Why don't you believe in Hell?

[Operaider]

Thanks, it makes perfect sense now.... wait... WHAT?

 

[Marquis de Carabas]

This is off subject, but what did you mean when you said

In all fairness, I did take that quote a bit out of context, but it was too good to pass up.

Anyway, 1inC, do you believe me about the afterlife?



edited to add this link for Operaider. It should explain things.

 

[Operaider]

I derailed the conversation. so ...

*Bump*

Nobody has yet given me one good reason for not believing in Hell. Every reason put forth I have refuted. Anyone else?

Marq - When you die, 1inC, if you don't accept David Gilmour as your Saviour, you will spend an eternity listening to Roger Waters whine about WWII.

Do you believe me

 

[c4ts]

Thanks, it makes perfect sense now.... wait... WHAT?

I'm not kidding, that's basically what he said. This was right after he rejected logic as the creation of Satan.

 

[Operaider]

wow, he was really on a roll that night

 

[monkboon]

I derailed the conversation. so ...

*Bump*

Marq - When you die, 1inC, if you don't accept David Gilmour as your Saviour, you will spend an eternity listening to Roger Waters whine about WWII.

Do you believe me

That's obviously wrong, because everyone knows that Roger Waters is the saviour, and David Gilmore the false prophet.

 

[c4ts]

wow, he was really on a roll that night

The thread is in my sig, under "rationalism.... debunked!"

Also the Marquis posted a link to it.

 

[Marquis de Carabas]

That's obviously wrong, because everyone knows that Roger Waters is the saviour, and David Gilmore the false prophet.

Heh, I knew I could start an argument with that post.

 

[monkboon]

Heh, I knew I could start an argument with that post.

I normally wouldn't have bit on it, but, well, this is Roger you were dissin.

 

[c4ts]

That's obviously wrong, because everyone knows that Roger Waters is the saviour, and David Gilmore the false prophet.

You win the debate! Argument by appeal to popularity.

 

[monkboon]

You win the debate! Argument by appeal to popularity.

I'm honored. My first public win, though I've won several already by abstinence.

 

[Marquis de Carabas]

I normally wouldn't have bit on it, but, well, this is Roger you were dissin.

Don't get me wrong. I love Roger. Even went and saw his show a few years back (which was excellent). But he does whine, incessantly, about WWII, Syd, the music industry, burning satin shirts, etc. He whines poetically, I grant, but he still whines.

And David's better musically, I think. Since I tend to focus more on music than lyrics, he wins.

 

[1inChrist]

I believe I won this debate because I have refuted all reasons not to believe in Hell.

 

[Marquis de Carabas]

I believe I won this debate because I have refuted all reasons not to believe in Hell.

Puss believes you're full of sh.

And you never answered my question...



...



...

 

[c4ts]

I believe I won this debate because I have refuted all reasons not to believe in Hell.

Argument by ignoring everybody else.

 

[1inChrist]

Puss believes you're full of sh.

And you never answered my question...



...



...

What question?

 

[monkboon]

And David's better musically, I think.

Agreed. But Gilmore would be nowhere without Waters's lyrics.

Saw Waters in Munich a couple years ago. Best part of the whole trip

 

[Marquis de Carabas]

What question?

[sigh]

When you die, 1inC, if you don't accept David Gilmour as your Saviour, you will spend an eternity listening to Roger Waters whine about WWII.

Do you believe me?

 

[monkboon]

I believe I won this debate because I have refuted all reasons not to believe in Hell.

So, you've been there?

 

[Marquis de Carabas]

Agreed. But Gilmore would be nowhere without Waters's lyrics.

Saw Waters in Munich a couple years ago. Best part of the whole trip

Yeah, they needed each other, I think. Neither of them has been as good since the split. I think their egos drove them to critique each other so heavily to push the product towards perfection that they'd have not attained without.