My aluminum foil can make a Drano bomb. Can your "aluminum foil" do that? If you really believe that, why haven't you done it yet?
Look, we've all seen aluminum foil make Drano bombs. You say you have aluminum foil -- and you say that you've demonstrated that it is aluminum foil using specific analytical techniques that you've documented. But I don't want to talk about those. I can't say exactly why, really, but it harshes my buzz. Please, in the interest of Truth, let's not discuss any of the evidence that your aluminum foil is, in fact, aluminum foil. Na-na-na-na-I'm not lis-tening!
No, the real question is, if you really think that you have aluminum foil, why didn't you make a Drano bomb?!? FFS, haven't you ever heard of reproducibility?!?
Granted, the actual facts are even more damning to your argument than this analogy is. But so far, the analogy seems to be more than damning enough.