In case you're not getting it, the point is that these conspiracy theory religious "studies" are BS in that they take completely different mythos and try to jam them together over some alleged similarity that usually winds up being something as simple as "sun worship" (vague much?) or as asinine as attempting to claim similar first letters to the names (Mary, Maya, Myrra). Hardly reliable evidence. Other attempts have been in trying to claim that similar sounding words have common ancestry, and as I've pointed out already there have been linguistic studies that have shown the error in using such a phenomenon as evidence. In each and every case, without fail, these religious conspiracy theories require the person subscribing to the theory to be mostly ignorant of any and all cultural and historical context in order to make the connection. If anything, this sort of fallacious and wild imaginitive speculation is precisely why the last half century of archaeology has been so controversial-- we are finding out just how much many of the earlier studies of ancient civilizations have had a lot of cultural projection placed on them, poisoning the well of scholarly study.
This is just a new dose of poison.
Oh, and Horus never died. Osiris did.![]()
Mystically, it has been said that Horus is Osiris reborn.
In Qabalah, the three Egyptian principles Osiris, Isis, and Horus are related around the 345 triangle thus....
Osiris=3 Father;
Isis=4 Mother;
Horus=5 Son.
Thus Osiris-Horus is 3:5
The Greek numeration of Jesus Christ is 888:1480, which by ratio breaks down to 3:5, thus implying that JC is symbolically an amalgam of Osiris and Horus.
Anubis wasn't an embalmer, he was a guide.
In case you're not getting it, the point is that these conspiracy theory religious "studies" are BS in that they take completely different mythos and try to jam them together over some alleged similarity that usually winds up being something as simple as "sun worship" (vague much?) or as asinine as attempting to claim similar first letters to the names (Mary, Maya, Myrra). Hardly reliable evidence. Other attempts have been in trying to claim that similar sounding words have common ancestry, and as I've pointed out already there have been linguistic studies that have shown the error in using such a phenomenon as evidence. In each and every case, without fail, these religious conspiracy theories require the person subscribing to the theory to be mostly ignorant of any and all cultural and historical context in order to make the connection. If anything, this sort of fallacious and wild imaginitive speculation is precisely why the last half century of archaeology has been so controversial-- we are finding out just how much many of the earlier studies of ancient civilizations have had a lot of cultural projection placed on them, poisoning the well of scholarly study.
Then why do I keep finding references to him being the god of embalming?
Why did priests wear his mask while they embalmed? Why is it said supposedly that he embalmed Osiris?
I get that just fine...but I am still wondering specifically how Massey's interpretation was "debunked" and replaced with something that you agree with. Could you please identify who did this, and where, and how?
See, you really don't get it. It isn't that Massey has been "debunked." He was simply incorrect. More accurate interpretations have been made and study moves on from there. That you seem determined to make this about someone having provided a "Massey was wrong" publication is your own problem. Massey got plenty of interpretations of texts wrong, but on the other hand he was still a respected art historian and did a lot for Egyptology with regard to saving, restoring, and presenting the art of ancient Egypt. There was no need to "debunk" anything, the need was in finding as precise a translation as possible. Scholars don't write papers on subjects like "there is no Anup the Baptizer like Massey claimed." Science doesn't work at proving negatives, it instead works to examine and prove positives. A lot of Massey's claims in his translations were not found in subsequent translations, and as such they are dropped because they did not withstand independent verification.
Thank you for reading so deeply into my question. One I still don't have an answer to. Whether he was debunked, found incorrect, or wrong you know exactly what I mean despite the choice of language. Why was he incorrect?
What did he misinterpret?
Who discovered the error? Why is their interpretation better suited then his?
Did he ever write any rebuttals to the claims that he was wrong, or did his being found incorrect occur after his death? Have any contemporary scholars attempted a rebuttal? Who were the independent verifiers, and how did they know they were right?
Spare me the "science doesn't prove a negative" quips for a second and just answer the question...I am not asking you to prove god doesn't exist, I am asking you to point out the where, how, and why since there obviously is one, otherwise you might think Massey was correct Since the whole of the assertion of horus/jesus hinges upon whether or not he was right or incorrect or debunked or whatever...I fail to see how these questions are invalid.
So please, indulge me for a minute or two. Providing the information that I am asking for would bolster your argument for those reading this thread in an attempt to sort out the validity of this section of the movie.
I was thinking of the best way to describe this in contemporary terms, and I think I got one. Basically, what you perform there is a mix of three things, each with their own flaws:
- An imperfect translation using a non-intuitive system, much like Alta Vista's Babelfish. For those who speak more than one language, it is clear how differences in grammar and inflection change between the languages that require an intuitive contextual shift of the words and intonations of the letters in order to actually say the same thing in two different languages. Very few languages have a straight one-to-one correlative connection for use, even languages that are of the similar age and same ancestry (like Arabic and Hebrew or like Spanish or Portugese). The fact that in this case Egyptian-- a language that hasn't been heard on this planet for millenia-- is facing translation attempts to divine some kind of meaning based almost solely on the literary translation from ancient Greek, the process of trying to extract some kind of hidden (or hyper-subtle) meaning using twice-removed translation and expecting any degree of accuracy using our only available conversion process is naive at best. It's similar to trying to make a pun or a double entedre with someone where they have no contextual reference for the 'extra' subject to which you refer.
- A postdiction or (in Latin) vaticinium ex eventu error, where a 'prophecy' correlation can only be made after-the-fact. Almost all religious or mystical prophecy falls under this type of hindsight (or confirmation) bias.
- The same phenomenon as the "NYC and Q33NY in Microsoft wingdings font" urban legend.
Using those three methods, I am confident that pretty much anything can be sufficiently connected to another thing, provided sufficient unnecessary complexity is applied to the equation and sufficient superficial simplicity is applied to the beginning and end subjects.
Whether you really care to go read the ofiginal texts or not, the summary answer is that mythical accounting Anubis in no way whatsoever resembles the mythical account of John the Baptist in any way, shape, or form.
I have no desire to partake in character assassination of Gerald Massey like I have seen in places like this and this, because I don't think his whole life's work was a waste-- he was an accomplished art historian who came to Egyptology later and made some outlandish and unsupported claims. The best way to show that they are indeed unsupported is to display the translated texts themselves, not try to find other books. Massey's claims about a Horus-Jesus myth are disregarded by the larger community of Egyptology because they have no supporting evidence. That's how science works: no evidence to support the hypothesis, hypothesis is dropped.
In my surfing around the 'net on the Jesus Myth Hypothesis , I've come up with more articles and reviews that put the JMH over into the realm of pop culture and call it a topic that, as of late, most serious scholars on the topic don't want to venture into. It seems the JMH has enough appeal to sell books, but not garner peer acceptance.
Hi GreNME,
Thanks for taking the time to explain the basis of your beliefs so well.
Might I ask you your thoughts on the Greco-Egyptian form of Anubis, Hermanubis?
This jackal-headed figure is seen in Hermetic symbology, notably Tarot Key 10, where his ears are the only part of his body rising above the central horizontal. (This symbolises that "inner hearing" is the route by which "ordinary man" may transcend his limitations and develop unto spiritual fullness.) I would say that the Greek version of Anubis clearly could be thought of as taking a similar role to John the Baptist. As Anubis prepares and preserves the way for Osiris, so John does similar for Jesus, as famously recounted in John 1....
"The next day John saw Jesus coming toward him and said, "Look, the Lamb of God, who takes away the sin of the world! This is the one I meant when I said, 'A man who comes after me has surpassed me because he was before me.' I myself did not know him, but the reason I came baptizing with water was that he might be revealed to Israel." - John 1:29-31
The role is the same, he is preparing and preserving the way.
Nick
I have not heard a description of the form of Anubis during the Roman occupation described as you have before, so I went looking for an early source. As it turns out, the earliest source I can find of Anubis having the features you describe are in Aleister Crowley's The Book of Thoth. Do you have an older source that describes Anubis in a similar fashion to John the Baptist?![]()
Because you don't bother to actually read the sources? Damn, man, read the books that explain what their "god of embalming" attribution means. Start with the Book of the Dead. The involvement of Anubis is one of overseer, protector of the body, and guide. Once you get to Plate 3 you see the funerary rites involving Anubis, who oversees the process. In Plate 7, which actually doesn't appear in the version of the Ani Papyrus (it was found at a different time and kept in the Louvre, where Massey was not located) involve presenting the 'words' (mouth) of the deceased to three gods, the main being Anubis, for judgment. Later, in Plate 15, organs of the deceased person's body are weighed by Thoth (the god scribe) in the presence of Anubis and later presented to Osiris for judgment. In Plate 16, after the body has been prepared and wrapped, Anubis is described as embracing the body-- this has more than one interpretation, but regardless of which interpretation of the action it is the beginning of the role of Anubis as the guide for the dead soul to the afterlife. This process continues until, by Plates 33 & 34, the body of the deceased is completely prepared, presented, and ready to follow through into the final part where the deceased soul partakes of the funerary offerings (Plates 35 & 36) and walks out into the afterlife (Plate 37). The whole ritual is described with Anubis playing the role of overseer and guide, to ensure the body is worthy and prepared to enter the life after death. Anubis plays a presiding role, not a servicing one. Even more important, he doesn't play the role of a herald or prophet, as was the role of John the Baptist.
GreNME...One thing I find confusing is your apparent personal respect for Massey. I'll defer to your knowledge on the subject of Egyptology and figure that there's something within that knowledge that dissuades you from wanting to attack Massey, however it does seem a bit of an odd deviation from the usual *your "evidence" is supplied by morons* style that's used by most CT debunkers.
Maybe attacks on Massey is more of what we need. ( I haven't been able to find any attacks on the Budge translation )
In my surfing around the 'net on the Jesus Myth Hypothesis , I've come up with more articles and reviews that put the JMH over into the realm of pop culture and call it a topic that, as of late, most serious scholars on the topic don't want to venture into. It seems the JMH has enough appeal to sell books, but not garner peer acceptance.
Am I even close here ?
Is my question not direct enough? How do you know the translations that you want me to go and read aren't off as well?
I am curious to know why Massey was accepted at one point, and then not later. There should be a clear path for you to describe other than "he made unsupported claims" ...to be honest, I'm not even sure what his claims actually are, but there should be a way to describe why academia doesn't agree, and who it is that doesn't agree, and why they think that.
Your answer seems to be for me to go and read a bunch of texts without a comparison to Massey's claims, whatever they are, as well as reading a bunch of other books...and while I would normally agree, in the context of the thread it would be so much easier for you to simply answer the basic questions of why his point of view is not favored...
I am surprised that Acharya S hasn't been mentioned yet to my knowledge in this thread, since she is supposedly the chief source of information on the topic for the creator of the video...and why her scholarship isn't in question as well...
Since you are obviously the scholar on this topic here, why not demonstrate for us why you have the position that you do in as clear a way as possible so that we might all benefit.
Hi GreNME,
The esoteric version of Tarot Key 10 is recorded as being published from around the 13th century AD. The interpretation I gave is from BOTA, and likely written around the 1920s, which probably places it at a similar period to the AC book.
Even disregarding the Greek form of the god, when one considers the metaphysical interpretation of the Christ or Osiris myth, the roles of Anubis and John are, I submit, clearly similar. Anubis preserves the body of Osiris through a long period of purgation such that the infant Horus, the emergent Christ consciousness, may be born. John prepares the people, the macrocosmic body, that Christ may walk among them and be recognised.
Hermanubis, being a man controlled by animal instinct, yet capable of inner hearing (capable of hearing the message of God), is a clear Christ precursor.
Nick
Looking at Plate 4 of your linked texts above, I note what may be an interesting correspondance to Tarot Key 10 and to the "four holy living creatures" of Revelation 4.
"Facing him, and standing on a lotus flower, are the four "children of Horus (or Osiris)," or gods of the cardinal points. The first, Mestha, has the head of a man; the second, Hapi, the head of an ape; the third, Tuamautef, the head of a jackal; and the fourth, Qebhsennuf, the head of a hawk."
This scene seems to occur just prior to the descent into the underworld, again placing it symbolically in alignment with Revelation of John, where just after the placing of the four holy living creature, so proceeds the opening of the seven seals which bind closed the unconscious mind.
Nick