World Hunger

Starvation and disease around the world is not a resource problem, it's not a funding and assistance problem, it's a political problem; and will remain a problem until the politics are fixed [ . . . ]
OK and all, now do you think the WTO and rich country governments alleviate the situation or make it worse?

No matter how many billions of dollars European, American, and Commonwealth countries throw at the problem [ . . . ] none of it will do much good.
Is it all nice and generous foreign aid or do tariffs and subsidies and IMF conditions play a part (in the opposite direction)?
 
Last edited:
If you go to Sierra Leone, you will have difficulty buying locallly grown rice in the capital Freetown because US Government subsidised rice is so much cheaper.

Yes, and it's not as though that's going to change in the foreseeable future. I consider that immoral commercial practice.
 
As long as the manufacture and distribution of food involves making a profit, there will always be hunger.

And if it didn't involve making a profit, what incentive does anybody have to go into food production or distribution? Are you going to force farmers at gun point to grow and give away the food they produce?
 
BTW, both Ghana and Sierra Leone have democratic governments - not the cliché dictatorships so beloved of those who would like to claim that Africa's problems are Africa's fault.
Yes but you might like to check how much of Sierra Leone's post independence history has enjoyed peaceful democracy.
 
And if it didn't involve making a profit, what incentive does anybody have to go into food production or distribution? Are you going to force farmers at gun point to grow and give away the food they produce?

Personally, no. I am not blaming farmers for wanting to make a profit.

Capitalism will always mean that some people will miss out. There is enough food to feed everyone in the world. There just isn't the will to do so.
 
If you were walking on the street, and a person was having medical problem that endangers his life ; if you were trained in medicine, would there be ___any___ excuse not to try and save his life?


I think not.
Then you are not thinking hard enough and it is a terribly poor analogy.

A good excuse to not help would be a threat to your health and safety. I would not do mouth to mouth to someone bleeding from their mouth. I would not go save someone who was shot if the gunman was still shooting the place up.

And remember the statement, "trained in medicine"? How many "trained in medicine" folk are there out as an equivalent to your food analogy?

You have in essence created a very biased false analogy. A real equivalent analogy would be "If someone was having a medical problem and you are walking down the street and medically trained, you are in affect demanding that the medical person donate a chunk of his life and time to treating that person FOREVER or until that person recovers."

However, people and children die from hunger in the world, and I think that by donating money, we could save lives. Do you agree that it is the same situation?
No. See above.
I am not sure about the conclusion, but perhaps as long as people are dying in third world countries from hunger, and we can stop that, we have no right to pursue our own happiness but need to invest all that we do in helping them.

Do you agree?
No, not one bit. I actually believe it is complete and utter nonsense.

People should donate time and money as they see fit to help save the poor and starving but what obligation should someone have to sacrifice their happiness for someone else? Because you say so?

That would be equivalent to that medical person donating hours a day trying to save people dying from lung cancer but never once mentioning that smoking is bad.

Treat and fix the underlying issue and stop trying to guilt people.
 
Last edited:
Yes but you might like to check how much of Sierra Leone's post independence history has enjoyed peaceful democracy.


Not a lot. They've had a dreadful time. I know, I was there.

But now that they do have democracy - as demonstrated by a peaceful handover of power in 2007 - isn't it all the more important that we help? Especially as the original causes of the war haven't really been resolved (essentially poverty leaving a lot of young men feeling socially excluded and useless).

We can help with the rebuilding of infrastructure, especially some decent roads, and re-equipping and training their police force. This is being done, which is excellent.

But if the current unfair world trade rules insist on preventing a fertile country from feeding itself and keeping its agricultural economy face-down at subsistence level, then it's only window-dressing.

There's nothing wrong with capitalism and the free market to encourage African farmers (or farmers anywhere - Haiti in the Caribbean is in a similar situation) to grow extra food for sale to the townies. I applaud the free market.

But the EU and the US are not being capitalist free-marketeers when they forceably dump their surplus food at below cost prices in African markets. That's just repeating the sort of disastrous mistakes typically made by the communists and their belief in the 'command economy'.
 
OK and all, now do you think the WTO and rich country governments alleviate the situation or make it worse?
Insofar as they directly or indirectly support the governments that are responsible for the problems with their nations, they exacerbate the problem. Please note that this can, and often does, include the providing of monetary and non-monetary material aid, since that is often co-opted by said governments for their own use.

I don't know enough about how the WTO works in this context, but it's mostly irrelevant, since no one is building "sweatshops" in these regions. There are some issues with labor in other depressed economies; but these are typically the result of kleptocratic governments preventing any substantial improvement locally.
Is it all nice and generous foreign aid or do tariffs and subsidies and IMF conditions play a part (in the opposite direction)?
Everything plays a part, if you want to go that far; but ultimately the responsibility falls on the oppressive governments that are preventing any improvements in quality of life for their own people, and warring tribes that continue to create turmoil and destruction in what are purely ethnocentric conflicts.

Despite what so many people, especially left-wing redistributionists, want to believe, there is no simple, pat solution to this problem. Ultimately, what thse people need is stability, cooperation, and self-sufficiency; but that is exactly what so many people in those regions do not want. They might go for stability, and may even be intersted in self-sufficiency; but cooperation is generally not on the agenda, either on a local or global level. Power is more often used to continue suppression of hated rivals than to create any sort of stable coalition -- the constant conflict between the Hutu and Tutsi peoples, or the Ethiopians, Somali, and Eritreans, is characteristic of most of Africa. And the only thing many groups hate more than each other are European, American, and Commonwealth "outsiders"; as evidenced by the problems with Myanmar.
 
I don't know enough about how the WTO works in this context, but it's mostly irrelevant, since no one is building "sweatshops" in these regions.
The WTO supports various protectionist moves made by rich countries under the guise of "anti-dumping", by which they get to impose tariffs on cheap imports to protect domestic agriculture and other industries. Thereby they prevent poor countries from exploiting their labour cost advantages.

Everything plays a part, if you want to go that far; but ultimately the responsibility falls on the oppressive governments that are preventing any improvements in quality of life for their own people, and warring tribes that continue to create turmoil and destruction in what are purely ethnocentric conflicts.
If rich countries indulge in protectionist trade policies there may not be very much that developing world governments can do about that. If IMF loans contain conditions about rapid liberalisation of capital controls and fast-track privatisations then likewise, and it's arguably more likely to result in a corrupted mess of asset-stripping lining thugs' pockets. It's not so much where "ultimate responsibility" lies but whether the rest of the world is actually helping. After all, poor countries growing should be a good thing for rich countries too.

Despite what so many people, especially left-wing redistributionists, want to believe, there is no simple, pat solution to this problem.
Who are they? People you don't agree with? Are you implying you are a "right wing selfist"? That wasn't my issue anyway.
 
But the EU and the US are not being capitalist free-marketeers when they forceably dump their surplus food at below cost prices in African markets. That's just repeating the sort of disastrous mistakes typically made by the communists and their belief in the 'command economy'.
I'm interested in what backup you have on this. I tend to be far more opposed to "anti-dumping"--because I think it is largely a misnomer--than "dumping". And I understood that antitrust rules were more often constructed and enforced the other way about--that is, to prevent poor countries from exporting rather than forcing them to import.
 
Years ago I lived next door to a PNO caption who carted wheat. He took a donated ship load to Bangladesh, no one would pay the import duty so it rotted on the docks. Stud cattle about 1000 were donated to India to improve there herds and the Indian army ate them. Would you in a starvation country bring children into the world? So it's a waste of time feeling sorry because they don't have drinking water, dig a bloody well like we do. Give money ha ha guess who gets it, I saw first hand how few got help or money when Darwin went down. The only way is to hand direct to someone that you know. Most funds are subject to costs and that is often people drawing a huge wage at the top and if it all goes in administration to bad. So to sum this hard view up. To give to poverty just improvishs the giver.
 
He took a donated ship load to Bangladesh, no one would pay the import duty so it rotted on the docks. Stud cattle about 1000 were donated to India to improve there herds and the Indian army ate them.

So your neighbour the P & O captain was attempting to dump unwanted wheat into somebody else's market without paying the local tax - and thereby (if he'd succeeded) destroying the livelihoods of local grain farmers?

How much import tax do you think a Bangladeshi ship loaded with rice would need to pay if it arrived at an American port - and let's say it wanted to give its rice away for free to the homeless there? (Or to Europe or Australia).

As for the cattle: Were they suitable and acclimatised for Indian conditions? Or was it another 'gift with strings'?


(Francesca, I will get back to you with evidence re West Africa. I've got my reports here somewhere, but it'll take me a wee while).
 
As for the cattle: Were they suitable and acclimatised for Indian conditions? Or was it another 'gift with strings'?
The Indian Army ate the cows given to them in Hindu majority India?
Somehow I smell cowdung in Old Bob' posts.
 
During the hegemony of the USSR, the Ukraine experienced devastating famine despite having the most productive land in Eastern Europe,
When I was in elementary and middle school in the 1950s and '60s, they taught world geography and world history (for those of you who went to high school in the 1990s and after, you can google the terms for an explanation...).

We were all taught that (repeat after me, class), "The Ukraine is the breadbasket of the Soviet Union."

One Sunday morning in 1989, I was watching This Week With David Brinkley, and the panel, which included Sam Donaldson and George Will, was discussing the ongoing breakup of th Soviet Union. Brinkley observed that the Ukraine looked likely to secede. Donaldson observed that if that were to happen, that would be the end of the Soviet Union, because, "the Ukraine is the breadbasket of the Soviet Union."

Will dryly objected: "No, Kansas is the breadbasket of the Soviet Union."
 
people and children die from hunger in the world,


Yes, they do.

and I think that by donating money, we could save lives. Do you agree that it is the same situation?

I am not sure about the conclusion, but perhaps as long as people are dying in third world countries from hunger, and we can stop that, we have no right to pursue our own happiness but need to invest all that we do in helping them.

Do you agree?


No, not really.
 
No. There is a simple law of the nature that must be understood.

More food = Increase in Population
Less food = Decrease in population

Giving them food is a temporary solution and a terrible one at that. If they are given food, they will be healthy enough to mate and produce more people. These people will also have no means of getting food for themselves and will also be starving, which will require more food to be sent. This cycle repeats ad infinum.

The world has so many people that we have no idea what to do with them. For example we encourage everyone to go to college to get a better education so as to get a better job. The fact is that there are a limited number of good jobs and far far more lower end jobs. In years past completing high school was good enough for most jobs, then 2 years of college, then 4 years of college. Now you are expected to complete graduate school to get good jobs. Is it really that you need 26+ years of schooling to do your job or is it that there simply aren't enough positions open until the older people die off, those already in the industry get promoted, and now there are positions open to be filled by the college grads. In addition our massive population has us destroying the planet, fighting over land and natural resources, starting wars. All sorts of good stuff. So personally I'm all for a nice drop in the world population and then a worldwide population policy.

However, for those who disagree with all that I would suggest that instead of wasting your money donating to charities that just give them food, you donate your money to an organization that will help build up their economy and agriculture so we can end the cycle of dependence.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom