oct 9, 2007
Messages
73
I lurk here a lot, spend most of my debunking time over on IMDB, but after having experienced a lot of Truther tactics over the past several years, I have come to the conclusion there are 3 cornerstones to the Truther movement. Nearly every exchange between Truthers and Debunkers will include one if not more of the following:

1. ALL loud noises heard at WTC1, 2, or 7, the morning of 9/11, were, WITHOUT question, planted exposives detonating.

2. There is no "fog of war" in the Truther movement. Everything everyone said in conjunction with the attacks on 9/11 was EXACTLY what they meant to say. No one ever makes a mistake or misspeaks due to being in a highly stressful life or death situation.

3. Whenever any Truther is exposed to any evidence that appears to contradict a Truther "theory", then that evidence is, WITHOUT QUESTION, faked.

Any more from anyone?
 
I thought the 3 cornerstones of trutherism was...
1. Ignorance
2. Arrogance
3. Mental illness
 
An obvious one, but if somebody has become a truther, they've 'woken up'. However, if they ditch The Movement, they've been 'gotten to'.

Also, nobody just dies...
 
2. There is no "fog of war" in the Truther movement. Everything everyone said in conjunction with the attacks on 9/11 was EXACTLY what they meant to say. No one ever makes a mistake or misspeaks due to being in a highly stressful life or death situation.

Even with the statements people did mean to say, many of the truthers misinterpret or misrepresent them or presume the author meant something unintended; i.e. with Larry Silverstein's "pull it" statement. Alex Jones is engaging in outright fraud. On his radio show yesterday, he claimed twice that the police officers/firefighters around WTC 7 were telling people to get away because "We're going to blow up the building" when actually the police officers/firefighters were telling people to "get away," as a precaution, because it was possible the building might collapse, given its condition and the two earlier precedents.
 
Last edited:
I think the "real cornerstones" behind these kind of movements and beliefs are something like this:

1. Being exposed to bad and/or deceptive information
2. Finding some comfort or advantage in believing the theory
3. Investing self image and/or reputation in believing the theory leading to self delusion and rejection of new information.

However these things have been studied and someone somewhere probably has much better understanding about this subject than me.

But there seems to be some specific underlying "cornerstone arguments" that are quite well acknowledged among all 9/11 conspiracy theorists.

1. Above all, he towers could not have collapsed in the way we are told, thus the official story has to be incorrect. And if the official story is incorrect there has to be a cover-up.
2. The government, or some powerfull rogue part of the ruling elite has to be involved in the conspiracy because no-one else could have the means to accomplish something like this.
3. Therefore anyone or any organization heavily promoting and/or contributing to the creation of the official story cannot be trusted as the conspirators are very powerful and potentially capable of doing almost anything.

This is pretty much irrefutable circular reasoning. Many hard core truthers are beyond help.
 
There are two/three "process" features of trutherism which are usually combined into:

1) A shift of "burden of proof" Truther says "I think some feature says that it was CD you prove it wasn't";

2) Which is also a logical fallacy - the requirement to prove a negative; AND

3) the first in a potentially infinite series of negatives where the truther introduces another feature or moves the goalposts every time you knock over the last one.
 
Please say this is a joke. There are twoofers on IMDB? Where? I gotta see this.

Yes the "World Trade Center" and "United 93" movie boards used to crawl with truthers and debunkers. Truthers have mostly disappeared from IMDB now, however, although JSSTyger has decided to set up shop on IMDB now. I know he was over here for awhile.

Speaking of truthers we haven't seen for a bit....what ever happened to "Max Photon"? That guy was hilarious.
 
I lurk here a lot, spend most of my debunking time over on IMDB, but after having experienced a lot of Truther tactics over the past several years, I have come to the conclusion there are 3 cornerstones to the Truther movement. Nearly every exchange between Truthers and Debunkers will include one if not more of the following:

1. ALL loud noises heard at WTC1, 2, or 7, the morning of 9/11, were, WITHOUT question, planted exposives detonating.

2. There is no "fog of war" in the Truther movement. Everything everyone said in conjunction with the attacks on 9/11 was EXACTLY what they meant to say. No one ever makes a mistake or misspeaks due to being in a highly stressful life or death situation.

3. Whenever any Truther is exposed to any evidence that appears to contradict a Truther "theory", then that evidence is, WITHOUT QUESTION, faked.

Any more from anyone?

Kind of hard to blame this doofus on the "fog of war"

His name is Aziz El Hallan.
Many people are not aware of him, but late in the afternoon on 9/11 he showed up to the local Washington D.C Fox with an actual piece of what he claimed to be flight 77, as seen here (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WpBH6YwXYnU) If that isn't strange enough, he claims to have been on the road for 15-20 minutes (after the attack), yet there is a picture of him at the latest 8 minutes after the attack, taken by an official military photographer, as seen here.( http://pilotsfor911truth.org/forum/index.php?showtopic=8818) It is at the Navy annex. Very strange indeed, also this photo was omitted from the official DOD release.
 
I lurk here a lot, spend most of my debunking time over on IMDB, but after having experienced a lot of Truther tactics over the past several years, I have come to the conclusion there are 3 cornerstones to the Truther movement. Nearly every exchange between Truthers and Debunkers will include one if not more of the following:

1. ALL loud noises heard at WTC1, 2, or 7, the morning of 9/11, were, WITHOUT question, planted exposives detonating.

2. There is no "fog of war" in the Truther movement. Everything everyone said in conjunction with the attacks on 9/11 was EXACTLY what they meant to say. No one ever makes a mistake or misspeaks due to being in a highly stressful life or death situation.

3. Whenever any Truther is exposed to any evidence that appears to contradict a Truther "theory", then that evidence is, WITHOUT QUESTION, faked.

Any more from anyone?

I sometimes suspect brain damage from a "fog of radon", seeing as how much troother research is done in Mom's basement, and we all know how poorly ventilated basements can harbor that potentially harmful gas. ;)
 
Fascinating. The links can almost certainly be attributed to the "fog of war" yet you post just the opposite.

WHY is it hard to assert "fog of war" in this situation?

I hope you're not serious. Kind of hard to say you were on the road in front of the pentagon when you were at the Annex. It's kind of hard to say you have a piece of the plane, when although I can't 100% say for sure he doesn't, I'm about 99.9% sure that isn't a piece of the plane. Also if he were just some guy that said he found a piece and wrote about it on the internet, I would say that he is just some nut. But the fact he was let into a TV studio, seems to indicate something else was going on. I mean think about it, how does something like that even happen? What did he do call up the studio and say "Hey I have a piece of the plane." If so, why did they not say you should give that to the FBI, if they believed him at all?
 
Last edited:
I...." If so, why did they not say you should give that to the FBI, if they believed him at all?
Why would the FBI need a piece of the plane. By the time 77 hits the Pentagon, it is clear it was not an accident. When a plane crash is not an accident it is correct the FBI is in charge, or the police. But since this was not a secret if this guy has a plane part, there is time to get the part if needed. Why would you need the part?
 
Kind of hard to blame this doofus on the "fog of war"

His name is Aziz El Hallan.
Many people are not aware of him, but late in the afternoon on 9/11 he showed up to the local Washington D.C Fox with an actual piece of what he claimed to be flight 77, as seen here (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WpBH6YwXYnU) If that isn't strange enough, he claims to have been on the road for 15-20 minutes (after the attack), yet there is a picture of him at the latest 8 minutes after the attack, taken by an official military photographer, as seen here.( http://pilotsfor911truth.org/forum/index.php?showtopic=8818) It is at the Navy annex. Very strange indeed, also this photo was omitted from the official DOD release.

Thanks for the enlightening re-visit to the dementia that is the CIT. Note that there are no timestamps or official records listed for the photo (which does look like El Hallan) just the usual, "I know a guy who knows a guy who got a picture" claims and even then, they can't agree on whether the picture was taken two minutes or twenty minutes after the event. Why not forty minutes?

Further and much more important.... where does this piece of plane fit into the investigation? In the reams of evidence from the Pentagon attack, why would this one lone claimant's little moment in the sun be considered so significant. No one's ever heard of this great piece of field work by the CIT. It's totally insignificant except to nit-picking loons who find conspiracies in everything they saw on TV that day.

This little interview was seen on a local TV station in Washington and didn't get any air play of any significance. It's the equivalent of a human interest filler in your daily newspaper. Yet, the brilliant minds of the CIT wove it into an important cog in the vast (impossibly vast) conspiracy.
 
And here I thought the "3 Cornerstones" were Moe, Larry and Curly.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom