WTC7 Girder 79-44 13th floor and Tony Szamboti’s graphics and inputs analysis.

There are photographs showing the stiffeners on the end of girder A2001 in the "as built" configuration with it sitting on its seat at column 79.
This answers my question, how? What are your assumptions for the rest of the structure? The NIST did not consider this in isolation. Did you?
 
Last edited:
This thread has shades of Pons/Fleischman. When no one could duplicate their cold fusion results, P/F said they weren't doing it right, but refused to provide enough info to help. Eventually...well, we know the rest.
 
This thread has shades of Pons/Fleischman. When no one could duplicate their cold fusion results, P/F said they weren't doing it right, but refused to provide enough info to help. Eventually...well, we know the rest.
The Harrit et al "thermite" paper is the same way. An independent study was dismissed because they "had the wrong chips". This dispite the fact they match exactly to all the criterion in the paper.
 
Last edited:
This answers my question, how? What are your assumptions for the rest of the structure? The NIST did not consider this in isolation. Did you?

Do you actually think you need the rest of the building to analyze the girder to column connection?

I am already giving the 6.25" thermal expansion of the beams which can be shown to be unlikely.
 
Asked and answered.

You are patently unwilling to let your work be reviewed by outside experts. Therefore I doubt it is as earth-shattering and conclusive as you claim it to be.

Plenty of my work is publicly available. I already gave you links to the three papers that are pertinent to this thread.
 
Do you actually think you need the rest of the building to analyze the girder to column connection?

I am already giving the 6.25" thermal expansion of the beams which can be shown to be unlikely.
Nope, just the effected area. It also is not just about that connection, displacement (of related members) by all means also fall into play. You really need to look at things with a much more broad focus. :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
This analysis shows the same focus as the heat sagging trusses in the towers. The NIST showed not enough sag in heat tests but Tony "forgets" to include this was not the only force in place.

I believe it's known as "lie by omission".
 
Last edited:
This analysis shows the same focus as the heat sagging trusses in the towers. The NIST showed not enough sag in heat tests but Tony "forgets" to include this was not the only force in place.

I believe it's known as "lie by omission".

What was the other force you are saying was involved?
 
The buildings collapse from one force.. gravity. The structure that held them up so that they could resist gravity were the columns held in place by beams and slabs composite with them.

The plane strike destroyed a portion of the axial capacity of the columns. There was reserve capacity and the loads were redistributed because the frame is composed of many members which can to some extent redistribute loads to other parts of the frame... Everything is copacetic if the reserve capacity of an individual column remains below ultimate yield strength. If the column is over loaded it will buckle, become no performing and the loads then find new paths.

Columns became non performing from several reasons:

Loss of some capacity as their temperature rose locally
loss of capacity if they lost bracing and their unsupported length increased
loss of capacity because the bearing area to a column below was decreased
additional load applied as redistributed loads from loss of other columns

Or a combination of the above.

Fires and heat warped and elongated steel, spalded concrete, burned contents, caused things like transformers and filled pipes to explode.

Who knows there may have been some exotic exothermic reactions as well... hot enough to melt aluminum which was seen pouring out of the corner of the south tower.

It's pretty clear that the loss of capacity of the SYSTEM in the plane strike region was progressing.... as individual columns became non performing and finally capacity was less than service loads and the tops came down... misaligned because of the non symmetrical loss of capacity of the structure.

It's really that simple on a gross level.

There is nothing which suggest bombs were placed.
 

You think gravity had a role in pulling the columns inward when the sagging trusses in the NIST model couldn't?

Or are you thinking I didn't apply gravity to my analysis of the girder to seat connection at column 79?
 
Last edited:
@BasqueArch, MileHighMadness - any other engineers.

I have many times observed that Tony's persistent major error is that he gets the premises of the starting point scenario wrong. Which means that the house of cards "argument" he erects is on a false foundation - therefore his claim is false or at least unproven before we even do the calculations or FEA.

My own preference when rebutting nonsense based on false premises is to attack the premise. I see little point in arguing details within the false context set by persons like Tony.

When Tony first presented his WTC7 Girder Walkoff claim he assumed that the columns supporting the ends of the girder remained in pristine state and location - unaffected by fire. And the fire only affected the failing girder and attached beams.

So I "called" Tony on the error of false - unproven - premises and didn't join in the extensive discussion of details.

Has he corrected his false premise or are we still engaging with a claim which has no valid foundations?

Sure his details are also wrong as demonstrated by many members.

Do you know if he has corrected his unproven and highly unlikely starting point?
 
I see little point in arguing details within the false context set by persons like Tony.

The contention seems to be that the FEA model and inputs will reveal more than just details. They will reveal the context in which they arose in in a way that can't easily be weasel-worded around.
 
I would think MHM and Newton's Bit can do their own analyses and tell us whether or not the girder flange fails with the stiffeners on it.

Lateral torsional buckling isn't the failure mode NIST claims. They have an alternate analysis in Chapter 8 where the girder is pulled back to the east by buckled beams but they say that was only preliminary and not what they support as a failure mode.

In Chapters 11 and 12 they claim the east side girder flange folded as it was not sufficient to take the bending stress once the web was past the seat to the west.

Dear Tony, are you really going to try to reason with people that are still thinking that the Chapter 8 prelim exercise, showing the girder being pulled backwards to the east, shows the same thing as the final conclusion in chapter 11, where the girder is pushed forward off to the west? You note, don´t you, that not a single one of BasqueArch´s forum friends - who like to pose as big-shot engineers and authorities on the WTC collapses - has corrected his error?

What´s the point? The forum has no audience anymore, besides the regular posters. In about 3.5 months, Chris Mohr´s big new "thermitedebunking" YouTube comedy has mustered 1228 views: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aGGJ4xzna8o&feature=youtu.be

When was the last time you encountered an even half-serious researcher referencing the regulars on this forum?
 
What´s the point?

None of the "regulars" here has any delusion of relevance. Well, I don't anyway. But keep in mind that there is not, nor has been for some time, any legitimate audience whatsoever for Truthers. What's the salience in the comparison? Truthers think they matter in the real world. They do not. Hence they have to resort to shilling in insignificant, backwater forums such as this where their presence is at least tolerated, complaining about how inadequate the venue and how incompetent the criticism. So here you are.
 
No, this is not a private thing. You make public arguments that rest upon data and methods you are unwilling to reveal in public. We're just supposed to take your word for it that you did it right. How is that even remotely scientifically valid?

LMAO @NIST refusal to do the same....
 
LMAO @NIST refusal to do the same....

The essentials of the model and its assumptions and error analysis were published in the Journal of Structural Engineering. Keep in mind it is the Truthers who demand that the full details of the NIST-commissioned models be published. The real engineering community considers the JSE publication sufficient. The hypocrisy belongs to Truthers alone, who will not submit to the same standards of transparency they propose to impose upon others. Please comment upon this.
 
The contention seems to be that the FEA model and inputs will reveal more than just details. They will reveal the context in which they arose in in a way that can't easily be weasel-worded around.

Understood. And I comprehend the self entrapment tactics.

I'm only trying to determine current state of play.

I nailed the false context issue several times for Tony in the first rounds of discussion some years back. He still managed to weasel around - IIRC by totally ignoring the point I made.

Then enik - also a dedicated truther - did an FEA which took in more context and was probably sufficient in scope to satisfy my point. BUT he posted it in support of Tony - apparently missing the scope limitation I had identified. So Tony became co-lateral damage in a friendly fire episode from someone on his own side.

I commended enik for his better effort.

BUT I left the scene which had all the usual details engineers arguing the details. SOP for this forum - no point in identifying where the fundamental problem definition is fatally flawed when most want to discuss details. Forest v trees syndrome that is a professional risk for us engineers. Or "Alligators v Swamp Draining".

So I'm interested in current state of play - are the underlying premises valid. And I don't want to read all the threads. :o
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom