first ya need to find out if you have the same chips.....ignite some of them, see if they produce iron and silicon rich microspheres.
Millette followed Jones'
isolation procedure. He showed that chips isolated this way are not thermitic. If you want to claim he did not have the same chips, blame on Jones that he didn't publish proper isolation procedures.
Same goes for MM's claim of resistivity as a criterion for selection, which obviously was performed on an entirely different kind of chip and it's not listed in the isolation procedure. Your MO and that of MM are basically the same: both of you are claiming that a test performed on who knows what, in a separate part of the paper, should serve as an isolation procedure. It's just a straw you both grasp. Millette picked chips a-d because they are the only chips properly characterized and cleaned, knowing perfectly well that
all many other
kinds of chips would be selected by the isolation procedure listed in the paper alone. There are no other kinds of chips properly characterized in the paper, so Millette can't replicate any other experiment, but he wasn't commissioned to do that anyway.
Thing is: on that dust there can be all kinds of chips. They didn't know or consider that at the time. The claim that Millette's chips are different, however, acknowledges that fact. The chips tested in DSC don't necessarily match chips a-d; no one knows what they tested in DSC because they don't say. The chip tested for resistivity doesn't necessarily match chips a-d; no one knows what they tested for resistivity because they don't say. Millette selected chips matching chips a-d and showed conclusively that they are paint. Are there any other chips that are thermitic? We don't know (well, some of us actually have strong reasons to think there aren't), but chips a-d certainly aren't, as per Millette's analysis.
The authors of the Bentham paper just show cherry-picked results for unknown chips that match their preconceived idea. It's like... "let's choose a chip that has aluminium, iron and oxygen; now let's choose a chip that produces iron when it burns; now let's choose a chip that produce alumina when it burns... oops, no success with that, let's skip over that... now let's choose a chip that shows a resistivity much more different than that of paints... now let's choose a chip that..."
Do you have a way to discard that, based on the data in the paper? Any serious classification and identification of chips prior to each analysis, per chance?
The remote possibility that it's unintentional would make their work sloppy at best. I don't believe that to be the case. Your claims and MM's are based on your belief that the chips in the paper are all the same thing. That assertion doesn't hold water based on the paper's contents.