WTC Dust Study Feb 29, 2012 by Dr. James Millette

The whole point is that Millette found different types of chips, using the same isolation method stated on page 9 of the Bentham paper.

BINGO! But, Harrit´s paper examines only one type of those chips, as characterized by the XEDS, resistivity, MEK, and ignition tests.

This type of chip does not soften in MEK(unlike paints), and does not have titanium, two clues Millette ignored. Another big clue is that the MEK leaves this kind of chip with aluminum. And it ignites, making reduced spheres.

The question Millette and others have to answer is if Harrit et al(and Basile) are correct when they say a thermite reaction made those spheres?
- And publish the result.
 
i would say they "look" compositonally similar according to edx. not chemically b/c millette never got any iron and silicon microspheres. no dsc to look at the curves.
Would dog crap be the same thing if it produced iron and silicon microspheres (hate to tell you, it could)?

DSC can't tell you what something is made of. Sorry.
 
Lol

The truther desperation in this thread is so funny.

Two faceless truthers making it up as they go along :D

Two chemically identical chips are not the same LMFAO
 
exactly!! you have done it by jolly!!!! we know henryco's did not react. therefore millette needs to see if his is the same as jones or henryco's. heat it up to produce or not produce iron and silicon rich microspheres!!!
But... then he would have to select the burning in DSC as a selection criterion, completely ditching EDX analysis! Is that what you want done? Why don't you ask Jones et al. to do that to one half and when they find a match, analyze the other half by competent methods, as they should have done in the first place? Aren't you applying double standards here?
 
Last edited:
BINGO! But, Harrit´s paper examines only one type of those chips, as characterized by the XEDS, resistivity, MEK, and ignition tests.

Show me in the paper where they say anything close to examining "one type of many red/gray that were attracted to a magnet".

Support your claim. I can show you that you are totally incorrect.
 
BINGO! But, Harrit´s paper examines only one type of those chips, as characterized by the XEDS, resistivity, MEK, and ignition tests.

This type of chip does not soften in MEK(unlike paints), and does not have titanium, two clues Millette ignored. Another big clue is that the MEK leaves this kind of chip with aluminum. And it ignites, making reduced spheres.

The question Millette and others have to answer is if Harrit et al(and Basile) are correct when they say a thermite reaction made those spheres?
- And publish the result.

Let me help you jtl.

Here is an excerpt from the Bentham paper. Page 10. Pay particular attention to the red text. They state in that red text how ALL CHIPS IN THE STUDY were selected. Your move...

1. Characterization of the Red/Gray Chips

Red/gray chips were found in all of the dust samples collected. An analysis of the chips was performed to assess the
similarity of the chips and to determine the chemistry and
materials that make up the chips. Fig. (2) displays photomicrographs of red/gray chips from each of the four WTC dust
samples. Note the scale marker in each image as they were
acquired at different magnifications. At approximately
2.5 mm in length, the chip in Fig. (2a) was one of the larger
chips collected. The mass of this chip was approximately 0.7
mg. All of the chips used in the study had a gray layer and a
red layer and were attracted by a magnet.
The inset image in
Fig. (2d) shows the chip in cross section, which reveals the
gray layer. The gray layer is also partially visible in Fig.
(2b). Similarities between the samples are already evident
from these photographs.
 
The red/gray chips are attracted by a magnet, which facilitates collection and separation of the chips from the bulk of the dust. A small permanent magnet in its own plastic bag was used to attract and collect the chips from dust samples. The chips are typically small but readily discernible by eye due to their distinctive color.

With the red/gray chips and iron-rich spheres, we were "lucky" in that these were attracted by a strong magnet, and I was able to concentrate them fairly easily.

Does anyone want to have ago at translating the above two quotes into truther :D

Oops my mistake, they already are
 
Last edited:
Senenmut back onto ignore. I just can't take the ignorance anymore. It's like trying to explain calculus to a 6 month old baby. The baby has no concept of numbers so it's impossible to teach it anything advanced. At least the baby will grow up and learn. Senenmut refuses to learn.

Harrit et al came out in April 2009 - 4 years later and Senenmut still hasn't learnt any chemistry.

Well, not too many bridges have chem labs under them.
 
Lol

The truther desperation in this thread is so funny.

Two faceless truthers making it up as they go along :D

Two chemically identical chips are not the same LMFAO

They may be chemically identical in their accidents but when a high priest of trutherdom says the words "This is thermite" the chips are transubstantiated into the essence of thermite.
 
Dr.Millette has found nothing he wasn't looking for. Nothing he had 'not found' before in all other Government DUST studies he was involved in. Why would anyone expect anything different? The iron-rich spheres were 6% by mass of the DUST clouds as disclosed by Ritchie LEE.

Sorry, but you are plain wrong!

Can someone with greater knowledge of chemistry help me out here? Is burning a substance a common part of identifying the composition of that substance? More importantly, is it possible to tell whether two substances have the same composition without burning them?

In former times, the formula of organic compounds was determined by burning them, collecting and weighing the combustion products and calculating the (empiric) formula afterwards. But you don't have to burn a substance to proof it's thermite, just identify the necessary ingredients of thermite (ferric oxide and aluminum) and the job is done.

ETA: Every chemist can tell you without problems, if two substances are the same, as he can use competent methods as NMR and FTIR spectrocopy and mass spectrometry. No burning of the substances is necessary.

i ask hard questions...its best just to ignore.

tell us why henryco's chip did not ignite (all the way up to 900C) or turn from red to pinkish post reaction to form silcon and iron rich microspheres?

Because his chips were identical to Harrit's chips and Harrit's chips are not thermitic. :D
 
Last edited:
Gamolon: Let me help you jtl.

JHC, you really don´t get it, do you?

There are now two different groups of you guys, one group says there is only one kind of chip attracted by magnet, but the other says there are many different kinds.

Both of you cannot be right

Edited by LashL: 
Edited for civility.


Let me make this really simple for you. Even if we assume that all the data about the chips in the paper is not relevant to the chips, and that you are right about all the chips attracted by a magnet being the same, that still leaves a huge problem for you and all your buddies, because then Sunstealer is wrong about not knowing what kind of chips they ignited in the DSC, and there would be no possibility for yet another version of Ivan´s debunked MEK handwave, which claims that the MEK chip was not the same as chips a to d.

Edited by LashL: 
Removed breach of Rule 0 and Rule 10.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
There are now two different groups of you guys, one group says there is only one kind of chip attracted by magnet, but the other says there are many different kinds.

You're lacking reading comprehension as this is totally wrong.
 
There are now two different groups of you guys, one group says there is only one kind of chip attracted by magnet, but the other says there are many different kinds.

Let me make this really simple for you. Even if we assume that all the data about the chips in the paper is not relevant to the chips, and that you are right about all the chips attracted by a magnet being the same, that still leaves a huge problem for you and all your buddies, because then Sunstealer is wrong about not knowing what kind of chips they ignited in the DSC, and there would be no possibility for yet another version of Ivan´s debunked MEK handwave, which claims that the MEK chip was not the same as chips a to d.
As I understand it, everyone is basically on the same page. Careful reading of the Bentham paper shows Harrit et al treated all the red / grey chips as the same. Everything they say reveals this assumption. The quotes have been posted so many times that I have no need to do so. That is the original paper. Thus, one criticism of the original paper is that it is flawed if it turns out there are different kinds of these chips.

In reality, there are multiple kinds of magnetic red / grey chips in the dust (even the Bentham paper's data establishes this). Millette chose to study chips matching Harrit et al's a-d because the most data was available for those, allowing the possibility of finding a match. He did find chips that match those. Millette's chips are the same as a-d, confirmed by multiple methods. That is where the insistence on sameness comes in.

And where do Harrit et al identify the composition of the DSC tested chips? Do they, or do they just assume they were the same as a-d without checking? Do we also not have sufficient data to show the MEK chip does not match a-d?
 
Lol

The truther desperation in this thread is so funny.

Two faceless truthers making it up as they go along :D

Two chemically identical chips are not the same LMFAO
It's not just that. Millette's analysed chips show an identical crystal structure of the particles contained in the chips.

Both show rhomboidal iron oxide and hexagonal aluminosilicate particles embedded in the same carbon matrix adhered to oxidised steel.

The characteristics of the chips are the same. It's ludicrous to suggest that they are somehow different. Truthers who support the Harrit et al paper steadfastly refuse to acknowledge such similarity.

I have shown, very simply, by putting two SEM BSE images side by side that this is the case. It's notable that no truther on JREF will even attempt to show any discrepancy between those two images. They simply won't dare, instead they hang their hats on a nondescript product of a reaction whilst ignoring the other expected reaction product, namely alumina.
 
? right over your head. henryco's did not produce iron and silicon rich microspheres and harrit's did.

henryco confirmed the composition of the chips and says that this composition is compatible with the nanothermite chips.

BTW you do not identify a compound/composit by its reactions, but by determining the chemical composition of the compound/composit. That's the way a chemist works.
 
henryco confirmed the composition of the chips and says that this composition is compatible with the nanothermite chips.
well, im glad you call jones' chips the nanothermite chips!


BTW you do not identify a compound/composit by its reactions, but by determining the chemical composition of the compound/composit. That's the way a chemist works.
so if he confirmed the composition that is compatible with the nanothermite chips and it did NOT react even when heated to 900C. what do you think about that?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom