Why do we continue to hear about Israel targeting civilians?

Hello? Incoming!

Actually, I believe the onus is on you to back up your statement. You made the observation of "...the Israeli way of war which does not seem to have changed very much."

I have pointed out one glaring difference that does demonstrate change from the past - the use of flyers dropped in the area to warn civilians of impending attack. Doing that would also imply that Israel is not merely giving lip service about avoiding innocent civilian deaths, but are proactively making the effort.

So do you still stand by the claim that it's business as usual for Israel as per the statements you cited by Gur?

The IDF is now making phone calls to the residents of the various locations which are about to be bombed!
I kid you not.
http://www.smh.com.au/news/world/unsolicited-phone-calls/2006/07/28/1153816380821.html
 
Someone (on another board) claims that the dropping flyers etc. thing to evacuate the citizens violates still international law, because it forces the civilians to become refugees. He also claimed that Israel is the biggest violator of international law of the region. :boggled:

I'm no expert on international law so I couldn't agree with nor refute it. Anyone?
 
Well, it's really his obligation to support that with legal citations. It's very hard to prove a negative.
 
[start bad joke] Maybe they accuse the Israeli of inflicting paper cuts? [end bad joke]

carry on
 
Where do you get this 100 % approval? I'd be glad to read where you get your figures. From what I know of Lebanese people where I live, they are very peaceful people,

They are in Canada are they not? A different social construct.

I doubt they all approve of this terrorist organization (at least before the Israeli attacks).

Ahh, so you too believe the only terrorists are ones with a genuine grievance? They voted pretty unanimously for Hizbullah. Hizbullah has always said it was at war, wanted war, intended war. Your excuses are getting petty.


No, I was saying the majority of Quebecers didn't approve of the FLQ but yet 497 people were arrested, and only 62 were charged. I call that excessive measures. My point of this analogy was that you can't blame an entire people for one group of extremists.

13% of those arrested were charged? That sounds like a pretty impressive percentage to me.

There you go again about the "entire people" and "one group of extremists", when it appears that these are pretty much one and the same.


But you're right, it was a clumsy analogy.

OK

I guess you're right, the Lebanese and their government are responsible for letting Hizbollah remain influent, or even exist. But I still think you can't blame all Lebanese, there's a limit of what innocent civilians can do to change things.

I don't blame all Lebanese. I have friends in Lebanon too, but they don't want another civil war. So you are right there are limits, and Israel has reached the limit and has to do what the Lebanese can't or won't.

Other reasons explain why the Hizbollah remained influent, you can't blame the Libanese people for everything.

Other reasons, other excuses. There are always reasons and they may very well be real, but one can't wish them away.

Even Bush said so in his 'talk' with Blair: "We are not blaming the Lebanese government."

It's true, because it is recognized that they are a government in name only. We should be bombing Syria and Iran, and I suspect we will eventually.
 
some kind of point

First of all, you're the one who grought up that poll to make some kind of a point, so you're the one who should have searched it through. Don't turn the burden of proof on me.

Secondly, how can you expect me to believe this poll to be valid and scientific when the country's population and infrastructures are being bombarded?

I expect you to regard my posting linking to the reporting of a poll result as acceptable and relevent data, in support of the point that nearly 100% of the Shi'ia Lebanese support the actions of Hezbollah, and huge percentages of the other segments of Lebanese society do as well.

If you want to argue that my mentioning the report of the data is from a dubious or fabricated source, (and by extension, that Ha'aretz journalist Zvi Bar'el is lying or mistaken), then I think that you would have to go ahead and be the one to do some further research and show what the real facts are. Why you would not be perfectly satisfied with the source I offered is a mystery to me. Am I well-known to just make stuff up here on JREF? No. I'm probably one of the more scrupulous providers of sources and website links to almost every piece of information I provide. You will notice that a large percent of my posts have blue links in them.
I certainly don't need to "jump through hoops for pardalis" ----

But, to help with your pursuit of the facts, I'll give you a head-start and point out that BLOOMBERG offers the same data.
Actually, I'm not sure why you're arguing this point with me.
There is nothing 'supernatural' or 'hocus-pocus' in a poll result showing overwhelming Public Approval of Hezbollah.

  • About 70 percent of Lebanese approve of Hezbollah's capture of two Israeli soldiers in the July 12 raid that sparked Israel's offensive, according to a poll of 800 people published July 26 by the Beirut Center for Research and Information.

You and a_u_p are saying that "the Lebanese are not (all) Hezbollah" and I countered with the point which illustrates the wide and popular support of these maniac terrorists. For that, after all, is exactly what they are.

Here is a poll taken in the Palestinian Authority -- would you wish to claim it's not valid or scientific, because the palestinians 'population and infrastructure' are also being bombarded?
http://www.miftah.org/Display.cfm?DocId=10909&CategoryId=17

96.3% from among respondents assess their attitudes towards Hezbollah as 'good'.
 
Your excuses are getting petty.

I'm not making excuses.

There you go again about the "entire people" and "one group of extremists", when it appears that these are pretty much one and the same.

I disagree. Are all Americans part of the KKK?

I don't blame all Lebanese. I have friends in Lebanon too, but they don't want another civil war.

So you do agree that the entire Lebanese people are not all terrorists? So why are we arguing ? Why did you say this then?:

There you go again about the "entire people" and "one group of extremists", when it appears that these are pretty much one and the same.


We should be bombing Syria and Iran, and I suspect we will eventually.

Good luck with that. :rolleyes:
 
I expect you to regard my posting linking to the reporting of a poll result as acceptable and relevent data, in support of the point that nearly 100% of the Shi'ia Lebanese support the actions of Hezbollah, and huge percentages of the other segments of Lebanese society do as well.

edited for space

OK, you have proven your point. I really didn't mean anything wrong, I just thought it was odd that a poll could be made under these circumstances.

Gees, this is a sensitive issue.
 
Last edited:
Or else what...?
This is where the "peace now" folks get stumped and change the subject. They are full of ideas about what Israel shouldn't do, but have no suggestions as to what they should do to permanently end the war.
 
Gees, this is a sensitive issue.

You think?

I have friends & relatives in Israel who are getting their country bombed for nothing. I was sent a call-up notice to come back and fight in this war (I am a reserves Sergeant in the IDF).

On July 11th, there was no threat to Lebanon from Israel. The Lebanese were in the midst of a huge tourist season, with casinos, beaches and restaurants & hotels filled to capacity.

Out of the clear morning sky 9am 7-12-06, missiles started flying from Iranian-proxy terrorists in South Lebanon at Israeli civilian population centers, at an obscure place you never before heard of, SHLOMI.
(which is based on the Hebrew word Shalom - peace)

Whatever has happened subsequently in response from Israel, is not immoral, is not targeting civilians, is not war crimes, is not massacres.

Israel is pursuing a fair combat goal --- to put an end to Lebanon being a base of operations for Iranian-proxy terrorists.

This goal is being simultaneously pursued against Iranian-proxy islamic terrorists in Gaza and the West Bank.

And I'll say one more thing -- Israel will win. No matter what the cost to Lebanon's or to Gaza's populations --- that is the bottom line.

It is ironic that the Japanese Prime Minister was present in Israel at the time (July 12th) when the events of that fateful morning brought the IDF into war.

We know how the Japanese were brought to surrender in WWII: Despite their absorbing horrific bombings daily, it still took two nuclear detonations on Nagasaki and Hiroshima to put an end to it.

(In Korea, it took the threat of this same result to cause that war to end).
(In many places still today, nuclear threats are effective and considered legitimate means to dissuade enemies from attacking or continuing to attack).

I don't know what will bring the Hezbollah (and by extension, Lebanon) and the HAMAS (by extension, the Palestinian Authority of Gaza and the West Bank) to surrender.

But surrender they are going to do.
 
This is where the "peace now" folks get stumped and change the subject. They are full of ideas about what Israel shouldn't do, but have no suggestions as to what they should do to permanently end the war.
Kill everyone else, right? Seriously, any other suggestions?
 
I can't figure out what you're asking here. :confused:
You were asking what they should do to permanently end the war. I see two options, leaving Israel or creating a large enough body count to make sure no one else feels the need to commit terrorist acts against them. The US won't help, the UN won't help, diplomacy won't help. No other ME country will help. The Palestenians refuse to help themselves. They absolutely refuse to let the smallest infraction go. So, what other options do they have to permanently end the war?
 
Kill everyone else, right? Seriously, any other suggestions?

The road to a cease-fire and the return of Goldwasser, Regev (and Shalit) leads through ----- Damascus.

The Syrians want to be given the benefits of being back in the good graces of the USA, and they certainly have a vested interest in the Shaba Farms, and they have a great deal of influence with Khaled Mashaal (HAMAS) and I would think that for all the above practical reasons, Sec'y Rice might wish to consider arranging a little visit to talk to Bashir.

Most likely, the Israelis would have no objection!
http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/spages/744003.html
 
The road to a cease-fire and the return of Goldwasser, Regev (and Shalit) leads through ----- Damascus.

The Syrians want to be given the benefits of being back in the good graces of the USA, and they certainly have a vested interest in the Shaba Farms, and they have a great deal of influence with Khaled Mashaal (HAMAS) and I would think that for all the above practical reasons, Sec'y Rice might wish to consider arranging a little visit to talk to Bashir.

Most likely, the Israelis would have no objection!
http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/spages/744003.html
That's fine for a cease fire, but ending the war permanantly?
 
You were asking what they should do to permanently end the war. I see two options, leaving Israel or creating a large enough body count to make sure no one else feels the need to commit terrorist acts against them. The US won't help, the UN won't help, diplomacy won't help. No other ME country will help. The Palestenians refuse to help themselves. They absolutely refuse to let the smallest infraction go. So, what other options do they have to permanently end the war?
That appears to be the only solution at this point, doesn't it? But as webfusion points out, perhaps Syria wishes to become part of the civilized world.
 
That's fine for a cease fire, but ending the war permanantly?

Yes.

The main sticking point, as is well documented, concerns the Har Dov salient on the Golan Heights. The other sticking point is the issue of mines (see: UNIFIL-MACC). The prisoners will go to the bottom of the 'wish list' and since the Iranians and the Syrians are in lock-step, whatever the two of them say, goes. Hezbollah would likely even copy HAMAS, and declare a 'tadiya'.
http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/spages/744003.html

Iranian chief nuclear negotiator Ali Larijani is the key to all this. He is waiting in Damascus for the USA to approach him with an offer. That's what's underlying everything.
Once that fact is recognized, all the other issues fall into place.
 
I'm not making excuses.



I disagree. Are all Americans part of the KKK?



So you do agree that the entire Lebanese people are not all terrorists? So why are we arguing ? Why did you say this then?:

Perhaps I should have explained something that I took for granted you recognized.

Some 40% of the population in Lebanon, mostly southern Lebanon is Shiite, and of them pretty much 100% support Hizbullah.

The Christians, Druze and I dare say Sunnis who make up the rest probably hate Hizbullah as much as Israel does, but their only option to do anything about them is another civil war.

KKK and other similar references are about as relevant as the previous one you agreed was poor.:D
 
Perhaps I should have explained something that I took for granted you recognized.

Some 40% of the population in Lebanon, mostly southern Lebanon is Shiite, and of them pretty much 100% support Hizbullah.

The Christians, Druze and I dare say Sunnis who make up the rest probably hate Hizbullah as much as Israel does, but their only option to do anything about them is another civil war.

KKK and other similar references are about as relevant as the previous one you agreed was poor.:D

OK, so in retrospect, we both agree with what AUP said:

The Lebanese are not Hizbollah.

Or, more specifically, not all Lebanese are Hizbollah.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom