WTC7 Girder 79-44 13th floor and Tony Szamboti’s graphics and inputs analysis.

Dear Tony, are you really going to try to reason with people that are still thinking that the Chapter 8 prelim exercise, showing the girder being pulled backwards to the east, shows the same thing as the final conclusion in chapter 11, where the girder is pushed forward off to the west? You note, don´t you, that not a single one of BasqueArch´s forum friends - who like to pose as big-shot engineers and authorities on the WTC collapses - has corrected his error?

What´s the point? The forum has no audience anymore, besides the regular posters. In about 3.5 months, Chris Mohr´s big new "thermitedebunking" YouTube comedy has mustered 1228 views: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aGGJ4xzna8o&feature=youtu.be

When was the last time you encountered an even half-serious researcher referencing the regulars on this forum?

Ziggi, I don't post here for the regulars as it is pretty clear that they are shills who cannot admit that the buildings came down via controlled demolition no matter how much evidence is put before them.

I only come on here occasionally for the benefit of any possible lurkers who come here and might not know many of the details and be on the fence.
 
Last edited:
I just used the real drawings for the actual configuration where the seat was 12 inches wide and girder A2001 had 3/4" thick x 18" high stiffeners and put the beam's web past the seat and did the stress analysis to see if the flange would fail as NIST claimed after the beams pushed it 6.25" laterally to the west.

I want to see the video.
 
I only come on here occasionally for the benefit of any possible lurkers who come here and might not know many of the details and be on the fence.

As a lurker in this forum, I suggest you save the wear and tear on your fingers because you aren't leaving a favorable impression on this member of your intended audience.
 
As a lurker in this forum, I suggest you save the wear and tear on your fingers because you aren't leaving a favorable impression on this member of your intended audience.

As a fellow lurker (mostly) I concur with this statement.
 
Ziggi, I don't post here for the regulars as it is pretty clear that they are shills who cannot admit that the buildings came down via controlled demolition no matter how much evidence is put before them.

I only come on here occasionally for the benefit of any possible lurkers who come here and might not know many of the details and be on the fence.

Where do you suggest one find an online robust "technical" discussions of the collapses regardless of cause?

slim pickens
 
Dear Tony, are you really going to try to reason with people that are still thinking that the Chapter 8 prelim exercise, showing the girder being pulled backwards to the east, shows the same thing as the final conclusion in chapter 11, where the girder is pushed forward off to the west? You note, don´t you, that not a single one of BasqueArch´s forum friends - who like to pose as big-shot engineers and authorities on the WTC collapses - has corrected his error?

What´s the point? The forum has no audience anymore, besides the regular posters. In about 3.5 months, Chris Mohr´s big new "thermitedebunking" YouTube comedy has mustered 1228 views: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aGGJ4xzna8o&feature=youtu.be

When was the last time you encountered an even half-serious researcher referencing the regulars on this forum?

The beams expanded to the west. The girder expanded towards the columns, trapped and buckled. The beams buckled and sagged pulling the top flange of the girder near where they were attached to the east and twisting the bottom flange to the west. After the top flange reached the critical twist angle the ~ 45 foot girder collapsed falling off the seat . The error is in your understanding .
 
Ziggi, I don't post here for the regulars as it is pretty clear that they are shills who cannot admit that the buildings came down via controlled demolition no matter how much evidence is put before them.

......

These claims are no longer engineering questions, they are medical questions.
 
I only come on here occasionally for the benefit of any possible lurkers who come here and might not know many of the details and be on the fence.

Then why do you so assiduously ignore the questions such a lurker would have, such as whether your allegedly gold-standard computer analysis has been reviewed by others skilled in the art? You're asking these lurkers to believe your skill and judgment over that of an entire industry. Don't you think that merits a very high standard of proof, not just your self-published and marginally-published papers? Don't you think the first thing that might pop into a lurker's mind is whether there is actually any traction here, or whether instead this guy is just an off-the-rails crackpot out in the intellectual weeds, so to speak?

You make such little effort to address the kinds of questions a lurker might ask. You might just as well admit you're continuously shopping for new converts. Lurkers can see how you behave in a debate. Then they're no longer fence-sitters. That's why you need fresh rubes who will let you spoon-feed them.
 
LMAO @NIST refusal to do the same....

Hehe my thoughts exactly!
Now I don't know if Toni also sings that hymn from the truther scoresheet that has the trusty old lyrics
Oh tell me NIST, where ar'st them files o' thee?
Methinks this prov'th there was CD!
​
But if he does, I chuckle.
 
Ziggi, I don't post here for the regulars as it is pretty clear that they are shills who cannot admit that the buildings came down via controlled demolition no matter how much evidence is put before them.

I only come on here occasionally for the benefit of any possible lurkers who come here and might not know many of the details and be on the fence.
You had me at "shills"...

... got to love the paranoia of CD fantasy pushers based on zero evidence, and maximum BS. or not



Love the "much evidence". Is it invisible evidence, matching the silent explosives and no product thermite.


shills - got some evidence for that claim? no

Hi lurkers - anyone found some evidence to help Tony's readcddeal? no
 
This analysis shows the same focus as the heat sagging trusses in the towers. The NIST showed not enough sag in heat tests but Tony "forgets" to include this was not the only force in place.

I believe it's known as "lie by omission".

What was the other force you are saying was involved?


You think gravity had a role in pulling the columns inward when the sagging trusses in the NIST model couldn't?

Or are you thinking I didn't apply gravity to my analysis of the girder to seat connection at column 79?

I know English is your primary language (I'm not sure or do I care if you have a second).

The NIST test was to show how much the trusses would sag over a given distance at a given temperature. I agree this was not enough to pull in the columns the amount as observed. Gravity load did the rest.

A simple test that I shouldn't have to show you. Take a straw and push down on it, it can take a pretty good push. Now bend it a bit, does it bend more then the straight one.

Like everywhere else, your focus is too narrow.

Sometimes Tony, your stubbornness just needs a slap of obvious.
 
Last edited:
The NIST test was to show how much the trusses would sag over a given distance at a given temperature. I agree this was not enough to pull in the columns the amount as observed. Gravity load did the rest.

As I recall, NIST calculated the pull-in force using a conservative figure for fireproofing removal - which would have minimised the number of floor trusses sagging and hence the pull-in forces - and without considering thermal expansion, which would have exerted different pull-in forces as the fires lessened and the already sagging trusses cooled, strengthened and contracted. Those are both ways in which NIST underestimated the pull-in force, to which the effects of axial force on an already buckling column can be added. Tony is perfectly aware of all this, but chooses not to know it.

Dave
 
As I recall, NIST calculated the pull-in force using a conservative figure for fireproofing removal - which would have minimised the number of floor trusses sagging and hence the pull-in forces - and without considering thermal expansion, which would have exerted different pull-in forces as the fires lessened and the already sagging trusses cooled, strengthened and contracted. Those are both ways in which NIST underestimated the pull-in force, to which the effects of axial force on an already buckling column can be added. Tony is perfectly aware of all this, but chooses not to know it.

Dave
This is true. The point is, all the sagging trusses had to do is to pull the exterior columns out of vertical(create the hinge). After that they are considered failed and gravity would do the rest. I'm not sure the bolt connection would survive the amount of pull in observed.
 
Last edited:
This is true. The point is, all the sagging trusses had to do is to pull the exterior columns out of vertical(create the hinge).

Well, they'd have to exceed the elastic limit, which they clearly hadn't when the photos were taken. But the Trinity Church video of WTC2 shows what happened when they did reach the elastic limit; the collapse started with the perimeter columns buckling inwards, then everything else followed horribly quickly. There isn't as clear a video of the WTC1 collapse initiation, but it may have been a very similar process.

Dave
 
Oh, for crissakes Tony! Just publish your friggin findings, at least here on the forums so others can check your work, and maybe you can actually discuss something. Gawds, I'm a lurker on these threads, but by no means any sort of engineer. Determining by your arguments, you have nothing.

So please, just post your findings! I mean, really?
 
Ziggi, I don't post here for the regulars as it is pretty clear that they are shills who cannot admit that the buildings came down via controlled demolition no matter how much evidence is put before them.

I only come on here occasionally for the benefit of any possible lurkers who come here and might not know many of the details and be on the fence.

Yes Tony, this used to be the reason any truther could justify spending some time on the old JREF forum, but the neutral audience is no longer there. It had been getting really thin for years and JREF totally killed it when it got rid of the forum.

If JREF had thought the forum could serve to make sure people on the fence would end up supporting the official story it would have kept the forum and proudly advertized Chris Mohr, JayUtah and buddies.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom