I don't see where she addressed much of anything. All Ms. Murdoch did was the same old song and dance of dropping names around her unbased justifications as if they were tic-tacs that would freshen up her conclusions. It's always "oh, Gerald Massey this" and "Gerald Massey that" when it comes to substantiating claims, but Massey rarely provided actual translations, only paraphrasing and his own interpretations of said paraphrasing. She tosses around Budge as if his interpretations were still valid today (something I correct Nick on a few posts up), when it's his translations that are still considered valid. Additionally, Budge never supported a Horus-Jesus myth connection, he simply projected his own interpretational views on mythology into his vignettes, which tended to 'over-Westernize' their presentation. Then she keeps going into the self-built strawman of over-accusing "CHRISTIANS" (why the constant capitalizing?) for being behind all of the skepticism toward the veracity of her work. She pulls linguistic nonsense-- like asserting 'proof' of Anup the Baptizer even though
the text she quotes doesn't use that name, neither 'Anup' nor 'Anup the Baptizer'-- and expects the audience to come to her foregone conclusion using her premise to support the example instead of the other way around. Even worse, though, she seems to get even the simplest things wrong through mis-attribution. For example, she uses the following quote:
Said at the Bark: Staff of Anubis, may I propitiate those four Glorified ones who follow after the Master of [all] things.
I am the Master of the champaign at their behest, and I am the Father of the Inundation, when he who hath charge of the canals is athirst.
Look therefore upon me, oh ye great and mighty gods, who are foremost among the Spirits of Annu; let me be exalted in your presence. I am a well-doer towards you. Lo I come, that I may purify this Soul of mine in the most high degree; let not that impediment proceeding from your mouth be issued against me which giveth one over to ruin: let me be purified in the lake of propitiation and of equipoise: let me plunge into the divine pool beneath the two divine sycamores of Heaven and Earth.
Now let my Fold be fitted for me as one victorious against all adversaries who would not that right should be done to me.
I am the Only one; just and true upon the Earth. It is I who say it.
(The Egyptian Book of the Dead, p. 165, tr. by Peter Le Page Renouf, Society of Biblical Archaeology, 1904)
Seems pretty definitive to hear her describe it. She claims it is describing a baptism. However, she's
lying. She goes on to say:
Ms Murdoch said:
Here Horus is approaching the "staff of Anubis" at the boat, asking for purification and exaltation in the "lake of propitiation" and "divine pool."
It is evident why Massey made the connection between Horus approaching Anubis/Anup for water purification and Jesus approaching John for baptism. I am pretty sure that if I keep digging I can come up with the primary-source precedents for most if not all of Massey's most salient correspondences.
Why is it evident? She gave a partial quote and used predetermined interpretational definitions. Moreover, she's leading the reader on with this claim, stating it as if it is a fact. The fact is that she's lying about the identity of the speaker in these texts.
You see, the speaker of the texts (follow her link and go back to page 160 and read for yourself) is the deceased person for whom the ritual is taking place. The words are supposed to be the words of the dead human, taking on aspects of
more than one god including Osiris (for the dead body left behind), Thoth (that their path is preordained), Ra (that they have strength and power in the 'storm' to follow), Khnum (named as Chnemu, The Dread One), and Ashu (named The Sprinkling God, who was a god of water), among others as the rite progresses. The 'divine pool' between the 'divine sycamores' is 'the Sutu' (translated: the Darkness, pg 163), which the 'divine sycamores' are literally the Earth (life) and the heavens (afterlife). The description yet goes on to also describe the lake as one of 'fire' and 'flame' as it crosses the skies (pg 166), with the human who has taken on the aspects of these gods to pass from life into afterlife standing on the boat after having proven worthy to pass on.
In case it isn't clear: this isn't a description of a baptism of Horus, it is a description of a rite of passage of a dead person who has taken on the aspects of a number of gods, one of whom is Horus, into the afterlife. It's a glorified funeral passage. That Ms. Murdoch felt the need to use such a dishonest method to "prove" something and yet still clearly come completely short of pointing out any naming of "Anup" in the text displays in full view how her conclusions are the ones supporting her "evidence" and how she relies on the ignorance of the reader in order to be convincing.
And the 'meri' thing... well, she just contradicts herself by pointing out that it isn't an official name, it is simply Egyptian for "beloved" or "beloved of." All of the capitalizations used in her descriptions are her own creation-- Egyptian doesn't do that.
Shall I go on? She goes to great lengths to defend the dismissed claims of Massey. Why is she going through so much trouble to attempt to do so if his translations are supposed to be perfectly valid, like she claims? Her simple answer in all of her posts there is that it's all the fault of the "CHRISTIANS" even though not all Egyptologists are Christians and I've been saying early on that
I'm not Christian. Basically, she
needs her opposition to be Christian so that she can use her strawman conspiracy claims, because her arguments can't stand on their own merits.