William Rodriguez: "I am 9/11!"

William is a buffer between us and the truthers, a shield that they hide behind as if to say "You call him a liar, he helped and aided people!".

It is somewhat defining of truthers, as they cherry pick evidence and in this case, a witness to one of the worst terrorist attacks in the history of man.

However, they tend to leave out the FDNY, hundreds of first responders, the 8000 man team at the pentagon, and the 1,100 man team at Flight 93's crash site. All who picked up human remains and form part of what you call the "governments official story". Guess what, it is not the "governments official story", it is the story of normal people who saw burnt bodies in their flight seats that could be your family members.

You have a man who speaks for you on your forums and your films, we on the other hand do not. Why? Because the vast majority do their jobs, and do not milk the cash cow for all it is worth. They do not want money or fame, they want to carry on with their lives, and it would help if you truthers stopped cowardly accusing them of covering up mass murder because they do not choose to have a public face.

Back in 1995 my father was stabbed when he put himself between the body of a boy on a North-London street being attacked by an iron bar. Unfortunatly he did not survive that attack, and I feel pride in his sacrafice every day.
But I feel pride because he acted like all of us should act, he acted like a man should act. If he survived, would it be right for him to tour the world saying what he did and how he did it? Would it be right for him to make money on what he did? It seems that simply because you were involved in an event that played before all our own eyes, you get more of a right to speak and make money over it? There are heroic acts performed by ordinary people every day, and you, on a humanitarian level, are no different. You are only different because you hold yourself to be, with the camera's and the spotlights thrust in your face.

You behaved like a true man on that day William, but you survived. 3000 did not. You are not 9/11. And saying you are, and getting money from all over the world, not on the issue of those people you helped, nor those we lost, but on a loud bang that has been debunked time and time again, destroys the humanitarinism you displayed on that day.

You are not 9/11. Nobody is 9/11. But here is one truth. 11th September 2001 was a day in which thousands of people joined together to save lives. And you are the only one attempting to give speeches and get paid for it.

Nominated.
 
Examine the ED in the basement here. http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=82498
It has nothing to do with the initiation of collapse.

When you went through the war games, did you do so as a pilot or an infantryman? If you did not do so as a pilot, you are using a false analogy.

I've done a good bit of research on the war games as well, so I have no need to read other's interpretations when I can read the statements and press releases from NORAD, the FAA, and the Air Force myself thanks for the suggestion though.
Nice dodge on the explosive device in the basement. Just tell me. Don't point me to a multi-page thread. We're talking here. In 80 words or less, explain how a basement explosion caused a top-down collapse.

Okay I guess you're right. Big old standdown by the Air Force. I can buy that.

"Officers and men, a horrific attack upon our country is expected shortly. Innocent people - thousands - will die. Even children. When it begins, you will do exactly nothing. You will sit at your stations with your hands folded and you will take NO action. This thing must happen, trust me. The reason why we are going to allow this murderous attack on our country to proceed, unopposed, is..."

<you provide reason, backed up with substantiated evidence>
 
If the elements in the U.S. government did in fact assist in the attacks there are numerous motives. As far as motives, that is such a broad scope of information to cover so I will throw out some broad issues.
Foreign policy, economic policy, and domestic policy.
I guess a better question would be, what would have those policies been had the 9/11 attacks not occurred?
You may chuckle, but I think Eisenhower was correct in his warning to the American people.

Indeed and thank you for the history lesson, so there is actually no motive for the US to attack herself on 911, is that what you are saying?
 
So changing one's mind after further research and evidence makes one a liar?

How is that logical?
Are you able to make more than two posts in a row without a straw man argument?

William Rodriguez:

1) Changed his story, not in response to new evidence, but because of political reasons. He says so.

Remember, he said he was going to get new evidence but failed to do so, and the person who he said would provide such evidence directly contradicts him.

2) And then he says that he's always told the same story. That's false.

Rational adults don't need straw man arguments to support their views, Swing.

IMHO, when Dylan or whomever changes their mind on an issue, it is most likely based upon further research. I'm not aware of a lie that was stated and maintained after further research.
Allow me to introduce you to Loose Change Second Edition.

Loose Change 1.0: Flight 93 crashed near Shanksville. Passengers and crew made phone calls!

Loose Change 2.0: Flight 93 landed in Cleveland. All phone calls were faked!

Gravy writes "Loose Change Viewer Guide," which points out dozens of errors of fact, gives it to Loose Change creators.

Gravy writes "Loose Change Creators Speak," which points out many more errors of fact, sends it to Loose Change creators.

Loose Change creators produce "Loose Change Second Edition Recut," which leaves in EVERY SINGLE MAJOR FALSE CLAIM THAT HAD ALREADY BEEN DEBUNKED.
 
Last edited:
Are you a victim or survivor of 9/11? Based upon your statement, the slope leads to the entire world being "9/11".

Did you read the entire post? I'm not claiming membership in the first responder or heroes camp. I merely lost a couple of friends that day and witnessed the horrors first hand, albeit from across the river as I was working and living in Jersey City that day.

My point isn't that I am 9/11. It's that William is not the poster boy for the events of that day, which is what he's claiming. It's all there in the post.
 
Yes. At least the ones posted under his name in this forum and a few posted under the same name in LC.
The forum seems to turn from constructive critics to character assassins at the mention of his name. It just doesn't feel right to me, so I spoke out. I just don't see how a thread like this can help to solve anything, especially the way it was headed this morning.

It appears that you have not read enough. If you had, you would realize that Rodriguez' ever-changing claims have been discussed in great detail here, and you would understand why skeptics do not accept his current story, since his story has changed so many times.

If you've read the previous threads you'll be aware that Mr Rodriquez has consistently refused to explain "his side of he story" and will not address problems we have with his numerous publicly stated versions of events.

The posters of this subforum were overwhelmingly polite and respectful to him for a very long time. But there is only so much BS a person will take before saying ENOUGH.

I agree much of the behaviour now towards him is unacceptable - it's against the forum rules after all. But frankly, it is well and truly deserved.

-Gumboot

Exactly.

Hi William. I doubt that you view the situation quite this way, but...isn't it better to be respected by a single rational person than worshipped by a crowd of lunatics?

Apparently, Mr. Rodriguez would rather be worshipped by a crowd of lunatics if that is what it takes to garner some personal fame or infamy for himself. Sad, really.

Perhaps it is. But it looks really bad to someone relatively new to the forum, and it certainly won't appear any better to those who aren't members. If it were any other forum I don't think it would be such an issue, but this is JREF. I know I have always made that distinction to the best of my ability.

Any discerning reader who gives more than a cursory glance at the threads here on the subject matter should easily be able to ascertain that there is ample evidence of Rodriguez' obfuscating and refusing to engage about his multiple inconsistent accounts of the events of September 11, 2001. It is his own words that condemn him in this regard.

Similarly, any discerning reader can easily find his outrageous and unfounded accusations against dozens of people. All without any facts or evidence, unlike the accusations against Rodriguez which are backed by facts and evidence.

Willie doesn't understand that the courage he displayed on 9/11 means nothing to his "fans.". They will be in his corner as long as he continues to lie and slander innocent people. If he ever told the truth, they'd turn on him ferociously.

You are right that the tinhatters would turn on him instantly if he told the truth, but I am not convinced that Rodriguez doesn't understand that the courage he displayed on 9/11 means nothing to the troofers. I suspect that he knows full well that it means nothing to them, and I suspect he knows that they are only embracing him for the time being because they want to exploit his "hero" status for their own benefit. I also suspect that while he understands that, he doesn't care because he is using troofers as much as they are using him, so he's okay with the mutual deceit as long as it furthers his personal goals.

Yes. His desire and efforts to help others that day are verified by others.

I find it very disturbing that he takes the time to post here, that he took the time recently to forward a Nico Haupt article to me, but he won't address the issues I raised in my paper.

So, William, I know you're reading this. You have the power to change your ways. Will you take the course of honor or dishonor?

You have no evidence that the U.S. government committed, aided, allowed to happen, or covered up the 9/11 attacks. Will you stop claiming that the U.S. was involved?

You have no evidence that the basement explosions were due to anything but jet fuel. Will you stop claiming that you do?

You falsely claim that there is no evidence of a fireball in the north tower #50 elevator shaft. Will you stop making that claim?

You falsely claim that you were the last person to be pulled from the rubble. Will you stop making that claim?

You falsely claim that you saved 15, dozens, or hundreds of lives on 9/11. Will you stop making those claims?

You falsely claimed that you dropped your 2004 lawsuit against the United States and that the suit wasn't dismissed by the court. Will you stop making those claims?

You falsely claim that the 9/11 Commission wanted your testimony, and yours alone, behind closed doors. Will you stop making that claim?

You falsely claim that the investigators didn't interview first responders who were in the buildings. Will you stop making that claim?

You falsely claim that NIST didn't want to hear your story, and you misrepresent what you told them. Will you stop making that claim?

You have no evidence for your claims that the U.S. media are deliberately trying to suppress your story, and that the media wants to criminalize Muslims. Will you stop making those claims?

You falsely claim that the story you tell now is the same as you've told from the start. Will you stop making that claim?

You falsely claim that the 34th floor of the north tower was unoccupied, did not have ongoing construction work, and that there is reason to be suspicious of noises on that floor. Will you stop making those claims?

You falsely claim that 21 floors of the north tower collapsed while you were in the building. Will you stop making that claim?

You falsely claim that the 9/11 Commission only addressed a few of the Family Steering Committee's questions. Will you stop making that claim?

You falsely claim that the president said, ‘We don’t need an investigation. We know who did it.’” Will you stop making that claim?

You falsely claim that it's impossilble for NORAD not to have intercepted the hijacked airliners. Will you stop making that claim?

You falsely claim that WTC 7 had only small fires. Will you stop making that claim?

You falsely claim that no steel frame building ever fell due to fire. Will you stop making that claim?

You falsely claim that the official version states that jet fuel melted the tower columns. Will you stop making that claim?

You falsely claim that evidence was deliberately removed from the WTC site to hide it. Will you stop making that claim?

You falsely claim that only FEMA was allowed to investigate the collapses. Will you stop making that claim?


William, why not be a man, take a few minutes from your whirlwind schedule of lying about 9/11, and address these questions?

Beautiful roundup of Rodriguez' false claims, Gravy. I do not anticipate any response from Rodriguez any time soon.

Willy was not always a liar.

He became a liar when he realized he could bask in fame a little longer if he changed his story and embraced a bunch of creepy people in black t-shirts.

I cannot comment on the first sentence as I have no knowledge of when Rodriguez first became a liar, but it does seem apparent that he changed his story about the events of 9/11 when he saw an opportunity for self-promotion that could only come about by embracing the loons in black t-shirts.

Wait...so when Willy, or Dylan, or any other Truthers slightly change their story, its just an honest mistake. But when Guiliani, or Kerik, or anyone else who isnt a Truther edits their accounts, they are lieing or hiding something?

Consistancy and Truthers are mutually exclusive.

Funny how that works, isn't it?
 
Last edited:
William is a buffer between us and the truthers, a shield that they hide behind as if to say "You call him a liar, he helped and aided people!".

It is somewhat defining of truthers, as they cherry pick evidence and in this case, a witness to one of the worst terrorist attacks in the history of man.

However, they tend to leave out the FDNY, hundreds of first responders, the 8000 man team at the pentagon, and the 1,100 man team at Flight 93's crash site. All who picked up human remains and form part of what you call the "governments official story". Guess what, it is not the "governments official story", it is the story of normal people who saw burnt bodies in their flight seats that could be your family members.

You have a man who speaks for you on your forums and your films, we on the other hand do not. Why? Because the vast majority do their jobs, and do not milk the cash cow for all it is worth. They do not want money or fame, they want to carry on with their lives, and it would help if you truthers stopped cowardly accusing them of covering up mass murder because they do not choose to have a public face.

Back in 1995 my father was stabbed when he put himself between the body of a boy on a North-London street being attacked by an iron bar. Unfortunatly he did not survive that attack, and I feel pride in his sacrafice every day.
But I feel pride because he acted like all of us should act, he acted like a man should act. If he survived, would it be right for him to tour the world saying what he did and how he did it? Would it be right for him to make money on what he did? It seems that simply because you were involved in an event that played before all our own eyes, you get more of a right to speak and make money over it? There are heroic acts performed by ordinary people every day, and you, on a humanitarian level, are no different. You are only different because you hold yourself to be, with the camera's and the spotlights thrust in your face.

You behaved like a true man on that day William, but you survived. 3000 did not. You are not 9/11. And saying you are, and getting money from all over the world, not on the issue of those people you helped, nor those we lost, but on a loud bang that has been debunked time and time again, destroys the humanitarinism you displayed on that day.

You are not 9/11. Nobody is 9/11. But here is one truth. 11th September 2001 was a day in which thousands of people joined together to save lives. And you are the only one attempting to give speeches and get paid for it.

Seconded (the nomination).
 
I was an instructor pilot in the USAF, I have trained hundreds of students.
There you go just pushing out the statements. Please list the things in the 9/11 commission report that are lies or misleading. Truthers like surprise statements and then they run away.


One, I've flown several bombing missions, CAPs, and intercepts, and even refueled in the air...in My F-16 computer game. However, I wasn't hijacking a plane, I was able to to take off and land and have complete SA during the whole mission, however, that doesn't translate to real world ability as I think both of us would agree. A few hours of stick time in a simulator doesn't transfer over to instrument knowledge, ability and skill. Based upon the article I examined from a meeting of professional pilots, they agreed that based upon his experience he could not complete his mission the way it was done.
As far as simulator's go, I'm unaware if Hani was in one with enough time.


Oh, and btw, although we have different views on 9/11, thank you for serving in our voluntary military forces.

First error I've come across:
The centerpiece of his original proposal was the tenth plane, which he would have piloted himself. Rather than crashing the plane into a target, he would have killed every adult male passenger, contacted the media from the air, and landed the aircraft at a U.S. airport. He says he then would have made a speech denouncing U.S. policies in the Middle East before releasing all of the women and children passengers.
Well we know hatred for the U.S has nothing to do with the government's policies, but because of what America is: free..with freedom of speech, freedom of religion, freedom of the press, the rights of women, etc.

Do you view that as an error?

The endorsement of two contradictory stories about the aircraft that hit the Pentagon---one in which it executed a 330-degree downward spiral (a "high-speed dive") and another in which there is no mention of this maneuver (222-23).

But I could go on and on about that...but I must retire for the evening. And no it is not a dodge or bow out of the conversation, but a date. Good evening gentlemen and enjoy your weekend.
 
In an earlier thread I successfully defended the basement explosive device theory based upon the empirical method. I also presented two possible suspects as well as a part of that discussion.

I'm assuming you believe that one of these possible suspects is Sakher Hammad...great, you have a name! Please tell use which law enforcement agencies you have reported him and the other person to.

About two weeks ago on the drive to work I saw a man crawl through a front window in a home. He might only be a suspect but I pulled over and called 911 anyway.

Almost 3,000 people died on 9/11. Swing, you have a moral obligation to follow up on your investigation and present your findings to everyone possible...the NYPD, the FBI, the CIA, your state's Congressional delegation (I assume you're American), Mayor Bloomberg, Governor Spitzer, and the the international media...let's just start with the BBC and CBC for now.

You are sitting on the biggest story since World War II.

If you're not willing to go public, why not?
 
William is a buffer between us and the truthers, a shield that they hide behind as if to say "You call him a liar, he helped and aided people!".

It is somewhat defining of truthers, as they cherry pick evidence and in this case, a witness to one of the worst terrorist attacks in the history of man.

However, they tend to leave out the FDNY, hundreds of first responders, the 8000 man team at the pentagon, and the 1,100 man team at Flight 93's crash site. All who picked up human remains and form part of what you call the "governments official story". Guess what, it is not the "governments official story", it is the story of normal people who saw burnt bodies in their flight seats that could be your family members.

You have a man who speaks for you on your forums and your films, we on the other hand do not. Why? Because the vast majority do their jobs, and do not milk the cash cow for all it is worth. They do not want money or fame, they want to carry on with their lives, and it would help if you truthers stopped cowardly accusing them of covering up mass murder because they do not choose to have a public face.

Back in 1995 my father was stabbed when he put himself between the body of a boy on a North-London street being attacked by an iron bar. Unfortunatly he did not survive that attack, and I feel pride in his sacrafice every day.
But I feel pride because he acted like all of us should act, he acted like a man should act. If he survived, would it be right for him to tour the world saying what he did and how he did it? Would it be right for him to make money on what he did? It seems that simply because you were involved in an event that played before all our own eyes, you get more of a right to speak and make money over it? There are heroic acts performed by ordinary people every day, and you, on a humanitarian level, are no different. You are only different because you hold yourself to be, with the camera's and the spotlights thrust in your face.

You behaved like a true man on that day William, but you survived. 3000 did not. You are not 9/11. And saying you are, and getting money from all over the world, not on the issue of those people you helped, nor those we lost, but on a loud bang that has been debunked time and time again, destroys the humanitarinism you displayed on that day.

You are not 9/11. Nobody is 9/11. But here is one truth. 11th September 2001 was a day in which thousands of people joined together to save lives. And you are the only one attempting to give speeches and get paid for it.

Nominated.

Edit: Make that thirded or fourthed, apparently :)
 
Last edited:
LashL; said:
William has had ample opportunity here and elsewhere to present his side of the story as it relates to his ever-changing story and as it relates to the numerous outrageous, unsubstantiated, and wholly unfounded accusations that he has levied against dozens and dozens of people, and he has refused to do so. He has been specifically invited to present "his side of the story" and he has declined.

Yes, I know.

LashL; said:
You might want to read through prior threads here in order to get the complete picture about Rodriguez' false representations before leaping to his defence and before accusing others of actions that "border on slander" (wrong, and I would suggest that you avoid using legal terms that you do not understand) and before accusing others of denying him "due process" (this is an internet forum, not a court of law).

I have observed statements that were a deliberate attempt at defamation. Until the statements have been proven as fact they are libelous. We seriously aren't going to argue about whether the internet presents itself as libelous or slanderous are we? And you are sadly mistaken if you believe the internet is not considered a credible source of publication in the eyes of the law, no matter how transient it may be. And I am not allowed to use the analogy of "due process" simply because this is an internet forum and not a court of law? That's your opinion, thank you for it.

LashL; said:
The accusations made against Rodriguez here pale in comparison to the accusations that Rodriguez has made against numerous people. The most notable difference, however, is that the accusations made against Rodriguez here are backed by facts and evidence, while the accusations made by Rodriguez against dozens of people are wholly unsubstantiated, often frivolous and vexatious, completely unfounded, and are not backed by facts or evidence. See the difference?

Oh I see, eye for an eye then? Hardly the words I would expect from a Solicitor. You have presumed your "facts and evidence" out weigh Mr. Rodriguez's "facts and evidence" (whatever they may be). Until proven in a court of law, and not an internet forum, neither hold any more weight and should not be presented as otherwise.

I am really tired of defending myself for expecting a modicum of decency in these matters. You don't think I deliberated about this very situation arising before I posted this morning? I did. And I chose to do what I felt was right anyways. Why should I have to do this, why should anyone for that matter?
 
IMHO, when Dylan or whomever changes their mind on an issue, it is most likely based upon further research. I'm not aware of a lie that was stated and maintained after further research.


Really, Swingie? Conspiracy liars are still peddling the falsehood that "pull it" means "blow up the building." I'm looking at my notes and I see that I've made phone calls to fourteen different demolition companies in three states. All of them deny that the phrase has any meaning apart from describing the act of attaching cables to a small structure to pull it, literally, off its center of gravity.

Are you prepared to acknowledge that this myth is dead and buried? Are the fantasists who persist in trotting out this fabrication ignoring the "research"?

Incidentally, how did you manage to defend your fantasy about a basement bomb? You don't have a shred of actual evidence to support your erroneous claim.
 
Yes, I know.

Your posts indicate otherwise.

I have observed statements that were a deliberate attempt at defamation. Until the statements have been proven as fact they are libelous. We seriously aren't going to argue about whether the internet presents itself as libelous or slanderous are we? And you are sadly mistaken if you believe the internet is not considered a credible source of publication in the eyes of the law, no matter how transient it may be. And I am not allowed to use the analogy of "due process" simply because this is an internet forum and not a court of law? That's your opinion, thank you for it.

Oh, please. Spare me your "internet lawyering" - I'm a real life, actual, practicing, trial lawyer. You claimed that the actions of people here "bordered on slander". You were wrong and I pointed that out to you. Now, you are pretending that you said something different, purporting to lecture me on the law of defamation, and moving the goalposts - probably after googling the difference between libel and slander and realizing that you were wrong in your prior post. Sorry, 3b, but words have meaning. You are entirely out of line and your attempt to reframe your prior post is entirely transparent.

Oh I see, eye for an eye then? Hardly the words I would expect from a Solicitor. You have presumed your "facts and evidence" out weigh Mr. Rodriguez's "facts and evidence" (whatever they may be). Until proven in a court of law, and not an internet forum, neither hold any more weight and should not be presented as otherwise.

Wrong again, 3b. I have presumed nothing. Either you have not read the threads as you claim or you do not understand them. Once you have read them, you can ask for clarification of the parts you don't understand and I'll be happy to assist you. The only one libelling anyone around here is William Rodriguez.

I am really tired of defending myself for expecting a modicum of decency in these matters. You don't think I deliberated about this very situation arising before I posted this morning? I did. And I chose to do what I felt was right anyways. Why should I have to do this, why should anyone for that matter?

Your weariness does not concern me. Your inability or unwillingness to research the issues upon which you purport to opine, however, does. Had you done a modicum of research into these particular issues, you would know why your allegations are entirely unfounded. I have no knowledge of what deliberations you engaged in before posting your erroneous assertions, and I take no issue with the fact that you felt that you were doing what "was right" even though your assertions were wrong.

The last paragraph of your post includes ridiculous and rhetorical questions which require no response. I could just as easily ask, "Why should I have to respond to such obvious erroneous posts and ridiculous questions, and why should anyone for that matter?" but doing so would be just as useless and silly as those portions of your post.

And here is an unsolicited, but genuine, piece of advice for you: Don't quit your day job.
 
Last edited:
I am really tired of defending myself for expecting a modicum of decency in these matters.
"Modicum of decency?" Libel and slander? Let's try to keep some perspective here. None of this would be an issue if William Rodriguez weren't touring the world and using his fame to accuse people of mass murder without a shred of evidence. As LashL does, I back my statements with evidence. I won't handle Rodriguez with kid gloves, and I'm glad that others don't.
 
Gravy,

Have you recived any reply from Willy regarding your "escape artist" paper?
Has he made any sort of rebuttal?
 
Is there any empirical evidence that Hani Hanjour was at the controls of the plane for the entire flight, Beach?

I agree with you to a point on the Hani can't fly a plane statement. The proper explanation is that Hani could not fly a plane with enough skill to fly a passenger airliner that way it was flown. This assessment based upon a group of professional pilots that to my knowledge are not affiliated with pilotsfor9/11truth.org.

try it for yourself.

just get that control knob

twist it hard

landing
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom