10 story hole in WTC 7

Status
Not open for further replies.
Christopher 7,
Just what is the initiating event your are referring to and where did it occur?

areaofinitiatingeventli5.png
 
There were no diesel fuel fires or debris damage in the area of the initiating event* that led to the global collapse of WTC 7.

*NIST Apx. L pg 30 - 33
http://img96.imageshack.us.img96/1337/areaofinitiatingeventli5.png


References:

NIST Appendix L
http://wtc.nist.gov/progress_report_june04/appendixl.pdf
[note: pg 18 is pg 22 on the page counter]

NIST Final 4-5-05
http://wtc.nist.gov/pubs/WTC%20Part%20IIC%20-%20WTC%207%20Collapse%20Final.pdf

FEMA Chapter 5
http:/www.fema.gov/pdf/library/fema403_ch5.pdf
[copy and paste in URL bar]


Debris damage:

- Southwest corner damage extended over floors 8 to 18 [NIST Apx. L pg 18]

- Damage starting at roof level....5 to 10 floors....near south west corner [NIST Apx. L pg 18]

- Large debris hole near center of south face around floor 14 [NIST Apx. L pg 18]
[just west of center*]

- South face damage, middle 1/4 - 1/3 width south face, floor 10 to ground [NIST Final 4-5-05 pg 15]

- No heavt debris in lobby area [NIST Apx. L pg 18]

- Damage...of core framing is not known [NIST Apx. L pg 51]

- Only damage to south wall on 9th floor at SW corner [FEMA Ch. 5 pg 20]

- 8th or 9th floor....2 elevator cars ejected into hallway north of elevator shaft, visible portion of south wall was gone....possible damage extended to the west [NIST Apx. L pg 18]


Explosion heard on floor 8
[http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=6475257160515133665&q=wtc7+new+footage
Start at 6:20 min.
[Warning: audio very loud and distorted, turn down volume before viewing]

* Steve Spak photograph with location of perimeter columns added graphically.
http://img165.imageshack.us/img165/9000/copyofwtc7holeanalysiscyk0.jpg


Looking from the south east corner of the south face:
Fire was seen on the 12th floor on the south face;
the face above the fire was covered with smoke [NIST Apx. L pg 24]
[the face below floor 12 was not covered with smoke]

No debris damage to the east 1/3 of the south face was reported

Debris would have to enter between columns 8 and 11 [Spak#] to damage core columns in the area of the initiating event.

sfacegraphic3np6.jpg


********************************************************

Fires:

There were no diesel fuel fed fires in the east half of WTC 7 where the initial event, that led to the collapse, occurred.

FEMA pg 28
[bolding mine]

Fuel oil was distributed through the 5th floor in a double wall pipe.
A portion of the piping was in close proximity to Truss 1
However, there is no physical, photographic or other evidence to substantiate or refute the discharge of fuel oil from the piping system.

The following is, therefore, a hypothesis based on potential rather than demonstrated fact.
Assume that the distribution piping system was severed.....

The east generator room was in the north east corner of WTC 7 on the 5th floor.
The supply pipe for the east generator room was north of the wall that is on the north side of the mechanical room, 90' from the south side of the building. [FEMA pg 14 - 15]

If the generators [and the pump feeding fuel oil to them] were running, the louver vents would be open. [FEMA pg 29]

http://img208.imageshack.us/img208/937/e5pt8.jpg

If there was a fire in this room, smoke would be pouring out thru the vents.

********************************************************

Fire on floor 12

Form 11:30 a.m. to 2:30 p.m. it burned west to east across the south side

From 2:00 to 3:00 p.m., the fire progresses north along east side
http://img262.imageshack.us/img262/7555/e40rv.jpg

About 3:00 p.m., it reached the north side, east of center, and spread in both directions
http://img337.imageshack.us/img337/6500/n5pq6.jpg
http://img401.imageshack.us/img401/5236/n6oj1.jpg

By 4:45 the fire on floor 12 had burned out
http://img84.imageshack.us/img84/2337/copyofwtc716474jw7rf2.jpg
Video of north side after fires on floors 7, 12 and 13 had burned out
http://vids.myspace.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=vids.individual&videoid=1548030539


Other fires:

11:30 a.m. to 2:30 p.m.: fire on floor 22 on south side
About 12:15 p.m.: Fire on floor 7 at west wall, toward the south side
2:00 to 2:20 p.m.: fire on floor 11 at SE corner, progressing north
Around 3:00 p.m.: fire on floor 7 near middle of north side
Sometime later, fire on floors 8 and 13
Fire on floor 8 eventually burned to NE corner and moved to east face

[NIST Apx. L pg 22 - 26]

********************************************************

The reports of fire to the east part of WTC 7 are not going to change in the final report.
The reports given are clear, the times are accurate enough to track the progression of the fires.
 
Last edited:
Here are some photos of office fires on the 12 floor of WTC 7.

http://www.amanzafar.com/WTC/wtc38.JPG

http://www.amanzafar.com/WTC/wtc23.JPG
Ain't no way i'm buyin' into the missle thing but that first photo is interesting.
You cannot say definitively that there is fire there but it is a possibility.

However, my primary concern is the lack of debris damage or diesel fires in the area of the initiating event. [post #1601]
I would prefer that you comment on post #1602

Thank you

Chris
 
I would admit from examining the diagrams of the fuel system layout and probable debris damage that C7 does have a point. I do think it was highly unlikely that diesel fuel fires from the Salomon emergency power system occurred in the eastern half of the building near the critical columns. Aside from the general idea that it might be too low in the building.
Thank you

I also found a writeup that suggested the possibilty that the large areas supported by each critical column in the eastern side and the ordinary office fires on and around the 12th floor may have resulted in circumstances leading to the buckling of critical columns which initiated the collapse. The writeup suggested a situation (floor sag, for instance) leading to column(s) being pulled off-center enough to initiate buckling.
Key words here are suggested and may have.


I would state that I find the idea of a clandestine act to demolish 7 WTC to be unfounded at this point. A lack of evidence is a big part. If NIST were to find that it was possible to initiate the collapse deliberately, without breaking windows or creating explosive sounds, I'd admit to plausibility but would otherwise be unconvinced.
Daryl said "we heard this sound that sounded like a clap of thunder....it looked like there was a shockwave ripping through the building and all the windows busted out"
 
Is MaGZ all choked up about the point of light visible on WTC 7 in the pictures of the towers burning?

Well MaGZ that is the south side of the building. Well not exactly, that side of the building runs about runs about ESE/WSW and the Sun would have been about at the SE. It could be a reflection, it could even be a double reflection, it could be office lights.

One thing is for sure, if it is a fire then there is video of it, there are reports from the people who were inside WTC 7 at the time, there are reports from the fire Dept of this fire. Where are those things MaGZ? Where are even the pictures from another angle that show this supposed fire?
 
Daryl said "we heard this sound that sounded like a clap of thunder....it looked like there was a shockwave ripping through the building and all the windows busted out"

Which is exactly what would be expected if a large structural member snapped and the column(s) going up underneath the east penthouse were sinking. There very well may be a visible vibration of the building as the column(s) sink, culminating in the east penthouse coming down.
 
Which is exactly what would be expected if a large structural member snapped and the column(s) going up underneath the east penthouse were sinking. There very well may be a visible vibration of the building as the column(s) sink, culminating in the east penthouse coming down.
You always talk about what else it could have been but you just can't bring yourself to admit that it also could have explosive devices going off all together or in very rapid succession.

ETA Your scenerio depends on a large structural member snapping.
The penthouse took 5 to 7 seconds to collapse.
Daryl heard a clap like thunder and then about a second later the bottom floor caved out.
He did not hear the framing under the penthouse break and fall.
 
Last edited:
Already read it. Are you saying this list:

ETA Your scenerio depends on a large structural member snapping.
The penthouse took 5 to 7 seconds to collapse.
Daryl heard a clap like thunder and then about a second later the bottom floor caved out.
He did not hear the framing under the penthouse break and fall.

is in chronological order, because you did not specify that it was.

If it was in chronological order, then was Daryl watching the penthouse section fall?
 
Daryl said "we heard this sound that sounded like a clap of thunder....it looked like there was a shockwave ripping through the building and all the windows busted out"

ETA Your scenerio depends on a large structural member snapping.
The penthouse took 5 to 7 seconds to collapse.
Daryl heard a clap like thunder and then about a second later the bottom floor caved out.
He did not hear the framing under the penthouse break and fall.

Chris. Don't. We've been over the Daryl issue before.
 
Ain't no way i'm buyin' into the missle thing but that first photo is interesting.

"Interesting" as in "suspicious" ?

You always talk about what else it could have been but you just can't bring yourself to admit that it also could have explosive devices going off all together or in very rapid succession.

One "clap" of thunder isn't anything in rapid succession.

You're just grasping, here.
 
Yes

No bearing?

As it turns out, there is clear evidence for office fires on several floors in the area of the initiating event.

The statement is a summary of statements in the FEMA and NIST reports.

It is true. [see post #1282 for references]


Food for thought

All the severe debris damage to the west half of the south side of WTC 7 could make the west end of the building collapse first but it could not make the east central part collapse first.

How do you know? Structural engineering is full of counterintuitive things. For instance, when I had an engineer look at my house last year because of a cracked slab and walls, he said that walls will often crack on the OPPOSITE end of the house from where the slab is sinking, because the top of the house is more stable than the bottom, and it pulls upward on the opposite end. Something similar could be going on here -- for instance, as columns fail, weight is transferred to other columns, which might hold up for a while, then collapse. Is the "initiating event" to be found where the first column failed, or where the subsequent failures occured?

I don't know. I'm not a structural engineer. And neither are you.
 
Is MaGZ all choked up about the point of light visible on WTC 7 in the pictures of the towers burning?

Well MaGZ that is the south side of the building. Well not exactly, that side of the building runs about runs about ESE/WSW and the Sun would have been about at the SE. It could be a reflection, it could even be a double reflection, it could be office lights.

One thing is for sure, if it is a fire then there is video of it, there are reports from the people who were inside WTC 7 at the time, there are reports from the fire Dept of this fire. Where are those things MaGZ? Where are even the pictures from another angle that show this supposed fire?

If what he's talking about is the small areas of red at the bottom of the first picture, they look like flags to me. I can't use photoshop here, but at home, I blew this pic up (Not with explosives, I assure you :p ) and that's what they appeard to be.

Linky to the picture I'm talking about since this is a reply to a reply:

http://www.amanzafar.com/WTC/wtc38.JPG
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom