World Hunger

JetLeg

Master Poster
Joined
Aug 29, 2007
Messages
2,414
If you were walking on the street, and a person was having medical problem that endangers his life ; if you were trained in medicine, would there be ___any___ excuse not to try and save his life?


I think not.


However, people and children die from hunger in the world, and I think that by donating money, we could save lives. Do you agree that it is the same situation?

I am not sure about the conclusion, but perhaps as long as people are dying in third world countries from hunger, and we can stop that, we have no right to pursue our own happiness but need to invest all that we do in helping them.

Do you agree?
 
No. Donating money can help, but it would depend on who takes the donations.
 
And a key part of this is what abilities are analogous to "trained in medicine"

It isn't just have money and time to fight hunger, it's knowing how to apply them usefully. Sending money through the right channels may help save lives, but sending it through the wrong agencies may instead fund
1) Mostly the agencies themselves
2) The corrupt government/rebel group that's creating these conditions in the first place
3) Dependence on aid, creating a society that can't feed it's children without constant injection of aid.
4) Agricultural experiments with good intentions but disastrous consequences.
5) All sorts of other unintentional harm.

If you can navigate all this and understand that your efforts will really be helping, then yes you should help. But keep in mind that the ability of someone with enough money to make a difference and an understanding of how to actually help instead of make the situation worse is somewhat rare, so you owe it to those you help to continue to make lots of money and to have an active social life to keep yourself emotionally stable to keep that high-paying job and remain useful.
 
UNICEF is set up to do exactly that. Have you donated to them lately, or do you think the UN is just the NWO in less letters? The point is that solving the food problem is trivial (at least now it is; the future is less sure); solving the transportation and distribution problem, without exacerbating graft, profiteering, incompetence and theft by irregular (and some regular) military forces is no set of simple problems, especially when nationalistic countries (both givers and takers) resist the sort of establishment it takes to overcome them.

Study the techniques of our latter-day robber-baron, Bill Gates, and his foundation. Send him an email asking him what you can do to help.
 
Last edited:
If you were walking on the street, and a person was having medical problem that endangers his life ; if you were trained in medicine, would there be ___any___ excuse not to try and save his life?


I think not.


However, people and children die from hunger in the world, and I think that by donating money, we could save lives. Do you agree that it is the same situation?

I am not sure about the conclusion, but perhaps as long as people are dying in third world countries from hunger, and we can stop that, we have no right to pursue our own happiness but need to invest all that we do in helping them.

Do you agree?
Your first para - yes you should not unless the problem is clear and the person agrees with witnesses for you to treat OR there is a law in place guaranteeing that no lawsuit can be made based on your treatment.

Won't work, but feel free to do that on your own - and ask why the countries involved are following that process.
 
As long as the manufacture and distribution of food involves making a profit, there will always be hunger.
 
As long as the manufacture and distribution of food involves making a profit, there will always be hunger.

I was about to say, we already have enough to feed everyone. If we have a NWO that rationally controlled food distribution in a completely totalitarian way, then world hunger would be solved.

Unfortunately, some see a problem with that.
 
However, people and children die from hunger in the world, and I think that by donating money, we could save lives. Do you agree that it is the same situation?

Yes!

And may I offer two comments:

Pleased to meet you. If you believe that to be the case, that would make three of us in existence that I know of who agree with it. If you know any others, bring 'em along.

The second point is that these threads are usually short-lived, because people do ultimately realise the answer is yes, but they get a bit embarrassed to admit it.

I am not sure about the conclusion, but perhaps as long as people are dying in third world countries from hunger, and we can stop that, we have no right to pursue our own happiness but need to invest all that we do in helping them.

Do you agree?

I'd change the wording a bit, because if we do things detrimental to our society in helping the less-fortunate, we'd ultimately end up hurting everyone. Also, pesky political problems tend to get in the way in places like Darfur, Zimbabwe and everywhere else, but your premise of "we ought to do more" is correct.

I'd also add in preventable disease and access to clean water rather than just hunger.

There are several standard arguments as to why your premise is wrong, and Cavemonster has summed them up pretty well:

1) Mostly the agencies themselves
2) The corrupt government/rebel group that's creating these conditions in the first place
3) Dependence on aid, creating a society that can't feed it's children without constant injection of aid.
4) Agricultural experiments with good intentions but disastrous consequences.
5) All sorts of other unintentional harm.

Which is a very complicated way of saying no, but works out the same.
 
If I encountered someone in distress, I would do what I could to help that person. If that person was malnourished, I would buy them some basic, healthy food, and put them in touch with the local food bank and help them secure some social aid. It's not so easy to help someone starving in India, though. Donations can help, but as has been mentioned, in some cases this can make things worse. There are ways to help, but you need to be careful.
 
Rather than donating money, a better option would be to campagin the various governments who buy surplus farm produce and dump it in the ocean
 
Rather than donating money, a better option would be to campagin the various governments who buy surplus farm produce and dump it in the ocean

Dump it in the ocean! Who does this?
 
Last edited:
And a key part of this is what abilities are analogous to "trained in medicine"

It isn't just have money and time to fight hunger, it's knowing how to apply them usefully. Sending money through the right channels may help save lives, but sending it through the wrong agencies may instead fund
1) Mostly the agencies themselves
2) The corrupt government/rebel group that's creating these conditions in the first place
3) Dependence on aid, creating a society that can't feed it's children without constant injection of aid.
4) Agricultural experiments with good intentions but disastrous consequences.
5) All sorts of other unintentional harm.

I wrote a reply to a similar comment on this issue in a different thread, specificially about Africa, but it applies equally to the Chittagong Hill Tract, Myanmar, and nearly every other location with widespread starvation. Here's a modified version of it.

The majority of areas where such starvation is occurring isn't because they land is unable to support the population, or because other people aren't sending enough aid, it's because the population isn't allowed to support themselves with the land.

Ethiopia has a lot of fertile land. Yet just a few decades ago, it was so well known for starvation, such an iconic image of The African Troubles, that there are still jokes being made about it. This was due to what would have been a minor famine which was exacerbated to disastrous proportions by an oppressive communist government. Political turmoil has kept the nation's recovery slow and sporadic, but it's hardly the poster child for African starvation now.

Zimbabwe went from being the breadbasket of Africa, one of its most prosperous nations, to being riddled with poverty and starvation. This is not a problem of resources, since it still has all the same resources it always has; but with politics. The problem is not inability to farm the land, but the Mugabe government's cronyist policies shutting down farms, taking them away from people who produced food, and given them as rewards to his lackeys who either refuse to allow anyone to farm them, or farm them solely for their own benefit. Underground markets in food and land have been ruthlessly suppressed; and droughts which would have caused survivable difficulties are now causing near devestation in many areas.

During the hegemony of the USSR, the Ukraine experienced devastating famine despite having the most productive land in Eastern Europe, a famine at least partly created by Stalin to suppress dissent. China under Mao saw the same occurrence during the Great Leap Forward, where Mao's inept collectivist polices and intentional mishandling resulted in millions of deaths. Throughout history, thousands and millions of people have died from famines artificially engineered or aggravated, either by deliberate intent, or by destructive political policy. The Irish Potato Famine could have been greatly mitigated had the Irish been allowed to import inexpensive wheat and barley from Europe and the US; instead of being forced to rely on unfamiliar British-controlled corn at greatly inflated prices. Nearly all disastrous famines have been at least partly the result of such political manipulation.

The story is similar all over the world The land is fertile, the water is available, sometimes directly, sometimes with a minor bit of technological assistance; but oppressive communist, Islamist, and military dictatorship governments are preventing people from instituting productive irrigation and farming practices. They're reduced to subsistance farming, if they're allowed to farm at all. Interneicine intertribal warfare disrupts any attempt at establishing reliable large-scale agriculture in much of Africa; and genocidal governments prevent it in much of southeast Asia. People are dying of easily preventable diseases because their own leaders are mired in ludicrious magical thinking combined with a rabidly anti-West and anti-science mentality that prevents decent medical care from reaching them; are simply too xenophobic to allow any outside resources to reach their people. Kleptocratic dictators and Islamist theocracies prevent aid from reaching the people who need it; typically diverting it to their own coffers and warehouses, for the use of themselves, their cronies, and their political allies; or to support their constant warring. In some cases, food and medical aid has simply been left to rot on loading docks, untouched.

Starvation and disease around the world is not a resource problem, it's not a funding and assistance problem, it's a political problem; and will remain a problem until the politics are fixed. No matter how many billions of dollars European, American, and Commonwealth countries throw at the problem; as long as the oppressive governments remain in control, none of it will do much good.
 
Starvation and disease around the world is not a resource problem, it's not a funding and assistance problem, it's a political problem; and will remain a problem until the politics are fixed. No matter how many billions of dollars European, American, and Commonwealth countries throw at the problem; as long as the oppressive governments remain in control, none of it will do much good.

Exactly.
Directly addressing poverty and hunger in many countries may even save some lives in the short term, but it's treating a symptom while ignoring the disease.
 
"Give a man a fish..." you know how the rest goes. Democracy, Capitalism, technology, and education are the cures for hunger. Mexico will always be poorer than the states as long as it is plagued with government corruption and too much socialism, its not an issue of arable land or other natural resources.

Wanna see how various countries have changed from poor and starving to thriving nations? Check out global health expert Hans Roslings very entertaining TED video (Technology, Entertainment, Design) entitled " Debunking third-world myths"


A striking case is Vietnam and what has happened with birth rates and life expectancy.
 
However, people and children die from hunger in the world, and I think that by donating money, we could save lives. Do you agree that it is the same situation?

No, not really. In your first example it is a single individual, and so relatively easy to help. And although it's not specifically stated, the implication of it being some sort of medical condition is that once it's treated, that's it, the problem is gone.

Let's see what happens if we do make them the same.

Instead of helping out one sick guy that you come across, how do we deal with the issue of illness in general? Do we all make it our personal responsibility to help each and every sick person alive, never resting until every last one of them receives our personal care and attention? Of course not. In fact we don't even commit ourselves to simply ensuring everybody is healthy all the time. What we do is fund charities and businesses and government bodies to a reasonable level, and those organisations do what they can to grapple with health issues as best they can. Which is exactly what we do with hunger.

I am not sure about the conclusion, but perhaps as long as people are dying in third world countries from hunger, and we can stop that, we have no right to pursue our own happiness but need to invest all that we do in helping them.

Do you agree?

Absolutely not. I strongly disagree, and in fact I couldn't possibly disagree more. it's always a nonsense when somebody declares "this particular problem must be solved, and it is so important that every other area of human activity must be put on hold until it is." Real, actual life is about compromises and balances and organising priorities and trying to fulfill as many of those priorities as you can as well as you can. I can't think of a single problem, ever in all of history, in which it was sensible to take that attitude that nobody is allowed to be happy until it was 100% solved.

I work hard for my money. Since I am a part of the society around me and that society is (partially) democratic, then I have some social obligations to others and we've elected a government that takes a hefty chunk of my money off me to spend it on them. Since I am also a member of world society I have some obligations there too, and my government thus has a foreign aid budget, helps to fund the UN, etc.

But I personally have every right to spend the money I earned on myself. I bought myself a £400 iPhone recently, and I did it purely because I like gadgets and I wanted to own this one. And I did it with an entirely clear conscience.
 
However, people and children die from hunger in the world, and I think that by donating money, we could save lives. Do you agree that it is the same situation?
No. The emotional response of the witness is rather different in each situation due to object permanence. Benevolence is also not in surplus supply and therefore will be rationed somehow.
 
Dump it in the ocean! Who does this?


Dumping food surplus in the ocean might well be better than dumping it in the marketplaces of West Africa and similar.

If you go to Sierra Leone, you will have difficulty buying locallly grown rice in the capital Freetown because US Government subsidised rice is so much cheaper.

The surplus American rice is dumped there. It is not possible for Sierra Leonean rice farmers to sell their own product in their own country. So they remain at subsistence level.

The African farmers grow what they need for their own families and villages - but they cannot grow extra to sell for cash, because no-one in town will buy it. The cost of transporting local rice to town a few miles by road is more than what is charged for rice imported across the Atlantic!

The US is not the only one to blame. The European Union is also guilty. In Ghana, the enforced dumping of EU-subsidised tinned tomatoes and chicken (chicken, tomato & rice are the basis of the national dish) make a mockery of local farmers' attempts to earn a living for themselves over and above subsistence.

BTW, both Ghana and Sierra Leone have democratic governments - not the cliché dictatorships so beloved of those who would like to claim that Africa's problems are Africa's fault.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom