WTC Dust Study Feb 29, 2012 by Dr. James Millette

My aluminum foil can make a Drano bomb. Can your "aluminum foil" do that? If you really believe that, why haven't you done it yet?

Look, we've all seen aluminum foil make Drano bombs. You say you have aluminum foil -- and you say that you've demonstrated that it is aluminum foil using specific analytical techniques that you've documented. But I don't want to talk about those. I can't say exactly why, really, but it harshes my buzz. Please, in the interest of Truth, let's not discuss any of the evidence that your aluminum foil is, in fact, aluminum foil. Na-na-na-na-I'm not lis-tening!

No, the real question is, if you really think that you have aluminum foil, why didn't you make a Drano bomb?!? FFS, haven't you ever heard of reproducibility?!?

Granted, the actual facts are even more damning to your argument than this analogy is. But so far, the analogy seems to be more than damning enough.
:rolleyes:
 
What are you talking about? What differences does it make. Aren't those goal post starting to get heavy? You do know electronic (charged) distribution of paint has been around for a long, long time (not that it matters)

it has not been around for a long long time.
 
Sunstealer: If a truther believes that chip a = chip b = chip c = chip d, then they must conclude that Millette's chips are the same. No truther at JREF will admit that the EDX of chips a-d are the same even though they support the Harrit et al paper fully and the paper concludes a-d are the same material. It's a false dichotomy.

Incidentally we have absolutely no idea which chips Farrer put in the DSC. We have no idea if he put chips a, b, c, d or a chip like the MEK chip or the chip in fig 31. No-one has any idea. So to ask for Millette to do the same test is meaningless because we have no idea what to compare it to.

For example;

It may only be chips containing epoxy such as chips a-d that produce microspheres. (possibly Laclade)

It may only be chips that contain alkyd resin as in Tnemec primer paint eg the MEK chip, that produces microspheres.
It may only be completely different red/gray chips.
There isn't anyway to tell, so it's a pointless exercise to repeat the test as there is nothing to compare the result with except some unknown.

Don´t you guys have any self respect?

On one hand, all you guys angrily claim that absolutely ALL red chips collected with a magnet are the same, so Millette MUST have the same chips!

- Never mind that Millette´s chips have titanium and some other chemical differences, and behave differently in the MEK. Forget about the different FTIR´s from Millette and Ryan. Shut up, they are the same, you say, they were collected with a magnet and they are red!

On the other hand, when it comes to the ignition tests that you are all evidently scared ******** of, you claim that there are SO MANY DIFFERENT kinds of red chips, that it is impossible to know which ones Harrit et al ignited.

According to Sunstealer, it could Tnemec chips that ignite and make the spheres, and it could be LaClede chips, or even some other unknown red chips material that was collected with a magnet, but poor Sunstealer just doesn´t know because gosh darn it, there are just so many different kinds of chips!:eye-poppi

JHC! The comedy, the comedy!

At least Sunstealer has made a couple of things clear with his rant:

1. Many different kinds of red chips are collected with a magnet

- Sunstealer has explained it so clearly that anyone that claims from now on
that all the red chips are the same must be a moron!

2. at least one of those kinds ignites and makes reduced iron spheres

Harrit et al published a paper that says that thermite-reaction made those spheres, and until someone publishes another paper with a better explanation, Harrit´s conclusion is the only one.

Edited by LashL: 
Edited to properly mask profanity. Please see Rule 10 re: the auto-censor.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Harrit et al published a paper that says that thermite-reaction made those spheres, and until someone publishes another paper with a better explanation, Harrit´s conclusion is the only one.

I thought you said you were only going to lurk until some evidence was presented? Did you miss us or are we the only ones paying attention?

You need us to sustain your belief. ;) (and we only do it for giggles)
 
Can anyone post up links from Jones & Co where they directly state that Millette had the wrong chips because he did not do DSC ?

Thanks
 
At least Sunstealer has made a couple of things clear with his rant:

1. Many different kinds of red chips are collected with a magnet


That's the point! The Bentham paper they published concludes that ALL the red/gray chips that were attracted by a magnet are thermitic. There is no other conclusion that can be reached by reading their paper. Which leads to the statement made by pgimeno below:

The authors of the Bentham paper just show cherry-picked results for unknown chips that match their preconceived idea. It's like... "let's choose a chip that has aluminium, iron and oxygen; now let's choose a chip that produces iron when it burns; now let's choose a chip that produce alumina when it burns... oops, no success with that, let's skip over that... now let's choose a chip that shows a resistivity much more different than that of paints... now let's choose a chip that..."

Now that Harrit and his group got caught with their pants down by incorrectly assuming all the red/gray chips they isolated using a magnet were thermitic, they have to cling to the resistivity test garbage as the only saving grace to why Millette's results were different, even though he used the same exact isolation method they spelled out on page 9 of their paper.

The bottom line is that the Bentham paper reads that no matter which red/gray chip you select out of the isolation pile, the results will be the same as reported in said paper no matter which test you perform on that randomly selected chip.
 
Wrong.

I'll keep saying this until you get it.

According to their Bentham paper, all the red/gray chips extracted out of the dust piles using a magnet will produce the same results as stated in the paper, regardless of which chip you select out of that isolated pile.

That is a fact according to their paper.

and ill say it again. what if all jones and crew chips did produce the same results. did henryco's chip produce the same result?

i have already stated all millette had to do was cut one in half and heat it to the ignition point to produce or NOT produce iron and silicon microspheres.

whats the big deal. way the pushback for such a simple test?
 
and ill say it again. what if all jones and crew chips did produce the same results. did henryco's chip produce the same result?

i have already stated all millette had to do was cut one in half and heat it to the ignition point to produce or NOT produce iron and silicon microspheres.

whats the big deal. way the pushback for such a simple test?

Because according to their Bentham paper, every single chip isolated by attraction to a magnet and having a red/gray layer will have the same results as those tested in the paper. According to them, it doesn't matter which damn chip you choose out of that isolated pile. As long as I isolated the red/gray chips with a magnet and set them aside, I could blindfold myself, pick a chip out of that pile, heat it up, and I should get microsphere's. I could then randomly select another chip from that isolated pile and run a resisitivity test on it and show that it's not paint. Take you pick of tests. Any damn chip you choose should have the same results as Harrit and his group found.

Do you understand yet?

There shouldn't be different kinds of red/gray chips that are attracted to a magnet according to Harrit and his paper. That's why I keep telling you to read the paper and find me one sentence that shows they found anything other then unreacted thermite in their isolated chips.

The whole point is that Millette found different types of chips, using the same isolation method stated on page 9 of the Bentham paper.
 
i ask hard questions...its best just to ignore.

tell us why henryco's chip did not ignite (all the way up to 900C) or turn from red to pinkish post reaction to form silcon and iron rich microspheres?

Harrit and his paper concludes that all the red/gray chips they isolated (per being attracted to a magnet and having red/gray layers) were thermtic.

ALL OF THEM. EVERY SINGLE ONE.

henryco and Millette show this conclusion incorrect.
 
Because according to their Bentham paper, every single chip isolated by attraction to a magnet and having a red/gray layer will have the same results as those tested in the paper. According to them, it doesn't matter which damn chip you choose out of that isolated pile. As long as I isolated the red/gray chips with a magnet and set them aside, I could blindfold myself, pick a chip out of that pile, heat it up, and I should get microsphere's. I could then randomly select another chip from that isolated pile and run a resisitivity test on it and show that it's not paint. Take you pick of tests. Any damn chip you choose should have the same results as Harrit and his group found.

Do you understand yet?
yes i do understand that jones and crew's red/gray chips should react.

There shouldn't be different kinds of red/gray chips that are attracted to a magnet according to Harrit and his paper. That's why I keep telling you to read the paper and find me one sentence that shows they found anything other then unreacted thermite in their isolated chips.
maybe there arent any different kinds in jones' sample.

The whole point is that Millette found different types of chips, using the same isolation method stated on page 9 of the Bentham paper.

BINGO
 
Harrit and his paper concludes that all the red/gray chips they isolated (per being attracted to a magnet and having red/gray layers) were thermtic.

ALL OF THEM. EVERY SINGLE ONE.

henryco and Millette show this conclusion incorrect.

exactly!! you have done it by jolly!!!! we know henryco's did not react. therefore millette needs to see if his is the same as jones or henryco's. heat it up to produce or not produce iron and silicon rich microspheres!!!

which one do you think it is?

i think you are the smartest debunker on the whole forum:D
 
So how long is a long time


The first commercial anodic automotive system began operations in 1963.
The first patent for a cathodic EPD product was issued in 1965 and assigned to BASF AG. PPG Industries, Inc. was the first to introduce commercially cathodic EPD in 1970.

considering i was born in the 70's, i would like to think that is not along time ago!:)

ivan speculates it was the anodic version used...
 
Last edited:
The first commercial anodic automotive system began operations in 1963.
The first patent for a cathodic EPD product was issued in 1965 and assigned to BASF AG. PPG Industries, Inc. was the first to introduce commercially cathodic EPD in 1970.

considering i was born in the 70's, i would like to think that is not along time ago!:)

ivan speculates it was the anodic version used...
How heavy are those goal posts?
 
How do you explain the fact they are chemically identical?

i would say they "look" compositonally similar according to edx. not chemically b/c millette never got any iron and silicon microspheres. no dsc to look at the curves.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom