3 Cornerstones of the Truther Movement

tmd2 1 said:
As for skid marks I always assumed they would be there somewhere, can you explain why there are none?
Because when you fly you are usually not in contact with the ground. Hence the term "flying". When the plane is in contact with the ground it is taxiing. AFAIK flight 77 did not taxi into the pentagon. Nor did it attempt to stop. Hence the lack of skid marks. Perhaps there were some INSIDE the building.:eye-poppi

As for the clocks, it would be a fairly straightforward experiment to get a similar clock, set the hands to 9:38 and drop it along a wall from a height of 6 feet or so to see whether the hands are jarred from their position. In fact, I think I'm going to look into it.
 
1.Right so all those clocks that stopped at 9:32 mean nothing? Let's just forget about them. Who cares? You can rationalize it all you want, those clocks are damning. Let me show here are two of the clocks one that hung in the Smithsonian, and another posted on the official Navy website. I think it's good for people to actually see it.

Nobody is "rationalizing" anything away. EVERY clock or measure of time shows a different time. NOTHING unusual about that. I would only find it odd if all of the clocks and measures said the same thing. Now that would not be normal.
 
The debris are skid marks are almost one in the same. I would expect them to be somewhat near the impact zone.
Can you quantify that? Or mark on a map or aerial photo?
Is 500 feet away from the wall "somewhat near", or would you consider 50 feet away from wall as "not somewhat near"?
Would you expect the skid marks precisely in the flight path, or how far away from it could they stray? Which path do you consider to be the true flight path anyway?

You see, you haven't really done anything to answer my question.

I believe that video gives us enough of a vantage point that we should see something. Skid marks because it is awfully hard to keep that plane in such a position that it did not bounce and yet the roof did not collapse initially.
huh? I am not sure I understand what you mean.
The plane did not bounce off of what? The lawn? The wall?
And what has the roof got to do with this?
Also, why does it matter if it is easy or "awfully hard to keep that plane in such a position"? Wouldn't be the actual path and orientation ("position") of the plane be all that matters? You see, we are looking at this ex-post.

Even if we believe this is possible I think some of the blow back of parts would cause skid marks, I mean they didn't just land and stay there,they had to be moving. I'm not sure why that would not have left a skid mark.
You mean you want to see skid marks of pieces of debris that you say are not there? Strange.

How do you think any plane parts at all would have fallen in front of the building? Can you describe the motion(s) and what it (they) would be caused by? For example, do you think that some plane parts would have been ripped off the wings upon impact with light poles and landed on the lawn with considerable, albeit reduced speed, moving still towards the building; or do you think pieces would be ripped off upon collision with wall, deflected from wall roughly like a billard ball would, and land on the lawn with considerable, albeit reduced speed, moving away from the building?
Or do you consider that the intact plane would have made ground contact, creating big skid marks and ripping of debris that moves toward the building? Etc.
 
1.Right so all those clocks that stopped at 9:32 mean nothing? Let's just forget about them. Who cares? You can rationalize it all you want, those clocks are damning. Let me show here are two of the clocks one that hung in the Smithsonian, and another posted on the official Navy website. I think it's good for people to actually see it.

http://www.americanhistory.si.edu/september11/collection/record.asp?ID=19

http://www.navy.mil/view_single.asp?id=2480Pentagonclock_BBC

They don't count as evidence unless they're on Youtube :rolleyes:

While checking out clocks, have you found any photos of AA77 wreckage yet?
 
Can you quantify that? Or mark on a map or aerial photo?
Is 500 feet away from the wall "somewhat near", or would you consider 50 feet away from wall as "not somewhat near"?
Would you expect the skid marks precisely in the flight path, or how far away from it could they stray? Which path do you consider to be the true flight path anyway?

You see, you haven't really done anything to answer my question.


huh? I am not sure I understand what you mean.
The plane did not bounce off of what? The lawn? The wall?
And what has the roof got to do with this?
Also, why does it matter if it is easy or "awfully hard to keep that plane in such a position"? Wouldn't be the actual path and orientation ("position") of the plane be all that matters? You see, we are looking at this ex-post.


You mean you want to see skid marks of pieces of debris that you say are not there? Strange.

How do you think any plane parts at all would have fallen in front of the building? Can you describe the motion(s) and what it (they) would be caused by? For example, do you think that some plane parts would have been ripped off the wings upon impact with light poles and landed on the lawn with considerable, albeit reduced speed, moving still towards the building; or do you think pieces would be ripped off upon collision with wall, deflected from wall roughly like a billard ball would, and land on the lawn with considerable, albeit reduced speed, moving away from the building?
Or do you consider that the intact plane would have made ground contact, creating big skid marks and ripping of debris that moves toward the building? Etc.

No...I am not playing this game with you. I know full well what you are trying to do. There's a plane, there's debris all around on the ground, the parts didn't just gently fall to the ground. Small as most of them were, it would seem there should be some skid marks. People can watch those videos and decide for themselves.
 
No...I am not playing this game with you. I know full well what you are trying to do. There's a plane, there's debris all around on the ground, the parts didn't just gently fall to the ground. Small as most of them were, it would seem there should be some skid marks. People can watch those videos and decide for themselves.

The only problem is that the plane did not hit the ground before hitting the building. The right engine struck the TOP of the generator just before impact. The FDR radar altimeter supports that it remained above ground. To have skid marks, it had to touch the ground. It did not.
 
The only problem is that the plane did not hit the ground before hitting the building. The right engine struck the TOP of the generator just before impact. The FDR radar altimeter supports that it remained above ground. To have skid marks, it had to touch the ground. It did not.

Skid marks from the debris? I mean they just gently floated to the ground? I have not seen a picture showing this. Maybe it exists just saying I haven't seen it.
 
Skid marks from the debris? I mean they just gently floated to the ground? I have not seen a picture showing this. Maybe it exists just saying I haven't seen it.

Why would the debris leave skid marks?
 
Why would the debris leave skid marks?
I worked, actually I "owned", a crash site for an USAF aircraft accident. The airspeed indicator was ejected hundreds of feet out of the cockpit as it crashed into the ground. It looked like it was dropped gently by hand in the grass, in what appeared to be perfect condition. No skid marks past the initial aircraft impact zone.

Your physics example was ignored and not extended to the 3-D world of reality by the 911 truth Follower.

He fails to realize the parts were ejected in the air during impact, they were not going 488 knots anymore, they were ejected up in the air, and fell to the ground, as in down. You did give him the pool table model, and he failed to comprehend.

How many aircraft accidents has he worked?
 
Why would the debris leave skid marks?

I mean when you cut your grass, don't the tires leave marks? Wouldn't the same thing apply here? It seems like it would. That debris would have been traveling awfully fast.
 
Have you watched the gate camera footage? The debris did not travel in a straight line, but an angular trajectory until it ultimately landed on the ground. That aside, from the videos you keep refering to, they do not capture the debris field area (helipad area).

I have not worked a plane crash, but I've worked my share of traffic accidents and the only skid marks I have ever encountered were caused by the vehicles involved, not the debris. Perhaps you can find a photograph of an aircraft accident scene with which to illustrate the concept.
 
Have you watched the gate camera footage? The debris did not travel in a straight line, but an angular trajectory until it ultimately landed on the ground. That aside, from the videos you keep refering to, they do not capture the debris field area (helipad area).

I have not worked a plane crash, but I've worked my share of traffic accidents and the only skid marks I have ever encountered were caused by the vehicles involved, not the debris. Perhaps you can find a photograph of an aircraft accident scene with which to illustrate the concept.

I mean not really. Just imagine a piece of siding from your house and it going real fast across your grass. I think it would leave some mark. I didn't see anything like that at the pentagon. Maybe I'm wrong in that link of thinking, or that there were no marks, but that's what I'm trying to say.
 
I mean not really. Just imagine a piece of siding from your house and it going real fast across your grass. I think it would leave some mark. I didn't see anything like that at the pentagon. Maybe I'm wrong in that link of thinking, or that there were no marks, but that's what I'm trying to say.

Well, I just did a google search of air crash photos and I could not find any that show what you describe. So leaving skid marks on the grass does not seem to be a very common thing for debris.
 
I worked, actually I "owned", a crash site for an USAF aircraft accident. The airspeed indicator was ejected hundreds of feet out of the cockpit as it crashed into the ground. It looked like it was dropped gently by hand in the grass, in what appeared to be perfect condition. No skid marks past the initial aircraft impact zone.

Your physics example was ignored and not extended to the 3-D world of reality by the 911 truth Follower.

He fails to realize the parts were ejected in the air during impact, they were not going 488 knots anymore, they were ejected up in the air, and fell to the ground, as in down. You did give him the pool table model, and he failed to comprehend.

How many aircraft accidents has he worked?

Yeah that is kinda what I would expect Beachnut. Debris goes up, then comes down. Some of it came down as far away as Reagan NAP. Came down in Arlington National Cemetery. Came down in the Doubletree parking lot. Watched it on camera as it landed. No lateral movement to it that I saw.
 
Well, I just did a google search of air crash photos and I could not find any that show what you describe. So leaving skid marks on the grass does not seem to be a very common thing for debris.

Like I said I could be wrong. But as you "debunkers" like to point out how many accidents have the A/C going over 500 MPH? As far as skid marks from the plane itself, I will leave that to viewers to decide for themselves if they should be there, and what else they see in the video.

Aziz and the clocks speak for themselves, all of your rationalizing and excuses can not change it.
 
Like I said I could be wrong. But as you "debunkers" like to point out how many accidents have the A/C going over 500 MPH? As far as skid marks from the plane itself, I will leave that to viewers to decide for themselves if they should be there, and what else they see in the video.

Aziz and the clocks speak for themselves, all of your rationalizing and excuses can not change it.

The clocks prove people don't use their wall clocks for anything, we get them issued to us, to put on the wall. I never recall an office in the USAF where we worried about the wall clock being accurate. We were pilots, we all kept our own time, we did not use the wall clock to do anything but comment how far off they were! If anything, the wall clocks being 5 minutes to 7 minute behind the real time is an effort for the office to arrive on time; gee boss, see, I am on time! lol, the dumbest thing is the Pentagon clocks right up with Nukes, thermite, and DEW. Dumb!

Skid marks is kind of far out. What is your point? How do you get a skid mark from this?
111pentagonplanedebris.jpg

Skid marks? What are you talking about?


911 crashes were not accidents, they were aiming at buildings, until they failed with 93.
Is this a skid mark?
pentagonbrickwall.jpg


Flight 93, are these skid marks with over a 500 mph impact?
flt93debris21sm.jpg

Where are the skid marks? 300 to 400 feet, debris ejected from the impact of 93. What happens when an aircraft hits the ground. Do you know what angle 93 hit at? Any clue?
 
And how about that? You are!

And what he does not realize is that 99% of the people reading this thread know it as well. But then again, he is a troll and really does not care what people think of him as long as they keep responding to his foolishness. But I was bored today, so troll-feeder I am today ;)
 
No...I am not playing this game with you.
This is not a game.
I want you to walk through a full thought processes.
You need to learn that just making stuff up is no substitute for finding facts, and assessing them with logic, science and actual empirical knowledge.

I know full well what you are trying to do. There's a plane, there's debris all around on the ground, the parts didn't just gently fall to the ground. Small as most of them were, it would seem there should be some skid marks. People can watch those videos and decide for themselves.
You say that you are missing visible debris and skid marks in specific video segments.
And your reason for saying that is
would
seem
should
And not even an indication where you think that debris and skid marks "would" "seem" to "should" be there.

Your argument boils down to "in my imagination I make something up, and if videos of real events do not look like my imagination, they are not really real".
That is the way a 3-year old might think.

Grow up already!
 
I mean not really. Just imagine a piece of siding from your house and it going real fast across your grass. I think it would leave some mark. I didn't see anything like that at the pentagon. Maybe I'm wrong in that link of thinking, or that there were no marks, but that's what I'm trying to say.

Maybe.

Do you have any idea how you can find out for yourself?
I can think of at least four different ways that your thinking could be checked for accuracy - not all of them easy or readily available to you or me perhaps, but still valid methods. Can you think of at least one?

I got a hint: Among the most recent few posts, three of the methods I am thinking of right now have been at least hinted at.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom