Tony's original error was in defining the context premises for his argument. He either got those right or got them wrong.
That, for sure. But there is also the framing of the discussion.
The NIST hypothesis is different.
The NIST
approach is different too.
Whereas Tony's failure to prove his assumption of "pristine conditions" other than the girder simply leaves his argument without a valid foundation.
His argument lacks a substantial plot of dirt upon which to put that foundation.
This is a chicken and the egg thingie... and it's truly hard to know which came first.
And it largely doesn't matter.
The fact is, from anywhere except the Truthers' vantage point, the collapse of WTC 7 is comparatively inconsequential. It is advantageous from an academic standpoint to determine why and how global collapse ensued, but the mystique in which Trutherism insists on shrouding the building is entirely a contrivance. You could, I'm sure, walk right up to any of the engineers involved in constructing the column-79 hypothesis, tell them you have a good case for column 79 not being the initial point of global collapse, and the answer would be, "Great; so what?"
The exact mechanism of global collapse in WTC 7 would be instructive
if it could be determined, but no great disappointment if it cannot. This is the environment in which NIST studied WTC 7, and the context in which their results should be interpreted. They naturally consider their hypothesis the best fit to the data they were able to develop. Nothing I read in their findings suggests they consider the last word that can possibly be written on the subject.
But this doesn't fit the Truther agenda, which is mostly political. We've discussed at length how the focus shifted away from the Twin Towers and onto WTC 7 as the "real" target of an alleged inside job or false-flag attack. That conjures up out of thin air a reason why WTC 7 should have been
extensively studied. Applying that amplified-salience policy toward a process of increasingly narrow focus, the Truthers envision what they insist is a house-of-cards coverup built upon WTC 7, the "official" investigation, the prevailing theory for global collapse, a single column, a single joint, and a single method used to study the performance of that joint. And having found, as Szamboti believes, a fatal flaw in that analysis, he asserts the whole house of cards must now tumble to the floor.
So yes, there are the flaws we can discover from an examination of a broad context and scope. Szamboti has to convince his readers that his interpretation of engineering best practices in this case is spot-on, so that he can aggrandize the error he thinks he's found. This is why it's important to know how competent he is to make those judgments, and whether there is a consensus among experts on them. Observations have evidentiary value only when someone can tell us what they
mean. In some cases we can do this for ourselves. In other cases we have to have an experience practitioner help us understand the implications of sagging and walk-off and these other elements of structural behavior. And we need someone to tell us whether a particular example of publication and comment is typical or atypical of how such things are done in the industry.
But notwithstanding those errors, we can also test it at the minute scale where he prefers to live. That's what this thread is about. Conspiracy theorists commonly select some bellwether McGuffin that allegedly represents the problem as a whole, and about which there can be endless discussion or debate. Tony keeps the hamster wheel spinning by asserting (but not showing) that a "proper" computer analysis would have a different outcome. The reader is supposed to accept Tony's judgment of what constitutes a proper model, and his assurance that his own model is proper.
But if Tony reveals that model to outside experts, its fidelity and correctness no longer becomes a matter solely of his opinion and assertion. This is why he's suddenly throwing up all the objections and obstacles -- we don't need to see the model to appreciate his genius, we aren't smart enough to understand it, etc. If we were watching a poker game, we'd characterize this as BasqueArch threatening to call Tony's bluff, and Tony has -- for all intents and purposes -- folded.