ZEITGEIST, The Movie

How many times are we going to go around this circle? You ask, I answer, you dispute, I show you the evidence, you ask the same question over again. Why not try something new, and actually give the idea of actually reading some of the stuff I've said already and suggested as supporting source, then ask when you think there is need for a clarification?

None. I think in your last reply you have summed up the answers well enough. However I will be declining to go and read for myself though, as I am capable of taking your word for it here. I really just wanted a clear explanation as to why you believe his conclusions are not true, and you finally provided it. thanks.

That doesn't mean that I still won't think that there is something to the transference of myth-themes across cultures regarding egypt. I don't know who these centuries of scholars are who didn't verify his claim when they did their own translation, or exactly why his are so far off the mark from theirs. I wonder if they were possibly christians themselves in some cases and not too eager to draw the same conclusions, or if he was just that wide of the mark that his conclusions merit nothing at all.

In other news, I went to Acharya's forum and looked for a zeitgeist thread...which I found...
http://forums.truthbeknown.com/view...s=0&postorder=asc&highlight=zeitgeist&start=0

And I must say, the one here at jref is much more enjoyable to read. I am pondering joining and bringing some of this up for their scrutiny....just to see what they say mostly...or perhaps I can direct them to this discussion...who knows.

Lastly-
Here is the interactive reference page for the film..as you read through the entire script he has provided links to all the references for every claim in the film:
http://zeitgeistmovie.com/transcript.htm
 
Last edited:
Nothing you described shows any evidence of it being a Christ precursor, and that is even if I take for granted that the tarot card in the version you linked is an accurate representation of a 13th Century counterpart.

In Western Qabalah, Hermanubis is clearly a Christ precursor. Some Qabalistic symbols are complex, some are so complex they're not even meant to be understood except at a subconscious level. However, Hermanubis isn't one of them. He's a totally simple symbol.

The jackal-headed human with long, upright ears is the symbolic intermediary between the Qabalistic Fourth and Fifth kingdoms.

1st Kingdom - Mineral
2nd Kingdom - Vegetable
3rd Kingdom - Animal
4th Kingdom - Humanity
5th Kingdom - Humanity reborn, regenerated

Hermanubis is Fourth Kingdom human, in that he is governed by animal instincts. Yet his large upright ears indicate that he has the capacity to advance through listening to the voice of his "inner hearing" (assigned in Qabalah to Taurus). He can hear the voice of his inner teacher - his Hierophant or Holy Guardian Angel - and thus can be guided on to advancement.

Symbolically, he is clearly close to John the Baptist.

In addition, if you research prominent Alchemical texts (those of Vaughn, Paracelus, Sendivogius, or especially Boehme) you will find numerous references to Baptism as being related to Regeneration, thus providing another parallel between the activities of JB and the Egyptian Anubis.


GreNME said:
The problem here is that you make a few mistakes in your interpretation. First, you are quoting the vignette as described by Sir Wallis Budge, not the actual text of the plate which is further down. Second, the actual descent into the underworld doesn't happen quite yet, they are instead entering the presence of Osiris after having his (Ani's) heart weighed in a balance for 'purity'.

Interesting. Could you relate the events that occur between the arrival of the four principles and the descent into the underworld?

GreNME said:
Third, keep in mind that even if you believe there is similatiry to the account of John the Revelator (of which I'd also disagree), John the Baptist and John the Revelator are two completely different individuals.

For sure. It's just coincidental that we were discussing JB when I noticed the possible parallel to the Revelation.

Apocalypsis Iessou Christou 1512+888+1480=3880 Helios x 10. This is the Unveiling of the Risen Sun. Iessou=888. x 10=8880. Ioannes=1119. 8880+1119=9999. Ooh, I do like a bit of obscure Greek Messianic gematria on a Sunday night!

Nick
 
Last edited:
None. I think in your last reply you have summed up the answers well enough. However I will be declining to go and read for myself though, as I am capable of taking your word for it here. I really just wanted a clear explanation as to why you believe his conclusions are not true, and you finally provided it. thanks.

Not a problem. For what it's worth, I encourage for people to check for themselves mostly because I really don't want to be considered the final word on things. I don't have the ego for that (any more). Also, I tend to be more a proponent of the study as opposed to the knowing as an absolute, and one thing I dislike about conspiracy theory productions like Zeitgeist is the way it uses inconclusiveness (a number of layered possibilities) to promote an absolute idea (i.e.- Christianity is just a sun-god mythos, Jesus is Horus, etc.), and rather simplistic absolutes at that

That doesn't mean that I still won't think that there is something to the transference of myth-themes across cultures regarding egypt. I don't know who these centuries of scholars are who didn't verify his claim when they did their own translation, or exactly why his are so far off the mark from theirs. I wonder if they were possibly christians themselves in some cases and not too eager to draw the same conclusions, or if he was just that wide of the mark that his conclusions merit nothing at all.

Well, just keep in mind that any translations prior to the discovery of the Rosetta Stone have no basis from which to establish their translation, and at least the first 50-60 years after the discovery of the Rosetta Stone the methodology for accurate translation still hadn't been worked out. Scholars now think they pretty much have the translation methodology hammered out pretty well, but there is still study today to refine translation of the language. Even Sir Budge, whose translation appears on the links I gave for the BotD, has flaws in that he decided translating Egyptian into KJV English was a good idea-- it's highly unlikely that Egyptians had separate wording for pronouns like 'you' and 'thee'. Lofty language aside, though, his translations have withstood much scrutiny over time, and for translation purposes (the words themselves, not necessarily interpretations on what they mean) Budge's work tends to be a staple of Egyptology study.

In other news, I went to Acharya's forum and looked for a zeitgeist thread...which I found...
http://forums.truthbeknown.com/view...s=0&postorder=asc&highlight=zeitgeist&start=0

And I must say, the one here at jref is much more enjoyable to read. I am pondering joining and bringing some of this up for their scrutiny....just to see what they say mostly...or perhaps I can direct them to this discussion...who knows.

Hrm. Well, if Acharya could guarantee that things could stay at least as civil as our conversation has been-- which has had heated moments at times, but I think we've worked it out rather impressively (kudos, by the way)-- I'd join the discussion. Alternatively, you could ask Ms. Murdoch if you could have access to any peer-reviewed work she's done on the subjects she sells books on.

Lastly-
Here is the interactive reference page for the film..as you read through the entire script he has provided links to all the references for every claim in the film:
http://zeitgeistmovie.com/transcript.htm

Yeah, this has been linked a few times, I think. I am actually using it in my critique instead of just using the film as I originally had been. It actually displays the habit of 'self-referencing' I indicated in an earlier page better than the actual film does. Though the writers of the interactive section go to great lengths to spread their sourcing out amongst many works, it seems all roads Jesus-Horus-related always lead back to Massey (either directly or indirectly through source attribution).
 
Last edited:
In Western Qabalah, Hermanubis is clearly a Christ precursor. Some Qabalistic symbols are complex, some are so complex they're not even meant to be understood except at a subconscious level. However, Hermanubis isn't one of them. He's a totally simple symbol.

The jackal-headed human with long, upright ears is the symbolic intermediary between the Qabalistic Fourth and Fifth kingdoms.

Right, but we've been over this: there is little evidence that today's form of Kaballah (Qabalah) in any way predates about the eleventh or twelth century, at best (and most only go back to about the sixteenth).

Hermanubis is Fourth Kingdom human, in that he is governed by animal instincts. Yet his large upright ears indicate that he has the capacity to advance through listening to the voice of his "inner hearing" (assigned in Qabalah to Taurus). He can hear the voice of his inner teacher - his Hierophant or Holy Guardian Angel - and thus can be guided on to advancement.

Symbolically, he is clearly close to John the Baptist.

In addition, if you research prominent Alchemical texts (those of Vaughn, Paracelus, Sendivogius, or especially Boehme) you will find numerous references to Baptism as being related to Regeneration, thus providing another parallel between the activities of JB and the Egyptian Anubis.

No, that would be Osiris, not Anubis. Osiris is the one who came back to life. Even that, though, I find questionable for reasons that I think the succession of ideas is a bit backward.

Interesting. Could you relate the events that occur between the arrival of the four principles and the descent into the underworld?

I can only give the text description, because I don't think there is a simple metaphorical interpretation that seems to work. Egyptian ritual was very unlike practices we can reference today, so relating them to rituals we think of today is a questionable practice in my opinion.

For sure. It's just coincidental that we were discussing JB when I noticed the possible parallel to the Revelation.

Coincidence? Coincidence is the bread and butter of CT canon! :eek:

Ooh, I do like a bit of obscure Greek Messianic gematria on a Sunday night!

Sunday! Sunday! Sunday! Tickets are for the whole seat, but you'll only need the edge! :)
 
Right, but we've been over this: there is little evidence that today's form of Kaballah (Qabalah) in any way predates about the eleventh or twelth century, at best (and most only go back to about the sixteenth).

I feel this is a bit of a peripheral issue. I think the central issue would be more to examine any early interpretations of Hermanubis that might exist and look for consistency with the Qabalistic interpretation. I will have a scout around.

ETA: I see Blavatsky mentions Hermanubis' Human-Animal form and its significance in the late 19th century. There's a reference by Creuzer, from earlier in the same century, but I don't have it. I will also look for Plutarch's description in De Iside, according to Budge on p.61.

BTW, the ideas that became Western Qabalah did not spontaneously emerge in the 13th Century. They can certainly be traced back to Gnosticism and Alchemy, both around at least in the very early centuries AD. It is not so much that there exist a whole range of coherently individual metaphysical philosophies - Qabalah, Freemasonry, Gnosticism, Alchemy, Rosicrucianism etc. Rather that there is essentially one "perennial philosophy" emerging and re-emerging in different ages, in different places, and simply with some superficial alteration to make the teaching more suited to the language, culture, and mores of the time and place.

GreNME said:
No, that would be Osiris, not Anubis. Osiris is the one who came back to life. Even that, though, I find questionable for reasons that I think the succession of ideas is a bit backward.

But Anubis is the supervisor of the regenerative process, is he not? Thus, I submit, John the Baptist and he have similar roles. It's not totally clean cut, I agree, but it's similar.


GreNME said:
I can only give the text description, because I don't think there is a simple metaphorical interpretation that seems to work. Egyptian ritual was very unlike practices we can reference today, so relating them to rituals we think of today is a questionable practice in my opinion.

Fair enough. What would be the text description?

BTW, I recall reading recently that the writing of the Alchemists, notably Hermes Trismegistos' "Hermetica" (likely written in Alexandria around 200 AD) was strongly drawn from the Egyptian Book of the Dead. If so, this could provide a useful missing link here.

Nick
 
Last edited:
I feel this is a bit of a peripheral issue. I think the central issue would be more to examine any early interpretations of Hermanubis that might exist and look for consistency with the Qabalistic interpretation. I will have a scout around.

ETA: I see Blavatsky mentions Hermanubis' Human-Animal form and its significance in the late 19th century. There's a reference by Creuzer, from earlier in the same century, but I don't have it. I will also look for Plutarch's description in De Iside, according to Budge on p.61.

BTW, the ideas that became Western Qabalah did not spontaneously emerge in the 13th Century. They can certainly be traced back to Gnosticism and Alchemy, both around at least in the very early centuries AD. It is not so much that there exist a whole range of coherently individual metaphysical philosophies - Qabalah, Freemasonry, Gnosticism, Alchemy, Rosicrucianism etc. Rather that there is essentially one "perennial philosophy" emerging and re-emerging in different ages, in different places, and simply with some superficial alteration to make the teaching more suited to the language, culture, and mores of the time and place.

The point I'm trying to make is that none of those ideas have any evidence going back far enough in any solid form that could sufficiently place it on a timeline of causality. I don't presume to make that a judgment on whether someone should place their belief in one mysticism or another-- that's a person's choice-- but to make cases of a causality where there is little or no clear evidence gets into the same speculative and questionable territory as works like those of Massey, Acharya (who relies heavily on Massey and, ironically, Blavatsky), and the makers of the film. I think the mysticisms of those groups you listed are established enough on their own that they don't need to play the "our framework is older" game, which is frankly a tired line of justification that assumes age accounts for authenticity (another fallacy used in citing Massey over newer, more recent interpretations).

But Anubis is the supervisor of the regenerative process, is he not? Thus, I submit, John the Baptist and he have similar roles. It's not totally clean cut, I agree, but it's similar.

Where are you getting regeneration from? Anubis steps in after death. No rebirth, no regeneration. The person is dead.

Fair enough. What would be the text description?

I linked to it. What did you want me to describe?

BTW, I recall reading recently that the writing of the Alchemists, notably Hermes Trismegistos' "Hermetica" (likely written in Alexandria around 200 AD) was strongly drawn from the Egyptian Book of the Dead. If so, this could provide a useful missing link here.

Nick

Except the link is on the wrong side of the beginning of Christianity to fit into a causal timeline.
 
Bah

Since Mussolini never said such a thing that definition is obviously meaningless, now isn't it?

Seriously, have you ever once looked into an actual source for any of the quotations you parrot? Could you even name a single source for any of them? And just to forestall any stupidity that may follow: no, a name next to the quote is not a source, nor is a website catalogue of quotes.

"Fascism should more appropriately be called corporatism because it is a merger of state and corporate power."

Italian philosopher Giovanni Gentile, Encyclopedia Italiana Mussolini, however, affixed his name to the entry, and claimed credit for it.)

Hence the quote became:

"Fascism should more appropriately be called corporatism because it is a merger of state and corporate power." - Benito Mussolini
 
The point I'm trying to make is that none of those ideas have any evidence going back far enough in any solid form that could sufficiently place it on a timeline of causality. I don't presume to make that a judgment on whether someone should place their belief in one mysticism or another-- that's a person's choice-- but to make cases of a causality where there is little or no clear evidence gets into the same speculative and questionable territory as works like those of Massey, Acharya (who relies heavily on Massey and, ironically, Blavatsky), and the makers of the film.

Well, I think there will inevitably always be issues when dealing with evidence from secret, or reasonably secret, societies, especially those who furthermore expound a subjective scientific doctrine. Trying to create a methodologically-valid case here will inevitably be a struggle, and largely more a work of interest than anything else. I think, realistically, that this goes with the terrain. (Of course, one could attempt some compromise in requirements, if one was keen to bring more hidden mystical doctrine into the scholarly mainstream.)

Personally, I have no doubt that, in Western Qabalah, Hermanubis may validly be considered a Christ precursor. Certainly, John the Baptist is the same. However, whether one can validly claim that the two are themselves significantly similar is to my mind (now that I've had a bit more time to study and think about it) a bit more questionable, though by no means not possessing some validity.

If one was in agreement that the Book of the Dead and the New Testament did reveal a similar metaphysical interpretation then the case for Anubis being John the Bap might be strengthened, given that, if not John, who would take Anubis' role? But we're not quite there yet!


GreNME said:
Where are you getting regeneration from? Anubis steps in after death. No rebirth, no regeneration. The person is dead.

Is there no belief in reincarnation in Egyptian mythology then?

GreNME said:
I linked to it. What did you want me to describe?

I'll check the links again.

GreNME said:
Except the link is on the wrong side of the beginning of Christianity to fit into a causal timeline.

Well, one of things that has been struggled with on this thread is relating the symbology of the Egyptian tale of Osiris, Isis and Horus to the Christian myth of the New Testament. I haven't seen it done yet. However, if the Book of the Dead can be taken as symbolically analogous to Hermetic writings from the 2nd or 3rd century AD, then this would, I submit, be a good start.

BTW, it's interesting that the writings of the Hermetica would now seem accepted as being the metaphysical basis for the Law of Gravity, having resulted from Newton's fascination with Hermes Trismegistus.

Nick
 
Last edited:
Is there no belief in reincarnation in Egyptian mythology then?

Not really, at least not through most of what I've read. There is the Osirian myth, but that's not necessarily a tale of "hey, you can do this too!" or even one that was the predominant Osiris myth. Basically, as far as Egyptian views go, once a body is dead they are dead. The whole treatment of the body after death was to ease their transition into the afterlife. They don't come back.

All those "curse of the mummy" stories from early films? Those were a mixture of the warnings in the tombs that Anubis will curse those who defile the tombs, and a bit of overexaggeration of one of the Osirian resurrection stories (where he rises while wrapped as a mummy).

Regardless, dead was dead (in the general sense). Resurrection and reincarnation are aspects of myths further east of Egypt.
 
Not really, at least not through most of what I've read. There is the Osirian myth, but that's not necessarily a tale of "hey, you can do this too!" or even one that was the predominant Osiris myth. Basically, as far as Egyptian views go, once a body is dead they are dead. The whole treatment of the body after death was to ease their transition into the afterlife. They don't come back.

All those "curse of the mummy" stories from early films? Those were a mixture of the warnings in the tombs that Anubis will curse those who defile the tombs, and a bit of overexaggeration of one of the Osirian resurrection stories (where he rises while wrapped as a mummy).

Regardless, dead was dead (in the general sense). Resurrection and reincarnation are aspects of myths further east of Egypt.

I was referring more to the notion that the physical body dies, but that there are higher dimensional bodies which grow a new physical body and are reborn. The idea usually is that this process repeats on and on until there has been sufficient purging to remove the need for physical incarnation.

This notion might well not be in the literal reading of the text. It could be there in metaphor. Or maybe not at all. Even without the reincarnation concept, or phase, the usual myth is that a regenerated consciousness is finally reborn after a phase of purgation. From my limited reading (which I'm hoping to improve on!) it would seem to me that the infant Horus is a symbol for this.

Nick
 
Hmmm... That's a tough interpretation for me to swallow without a lot of caveats, because the idea of being 'reborn' isn't what is described, not even in the account of Ani in the plates linked (in the Book of the Dead). The person was considered to be basically the same person they were before they died, they are just dead now and are now in the realm of the dead. Adding much more to that just seems like personal projection of ideas to me.
 
You really want me to go into all that piece by piece?

Do whatever you are comfortable with. I just thought you might like to read it and perhaps comment on it. They are basically calling your bluff on this one by saying that it is all verified in the original texts, and that Massey wasn't wrong, and yadda yadda yadda...I just sorta figured you might have an opinion on that...:)

Personally I would really like to hear what you have to say about it, but hey...it's your call....and it's not all that long either....supposedly she is going to publish a few articles in the near future that are designed to debunk the debunking...or something to that effect...this is just a taste.
 
Last edited:
I don't see where she addressed much of anything. All Ms. Murdoch did was the same old song and dance of dropping names around her unbased justifications as if they were tic-tacs that would freshen up her conclusions. It's always "oh, Gerald Massey this" and "Gerald Massey that" when it comes to substantiating claims, but Massey rarely provided actual translations, only paraphrasing and his own interpretations of said paraphrasing. She tosses around Budge as if his interpretations were still valid today (something I correct Nick on a few posts up), when it's his translations that are still considered valid. Additionally, Budge never supported a Horus-Jesus myth connection, he simply projected his own interpretational views on mythology into his vignettes, which tended to 'over-Westernize' their presentation. Then she keeps going into the self-built strawman of over-accusing "CHRISTIANS" (why the constant capitalizing?) for being behind all of the skepticism toward the veracity of her work. She pulls linguistic nonsense-- like asserting 'proof' of Anup the Baptizer even though the text she quotes doesn't use that name, neither 'Anup' nor 'Anup the Baptizer'-- and expects the audience to come to her foregone conclusion using her premise to support the example instead of the other way around. Even worse, though, she seems to get even the simplest things wrong through mis-attribution. For example, she uses the following quote:
Said at the Bark: Staff of Anubis, may I propitiate those four Glorified ones who follow after the Master of [all] things.

I am the Master of the champaign at their behest, and I am the Father of the Inundation, when he who hath charge of the canals is athirst.

Look therefore upon me, oh ye great and mighty gods, who are foremost among the Spirits of Annu; let me be exalted in your presence. I am a well-doer towards you. Lo I come, that I may purify this Soul of mine in the most high degree; let not that impediment proceeding from your mouth be issued against me which giveth one over to ruin: let me be purified in the lake of propitiation and of equipoise: let me plunge into the divine pool beneath the two divine sycamores of Heaven and Earth.

Now let my Fold be fitted for me as one victorious against all adversaries who would not that right should be done to me.

I am the Only one; just and true upon the Earth. It is I who say it.

(The Egyptian Book of the Dead, p. 165, tr. by Peter Le Page Renouf, Society of Biblical Archaeology, 1904)

Seems pretty definitive to hear her describe it. She claims it is describing a baptism. However, she's lying. She goes on to say:
Ms Murdoch said:
Here Horus is approaching the "staff of Anubis" at the boat, asking for purification and exaltation in the "lake of propitiation" and "divine pool."

It is evident why Massey made the connection between Horus approaching Anubis/Anup for water purification and Jesus approaching John for baptism. I am pretty sure that if I keep digging I can come up with the primary-source precedents for most if not all of Massey's most salient correspondences.

Why is it evident? She gave a partial quote and used predetermined interpretational definitions. Moreover, she's leading the reader on with this claim, stating it as if it is a fact. The fact is that she's lying about the identity of the speaker in these texts.

You see, the speaker of the texts (follow her link and go back to page 160 and read for yourself) is the deceased person for whom the ritual is taking place. The words are supposed to be the words of the dead human, taking on aspects of more than one god including Osiris (for the dead body left behind), Thoth (that their path is preordained), Ra (that they have strength and power in the 'storm' to follow), Khnum (named as Chnemu, The Dread One), and Ashu (named The Sprinkling God, who was a god of water), among others as the rite progresses. The 'divine pool' between the 'divine sycamores' is 'the Sutu' (translated: the Darkness, pg 163), which the 'divine sycamores' are literally the Earth (life) and the heavens (afterlife). The description yet goes on to also describe the lake as one of 'fire' and 'flame' as it crosses the skies (pg 166), with the human who has taken on the aspects of these gods to pass from life into afterlife standing on the boat after having proven worthy to pass on.

In case it isn't clear: this isn't a description of a baptism of Horus, it is a description of a rite of passage of a dead person who has taken on the aspects of a number of gods, one of whom is Horus, into the afterlife. It's a glorified funeral passage. That Ms. Murdoch felt the need to use such a dishonest method to "prove" something and yet still clearly come completely short of pointing out any naming of "Anup" in the text displays in full view how her conclusions are the ones supporting her "evidence" and how she relies on the ignorance of the reader in order to be convincing.

And the 'meri' thing... well, she just contradicts herself by pointing out that it isn't an official name, it is simply Egyptian for "beloved" or "beloved of." All of the capitalizations used in her descriptions are her own creation-- Egyptian doesn't do that. :)

Shall I go on? She goes to great lengths to defend the dismissed claims of Massey. Why is she going through so much trouble to attempt to do so if his translations are supposed to be perfectly valid, like she claims? Her simple answer in all of her posts there is that it's all the fault of the "CHRISTIANS" even though not all Egyptologists are Christians and I've been saying early on that I'm not Christian. Basically, she needs her opposition to be Christian so that she can use her strawman conspiracy claims, because her arguments can't stand on their own merits.
 
Arnold's dad was high ranking enough... he volunteered for the SA.... its not like he was just a member of the nazi party and thats it. He was a member of a special branch of police forces designed to keep soldiers and civilians in war torn areas in check.

You made the statement "so if arnold's dad was a nazi he must be one too right!?!?" ... no I didn't say that... YOU did. To answer it though: yes a son does learn a lot from his dad and his dads philosphies have an affect on the childs morality.

You think you know these people? You talk about them like you know them. You do not know them. You see brief second or minute clips where they say something someone else wrote and look geniune when they say it.

You have no idea how moral arnold may or may not be. Thats my point. ALL INFORMATION is being controlled by someone... why are you taking information from one source over the other? You seem to point towards respectability or some other moot philosphy.

Overall, I agree with the one guy saying I refuse to have an interaction. I think its pointless for me to stay here because you already are set in your beliefs. You don't want to look at things from another angle... you think what you think and thats it.

Good luck. You'll need it.
Yeah, we're the ones with our minds made up. :wackytwitcy:
 
Right, but I mean to I really need to go into lectures on every detail she got wrong and the blatantly biased way she goes about it? I've actually sent an e-mail to the only known contact address to her to inquire about her sources and methodology, rather than to pick a fight with her. I made sure to caveat that I don't agree with her in the message, but in the interest of intellectual honesty I'd like to share methodologies and sources between the two of us so that we have an understanding as fellow lay-scholars.

The thing is, I really don't think ragging on and on about her obsession with any refuting evidence as "CHRISTIAN" or influenced by Christians as being useful to any kind of discussion. If she wants to play god-killer then good for her, but that's not history and that's not archaeology. If it's "refuting" Christianity, then that's a discussion I want no part of because I'm not a Christian and I am not as concerned with people's personal faiths as some others might be.
 
Nick. it may very well be a little off balance as it seems the whole Massey/Egypt/Christianity thing is an offshoot of the larger JMH.

Can we all take it as a given that the New Testament was written several hundred years after the death of Jesus. ?

Let's suppose, that people back in "those days" were every bit as smart ( from an IQ perspective) as we are today and therefore there must have existed guys with the mental bent to become what are by today's standards, novelists.

Suppose, for instance you have a guy ( or guys ) who enjoy writing hero stories, like Tom Clancy or Wilbur Smith, or Clive Cussler. Don't these authors usually follow the same basic formula to make there heroes more likeable ? Like hero overcoming a vast and seemingly insurmountable obstacle like in every Jean Claude Van Damme movie where he gets beaten nearly to death before overcoming his near deathness ( through some sort of Kung-Fu woo for instance ) and coming back to kick some serious ass.

Flashback to the time the author of the bible is sitting around with his focus group trying to come up with a new religion to sway the masses. No doubt , they're going to have the basic premises of a hero story at hand and are more than likely to "expand" on the current knowledge and theories of the day.

An interesting question...Where or what, was the status of Christianity during the time between Jesus, and the NT ? Did it exist "officially", or was it more of an underground, "alternative" kind of theory ? Point is...it obviously didn't disappear entirely.

Hi Stout,

Well I'm probably not the best person to answer this question. I've read that Christian sects certainly existed around the first century AD. There were guys like Philo around, and then Origen a hundred or so years later. A chap called Celsus famously wrote a long tirade about Christianity around 170 AD. I don't know when the first concrete reference to the NT or the gospels is found but I think it's sooner that a few hundred years.

Nick
 
Hmmm... That's a tough interpretation for me to swallow without a lot of caveats, because the idea of being 'reborn' isn't what is described, not even in the account of Ani in the plates linked (in the Book of the Dead). The person was considered to be basically the same person they were before they died, they are just dead now and are now in the realm of the dead. Adding much more to that just seems like personal projection of ideas to me.

Hi GreNME,

I just looked on Wikipedia, which I appreciate may not be a perfect source. It did seem that, in the Saite recension of the Book of the Dead, there was re-birth, see synopsis from Wikipedia copied below...

* Chapters 1-16 The deceased enters the tomb, descends to the underworld, and the body regains its powers of movement and speech.
* Chapters 17-63 Explanation of the mythic origin of the gods and places, the deceased are made to live again so that they may arise, reborn, with the morning sun.
* Chapters 64-129 The deceased travels across the sky in the sun bark as one of the blessed dead. In the evening, the deceased travels to the underworld to appear before Osiris.
* Chapters 130-189 Having been vindicated, the deceased assumes power in the universe as one of the gods.

I must say that it does also appear to bear a resemblance to the Emerald Tablet of Hermes, the cornerstone work on Alchemy usually dated to around the 1st or 2nd century BC.

Nick
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom