World Hunger

The world has so many people that we have no idea what to do with them.


I notice primarily the interesting distinction between ”we” and ”people” (or ”them”).

I guess the total failure of Marxism as a economic system sort of passed dann by.....


And what do the two articles criticizing the capitalist economic system have to do with "Marxism as a economic system"???
 
Because they both advocate Marxism as a "solution". They all say that to make a profit is evil. That is Marxism at it's purest.
Funny,how all the "criticisms" of Capitalism you post are from Hard Line Marxist websites. We are not talking Social Democratic or milder forms of Socialism but good old fashioned "The State should control everything" Soviet/Maoist style Marxism.
And I think the two sigs dann have should remove all doubt of where he is coming from.
 
Giving them food is a temporary solution and a terrible one at that. If they are given food, they will be healthy enough to mate and produce more people. These people will also have no means of getting food for themselves and will also be starving, which will require more food to be sent.


The language used in this post, with words like 'them' and 'these people', it's getting pretty close to saying 'undermenschen' isn't it?


The world has so many people that we have no idea what to do with them.
So personally I'm all for a nice drop in the world population and then a worldwide population policy.


And the sentiment expressed here reinforces my fears about where this is leading.


Yes, I know, I'm wasting my time by responding to this. Few listened in the 1930s either, until it was too late. I won't be posting any more in this thread.
 
Seismosaurus said:
But I personally have every right to spend the money I earned on myself. I bought myself a £400 iPhone recently, and I did it purely because I like gadgets and I wanted to own this one. And I did it with an entirely clear conscience.
__________________
"Any man's death diminishes me, because I am involved in mankind, and therefore never send to know for whom the bell tolls; it tolls for thee." - John Donne


Don't you see some contradiction between your quoted post and your signature?
 
What do you think about dedicating your life to the alleviate the suffering of others, like Mother Theresa allegedly did. (I know that many people don't agree that she actually did any good, and I do not want to discuss that. It seems that some people really do what she did allegedly, and the question is if that is the highest virtue).
 
Because they both advocate Marxism as a "solution".

They do? Where exactly do they "advocate" this alleged "solution"?

They all say that to make a profit is evil.

They do? Where exactly do they call profit "evil", dudalb?

That is Marxism at it's purest.

If they did what you accuse them of, it would me Marxism at its most stupid, not purest, so it's a good thing that they don't.

Funny,how all the "criticisms" of Capitalism you post are from Hard Line Marxist websites.

Why is that "funny", dudalb?

We are not talking Social Democratic or milder forms of Socialism but good old fashioned "The State should control everything" Soviet/Maoist style Marxism.

We are???! "The State should control everything"?! Really??! And where exactly are "we" "talking" that, dudalb? I've been trying to find it, dudalb, and I just weren't able to ... anywhere, so I'm sure you won't mind pointing it out to me and the rest of us: The Democratic Sate

And I think the two sigs dann have should remove all doubt of where he is coming from.

Thank you, dudalb! You are soooo clever!!!
”If one tells the truth, one is sure, sooner or later, to be found out.”
So it's not really a question of what the articles say, as long as you think that you know where something comes from. Well, that says all you need to know about your attitude!
 
So your neighbour the P & O captain was attempting to dump unwanted wheat into somebody else's market without paying the local tax - and thereby (if he'd succeeded) destroying the livelihoods of local grain farmers?

How much import tax do you think a Bangladeshi ship loaded with rice would need to pay if it arrived at an American port - and let's say it wanted to give its rice away for free to the homeless there? (Or to Europe or Australia).

As for the cattle: Were they suitable and acclimatised for Indian conditions? Or was it another 'gift with strings'?


(Francesca, I will get back to you with evidence re West Africa. I've got my reports here somewhere, but it'll take me a wee while).

Do you think the wheat was just sent and not requested? at the time they were starving. As for the cattle, Queensland cattle thrive in a similar climate. Not all of India hold the cow sacred and I've forgotten where they were sent as India is big. There may have been strings, as we know that usually happens. The Captions name was Jan Sokalsai, PNO records would confirm.
 
Give a man a fish and he will eat for a day. Teach him how to fish, and he will sit in a boat and drink beer all day.

-George Carlin
 
As long as the manufacture and distribution of food involves making a profit, there will always be hunger.
Why? If people have an incentive to provide food to others, does that somehow guarantee a food shortage somewhere?

If you relied on goodwill (instead of self-interest) to feed populations, you'd have a famine pretty quickly.

Capitalism will always mean that some people will miss out. There is enough food to feed everyone in the world. There just isn't the will to do so.
In the current system, people gain from producing and distributing food; consequently, lots of people work very hard at it, and a lot of food is produced & distributed. Why do you think "There just isn't the will"? You seem to have contradicted yourself. What alternative do you think will do better?
 
Last edited:
If people's incentive to "provide food to others" is to sell it to them in order to make a buck, the incentive really isn't "to provide food to others" but to sell food to others, i.e. it guarantees that only people with the ability to pay are fed.
So some people gain a lot "from producing and distributing food", and consequently lots of people starve.
 
I notice primarily the interesting distinction between ”we” and ”people” (or ”them”).

The language used in this post, with words like 'them' and 'these people', it's getting pretty close to saying 'undermenschen' isn't it?

And the sentiment expressed here reinforces my fears about where this is leading.

Dear god. Fine. The world has so many people that people have no idea what to do with people. Happy? I like how you completely miss the point of my post and try to frame me as if I'm some sort of Nazi. Ridiculous. I'm not for genocide. I'm for sustainability. Massive worldwide population that continues to rise indefinitely makes sustainability impossible, and I believe causes numerous addition problems on a global scale.

You say whatever you want but worldwide population control will have to be taken seriously sooner or later and the later we do it the harder the problems they cause will be to overcome.

Insanity is when you do the same thing over and over and expect different results. Sending food to poor starving kids has worked very well in the past. That is why we don't have starving people anymore right?

[FONT=Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif]World hunger is increasing, with an estimated 842 million people going to bed hungry every night. Most people suffering from hunger live in Africa and Latin America, but 34 million are in the former Soviet Union and 10 million live in the rich industrialised countries.

This startling evidence of the growing division between rich and poor on a world scale appears in a recent report published by the United Nations Food and Agriculture Organisation (FAO).

Halving hunger was one of the UN Millennium Development Goals announced in 1992. The number of people experiencing hunger was supposed to be halved by 2015. Rather than decreasing as the FAO anticipated, the number of hungry people has increased by 4.5 million a year between 1995 and 1997 and from 1999 to 2001. Improved nutrition in some countries is being more than offset by a decline in others.
[/FONT]

Let's keep treating the symptom instead of the disease because that is a good long term solution...
 
Last edited:
If people's incentive to "provide food to others" is to sell it to them in order to make a buck, the incentive really isn't "to provide food to others" but to sell food to others, i.e. it guarantees that only people with the ability to pay are fed.
No; you are wrong. There is an incentive to provide food. The more a farmer can gain from selling food, the more likely they are to put in extra hours or find some other means of reallocating resources to increase their production.

Food doesn't fall from the sky to be divided up among the population. It's produced by real people. Real people respond to price incentives.

So some people gain a lot "from producing and distributing food", and consequently lots of people starve.
How do you feel that supports your point? Bizarre rhetoric about bourgeois manipulators and imperialists won't help, and this is an absurd and disgusting lie: "Above all, however, hunger is an “order problem” – say the responsible supervisors of the global misery."

Anyway, let's return to the real world. What would happen if incentives were removed or distorted? Appalling famines follow.
 
No; you are wrong. There is an incentive to provide food. The more a farmer can gain from selling food, the more likely they are to put in extra hours or find some other means of reallocating resources to increase their production.

What you fail to understand is that there is no shortage of food in the world! People don't starve because of a lack of the stuff. However, the 'incentive to provide food' to the people who can pay means that if you cannot pay, you starve! Maybe you just haven't noticed, but when a 'farmer puts in extra hours' in order to gain from selling food, providing it to starving people really does not work as an incentive to him. Instead they tend to destroy the stuff they cannot sell.
So much for your reallocated resources ...
Try googling "destruction of surplus food"! You'll notice that surplus food does not mean food that nobody wants to eat. It means food that nobody wants (or is able) to buy.
So much for your idealization of the market economy. In reality it just does not work the way it does in your fairy tale. Sometimes surplus food is even turned into dog food - but, of course, only if dog owners want to and are able to buy the stuff ...
Producers will be allowed to destroy their surplus stocks either by processing it into animal feed or biofuels, or by exporting it without export refunds.
http://www.foodnavigator.com/Financial-Industry/New-members-face-EU-fines-over-sugar-surplus
Sometimes it's dumped on markets in third-world countries, thus ruining the 'incentive' of local farmers ...

PS Maybe you haven't noticed, but in your fairy tale the nice house builders probably build houses because of the wonderful incentive to provide homes to people who want a place to live, right? Guess what happens when people cannot pay their mortgages.
If you don't know, go ask the homeless ...
http://www.gegenstandpunkt.com/english/poverty.html
 
Food doesn't fall from the sky to be divided up among the population. It's produced by real people. Real people respond to price incentives.

No, it doesn't fall from the sky. But it does grow on trees. And bushes, and out of the dirt. And various animals are running around all over. But then again it is pretty hard to convince people they need to spend large portions of their life working jobs if all the food and shelter isn't locked up so you have to pay for it. Yields for corn turn out to have a cost of about 2 cents per ear of corn.

dann is right. Farmers don't grow food to provide it for other people, and construction workers don't build homes to provide shelter for other people. It's all to make money. Businesses are not in business for the consumer, to benefit people or society. They are in business to make money, and to use that money to then make more money, in an endless cycle of pointlessness. Do people get things they want from business? Sure. If a construction company makes 3 billion net profits will they lower the price of the homes they make so more people can have somewhere to live? No. Why? It would provide shelter for people and the company would still make profits. But it won't make as much profits. And that is the bottom line. Screw everything else, the one and only real goal is to make the most profits. Everything else that is done is towards that goal. Price cuts, research and developement, these things are not done for the customer. They are done because it gets the company more profits. If they don't do it, their competitors will and they will lose business, and lose profits.

Business is arguably the most influential thing on the lives of the people. It is sad that something so powerful and influenctial has such a terribly poor goal of operation.
 
Profits provide the means to better one's own life - to start with, so as to not have to live on the random twigs and bugs found in one's own backyard during the growing season of your chosen habitat.

Oh, yes, we all know the history of those rolling fields of corn that existed across the world before mankind desolated the land with agriculture!
:rolleyes:

Jeez, just try growing 600 million bushels of corn without fertile land; high-production seed; fertilizers; herbicides and pesticides; planting, irrigation, and harvesting machinery; labor/wages for each production stage; and, of course, the initial capital to provide all that.

And don't forget about the costs of crop storage, protection, and preservation.

Oh, and processing for human consumption in various ways.

Oh, and distribution to all those hungry people who didn't grow their own.

And, oh, all those other costs I've left out ...
 
Oh, yes, we all know the history of those rolling fields of corn that existed across the world before mankind desolated the land with agriculture!
:rolleyes:
We do??! Well, that is certainly an interesting strawman ...

Don't forget that the exploited farm labourers primarily count as costs to a guy like balrog666 who seems to be complaining about the poor agricultural industrialists having to pay their workers at all, thus adding to their expenses!
Oh, the costs of it all!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom