ZEITGEIST, The Movie

You're close. Actually, it was the acceptance of death and reaspect for the dead, if you want to look at the basest components of the earliest examples of mankind regarding "something bigger" than themelves.

Hi GreNME,

Just to mention, anyone can regard "something bigger than" oneself simply by becoming aware of the notional nature of selfhood!

Regarding Anubis and Hermanubis, I offer a couple of quotes from the early historian Plutarch, taken from here...

"By Anubis they understand the horizontal circle, which divides the invisible, to which they give the name of Isis; and this circle equally touches upon the confines of both light and darkness, it may be looked upon as common to them both"


"Anubis, and sometimes likewise Hermanubis {i.e., Heru-em-Anpu}; the first of these names expressing the relation it has to be superior, as the latter, to the inferior world."

Plutarch, writing in the mid 1st century AD, clearly recognises the metaphysical significance of Anubis (Hermanubis). He is the god of the divide between the conscious and unconscious worlds. He is an intermediary, and in metaphysical terms is leading the aspirant along one section of the spiritual journey. As such, he clearly has a role similar to John the Baptist in Christian mythology.

He would also seem to me to be analogous to the modern day notion of time, the process by which the unconscious is unfolded into our day to day reality.

Nick
 
Last edited:
Hi GreNME,

Just to mention, anyone can regard "something bigger than" oneself simply by becoming aware of the notional nature of selfhood!

Are you positing that mankind began developing religion when they began to be self-aware? Okay. If so, I neither support nor oppose that statement, but I'm talking about the behavior that we can describe in the little evidence we have, not attributing a psychoanalysis to it. ;)


Regarding Anubis and Hermanubis, I offer a couple of quotes from the early historian Plutarch, taken from here...

"By Anubis they understand the horizontal circle, which divides the invisible, to which they give the name of Isis; and this circle equally touches upon the confines of both light and darkness, it may be looked upon as common to them both"


"Anubis, and sometimes likewise Hermanubis {i.e., Heru-em-Anpu}; the first of these names expressing the relation it has to be superior, as the latter, to the inferior world."

Plutarch, writing in the mid 1st century AD, clearly recognises the metaphysical significance of Anubis (Hermanubis). He is the god of the divide between the conscious and unconscious worlds. He is an intermediary, and in metaphysical terms is leading the aspirant along one section of the spiritual journey. As such, he clearly has a role similar to John the Baptist in Christian mythology.

He would also seem to me to be analogous to the modern day notion of time, the process by which the unconscious is unfolded into our day to day reality.

Nick

That's some selective quoting on your part, Nick. The second quote you use skips the part where the introduction of the quote shows it being a description of the names used. What is being describedis how Lower Egypt was known (by the Romans) to sometimes use the name 'Hermanubis', for reasons I already pointed out (shows for and to please their conquerers). The description goes on to describe how, by this time, they even made sure to cover all their bases when making sacrifices: "And for this reason it is, they sacrifice to him two Cocks, the white one,as a proper emblem of the purity and brightness of things above, the other of a saffron color, expressive of that mixture and variety which is to be found in these lower regions." The first quote is a Roman attempt to understand Egyptian religious practice, which they did often by comparing to their own-- incidentally, Justin Martyr knew this as well, which is why he is quoted so often in Zeitgeist as comparing Roman deities with their blossoming Christian faith.

There are two things you should keep in mind about the time frame of the world during those quotes: 1) Rome was the world superpower, often challenged but generally unbeaten, and the classical Roman outlook was not only that everyone else should be like them but that they wanted to be like them-- Romans tended to judge everything about their conquered lands according to their own practices and beliefs because they assumed their civilization was superior; and 2) by the Second Century CE Egypt was already being interbred with Romans and with encroaching Bedoins, and this leads eventually to the ethnic and cultural Egyptians becoming the minority over the next few centuries, taking the culture, religion, language, and society with it into obscurity-- you may as well be studying only the last few centuries of the declining Roman Empire and calling that indicative of the height of Roman power the way you are comparing it.
 
Are you positing that mankind began developing religion when they began to be self-aware? Okay. If so, I neither support nor oppose that statement, but I'm talking about the behavior that we can describe in the little evidence we have, not attributing a psychoanalysis to it. ;)

Hi GreNME,

I think I would rather state that belief in religion goes hand in hand with the development of the ego. Identifying with the body and thoughts, it's inevitable that the mind tries to create a framework to interpret both occasional wider experiences of selfhood and also the inevitable questions relating to who we are, what's our purpose, so on and so forth.

GreNME said:
That's some selective quoting on your part, Nick. The second quote you use skips the part where the introduction of the quote shows it being a description of the names used.

Well, I wasn't trying to be selective with regard to making a proposition.

GreNME said:
What is being describedis how Lower Egypt was known (by the Romans) to sometimes use the name 'Hermanubis', for reasons I already pointed out (shows for and to please their conquerers). The description goes on to describe how, by this time, they even made sure to cover all their bases when making sacrifices: "And for this reason it is, they sacrifice to him two Cocks, the white one,as a proper emblem of the purity and brightness of things above, the other of a saffron color, expressive of that mixture and variety which is to be found in these lower regions."

I would say that they are simply trying to indicate that Anubis is mediating the border between the conscious and unconscious worlds. The two sacrifices seem to me to indicate that they are acknowledging and respecting him in both.

It would be interesting to know more of how Hermanubis developed from Anubis, as the latter name certainly seems to suggest that he has expanded his symbolic role!

GreNME said:
The first quote is a Roman attempt to understand Egyptian religious practice, which they did often by comparing to their own-- incidentally, Justin Martyr knew this as well, which is why he is quoted so often in Zeitgeist as comparing Roman deities with their blossoming Christian faith.

There are two things you should keep in mind about the time frame of the world during those quotes: 1) Rome was the world superpower, often challenged but generally unbeaten, and the classical Roman outlook was not only that everyone else should be like them but that they wanted to be like them-- Romans tended to judge everything about their conquered lands according to their own practices and beliefs because they assumed their civilization was superior; and 2) by the Second Century CE Egypt was already being interbred with Romans and with encroaching Bedoins, and this leads eventually to the ethnic and cultural Egyptians becoming the minority over the next few centuries, taking the culture, religion, language, and society with it into obscurity-- you may as well be studying only the last few centuries of the declining Roman Empire and calling that indicative of the height of Roman power the way you are comparing it.

My overall point is that there was a coherent and intelligible metaphysical interpretation of the myth and symbols of Osiric legend present at the time of the creation of the New Testament gospels. For me, this is clear from Plutarch. The degree to which it fits in with a metaphysical interpretation of Christian myth I would have to assess by looking at it more. It would also be great to check out some slightly earlier writers on Egyptian belief and mythos more.

Nick
 
My overall point is that there was a coherent and intelligible metaphysical interpretation of the myth and symbols of Osiric legend present at the time of the creation of the New Testament gospels. For me, this is clear from Plutarch. The degree to which it fits in with a metaphysical interpretation of Christian myth I would have to assess by looking at it more. It would also be great to check out some slightly earlier writers on Egyptian belief and mythos more.

Nick

But it wasn't a coherent and intelligible interpretation. It was all guesswork and changing symbolism.

As for earlier writers, what do you mean? Defining Egypt by those who defined Egypt according to their own prejudices is precisely the kind of mistake that those who made up these Jesus-Myth theories made. It's like trying to translate Korean by using Babelfish to first translate it to German, then to Spanish, then to English. The more degrees of separation one gets from the object being studied the less accurate the study is likely to be.
 
But it wasn't a coherent and intelligible interpretation. It was all guesswork and changing symbolism.

As for earlier writers, what do you mean? Defining Egypt by those who defined Egypt according to their own prejudices is precisely the kind of mistake that those who made up these Jesus-Myth theories made. It's like trying to translate Korean by using Babelfish to first translate it to German, then to Spanish, then to English. The more degrees of separation one gets from the object being studied the less accurate the study is likely to be.

That's assuming that language is the only common denominator here. I see it more as a coherent procession of symbols. The linguistic interpretations are more on the surface, more transcient.

I would still like to know more about Anubis' shift to Hermanubis, I must admit. His job description seems to have increased with his re-naming.

Nick
 
Hi guys!

I've been meaning to come in on this thread, but it's taken the last three days to catch up on reading what's getting on for 1000 posts :eek:, with probably as many links.

I came across the Zeitgeist video a few months ago from a link posted on forums I was visiting. Doubting many of the claims I started my own research. Since then, at regular intervals, someone will post up a link to Zeitgeist, usually accompanied by some "free your mind" kind of reference and then become offensive if you dare to cricitise any of the claims. I think I've been called closed minded, brainwashed, sheeple and lacking critical ability at various times.

It was a very pleasant surprise to come across this discussion, with some highly impressive posts - most notably GreNME's - but there's a lot of other good stuff in this thread too.

What is remarkable about the Zeitgeist movie is the way that it seems to convince many sensible, intelligent people of the merits of the information it delivers. My guess is that aside from the dramatic presentation, much of its strength lies in repeating myths that have been repeated so often that people are prepared to believe them.

Take the similarities between Horus and Jesus for example. I've come across sceptical thinkers, who really should know better, quoting such connections as established fact. A quick Google search reveals thousands upon thousands of sites repeating the supposed similarities (very few with any kind of source).

From my research, I have found, as GreNME did, that those who do reference such claims all seem to reference each other and eventually all roads appear to lead to Gerald Massey (and very rarely to any actual Egyptian texts).

Anyway, I'm glad to have found these forums, I'm looking forward to seeing "Screw Zeitgeist" and GreNME, I hope you can find the time to put together a website with a good critique of part 1 - from reading your posts, I suspect that would be a great site.
 
Welcome to the forums Egg!

There were a few other Zeitgeist threads in General Skepticism and Religion, so you may want to hunt around a bit. However, this one certainly had the largest amount of discussion.
 
Hiya Egg..welcome aboard.

That's pretty impressive, 1000 posts in three days. It took me three days to catch up when this thread was at 450 posts, and that's just when it started getting complicated.

I spent hours and hours doing my own research on part 1, what can I say I've got a lot of free time on my hands and I feel there's enough info on this thread to clearly explain just what's 'wrong" with part 1 to your average person.

The nuts and bolts of the "debunking" are over most peoples heads and I'm content to describe Massey as being a "fringe" theory that a few people subscribe to in order to sell their books. In short I'm prepared to say that part 1 is all about money, fame, and hating Christians. Problem is, since I've been reading this thread, I haven't run across anyone promoting Zeitgeist either in real life or on any other message boards I haunt.

I was convinced by part 1, and I may have given it more significance had it been a stand alone flick, but seeing as how it was married to "the other cowspoo" ( parts 2 & 3 ) I automatically rejected it just by association.

Problem was, of course, proving it, and in retrospect, I could have saved myself a lot of time just by believing GreNME.
 
What is remarkable about the Zeitgeist movie is the way that it seems to convince many sensible, intelligent people of the merits of the information it delivers. My guess is that aside from the dramatic presentation, much of its strength lies in repeating myths that have been repeated so often that people are prepared to believe them.

Hi Egg,

Thanks for writing in and expressing your views. It saddens me that people on these other lists call you names. I don't suppose it makes you feel better but I can certainly attest that plenty of people on this list will do similar and use all sorts of childish rhetoric if you oppose what they believe to be true. Such is life, I guess.

Regarding your assertion above, personally, I don't feel that this is where the movie succeeds. I doubt so many of the millions who have watched the movie were so aware of the Jesus-Horus concept previously. One factor that I think is significant is the presentation, which is excellent. The movie makes very good use of many subtle techniques that can easily convince people something is true. I think another big factor is that people are ready for an internal shake-up. They crave it. Life seems so manufactured now, people are getting bored. It's exciting to have your whole perspective thrown around.

I agree that the Jesus-Horus connection is tentative on a strictly historical level, but frankly it's a lot more exciting than a bunch of rigid old history professors telling you that it's not so simple. People are up for some excitement and if our existing history cannot provide it, then it just gets re-written.

Nick
 
Last edited:
Carlo de Buonaparte

All of my information comes from direct experiences I've had. I am not a CT fanatic nor have I ever visited any 9/11 conspiracy websites. This movie generally just put together things I already knew.

Part 1 basically just establishes that Christianity shares many characteristics of previous religions and that in all likelihood most of these religions were inspired by or were personifications of the sun. While in my personal studies I've always associated Zoroastriaism as the basis for christianity; I believe the sun explanation to be more accurate based on what I saw in the movie and further research.

Part 2 is shakey. I understand that many of the theories have been disproven... but ultimately if even one question raises doubt as to the legitamacy of the official explanation I believe it should fall on the government to explain it. Ultimately, I just do not believe that NORAD could not have gotten the planes in time and I do not believe that with all of the US intelligence capabilities that they had "no way of knowing". Given the fact that terrorism is now a part of our everyday life, that it was used to pass so many unconstitional laws, sway public opinion, etc. I believe it was an inside job; despite debunkings.

As far as secret government goes, again my belief in this does not come from going to some conspiracy seminars or listening to prominent theorists in those communities. It comes from the fact that I knew a local politician very well... someone who formerly lived on the main line (a very rich area in PA) and had many connections... sons of senators... supreme court justices.. judges etc. In private conversation and through stories I know the truth about how this country is generally run... and no public hearings matter... all votes are decided beforehand. In fact I remember one day he asked me what a politician was. I gave him some textbook answer and he said .."no .. a politician is someone that can get on the payroll and stay on the payroll." That about sums it up for me ;/

As far as my thoughts on rich people and their lack of morality... I want to state that I'm talking about extremely wealthy people at the top of the socio political spectrum.

Again here are the facts: The bushes clearly have links to nazism... they can downplay this all they want.. you can by into their propaghanda and ignore these facts... but the bottom line for me is the connection is clear. Arnold also has nazi connections. People at NASA and within the US military have nazi connections.

In addition to that take small facts:

Kerry and Bush are related to each other. (both of whom are related to George Washington and Queen Victoria)

My guess is that hilary clinton will win the presidency. If that happens we would not have had a president in the last 25 or so years that wasn't a bush or a clinton.

Very wealthy people have been in control for a long time. I don't know why people even dispute this. Even if you don't believe they lack morales and don't look any anyone beneath their class (this includes the lower upper class) as "real people" ... it's still hard to deny they have a disproportionate influence on politics.

Unless you are a millionarie your opinion on anything regarding how this country works is irrelevant unless it happens to agree with whats already been decided. Even if you are a multi-millionarie their is still no guarentee that you will have much influence.

Part 3: I believe this to be pretty accurate. I haven't seen much debunking in this regard. Again the bottom lines:

The founding fathers were aware of and highly against the central banking concept.

Their exists a central bank.

It's operated privately.

Thats the core of what the movie is saying... the other stuff is nice dressing but ultimately irrelevant.

Again guys... you can sit around and point out "that evidence isn't good enough for me" ... or "this detail or fact here was wrong so the whole thing must be wrong".... or you can believe in the idea that because you can't prove it it can't be correct.

My thoughts on why the average working man is more likely to believe in political conspiracy theories: (nothing to do with intelligence level, but rather experience)

Take a working class construction worker who is apart of a union. He realizes very quickly through experience that his vote on union matters is mostly irrelevant and that a few guys at the very top make all the important decisions. Furthermore, he realizes that his union doesn't really care about the work itself... (not that they would hestitate to use violence to secure contracts)... but also has active criminal ties and uses their organizational status for political power.

Because he has witnessed this kind of corruption on a smaller level, it becomes easier for him to believe it occurs on a larger level. (government, international politics.)

Now take a middle class scientist. This is someone who in general is anti social, details oriented, believes his vote matters and that his government, while corrupt, is generally good and is trying to "do the right thing".

It's a joke.

It's kind of like a mobster vs a prosecutor. The prosecutor is obsessed with details and evidence... 50% of the time he gets it right... other times it's wrong... and even when he goes over the evidence he's still not 100% sure who dun it.

Now ask a mobster to find the guy who took his money... and without any proof at all and relying solely on "anecdotal evidence" he's able to track down exactly who took his money, everyone involved, where they are, who they gave money too, who knew about it, and he's able to put the whole thing together and take care of everything before sun down. And he's 100% correct.

I haven't meant one criminal (mobster or otherwise) that doesn't believe 9/11 was an inside job orchestrated by elements of the upper upper class/government.

;/
 
Problem was, of course, proving it, and in retrospect, I could have saved myself a lot of time just by believing GreNME.

I'm glad you didn't. I think what you did was respectable and commendable. I'm no one special, just a history geek who decided to look for himself.

Incidentally, I've been trying to communicate with some of the sources the movie names (though most of them are conveniently dead). One is reacting in a hostile manner, the other refused to talk with me altogether.
 
As far as my thoughts on rich people and their lack of morality... I want to state that I'm talking about extremely wealthy people at the top of the socio political spectrum.

Sounds like jealousy to me.

Again here are the facts: The bushes clearly have links to nazism... they can downplay this all they want.. you can by into their propaghanda and ignore these facts... but the bottom line for me is the connection is clear. Arnold also has nazi connections. People at NASA and within the US military have nazi connections.

And I thought you were going to post actual facts.

Part 3: I believe this to be pretty accurate. I haven't seen much debunking in this regard.

Ignorance is no excuse.

Again the bottom lines:

The founding fathers were aware of and highly against the central banking concept.

Except for the fact that some of our founding fathers actually started the first central bank.

Their exists a central bank.

In every first world nation in the world.

It's operated privately.

This is utterly false.

Thats the core of what the movie is saying... the other stuff is nice dressing but ultimately irrelevant.

Because it's all just as false as the rest of the claims.

Again guys... you can sit around and point out "that evidence isn't good enough for me" ... or "this detail or fact here was wrong so the whole thing must be wrong".... or you can believe in the idea that because you can't prove it it can't be correct.

Ahh, the good old "can't prove a negative" defense. Unfortunately, the anti-Fed stuff is easy to prove where it's wrong, because most of the information is easy to find.

My thoughts on why the average working man is more likely to believe in political conspiracy theories: (nothing to do with intelligence level, but rather experience)

Take a working class construction worker who is apart of a union. He realizes very quickly through experience that his vote on union matters is mostly irrelevant and that a few guys at the very top make all the important decisions. Furthermore, he realizes that his union doesn't really care about the work itself... (not that they would hestitate to use violence to secure contracts)... but also has active criminal ties and uses their organizational status for political power.

Because he has witnessed this kind of corruption on a smaller level, it becomes easier for him to believe it occurs on a larger level. (government, international politics.)

Now take a middle class scientist. This is someone who in general is anti social, details oriented, believes his vote matters and that his government, while corrupt, is generally good and is trying to "do the right thing".

It's a joke.

Your descriptions, while I agree they are a joke, make a lot of assumptions that aren't evidence of anything but that you are making a populist argument to support belief in conspiracies.

It's kind of like a mobster vs a prosecutor. The prosecutor is obsessed with details and evidence... 50% of the time he gets it right... other times it's wrong... and even when he goes over the evidence he's still not 100% sure who dun it.

Now ask a mobster to find the guy who took his money... and without any proof at all and relying solely on "anecdotal evidence" he's able to track down exactly who took his money, everyone involved, where they are, who they gave money too, who knew about it, and he's able to put the whole thing together and take care of everything before sun down. And he's 100% correct.

You describe fictional television/movie characters as if they are representative of real people and you honestly wish to be taken seriously.

I haven't meant one criminal (mobster or otherwise) that doesn't believe 9/11 was an inside job orchestrated by elements of the upper upper class/government.

Considering the way you describe 'mobsters' it's pretty clear you've never met any in your life, so what does this have to do with the price of tea in China?
 
King of New York

Sounds like jealousy to me.

It sounds like jealousy to you because thats how you percieve it.

Two beliefs I hold:
- That their is a god(s). That all of this didn't just happen. That the creator is clearly existing on a level of thought far above anyone on Earth.
- God didn't invent money

Furthermore, even without the belief in god and my own thoughts of my place beneath him .. .in a sort of pupil or learner capacity.. it still leaves the question:

What do I have to be jealous of? I have the ability to start a relationship with any woman I meet very quickly ... money for me.. not that I have an unlimited supply of it... is not really of importance. If I want to eat good food I can call a chef I'm friends with that works at a really nice restaurent and eat the food for free. If I want to buy something I can goto any number of places to get it...

In short: I have so much ability naturally... naturally charming, personable, intelligent, etc. that a lack of money will not keep me from doing whatever it is I choose to do at any given moment. I can either accomplish the same feat without money or make enough money to pursue it very quickly.


And I thought you were going to post actual facts.

They are facts... please prove to me that Arnold's dad didn't volunteer for the SA and that the SA isn't just some military german wing.. it was specifically created by hitler to act as a sort of Gestapo for areas outside of germany. Prove to me that prescott bush wasn't the director of the union bankin corp... I don't care how many stocks he 'officially' held... money has a way of sneaking around when politicians, hollywood accountants, or other money manipulators are involved.


Ignorance is no excuse.

And I thought you were going to post actual facts.

Their exists a central bank.
In every first world nation in the world.

Sounds like the people that benefit from having a central bank in every first world nation are doing very, very well. Of course, this comment also shows that you believe in the idea "because many people pursue something it must be correct".

This is utterly false.

It's not. Appointments are just another way of saying "operated privately."

Because it's all just as false as the rest of the claims.

I'm rubber, your glue... whatever you say bounces off of me and sticks to you. (this is me reducing myself to your level.)

Ahh, the good old "can't prove a negative" defense. Unfortunately, the anti-Fed stuff is easy to prove where it's wrong, because most of the information is easy to find.

Aye, it's a very important concept. To me, faith has nothing to do with religion... it has to do with the belief that you can accomplish something without proof. It's something I've seen done numerous times throughout my own life... in both my own direct experiences and experiences observing others.

Your descriptions, while I agree they are a joke, make a lot of assumptions that aren't evidence of anything but that you are making a populist argument to support belief in conspiracies.

My descriptions illustrate why someone from a poorer environment who has more direct experience controlling other people would know why things happen as they do. A middle class man with control over nothing lacks this experience. A union leader, a gang leader, anyone in direct control of large groups of other people have experience in some form of politics. A lead banker, a wall street firm, and anyone with direct control over governmental or corporate organizations also has this same power. The only ones that lack this kind of power are middle class people who operate only themselves. The poor don't buy into ******** because they know it's ********, the rich use propaghanda to convince the middle class to follow them.

You describe fictional television/movie characters as if they are representative of real people and you honestly wish to be taken seriously.

No, I describe actual, real people and events.

In the 1960s:

The Italian Mafia controlled virtually all trucking & transportation in the country and could effectively halt all trade as a result of this. Additionally, they controlled a national drug distribution network, controlled a significant part of international drug production, controlled national gambling & prostitution rackets, maintained a very efficient intelligence gathering network, held substantial investments in a variety of economies & currencies, maintained highly profitable, legitatmate front companies, offered money laundering and assassination services to both individuals AND GOVERNMENTS (including the US government), held a presence ... and in many cases a great influence in nearly all international industrialized cities, and controlled substantial portions of both the US and Italian governments. ETC. ETC. ETC. ETC. ETC.

Do you know what the difference is between when the Italian Mafia ran the lottery (numbers) and now that the US government runs it? When the mob ran it you actually won sometimes ;)

Considering the way you describe 'mobsters' it's pretty clear you've never met any in your life, so what does this have to do with the price of tea in China?

Well the mobsters I'm describing are actual italian secret society members or dissidents of them. Their are a lot of remnants from the 1980s crackdown... those guys are mostly sons of people who were left behind when the mafia became less visible. Thats why they are so visible and appear more thug like... because their fathers were nothing more than soldiers and they themselves are nothing.

Also my real name is Tommy de Prisco.
 
Question

It is of no relation, but can anyone here point me to information regarding Decius and the conflict with christians over religious practices? I prefer something that gives a balanced overview of what happened.
 
You cannot change nature; you can only hide or ignore it.

Gravy... you are suggesting that experience is of no importance? I'm confused, what point are you trying to make?

If it's connected to the scientific method I do not want to hear about it. If the scientific method were a correct philosophy to apply anywhere outside of research, scientists would live like rock stars.

The opposite is true for many scientists, because they fail to submit to nature.

Also placing importance on spelling errors, especially in a casual web forum is an insight into your mentality. Not to mention the fact that its of no real significance assuming the meaning is understood.
 
Last edited:
You cannot change nature; you can only hide or ignore it.

double post
 
Last edited:
It sounds like jealousy to you because thats how you percieve it.

No, it sounds like such because instead of actually accusing people on grounds that are supportable you instead opt for a ridiculously simplified and paranoid descriptor, and are trying to appeal to the notion that everyone loves an underdog.

Two beliefs I hold:
- That their is a god(s). That all of this didn't just happen. That the creator is clearly existing on a level of thought far above anyone on Earth.
- God didn't invent money

Who invented cars? Who invented the computer you're tapping at? Your religious belief is your own choice to make, but you obviously don't wait for a divine creator to create a computer for you to work at, the internet you are posting messages on, or likely the roads you drive (or ride as a passenger) down.

Furthermore, even without the belief in god and my own thoughts of my place beneath him .. .in a sort of pupil or learner capacity.. it still leaves the question:

What do I have to be jealous of? I have the ability to start a relationship with any woman I meet very quickly ... money for me.. not that I have an unlimited supply of it... is not really of importance. If I want to eat good food I can call a chef I'm friends with that works at a really nice restaurent and eat the food for free. If I want to buy something I can goto any number of places to get it...

In short: I have so much ability naturally... naturally charming, personable, intelligent, etc. that a lack of money will not keep me from doing whatever it is I choose to do at any given moment. I can either accomplish the same feat without money or make enough money to pursue it very quickly.

I find this interesting in that everything you just wrote here is no different than several affiliate networking advertising sites I've seen of late. I can't even say it's a "good" game you talk because there isn't thing one original about it. You're evangelizing, and I'd caution you to be sure you don't get too heavy on the evangelizing, as I do recall it not being considered acceptable behavior per the membership agreement.

They are facts... please prove to me that Arnold's dad didn't volunteer for the SA and that the SA isn't just some military german wing.. it was specifically created by hitler to act as a sort of Gestapo for areas outside of germany. Prove to me that prescott bush wasn't the director of the union bankin corp... I don't care how many stocks he 'officially' held... money has a way of sneaking around when politicians, hollywood accountants, or other money manipulators are involved.

I don't have to prove any such thing. The onus is on you to prove that any of that means that people who are around today are secretly conspiring to do... whatever it is you seem to be convinced they are doing.

And I thought you were going to post actual facts.

All I have to do is point out your arguments from ignorance in this case, because you haven't done anything more that say the equivalent of "rich people are evil" and some religious malarky.

Sounds like the people that benefit from having a central bank in every first world nation are doing very, very well. Of course, this comment also shows that you believe in the idea "because many people pursue something it must be correct".

Not at all. I believe the idea "if the system works pretty well, go with it until a better system comes along." Unlike where you seem to be arguing from, I don't have to believe any system is flawless or the absolute best for all time to consider it workable for now.

GreNME said:
Depris said:
It's operated privately.
This is utterly false.
It's not. Appointments are just another way of saying "operated privately."

Nope, you're still incorrect, and are just showing you don't understand how it really works. I bet that you are under the impression that Fed stock works the same as regular market stock, and that's where you get your incorrect view of ownership. Like I said, just because you're ignorant doesn't give you an excuse to be wrong.


GreNME said:
Depris said:
Thats the core of what the movie is saying... the other stuff is nice dressing but ultimately irrelevant.
Because it's all just as false as the rest of the claims.
I'm rubber, your glue... whatever you say bounces off of me and sticks to you. (this is me reducing myself to your level.)

Interestingly, when looked at as a reply to what you claimed, it looks like what you're doing is trying to change the subject.

Aye, it's a very important concept. To me, faith has nothing to do with religion... it has to do with the belief that you can accomplish something without proof. It's something I've seen done numerous times throughout my own life... in both my own direct experiences and experiences observing others.

Regardless, you're still proselytizing, and as far as I am aware proselytizing is not necessarily considered acceptable behavior on this forum.

My descriptions illustrate why someone from a poorer environment who has more direct experience controlling other people would know why things happen as they do. A middle class man with control over nothing lacks this experience. A union leader, a gang leader, anyone in direct control of large groups of other people have experience in some form of politics. A lead banker, a wall street firm, and anyone with direct control over governmental or corporate organizations also has this same power. The only ones that lack this kind of power are middle class people who operate only themselves. The poor don't buy into ******** because they know it's ********, the rich use propaghanda to convince the middle class to follow them.

That's possibly one of the more twisted interpretations of Marx (or possibly Stalin) I've seen in a long time. The problem is: it doesn't actually say anything except accuse the rich of being evil and elevates the idea that poor people are honorable simply because they are poor. You use blanket generalizations and assumptions based on wealth instead of character to assert a value judgment on people and imply a conspiracy. The problem is, you don't offer anything as proof for it.

No, I describe actual, real people and events.

From a conspiracy theorist's point of view.

In the 1960s:

The Italian Mafia controlled virtually all trucking & transportation in the country and could effectively halt all trade as a result of this. Additionally, they controlled a national drug distribution network, controlled a significant part of international drug production, controlled national gambling & prostitution rackets, maintained a very efficient intelligence gathering network, held substantial investments in a variety of economies & currencies, maintained highly profitable, legitatmate front companies, offered money laundering and assassination services to both individuals AND GOVERNMENTS (including the US government), held a presence ... and in many cases a great influence in nearly all international industrialized cities, and controlled substantial portions of both the US and Italian governments. ETC. ETC. ETC. ETC. ETC.

Now I know you have no idea of what you're describing. You actually come close on a few of the points (laundering, trafficking), but you flew way out into left field with your vague descriptions of the rest. You also seem to be attempting to ignore the fact that 40 years have gone by since that time.

Do you know what the difference is between when the Italian Mafia ran the lottery (numbers) and now that the US government runs it? When the mob ran it you actually won sometimes ;)

Just as I thought: you're getting your dialogue from Hollywood mafia films.

Well the mobsters I'm describing are actual italian secret society members or dissidents of them. Their are a lot of remnants from the 1980s crackdown... those guys are mostly sons of people who were left behind when the mafia became less visible. Thats why they are so visible and appear more thug like... because their fathers were nothing more than soldiers and they themselves are nothing.

Uh huh. I knew a lot of guys who talked like you do in Philly. When they weren't reminiscing about glory days of this and that, they bragged on how their family helped take down Mussolini and even Hitler and how all they got in return were jail sentences and crackdowns. They make up stories about a suppsedly 'secret' society of old-folks, some of whom allegedly "still have active family back in the Old Country," as they while away their days playing cards and sipping virgin cocktails.

Also my real name is Tommy de Prisco.

Still hanging out with the Brazzo's then?

Now, I'm pretty sure at this point that you're a fraud. Since I know you're not the former Attorney General for the Emergency Management Agency of NYC, I'm guessing that you're instead a fan of people like Rick Porello, who hassles just about everyone with an Italian or Irish name similar to those from three decades ago.
 
I am not a supporter of swindlers, con artists, or the uneducated person that supports them. Additionally, I understand the scientific method and appreciate the concept of proof. Nevertheless, there are things in life, while although true, do not have much proof. Love is a very good example of this. Now while I do not condone the aspects of 9/11 conspiracy designed to promote illogical thought for profit, the fact that I am not only highly intelligent but also what I call “street smart” guides my belief that there is more to the official explanation.

Rather than focus on the buildings themselves and anything related to fires, eyewitness accounts, or angles of fall... I think its better to focus on the human aspect of it.

The movie brings up key points:
Was was the head of the 9/11 commission a close friend and professional associate of the people they were investigating?
Why are some of the hijackers still alive?
Why was the bin laden family not investigated?
Why would their be career IRS agents and Police officers who would resign after 20 years of service because they think something is very wrong... if nothing is wrong?
Looks like your extensive pile of experience has only made you susceptible to lies and BS. What a waste.
 
You are free to do whatever we tell you

No, it sounds like such because instead of actually accusing people on grounds that are supportable you instead opt for a ridiculously simplified and paranoid descriptor, and are trying to appeal to the notion that everyone loves an underdog.
No I am appealing to the notion that one persons idea of an underdog is different from another persons. I have power on this earth naturally.
In other words take one man who can pay abunch of people to campaign for him. Do they really care? No. Why are they doing it? Purely for their own benefit... they want the short term cash and they have a long term chance to be connected to someone in power so they campaign.
Now take someone whose walking through the streets with hundreds of thousands of people who voluntarily followed him? ...which one of these guys is the “underdog” again?

Who invented cars? Who invented the computer you're tapping at? Your religious belief is your own choice to make, but you obviously don't wait for a divine creator to create a computer for you to work at, the internet you are posting messages on, or likely the roads you drive (or ride as a passenger) down.
Aye, but my question is “were their inventions before money?” You are also making a lot of assumptions... like the car I drive is my own... or this computer is owned by me...
Ultimately, I am missing your point here. Explain further please. All I am saying is that money is not a natural way of life.. it's something that was invented and used in only a small portion of human history (relatively speaking) and it is not a universal truth... it won't be around for very much longer... i mean that quite literally... even if the system stays as it is the people that control money are trying to move towards a completely electronic concept... which basically means your wealth is a couple of numbers in someone's computer... who controls those numbers? At that point to keep the people at the top in power becomes a bit ridiculous for anyone in the middle or lower classes. (the majority)
I find this interesting in that everything you just wrote here is no different than several affiliate networking advertising sites I've seen of late. I can't even say it's a "good" game you talk because there isn't thing one original about it. You're evangelizing, and I'd caution you to be sure you don't get too heavy on the evangelizing, as I do recall it not being considered acceptable behavior per the membership agreement.
I'm not evangelizing...
I think it's funny that you completely avoided my question.







I don't have to prove any such thing. The onus is on you to prove that any of that means that people who are around today are secretly conspiring to do... whatever it is you seem to be convinced they are doing.
The onus is only on me if you are the one I'm trying to convince. Frankly, I don't care what you believe.
All I have to do is point out your arguments from ignorance in this case, because you haven't done anything more that say the equivalent of "rich people are evil" and some religious malarky.
Interesting...

Not at all. I believe the idea "if the system works pretty well, go with it until a better system comes along." Unlike where you seem to be arguing from, I don't have to believe any system is flawless or the absolute best for all time to consider it workable for now.
If you believe the system is working well you are the one living in an ignorant bubble. I also disagree with “lets just keep this system and wait for something better... their isn't anything better right now.” The only ones saying that are the people in power... most of the people that make up this country, especially in major cities.. disagree with you. Even middle class people are starting to disagree with you. It's funny:
If you have a few hundred people with you, your nuts. If you have thousands... your noticeable but still nuts. If you have tens of thousands ... “they've got a point, but there are other ways to do this..” ... but if you have hundreds of thousands of people? Guess what... their right and they are going to win.
Nope, you're still incorrect, and are just showing you don't understand how it really works. I bet that you are under the impression that Fed stock works the same as regular market stock, and that's where you get your incorrect view of ownership. Like I said, just because you're ignorant doesn't give you an excuse to be wrong.
YAWN .. you were putting me to sleep here.
Interestingly, when looked at as a reply to what you claimed, it looks like what you're doing is trying to change the subject.
Yeah ... I'm beginning to realize that how things look to you are very different from how they look to those of us living in “reality”.
Regardless, you're still proselytizing, and as far as I am aware proselytizing is not necessarily considered acceptable behavior on this forum.
I believe the original intention of the policy was to keep religious fanatics from preaching. I am not preaching ... I'm not a follower of any religion... I'm talking about life. Some things in life are the same for everyone... many people lack awareness of their own abilities. You will also find the idea of killing someone, silencing them, moving them, threatening them, are generally methods used by cowards to silence people who speak truth and/or speak things that they disagree with. It's oppressive... this statement is equally insightful into your mentality. So two things we can gather from you thus far:
You place high value on correcting minor spelling mistakes in an effort to make yourself appear superior.
You won't hesitate to misinterpret some policy in an effort to silence someone you disagree with.
That's possibly one of the more twisted interpretations of Marx (or possibly Stalin) I've seen in a long time. The problem is: it doesn't actually say anything except accuse the rich of being evil and elevates the idea that poor people are honorable simply because they are poor. You use blanket generalizations and assumptions based on wealth instead of character to assert a value judgment on people and imply a conspiracy. The problem is, you don't offer anything as proof for it.
I'm not a communist... nor do I believe democracy and communism to be all that much different in practice. Poor people are not honorable simply because they are poor... I'm just saying certain members of the lower classes who pursue certain professions encounter problems and develop solutions to issues that very wealthy people also encounter and develop solutions to on a larger scale. Many poor people know the system isn't fair... but they aren't sure why. I have meant a lot of people that are against the government but they don't really understand the complex language of law and they buy into the fact that because they lack formal education... their opinion must not matter.
Luckily, I've had formal education... I'm also a genius... so I'm around to explain to them very simply using metaphors and examples of things that they know about to explain how things really happen. ;/

Now I know you have no idea of what you're describing. You actually come close on a few of the points (laundering, trafficking), but you flew way out into left field with your vague descriptions of the rest. You also seem to be attempting to ignore the fact that 40 years have gone by since that time.
Well 40 years have gone by... but thats just allowed time for growth. In 2002, a new york mobster made 500 million dollars off of one two month phone scam he ran out of an empty warehouse in the bronx. This is someone that has money coming in from all over, owns many multi-million dollar legal front companies that actually produce real products... in other words.. the real mafia exists and is now dealing with billions of dollars instead of millions. Those guys you see on TV or that fictional characters are based off of or who are writing books are people that dealth with hundreds of thousands or thousands of dollars at best and are no longer connected to the heart of whats going on.
your getting yoru dialogue from hollywood films
No, thats just a joke I made up. It's actually not all that true... the lottery was mostly fixed back then too.

Uh huh. I knew a lot of guys who talked like you do in Philly. When they weren't reminiscing about glory days of this and that, they bragged on how their family helped take down Mussolini and even Hitler and how all they got in return were jail sentences and crackdowns. They make up stories about a suppsedly 'secret' society of old-folks, some of whom allegedly "still have active family back in the Old Country," as they while away their days playing cards and sipping virgin cocktails.
Proof is a funny thing. Ultimately it comes back to, if you can't prove something... is it still true? Ultimately though, a secret society is nothing more than a group of people whom work together for their own benefit without outside interference. I find it astonishing that people don't believe in secret societies without proof. If their was proof, it wouldn't be a secret... would it?
Still hanging out with the Brazzo's then?
Never knew any brazzo's... maybe someone else in my family did.. no idea. I'm not a mobster... I just know a lot of people.

Now, I'm pretty sure at this point that you're a fraud. Since I know you're not the former Attorney General for the Emergency Management Agency of NYC, I'm guessing that you're instead a fan of people like Rick Porello, who hassles just about everyone with an Italian or Irish name similar to those from three decades ago.

No... never heard of rick porello. I don't hassle anyone with italian or irish last names.. I am friends with them. Many middle class people think that because they are in a mixed family or left their cultural roots decades ago that their no longer exists within major cities a clearly “irish, italian, and polish” working class ...they live just as urban as african americans and hispanics but you don't see them on tv. Why is that? And all media tries to convince them that they are white.... there are no ethnicities in the last decade instead everyone became white. I'm not white... I'm Irish Italian.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom