3 Cornerstones of the Truther Movement

I don't know exactly never made that claim. They (BCR etc..did) What I've said is that video seems to defy what one would expect by simple observation. I would like for them to show why we are not seeing, what a reasonable person would expect to see.

Personal incredulity rocks!

Perhaps you can explain a few other things about physics that defy what one would expect, such as why light behaves as both a wave and a particle, or why electrons can suddenly appear on the other side of a barrier.

No, I am not suggesting quantum physics effects were dominant on Sept 11 any more than they are now. This is just to illustrate that 'common sense' can many times be renamed 'common ignorance'. The later would seem to apply so very well to you.
 
The point is clocks as in more than one. Look up that link to see how many. So all of those clocks had the wrong time? Not only that they all had the same wrong time? I mean they were within a minute of each other either way.
I don't know about the Pentagon, but if it's anything like the Air Force base I work at, the clocks are cheap, battery operated clocks (often made by Lighthouse for the Blind). There are hundreds of these clocks just in the building I work in - so many in fact, I quit wearing a wristwatch over 25 years ago.

If I look at the clock in my office, then walk 20 ft away into a shop area, they are off by over 6 minutes, 50 ft from that is a clock in the dock area that is off by 5 minutes (in the other extreme). So not only do neither of those clock match my office clock, but the two I compared mine too are 11 minutes apart.

Putting any stock into the Pentagon clocks being a few minutes off is just silly IMO. Why are you wasting your time on this "evidence"?
 
You want to talk about about a lack of Physics knowledge? Look at the missile thread debacle you had. I mean I think you could have greatest physicist in the world work together and they wouldn't know what you were trying to say. Which is proabably a good thing. I'm not sure you knew what you were trying to say. Which may be an even better thing.

Are you talking about the post where he calculated the release point of the supposed missile, made an error in his calcs. and promptly corrected it?

If so, I knew what he was trying to say, and I've only had three university level physics courses.

I wouldn't blame someone else for your own lack of knowledge.

I count 8 physics, one chemistry and 6 math courses at that level. OTOH they were all a quarter of a century ago and I switched from physics to college electronics before completing my B.Sc. (a physics B.Sc. qualifies you to go to teacher's college and then teach high school, to go on to a Masters degree,,,, or drive a taxi. A college electronics diploma was a ticket to a job in the field upon graduation. But I digress)
Regardless though, the calcs I did in the 'missile' thread used formulae that I first was exposed to in high school and requires only high school level algebra.



Everybody but me hungh? Yet I was the only one (and this includes you) who commented on it one way or the other, after awhile I just gave up. He kept changing his mind, saying he made mistakes...etc. What he had initially seemed correct. I think we both know I have some clue about physics, ........... But this thread is not about this missile ?

No its not about a supposed missile but you were prtesented with a demonstration of a physics concept and you pooh-poohed it and attempted to handwave it away.
I point out that you were incapable of following the physics calcs I posted in the 'missile' thread.

Yes, the calcs that I immediatly corrected as soon as I noticed them. The first mistakes were the direct result of trying to write them out in formatted text using 2[/ sup] and other formatting oddities that really make reading it difficult. I should have written it down on paper first(as I said in that thread). The second (and only other) mistake that I corrected was obvious as it did not conform to the math I had just laid out. Basically it was a typo. In at least one post I practically begged you to point out any mistake in my math. Often when I do post claculations I include such an exhortation to correct me. I ask for and invite correction, but not a peep from you who, it would seem, has the most to gain from pointing out a mistake I made in that thread. No one else did notice the mistakes but no one else was as attached to the subject as you and YOU did not notice them either, instead you simply took the results as a given. So when PfT or the CiT make mistakes do you do the same? Just accept their pronouncements? Furthermore you have had the temerity to defend the 911 conspiracy phrase 'free fall speed', even going so far as to suggest that it is the better term to use. This despite the fact that it goes against several conventions of 2 centuries of physics study. You do realize that with that you were saying that you and the other 911 conspiracists who use that term are better physicists than ,for instance, Issac Newton? With all that weighing you down pray tell why should we take anything you say seriously?
2 points. First ,beachnut?? LOL Oh my God, now that is funny. Did you ever notice how many of his posts get ignored, I mean not responded to, even by "debunkers?" I don't mean to make fun of him...but there's probably a reason for that. The other two are smart no doubt about that, maybe beachnut is too I don't know, he doesn't always come across that way. I believe the other two are intentionally deceiving, and will spout anything as long as they think it is "debunking" Second point, your answer to the physics was nothing short of what I expected.
Beachnut is a pilot and former crash investigator. He has correctly pointed out that the brain trust at PfT is wrong about several things, not the least of which is still adhered to by John Lear. That is that an aircraft absolutly cannot exceed Vmo (according to Lear), when in fact this is the upper limit that Boeing puts on the aircraft as part of its certification that the a/c will perform well. According to Lear though, the a/c will practically immediatly disintegrate at this speed. That's 1 for Beachnut who points out that such a position is ridiculous(in typical Beachnut fashion) He also points out, at every mention of PfT, that the Balsamo brain trust completely ball'd up physics and math in their 11 g 'paper' which they left up on their site for months (years? is it still there?) Personally I do not see why I or anyone else needs to respond to Beachnut's posts unless he makes a mistake or I have a question. In looking at his last few posts again, nope, no mistakes and no questions.
 
Last edited:
Hmmm, I checked a few clocks here. In ascending order, my computer said it was 1:04, my cable box said it was 1:05, my cell phone said 1:06, and my clock radio said 1:08, and my watch said 1:10.

I would tend to take the cell phone and cable box as the most accurate and given that they do not display seconds they may well be within 30 seconds of each other.

At work we take feeds from the CTV network and thus corordinate our clock with them. This is a few minutes different than WWV time. The automated master control system clock must be reset every day or so as its only as good as any computer timer. The clock on the wall must be reset every single day (more often when the battery is getting low). Granted that a difference of greater than 5 seconds demands correction in that enviroment.
 
The point is clocks as in more than one. Look up that link to see how many. So all of those clocks had the wrong time? Not only that they all had the same wrong time? I mean they were within a minute of each other either way.


read my post again. This time try to understand it.
 
Putting any stock into the Pentagon clocks being a few minutes off is just silly IMO. Why are you wasting your time on this "evidence"?

Because, he says, it is evidence that supports a contention that an explosion went off BEFORE the aircraft hit the Pentagon. Apparently it goes off a full 5 minutes prior, while the aircraft is still several miles from impact ( It would travel about 20 miles in 5 minutes assuming an average speed between 250 and 300 MPH). No smoke or flying glass, no alarms, no people streaming out of the building, no calls to 911 are made as a result of this prior explosion though (or ones that describe two obviously separate events) and even April Gallop, no friend of the 'official story' makes no claim that there were two incidents separated by 5 minutes.

In point of fact all reports from people in the Pentagon at the time is that all was quiet and well until suddenly all H broke loose at once, not a little H then a whole lot 5 minutes later.

Given the evidence for a prior explosion is nil and the fact that clocks not being accurate to within 1 minute of 'true' time is commonplace, it is a practical certainty that no such prior explosion took place.

So its really looking like I was correct in my assumption that this would be a case of tmd hanging onto a contention long after it is thoroughly countered, and another illustration of his dogmatic approach to 9/11.
 
Last edited:
I count 8 physics, one chemistry and 6 math courses at that level. OTOH they were all a quarter of a century ago and I switched from physics to college electronics before completing my B.Sc. (a physics B.Sc. qualifies you to go to teacher's college and then teach high school, to go on to a Masters degree,,,, or drive a taxi. A college electronics diploma was a ticket to a job in the field upon graduation. But I digress)
Regardless though, the calcs I did in the 'missile' thread used formulae that I first was exposed to in high school and requires only high school level algebra.





No its not about a supposed missile but you were prtesented with a demonstration of a physics concept and you pooh-poohed it and attempted to handwave it away.
I point out that you were incapable of following the physics calcs I posted in the 'missile' thread.

Yes, the calcs that I immediatly corrected as soon as I noticed them. The first mistakes were the direct result of trying to write them out in formatted text using 2[/ sup] and other formatting oddities that really make reading it difficult. I should have written it down on paper first(as I said in that thread). The second (and only other) mistake that I corrected was obvious as it did not conform to the math I had just laid out. Basically it was a typo. In at least one post I practically begged you to point out any mistake in my math. Often when I do post claculations I include such an exhortation to correct me. I ask for and invite correction, but not a peep from you who, it would seem, has the most to gain from pointing out a mistake I made in that thread. No one else did notice the mistakes but no one else was as attached to the subject as you and YOU did not notice them either, instead you simply took the results as a given. So when PfT or the CiT make mistakes do you do the same? Just accept their pronouncements? Furthermore you have had the temerity to defend the 911 conspiracy phrase 'free fall speed', even going so far as to suggest that it is the better term to use. This despite the fact that it goes against several conventions of 2 centuries of physics study. You do realize that with that you were saying that you and the other 911 conspiracists who use that term are better physicists than ,for instance, Issac Newton? With all that weighing you down pray tell why should we take anything you say seriously? Beachnut is a pilot and former crash investigator. He has correctly pointed out that the brain trust at PfT is wrong about several things, not the least of which is still adhered to by John Lear. That is that an aircraft absolutly cannot exceed Vmo (according to Lear), when in fact this is the upper limit that Boeing puts on the aircraft as part of its certification that the a/c will perform well. According to Lear though, the a/c will practically immediatly disintegrate at this speed. That's 1 for Beachnut who points out that such a position is ridiculous(in typical Beachnut fashion) He also points out, at every mention of PfT, that the Balsamo brain trust completely ball'd up physics and math in their 11 g 'paper' which they left up on their site for months (years? is it still there?) Personally I do not see why I or anyone else needs to respond to Beachnut's posts unless he makes a mistake or I have a question.
I don't care what you were trying to or not do in that other thread, I really don't. I gave up trying to follow it, I gave my own calculations, showing that there would be enough KE to penetrate the column. That's based on the missile hitting half a second or so before the plane hits. I know you think the flash was after impact, so we'll just have to disagree. From now on you can be assured I won't pay any attention to it. In regards to freefall speed re-read it, I clearly said acceleration was the better term, just that speed in not an incorrect term. So let's see you are evidently color blind, you can't see silver or orange. You think the flash is before impact as evident by you spending a lot of time trying to explain a compression zone to me, then someone suggests it is an oxygen bottle, now the flash is after impact. You do resort to name calling, remember this was you who started this, by claiming I didn't know anything about Physics. And it is I who people should not take seriously? As I've just stated, you have exhibited behavior that has things in common with deceivers. Why you choose to do this I don't know, but you clearly are.
 
Hmmm, I checked a few clocks here. In ascending order, my computer said it was 1:04, my cable box said it was 1:05, my cell phone said 1:06, and my clock radio said 1:08, and my watch said 1:10.

I would tend to take the cell phone and cable box as the most accurate and given that they do not display seconds they may well be within 30 seconds of each other.

At work we take feeds from the CTV network and thus corordinate our clock with them. This is a few minutes different than WWV time. The automated master control system clock must be reset every day or so as its only as good as any computer timer. The clock on the wall must be reset every single day (more often when the battery is getting low). Granted that a difference of greater than 5 seconds demands correction in that enviroment.

I have 2:31 (computer) 2:33 (phone) and 2:30 (wall clock)
 
I don't know about the Pentagon, but if it's anything like the Air Force base I work at, the clocks are cheap, battery operated clocks (often made by Lighthouse for the Blind). There are hundreds of these clocks just in the building I work in - so many in fact, I quit wearing a wristwatch over 25 years ago.

If I look at the clock in my office, then walk 20 ft away into a shop area, they are off by over 6 minutes, 50 ft from that is a clock in the dock area that is off by 5 minutes (in the other extreme). So not only do neither of those clock match my office clock, but the two I compared mine too are 11 minutes apart.

Putting any stock into the Pentagon clocks being a few minutes off is just silly IMO. Why are you wasting your time on this "evidence"?
I think the problem here is that tmd2_1 doesn't work in an environment where there is more than one clock (Burger joints tend to be quite small afterall) He cannot fathom the concept that clocks don't all tell the same time. He would also not be aware that most clocks in workplaces run on batteries and batteries run down or that clocks can be set by human beings and human beings make mistakes. I also suspect that he has no idea how difficult it can be get a department to change the time of a clock if the clock is out of normal reach.

I myself have been waging a battle, putting in complaint after complaint to the maintenance department to get all of the clocks I see everyday synchronised with one another. It really pains me to see the clocks on the PCs, the clocks on the walls, the clock on the microwave along with everyone's wristwatches and other time keeping devices to not reading the same time. It's a scandal I tell you. In fact, come to think of it, I'm beginning to suspect a conspiracy.

Oh btw that last bit was sarcasm - just so truthers understand because reading comprehension is not one of their strong points.
 
Because, he says, it is evidence that supports a contention that an explosion went off BEFORE the aircraft hit the Pentagon. Apparently it goes off a full 5 minutes prior, while the aircraft is still several miles from impact ( It would travel about 20 miles in 5 minutes assuming an average speed between 250 and 300 MPH). No smoke or flying glass, no alarms, no people streaming out of the building, no calls to 911 are made as a result of this prior explosion though (or ones that describe two obviously separate events) and even April Gallop, no friend of the 'official story' makes no claim that there were two incidents separated by 5 minutes.

Given the evidence for a prior explosion is nil and the fact that clocks not being accurate to within 1 minute of 'true' time is commonplace it is a practical certainty that no such prior explosion took place.

So its really looking like I was correct in my assumption that this would be a case of tmd hanging onto a contention long after it is thoroughly countered, and another illustration of his dogmatic approach to 9/11.

What was thoroughly countered? Weren't the A/C going over 500 MPH? I've stated that I don't know perhaps there were two events. Those clocks are very damning evidence, you'll never admit it, but they are. The initial early attack time is damning evidence again you'll never admit it. Aziz casts doubts as to what going on, you'll never admit it.
 
I have 2:31 (computer) 2:33 (phone) and 2:30 (wall clock)
I think you should know that perhaps there is a NWO conspiracy to alter your clocks. I take at least 20 minutes each morning synchronising all my clocks so that they can't get to me. Unfortunately last March I was late - not because it took me 20 minutes to set all my clocks, but I forgot about daylight saving, which I also believe is a conspiracy, because who else other than the NWO could steal our time?
 
I think you should know that perhaps there is a NWO conspiracy to alter your clocks. I take at least 20 minutes each morning synchronising all my clocks so that they can't get to me. Unfortunately last March I was late - not because it took me 20 minutes to set all my clocks, but I forgot about daylight saving, which I also believe is a conspiracy, because who else other than the NWO could steal our time?

Give up, all the clocks (I mean all the clocks that were damaged) showing about the same time, and no I would not expect to find a 6 to 7 minute difference between most wall clocks. That I believe is a level where most people would notice.
 
No, it is not YOUR best guess. You have been told to believe it is Aziz, and you refuse the entertain the possibility that they, and you, simply err.
If you DID use your own head independently, you'd have toned down your story from the beginning, or at the latest when you realized that there are THREE Aziz look-alikes in that one photo alone, which should have made you aware that your story is on very shaky grounds. You don't know if Aziz was next to the Navy Annex at all, and if he was, you don't know exactly when he was there.

My brother is bald, I am almost bald. Both of us were 1000+ miles away from Viginia on Sept 11/01 thus it proves that Aziz could not have done what he said he did!
 
Give up, all the clocks (I mean all the clocks that were damaged) showing about the same time, and no I would not expect to find a 6 to 7 minute difference between most wall clocks. That I believe is a level where most people would notice.

lol really? I have several clocks in my house and they are all off from each other. I once walked around with a watch a hour out for a year because I couldnt be bothered to change it back after going on holiday.
 
Give up, all the clocks (I mean all the clocks that were damaged) showing about the same time, and no I would not expect to find a 6 to 7 minute difference between most wall clocks. That I believe is a level where most people would notice.

really? prove it........and personal incredulity noted.
 
read that link

That article is STUPID.

STUPID.....its also RETARDED. I explained some of the issues already to you in it....

I mean just the mysterious "clocks" ALONE is enough to render the article completely brain dead....then they bring up April Gallop's "experience with explosives in the Army" and her "Top Secret" clearance...

Top Secret! OMG....Surely THAT makes her credible! I mean that is SUCH a HIGH level clearance :rolleyes:

Surely someone working on "declassifying documents" at the Pentagon is an expert in all kinds of things, right?

Get a freaking grip tmd.

Stop
Being
Stupid
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom