WTC Dust Study Feb 29, 2012 by Dr. James Millette

i think he needs to take it to the next level and make his produce iron and silicon rich microspheres.

Why? Is the scientific world asking for this or only a handful of believers on the internet.

Why don't you explain why anyone needs to make this effort.
 
Wouldn't them being chemically identical do the same thing.
Yep, and this is the crux of it. Millette specifically used all of the data on chips a-d in Harrit et al as a criteria for ensuring he had the same chips.

If a truther believes that chip a = chip b = chip c = chip d, then they must conclude that Millette's chips are the same. No truther at JREF will admit that the EDX of chips a-d are the same even though they support the Harrit et al paper fully and the paper concludes a-d are the same material. It's a false dichotomy.

Incidentally we have absolutely no idea which chips Farrer put in the DSC. We have no idea if he put chips a, b, c, d or a chip like the MEK chip or the chip in fig 31. No-one has any idea. So to ask for Millette to do the same test is meaningless because we have no idea what to compare it to.

For example;

It may only be chips containing epoxy such as chips a-d that produce microspheres. (possibly Laclade)

It may only be chips that contain alkyd resin as in Tnemec primer paint eg the MEK chip, that produces microspheres.

It may only be completely different red/gray chips.

There isn't anyway to tell, so it's a pointless exercise to repeat the test as there is nothing to compare the result with except some unknown.

Senenmut clings desperately to the idea and ignores every single other piece of data. He's simply trolling now.
 
Why? Is the scientific world asking for this or only a handful of believers on the internet.

Why don't you explain why anyone needs to make this effort.

ive offered the man cash money to redo the muffle furnace test that goes up to 450C per astm standards. his paper even states he followed astm standards. do you think he will do it?
 
ive offered the man cash money to redo the muffle furnace test that goes up to 450C per astm standards. his paper even states he followed astm standards. do you think he will do it?
Why? He found chips that were chemically identical. If my kid emptied my vodka and replaced it with water and I identified it a chemically identical to water. I wouldn't have to drink the whole bottle to see if I got drunk to figure out what happened.
 
Last edited:
Yep, and this is the crux of it. Millette specifically used all of the data on chips a-d in Harrit et al as a criteria for ensuring he had the same chips.

If a truther believes that chip a = chip b = chip c = chip d, then they must conclude that Millette's chips are the same. No truther at JREF will admit that the EDX of chips a-d are the same even though they support the Harrit et al paper fully and the paper concludes a-d are the same material. It's a false dichotomy.
just like the aluminum foil vs tin foil making the bomb....both foils my look alike and exhibit same properties but they will not react alike.

Incidentally we have absolutely no idea which chips Farrer put in the DSC. We have no idea if he put chips a, b, c, d or a chip like the MEK chip or the chip in fig 31. No-one has any idea. So to ask for Millette to do the same test is meaningless because we have no idea what to compare it to.

For example;

It may only be chips containing epoxy such as chips a-d that produce microspheres. (possibly Laclade)
millettes gotta produce or not produce some iron and silicon rich microspheres. PERIOD

It may only be chips that contain alkyd resin as in Tnemec primer paint eg the MEK chip, that produces microspheres.
jtl has brought up the MEK chip and shown it not to be Tnemec.

It may only be completely different red/gray chips.
bingo!!! reverse engineered to "appear" like jones' to do exactly what we are doing now...... debating something that is pretty meaningless until millette steps up to the plate to produce or not produce iron and silicon rich microspheres!! think of henryco's chips. stayed red all the way to 900C. didnt react or turn pinkish or produce any iron or silicon rich microspheres. hummmmm......

There isn't anyway to tell, so it's a pointless exercise to repeat the test as there is nothing to compare the result with except some unknown.
the unknown in jones' case produces iron and silicon rich microspheres. did millettes unknown do that? money buys experiments. it shouldnt take millette any time to crank that muffle furnace up another 50C and follow ASTM standards and give us that. he should do it for free since he did not follow astm standards for the muffle furnace test.

Senenmut clings desperately to the idea and ignores every single other piece of data. He's simply trolling now.
when he heats his chips up to produce the micropheres, then we can talk about the evidence and what millette says about why his chips created or didnt create the speheres.
 
no, its a sign we need to right chips to even start a converstion.

How did Millette get the wrong chips? He did exactly what is stated in the Bentham paper for chip selection/separation on page 9.

2. Chip Size, Isolation, and Examination

For clarification, the dust samples collected and sent to
the authors by Ms. Janette MacKinlay will be sample 1; the
sample collected by Mr. Frank Delassio, or the Delassio/Breidenbach sample, will be sample 2; the sample collected by Mr. Jody Intermont will be sample 3; and the sample collected by Mr. Stephen White will be sample 4. The
red/gray chips are attracted by a magnet, which facilitates
collection and separation of the chips from the bulk of the
dust. A small permanent magnet in its own plastic bag was
used to attract and collect the chips from dust samples. The
chips are typically small but readily discernible by eye due to
their distinctive color. They are of variable size with major
dimensions of roughly 0.2 to 3 mm. Thicknesses vary from
roughly 10 to 100 microns for each layer (red and gray).
Samples of WTC dust from these and other collectors have
been sent directly from collectors to various scientists (including some not on this research team) who have also found
such red/gray chips in the dust from the World Trade Center
destruction.

According to their paper, every single red/gray chip isolated using the above criteria was thermitic.
 
How did Millette get the wrong chips? He did exactly what is stated in the Bentham paper for chip selection/separation on page 9.
he sure stayed away from heating them up to ignition temp;)


According to their paper, every single red/gray chip isolated using the above criteria was thermitic.
and what if they are...in jones and crew samples.
 
You might want to add they are also not chemically identical. Did you forget to mention that? :rolleyes:

yes i do know that.....what may "look" alike may not be the same thing. thats the whole point.
 
you havent even proved that the compnay used electrophoretic deposition to coat the metal to begin with. ive emailed them too. no response.

Aha:cool: So you, Doubting Thomas, even do not really believe that WTC floor trusses were painted with the red primer;) Who cares about the photographs, data in NIST reports and all the evidence?

On the other hand, the planting of very evil nanothermite on WTC steel with is a proven fact for you! Cool:D
 
Last edited:
and what if they are...in jones and crew samples.

There is no "what if". The paper clearly states that all the chips isolated using a magnet and the visual "red/gray layer" criteria are thermitic.

You also didn't answer my question.

How did Millette get the wrong chips if he followed the isolation method printed on page 9 of the Bentham paper?

From page 10. Pay particular attention to the bolded/red section below.

1. Characterization of the Red/Gray Chips

Red/gray chips were found in all of the dust samples collected. An analysis of the chips was performed to assess the
similarity of the chips and to determine the chemistry and
materials that make up the chips. Fig. (2) displays photomicrographs of red/gray chips from each of the four WTC dust
samples. Note the scale marker in each image as they were
acquired at different magnifications. At approximately
2.5 mm in length, the chip in Fig. (2a) was one of the larger
chips collected. The mass of this chip was approximately 0.7
mg. All of the chips used in the study had a gray layer and a
red layer and were attracted by a magnet.
The inset image in
Fig. (2d) shows the chip in cross section, which reveals the
gray layer. The gray layer is also partially visible in Fig.
(2b). Similarities between the samples are already evident
from these photographs.

On page 29, in their conclusion:

Based on these observations, we conclude that the red
layer of the red/gray chips we have discovered in the WTC
dust is active
, unreacted thermitic material, incorporating
nanotechnology, and is a highly energetic pyrotechnic or
explosive material.

I dare you or anyone else to find any section in the Bentham paper that says they found ANYTHING other then unreacted thermite among the red/gray, "attracted to a magnet" chips they isolated.
 
The concept of "chemically identical" seems to be escaping him.

the composition might "look" similar but the chemical properties might be different. get millette to produce iron and silicon microspheres then we can talk about "chemically identical."
 
first ya need to find out if you have the same chips.....ignite some of them, see if they produce iron and silicon rich microspheres.
Millette followed Jones' isolation procedure. He showed that chips isolated this way are not thermitic. If you want to claim he did not have the same chips, blame on Jones that he didn't publish proper isolation procedures.

Same goes for MM's claim of resistivity as a criterion for selection, which obviously was performed on an entirely different kind of chip and it's not listed in the isolation procedure. Your MO and that of MM are basically the same: both of you are claiming that a test performed on who knows what, in a separate part of the paper, should serve as an isolation procedure. It's just a straw you both grasp. Millette picked chips a-d because they are the only chips properly characterized and cleaned, knowing perfectly well that all many other kinds of chips would be selected by the isolation procedure listed in the paper alone. There are no other kinds of chips properly characterized in the paper, so Millette can't replicate any other experiment, but he wasn't commissioned to do that anyway.

Thing is: on that dust there can be all kinds of chips. They didn't know or consider that at the time. The claim that Millette's chips are different, however, acknowledges that fact. The chips tested in DSC don't necessarily match chips a-d; no one knows what they tested in DSC because they don't say. The chip tested for resistivity doesn't necessarily match chips a-d; no one knows what they tested for resistivity because they don't say. Millette selected chips matching chips a-d and showed conclusively that they are paint. Are there any other chips that are thermitic? We don't know (well, some of us actually have strong reasons to think there aren't), but chips a-d certainly aren't, as per Millette's analysis.

The authors of the Bentham paper just show cherry-picked results for unknown chips that match their preconceived idea. It's like... "let's choose a chip that has aluminium, iron and oxygen; now let's choose a chip that produces iron when it burns; now let's choose a chip that produce alumina when it burns... oops, no success with that, let's skip over that... now let's choose a chip that shows a resistivity much more different than that of paints... now let's choose a chip that..."

Do you have a way to discard that, based on the data in the paper? Any serious classification and identification of chips prior to each analysis, per chance?

The remote possibility that it's unintentional would make their work sloppy at best. I don't believe that to be the case. Your claims and MM's are based on your belief that the chips in the paper are all the same thing. That assertion doesn't hold water based on the paper's contents.
 
Last edited:
he sure stayed away from heating them up to ignition temp;)

So?

According to the Bentham paper, it didn't matter which of the chips they isolated according to their criteria on page 9.

All of the chips isolated as above were stereo-typed as being unreacted thermite by testing only a few specimens.
 
jones chips can. can millettes? why do you think millettes can?

My aluminum foil can make a Drano bomb. Can your "aluminum foil" do that? If you really believe that, why haven't you done it yet?

Look, we've all seen aluminum foil make Drano bombs. You say you have aluminum foil -- and you say that you've demonstrated that it is aluminum foil using specific analytical techniques that you've documented. But I don't want to talk about those. I can't say exactly why, really, but it harshes my buzz. Please, in the interest of Truth, let's not discuss any of the evidence that your aluminum foil is, in fact, aluminum foil. Na-na-na-na-I'm not lis-tening!

No, the real question is, if you really think that you have aluminum foil, why didn't you make a Drano bomb?!? FFS, haven't you ever heard of reproducibility?!?

Granted, the actual facts are even more damning to your argument than this analogy is. But so far, the analogy seems to be more than damning enough.
 
the composition might "look" similar but the chemical properties might be different. get millette to produce iron and silicon microspheres then we can talk about "chemically identical."

Wrong.

I'll keep saying this until you get it.

According to their Bentham paper, all the red/gray chips extracted out of the dust piles using a magnet will produce the same results as stated in the paper, regardless of which chip you select out of that isolated pile.

That is a fact according to their paper.
 
Aha:cool: So you, Doubting Thomas, even do not really believe that WTC floor trusses were painted with the red primer;) Who cares about the photographs, data in NIST reports and all the evidence?

On the other hand, the planting of very evil nanothermite on WTC steel with is a proven fact for you! Cool:D

electroplalting was way early in its develpment. so did they paint or electrocoat the steel? did the company say that is what they did. how did you create your epoxy paint chips?
 
electroplalting was way early in its develpment. so did they paint or electrocoat the steel? did the company say that is what they did. how did you create your epoxy paint chips?
What are you talking about? What differences does it make. Aren't those goal post starting to get heavy? You do know electronic (charged) distribution of paint has been around for a long, long time (not that it matters)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom