Why I despise the Truthers

I'm not sure about physicists, but THESE GUYS disagree with your nonsense.

http://www.asce.org/pdf/5-1-02wtc_testimony.pdf

But of course... In your world, people who disagree with you, who HAVE THE CREDENTIALS, are just ignored. Or wait, let me guess, ASCE is run by alien lizardmen using chemtrails?
Didn't say anything about lizarsmen or anything like that but Kevin Ryan did point this out.

http://911research.wtc7.net/reviews/kevin_ryan/newstandard.html

"Ryan shows that the same principals headed the various government investigations of the WTC collapses, the Pentagon crash, and Oklahoma City bombing, despite the fact that the investigations involved assessments of entirely different kinds of structures inflicted with different kinds of damage. Why do the same five or so individuals turn up in investigations relating to terrorist attack, when, according to the American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE) ,there are 1.5 million engineers in the US? The authors of the official report on the Murrah Federal Building -- Gene Corley, Charles Thornton, Paul Mlaker, and Mete Sozen -- were all among the initial team of the ASCE WTC investigation. Several of these individuals have strong connections to industries that benefited from the attack, such as armaments makers and oil and gas producers. "
 
Does Greening fully support the official version?

Greening does NOT like the current administration, and has a problem with American policies. He has no reason to trust the government at all.

As far as the entire official story, you'd have to ask him.

But, since you think that the collapses defied the laws of physics, he would probably not agree with you in the least.
 
That's an answer?

ok
Would you prefer all the ones that PM cites? Something tells me that won't be any more of a satisfactory answer to you.

Of course, neither will anything other than "it was a conspiracy." Everything else is just words for your movement to tap dance around.
 
Didn't say anything about lizarsmen or anything like that but Kevin Ryan did point this out.

http://911research.wtc7.net/reviews/kevin_ryan/newstandard.html

"Ryan shows that the same principals headed the various government investigations of the WTC collapses, the Pentagon crash, and Oklahoma City bombing, despite the fact that the investigations involved assessments of entirely different kinds of structures inflicted with different kinds of damage. Why do the same five or so individuals turn up in investigations relating to terrorist attack, when, according to the American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE) ,there are 1.5 million engineers in the US? The authors of the official report on the Murrah Federal Building -- Gene Corley, Charles Thornton, Paul Mlaker, and Mete Sozen -- were all among the initial team of the ASCE WTC investigation. Several of these individuals have strong connections to industries that benefited from the attack, such as armaments makers and oil and gas producers. "

This is called conjecture. Conjecture isn't proof of anything. This is the kind of reasoning that dumbfounds rational people and why you are fighting to be taken seriously as an investigator.

Do you think it's good form to toss out conjecture with no evidence to support it and pretend it's some kind of proof? These 5 were AMONG THE INITIAL TEAM. If you want to accuse these people of being in on it, you must accuse the other members of the team of either being stupid or in on it. Unless you thing those 5 were the only members of the team.

In true form, the quote you submitted implies an accusation of wrongdoing, but refuses to accept any responsibility for it by "just asking questions".

The thread is entitled why I despise the Truthers

This kind of skewed and biased reasoning to support a position is one of those reasons for me.
 
Last edited:
Didn't say anything about lizarsmen or anything like that but Kevin Ryan did point this out.

http://911research.wtc7.net/reviews/kevin_ryan/newstandard.html

"Ryan shows that the same principals headed the various government investigations of the WTC collapses, the Pentagon crash, and Oklahoma City bombing, despite the fact that the investigations involved assessments of entirely different kinds of structures inflicted with different kinds of damage. Why do the same five or so individuals turn up in investigations relating to terrorist attack, when, according to the American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE) ,there are 1.5 million engineers in the US? The authors of the official report on the Murrah Federal Building -- Gene Corley, Charles Thornton, Paul Mlaker, and Mete Sozen -- were all among the initial team of the ASCE WTC investigation. Several of these individuals have strong connections to industries that benefited from the attack, such as armaments makers and oil and gas producers. "


ad hominem
 
Do you think it's good form to toss out conjecture with no evidence to support it and pretend it's some kind of proof?
If they didn't, the twoof movment would consist of one 11 second youtube video and a website of pictures of Bush and Cheney with devil horns drawn on them. :p
 
Give it up.


You parade your empty-headed arrogance and tell rationalists to give it up? Do you realize that you just asked posters on the JREF if they were familiar with Gordon Ross's worthless junk? Ross has been utterly destroyed by Dr. Greening and Ryan Mackey. But, you don't know that.
 
And what? Finding out then mechanisms behind just how fast a 110 story building can completely collapse on people isn't just as important?

No, it's not. We want to prevent the collapses from happening at all, or delay them from starting as much as we can, not stop them or slow them down once they start.

Reposted in case you missed it. Have you begun to understand why your own personal incredulity doesn't (and shouldn't) govern the scope of the NIST's investigation?
 
Back up.

I was told there are no actual physicists that say the laws physics were defied on 9-11. I never claimed there was.

I only said Steven Jones is a real physicist who disputes the official version. Then of course we have to go down the same old tired road about peer review and if it's valid peer review and blah blah blah.

So I asked what physicist supports the official version and with what paper.

I was given Bazant which although he has a diploma in physics he is really more of an engineer. But that's fine. He just doesn't have the credentials of Jones in physics. I gave a link of a whole list of engineers and architects. Discredit them all it’s just your opinion.

I was also given Gravy's paper. Fine. Gravy has no degrees in Physics or Engineering or anything that I know of. So who was the one who brought up actual physicist in the first place?

Me?


Characteristic dishonesty. You parroted the fantasist line about "impossible physics." You.
 
Look, this really isn't something we're particularly interested in, as physicists. There is no unexplained physics in the WTC collapses. If I wrote and submitted a paper to a physics journal explaining how the collapses agree with known laws of physics, the rejection slip would read something along the lines of "Well, duh!" Pomeroo should really have pointed out the unanimity of peer-reviewed papers from structural engineers in their opinion that the collapse was due to fire and structural damage. There are actually a few physicists who are sufficiently out of touch with the real world that they do believe there's something wrong about the WTC collapses (A. K. Dewdney is another). They're idiots, and I apologise for them on behalf of my profession, but they exist. However, I defy you to find a single anonymously peer-reviewed paper in any discipline which supports the controlled demolition theory, whereas there are plenty that categorically reject it.

Dave


Since when is Dewdney a physicist? I thought he was a mathematics/computer science guy.
 
I only said Steven Jones is a real physicist who disputes the official version. Then of course we have to go down the same old tired road about peer review and if it's valid peer review and blah blah blah.

Peer review, blah blah blah??? So you really don't see how important it is to get an objective expert second, third, or even forth opinion about papers that you aren't qualified to judge? Wow.

So. How do YOU judge the merits of a scientific paper? I judge it by how many other experts concur. How else could I? I certainly won't judge a paper that I'm not qualified to critique by ANYBODY, even if I agree with their position, unless that position is verified by other experts.

I think you judge it by if it supports your world view.
 
Reposted in case you missed it. Have you begun to understand why your own personal incredulity doesn't (and shouldn't) govern the scope of the NIST's investigation?
I didn't say it was although I feel I've pointed to more then just my own personal incredulity.



Now people here more then once have asked me what my problem is with any of the official versions. I'm only answering. And you're chiming in after the fact. To insinuate I am the only one in the world who has a problem with NIST following through with their theory is nothing more then your personal incredulity.
 
Peer review, blah blah blah??? So you really don't see how important it is to get an objective expert second, third, or even forth opinion about papers that you aren't qualified to judge? Wow.

So. How do YOU judge the merits of a scientific paper? I judge it by how many other experts concur. How else could I? I certainly won't judge a paper that I'm not qualified to critique by ANYBODY, even if I agree with their position, unless that position is verified by other experts.

I think you judge it by if it supports your world view.
Yes it is important. For instance Quinteres call for a second opinion on NIST is very important. I'm only pointing out if you are going to call for it on Jones call for it on your own versions and theories.
 
You parade your empty-headed arrogance and tell rationalists to give it up? Do you realize that you just asked posters on the JREF if they were familiar with Gordon Ross's worthless junk? Ross has been utterly destroyed by Dr. Greening and Ryan Mackey. But, you don't know that.
Opinion. And again I ask. Does Greening fully support the official version according to NIST?
 
Who wants to place bets as to how long this thread is going to get?

100 pages?
200 pages?

.....I don't even want to think about it. If you removed Zens argument and all rebuttals this thread would only be like 4 pages long.
 
Opinion. And again I ask. Does Greening fully support the official version according to NIST?

Dude. Again, he is on this forum. Apollo20 is his nick.

Start a thread and ask him how much of the official version he supports, or send him a PM, or whatever.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom