WTC7 Girder 79-44 13th floor and Tony Szamboti’s graphics and inputs analysis.

If JREF had thought the forum could serve to make sure people on the fence would end up supporting the official story it would have kept the forum and proudly advertized Chris Mohr, JayUtah and buddies.

Think carefully about why this post demonstrates how much more you need us than we need you.
 
Think carefully about why this post demonstrates how much more you need us than we need you.
thumbup.gif
 
Oh, for crissakes Tony! Just publish your friggin findings...

It's not so much the "findings" that is being requested. Tony believes the various papers he's written expound his general findings sufficiently. But with narrow respect to WTC 7, Tony believes he's constructed a finite-element analysis model that more accurately reflects the behavior of a joint NIST identifies as the best candidate for where global collapse initiated in that structure. In Tony's computer model the joint does not fail, leading him to speculate that NIST intentionally contrived their model to "fail" and thereby provide a fabricated excuse for the global collapse. Otherwise, he maintains, the data would inevitably indicate circumstances that only controlled demolition could produce.

What some critics are asking for is the computer file that contains his model, and its inputs, so that experts can determine how correct it is. Tony has given reasons why he believes his model to be more accurate, but those assurances paint only a very incomplete picture about the many ways such a model might be misconstructed or misapplied. Until outside experts are allowed to assess its quality, it remains simply Tony's bare assurance.
 
It's not so much the "findings" that is being requested. Tony believes the various papers he's written expound his general findings sufficiently. But with narrow respect to WTC 7, Tony believes he's constructed a finite-element analysis model that more accurately reflects the behavior of a joint NIST identifies as the best candidate for where global collapse initiated in that structure. In Tony's computer model the joint does not fail, leading him to speculate that NIST intentionally contrived their model to "fail" and thereby provide a fabricated excuse for the global collapse. Otherwise, he maintains, the data would inevitably indicate circumstances that only controlled demolition could produce.

What some critics are asking for is the computer file that contains his model, and its inputs, so that experts can determine how correct it is. Tony has given reasons why he believes his model to be more accurate, but those assurances paint only a very incomplete picture about the many ways such a model might be misconstructed or misapplied. Until outside experts are allowed to assess its quality, it remains simply Tony's bare assurance.

I am not at all a structural engineer....or even an engineer of any type. In my rather uninformed and ignorant mind, it seems rather....dishonest for someone to focus purely and only on a single joint; as Tony seems to be doing. A single joint or a single beam, an entire structure does not make.

As I understand it in my layman's mind, as one joint or beam weakens, it tends to redistribute the load onto other parts of the supporting structure, increasing tensions elsewhere. The joint Tony keeps wanting to talk about, seems, to me at least, to be a critical point of the structure. From what I understand, that point has been taking a larger load from other areas, and eventually went past it's breaking point.

(Just fostering an actual discussion. I don't have a whole lot to say or add, and have a very strong feeling I am speaking out my ass in the above two paragraphs.)
 
Think carefully .....................

If they did they wouldn't be "truthers".

It's funny to think they come here, fighting us thinking we are the ones holding them back. Not once have I seen anyone attempt to stop them from doing an independent investigation. In fact, everyone here encourages it.

Biggest fallacy in the "truth" movement, the "debunkers" are holding them back.

Tip for real "truthers". Identify your real enemy.
 
Last edited:
A single joint or a single beam, an entire structure does not make.

Correct, but it's the joint NIST centered on as the most likely site of global collapse initiation, which is a point of some interest to builders of tall buildings. Its certainly not the sum total of the structural analysis that applies to WTC 7. It's not so much its role in the structure that matters as its role as one of the sources of the conventional narrative. Conspiracism is not about finding an alternate truth and showing it to be objectively more attractive. It's about challenging the conventional wisdom to show how clever and important the conspiracists are.

(Just fostering an actual discussion. ...)

This forum has many lengthy threads on the structural analysis of WTC 7 and Tony's contributions in particular. This thread is rather narrowly focused on urging a useful disclosure of the basis for Tony's conclusion in this particular point. And since Tony has indicated he will not grant the request, it's pretty much a dead thread from here on out.
 
Biggest fallacy in the "truth" movement, the "debunkers" are holding them back.

Tip for real "truthers". Identify your real enemy.

Their real enemy ignores them, as well they should. So in order to maintain some belief in their own relevance, they have to find an enemy of convenience, vest them in the proxy robes of their designated enemy ("defenders of NIST" etc.) and style them as formidable enough to be worth their attention, yet feeble and deluded enough not to appreciate the clearly superior reasoning of the conspiracy theorists.

Yes, Tony, Ziggi, and others come here because they need the criticism in order to feel like they're accomplishing something, if only to crash up against supposedly stubborn foes. As Oscar Wilde wrote, the only thing worse than being talked about is not being talked about.
 
Their real enemy ignores them, as well they should. So in order to maintain some belief in their own relevance, they have to find an enemy of convenience, vest them in the proxy robes of their designated enemy ("defenders of NIST" etc.) and style them as formidable enough to be worth their attention, yet feeble and deluded enough not to appreciate the clearly superior reasoning of the conspiracy theorists.

Yes, Tony, Ziggi, and others come here because they need the criticism in order to feel like they're accomplishing something, if only to crash up against supposedly stubborn foes. As Oscar Wilde wrote, the only thing worse than being talked about is not being talked about.

There's an old saying that harkens back to theatre critics.....

A good review makes an actor a god
A bad review makes an actor a hero
No review makes an actor a nobody.
 
Correct, but it's the joint NIST centered on as the most likely site of global collapse initiation, which is a point of some interest to builders of tall buildings. Its certainly not the sum total of the structural analysis that applies to WTC 7. It's not so much its role in the structure that matters as its role as one of the sources of the conventional narrative. Conspiracism is not about finding an alternate truth and showing it to be objectively more attractive. It's about challenging the conventional wisdom to show how clever and important the conspiracists are.



This forum has many lengthy threads on the structural analysis of WTC 7 and Tony's contributions in particular. This thread is rather narrowly focused on urging a useful disclosure of the basis for Tony's conclusion in this particular point. And since Tony has indicated he will not grant the request, it's pretty much a dead thread from here on out.

yeah, there are 14 years of threads, no doubt. I remember back when I first signed up on the forum, I was perusing some of those threads for a while. I got bored. Like, really, really totally bored. Out of my mind. Though it isn't as bad as the AK threads, it's still quite bad.

But I understand the point of this particular thread now. Thanks.
 
I am not at all a structural engineer....or even an engineer of any type. In my rather uninformed and ignorant mind, it seems rather....dishonest for someone to focus purely and only on a single joint; as Tony seems to be doing. A single joint or a single beam, an entire structure does not make.

As I understand it in my layman's mind, as one joint or beam weakens, it tends to redistribute the load onto other parts of the supporting structure, increasing tensions elsewhere. The joint Tony keeps wanting to talk about, seems, to me at least, to be a critical point of the structure. From what I understand, that point has been taking a larger load from other areas, and eventually went past it's breaking point.

(Just fostering an actual discussion. I don't have a whole lot to say or add, and have a very strong feeling I am speaking out my ass in the above two paragraphs.)

As you correctly state: "...dishonest for someone to focus purely and only on a single joint; as Tony seems to be doing. A single joint or a single beam, an entire structure does not make."

Tony is working on part of the structure and starting from false premises. He wants the discussion down in the details and going round in circles. He is succeeding. And most of his opponents are also determined to play it by Tony's rules - make absolutely sure we do not identify or discuss the errors in the starting assumptions. Just keep debating Tony's technical bits OR the protocols of debate - either track supports Tony's goal.

Narrow or nonsense discussion based on false premises is Tony's unwavering tactic. I identified it in my very first internet post back in 2007 - I didn't know Tony then but he hasn't changed:
me - another forum Nov 13 said:
The paper referenced as Engineering Reality by Tony Szamboti is typical of many which look impressive in detail to the non-engineer. The complex calculations may even be correct but the base premises are faulty and the resulting conclusions can readily be demonstrated to be totally wrong.

That is SOP for Tony - start from wrong premises which pre-set the desired outcome THEN pad the "argument" out with a lot of engineering looking gobbledygook which may fool the gullible and - surprising to me - seems to fool quite a few engineers.

When he originally posted the "Girder Walk-off" claims his bounding premises - his context setting - was false. I told him and the opposing debunkers that at the time. I don't think he has corrected his assumptions BUT neither he nor the debunkers opposing him want to discuss those potentially fatal issues. In fact the only support I remember having gained for the assertion of false premises was from another truther - enik - who did his own FEA which used far more valid context setting parameters.

The implicit goal - both sides - seems to be "keep going round in circles". As I commented recently on another topic:
'"How many leaves on the seventh branch of the fourth tree?" is meaningless when you are in the wrong forest.'

I don't think we are in the wrong forest but we are certainly discussing leaves when we are not sure we have the right tree.

Your post is a good "sitrep" of the state of debate.
 
Last edited:
Yes, Tony, Ziggi, and others come here because they need the criticism in order to feel like they're accomplishing something, if only to crash up against supposedly stubborn foes. As Oscar Wilde wrote, the only thing worse than being talked about is not being talked about.
thumbup.gif


And playing ""Whack-A-Mole" games with them gives them the attention they seek with he minimum expenditure of mental effort.

...whilst guaranteeing that those few who, like me. are interested in understanding the technical issues are inevitably going to remain frustrated.

"Bash a Truther" is more fun than serious engineering forensic discussion. :(
 
Ozzie,
Maybe NIST had some false premises too to start with? The col 79 discussion to me... seems like trying to understand a car crash cause by ONLY looking at the mangled cars and not at the road conditions and what the cars were doing BEFORE they impacted.

At every level or moment in time of a "mechanical" destruction... you can isolate it and study the "forces" involved (I suppose).. and almost ignore things back in time already lost to entropy.

As you know I see the col 79 "discussion" as looking in the wrong place for the initial failure. Of course a flr 13 col 79 failure would lead to the collapse of what was above it... but IT would "fail" if stuff happened below it making THAT failure consequence not the initial cause.

I don't "KNOW" anything because I was not there. But it's pretty obvious that all the "initiation" explanations are ASSUMPTION driven... change the assumptions / location and you can come up with another "viable" scenario.

And it's interesting to me that NIST's driver (heat) works in different locations in the two different designs... 7wtc its about expanding beams moving things around... and in the twins its sagging trusses pulling things apart. (likely happened but not the primary causes)

The knee bone connected to the thigh bone... the thigh bone connected to the hip bone.
 
Ozzie,
Maybe NIST had some false premises too to start with?
Maybe..but.
Tony's original error was in defining the context premises for his argument. He either got those right or got them wrong.

The NIST hypothesis is different.

First - as you know if you recall previous discussions - I disagree with the NIST assertion that Col 79 started the collapse. My argument mostly a bit of pedantry. Something started Col79 failure. It couldn't start by itself - except if taken out by CD.

BUT there can be no doubt that Col 79 failed and that it was the key identifying feature of the collapse initiation. Col 79 and nearby associated structures under the EPH without doubt failed.

NOW NIST says "girder walkoff" started - or contributed to starting Col 79 failure.

If I understand your alternate transfer truss failure started Col 79. So Col 79 is still the key feature - the only difference being the ranking or sequencing of the supporting factors.

So I don't think Col 79 can be eliminated as a key feature of the collapse.

Wheras Tony's failure to prove his assumption of "pristine conditions" other than the girder simply leaves his argument without a valid foundation. His claim not "made out" tho not necessarily false - just "not proven".
 
Last edited:
So I don't think Col 79 can be eliminated as a key feature of the collapse.


Well sure... of course if a column failed everything above it would drop or fracture... unless it all could be cantileved and then that column was almost redundant.

Everything above flr 13 came down... so at least from flr 13 there was a failure of the column.

BUT

We don't really know what was going on below flr 13... If everything was "pristine".. column 79 flr 13 might be the straw that broke the camel's back... failing and sending downward an avalanche of 32 floors of debris.

Would that take out more bracing and by pass the columns? Would the huge mass destroy the transfer structure below and THAT propagate laterally causing what's above all that to then collapse? Seems possible.

This is a chicken and the egg thingie... and it's truly hard to know which came first.

Would the whole building collapse if there were no massive load transfer structures on the lower floors? Would the collapse be limited to the area around column 79 down to the ground? What would cause such a collapse to propagate laterally through the structure taking it all down? Beams pulling other adjacent columns into the collapse zone? Dunno.
 
Tony's original error was in defining the context premises for his argument. He either got those right or got them wrong.

That, for sure. But there is also the framing of the discussion.

The NIST hypothesis is different.

The NIST approach is different too.

Whereas Tony's failure to prove his assumption of "pristine conditions" other than the girder simply leaves his argument without a valid foundation.

His argument lacks a substantial plot of dirt upon which to put that foundation.

This is a chicken and the egg thingie... and it's truly hard to know which came first.

And it largely doesn't matter.

The fact is, from anywhere except the Truthers' vantage point, the collapse of WTC 7 is comparatively inconsequential. It is advantageous from an academic standpoint to determine why and how global collapse ensued, but the mystique in which Trutherism insists on shrouding the building is entirely a contrivance. You could, I'm sure, walk right up to any of the engineers involved in constructing the column-79 hypothesis, tell them you have a good case for column 79 not being the initial point of global collapse, and the answer would be, "Great; so what?"

The exact mechanism of global collapse in WTC 7 would be instructive if it could be determined, but no great disappointment if it cannot. This is the environment in which NIST studied WTC 7, and the context in which their results should be interpreted. They naturally consider their hypothesis the best fit to the data they were able to develop. Nothing I read in their findings suggests they consider the last word that can possibly be written on the subject.

But this doesn't fit the Truther agenda, which is mostly political. We've discussed at length how the focus shifted away from the Twin Towers and onto WTC 7 as the "real" target of an alleged inside job or false-flag attack. That conjures up out of thin air a reason why WTC 7 should have been extensively studied. Applying that amplified-salience policy toward a process of increasingly narrow focus, the Truthers envision what they insist is a house-of-cards coverup built upon WTC 7, the "official" investigation, the prevailing theory for global collapse, a single column, a single joint, and a single method used to study the performance of that joint. And having found, as Szamboti believes, a fatal flaw in that analysis, he asserts the whole house of cards must now tumble to the floor.

So yes, there are the flaws we can discover from an examination of a broad context and scope. Szamboti has to convince his readers that his interpretation of engineering best practices in this case is spot-on, so that he can aggrandize the error he thinks he's found. This is why it's important to know how competent he is to make those judgments, and whether there is a consensus among experts on them. Observations have evidentiary value only when someone can tell us what they mean. In some cases we can do this for ourselves. In other cases we have to have an experience practitioner help us understand the implications of sagging and walk-off and these other elements of structural behavior. And we need someone to tell us whether a particular example of publication and comment is typical or atypical of how such things are done in the industry.

But notwithstanding those errors, we can also test it at the minute scale where he prefers to live. That's what this thread is about. Conspiracy theorists commonly select some bellwether McGuffin that allegedly represents the problem as a whole, and about which there can be endless discussion or debate. Tony keeps the hamster wheel spinning by asserting (but not showing) that a "proper" computer analysis would have a different outcome. The reader is supposed to accept Tony's judgment of what constitutes a proper model, and his assurance that his own model is proper.

But if Tony reveals that model to outside experts, its fidelity and correctness no longer becomes a matter solely of his opinion and assertion. This is why he's suddenly throwing up all the objections and obstacles -- we don't need to see the model to appreciate his genius, we aren't smart enough to understand it, etc. If we were watching a poker game, we'd characterize this as BasqueArch threatening to call Tony's bluff, and Tony has -- for all intents and purposes -- folded.
 
Jay,
Understanding the collapses depends on who is trying to understand them. As there is no evidence of CD the how becomes navel gazing... unless it reveals some sort of serious flaws in building practice which has put millions in jeopardy or will in the future. The basic recommendations for more robust fire suppression and protected emergency egress is a no brainer.

My interest is whether the were engineering decisions... which participated in the building collapses. I don't believe NIST addressed this question and so the unstated take away is that all high rises would fare the same under similar conditions. I personally believe that not all steel frame designs would fare the same. The twin towers had many design innovations such as the manufactured floor systems and the 3 story off site pre assembled structural facade panels. And in 7wtc few to no high rises are built over power substations requiring massive load transfer structures and contain massive amounts of stored diesel. Admittedly it would seem that few such requirements will present in the future, but why was there no mention of the efficacy of these "systems"?

So I am one of the few who was not thrilled with the NIST reports but not for covering up CD... but for not discussing the merits of the designs.
 
That, for sure. But there is also the framing of the discussion.

His argument lacks a substantial plot of dirt upon which to put that foundation.


And it largely doesn't matter.

The fact is, from anywhere except the Truthers' vantage point, the collapse of WTC 7 is comparatively inconsequential. It is advantageous from an academic standpoint to determine why and how global collapse ensued, but the mystique in which Trutherism insists on shrouding the building is entirely a contrivance. You could, I'm sure, walk right up to any of the engineers involved in constructing the column-79 hypothesis, tell them you have a good case for column 79 not being the initial point of global collapse, and the answer would be, "Great; so what?".
My most often stated "strategic summary" for WTC7 discussion goes to the reason for focusing on WTC 7 rather than twin towers. The willingness of debunkers to accept the "burden of DISproof".

There were several years of delay before the NIST WTC7 report was released. During that period the polarisation of discussion into two main camps had occurred and the names "truther" and "debunker" had come into common usage for the two main "camps".

"truthers" has made many assertions of CD at the "Twins" without meeting burden of proof whilst debunkers had readily accepted the challenge to "disprove". And rebuttal of CD claims was relatively easy for the Twin Towers collapses where sufficient visual evidence was available.

And truthers had essentially lost the argument for CD at the Twin Towers - their claims of CD "disproved" if we allow for the lay person terminology.

Debunkers accepting "burden of DISproof" had become the norm for forum discussions.

Then along came the WTC7 report - most of the evidence internal and hidden. Not available. A gift to the truthers in that "disproof" was much harder.

Whether they were conscious of it or not the tactical benefits of hidden evidence were seized on and most attention shifted to WTC7.

And - as you stated several times it is a "So what?" A steel framed building, subject to extensive fires, No resources to implement active fire fighting and all the occupants had escaped. A legitimate decision taken to leave the building to take its chances. It lost. End of story.

And debunkers are still valiantly accepting the "burden of DISproof" :rolleyes:
 
I'm having the most peculiar deju vu. Didn't we already go over all of this a couple years ago?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom