Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Oh boy here we go the strawman, this thread never changes.

Did you even read the contents of the link you posted?

One of the criteria used to measure the effectiveness of each treatment is labelled:

"Mean Severity of Treatment Population"

Any idea how they arrive at those numbers?

Straight into the rabbit hole, where pointing out a red herring is considered a strawman...

They definitely didn't get their methodology out of the Big Book.
 
I've been in A.A for three years and never experienced anything close to what you're describing, sorry it didn't work for you.

Oh yes...the "I've never seen that in all my years." It applies to all things AA: 13th stepping, people being encouraged to stop taking their prescription medication, etc. If in this case you are saying that you have never seen an AA fundie, big book thumper; or you have never seen someone encouraged to use something like an inanimate object, the AA group itself, or some other mystical thing like "the spirit of the universe; as their higher power, I would have to say you are using the patented AA brand of rigorous honesty™.

A simple google search of "group of drunks" or "god of my understanding" will take you to a treasure trove of suggested deities. Tomorrow's post on our blog, Stinkin Thinkin (I'm Ilsita's co-writer) is of someone encouraged to use their Wicca god as their higher power. And as long as we're pretending not to have seen an AA fundamentalist, I'll encourage you to google "back to basics AA," where you'll find more AA nazis than you can shake a stick at.

As for AA "not working for me," it doesn't work for anyone. Faith healing doesn't work (Really). There is no god waiting in the wings as you're getting sloppy drunk, waiting for you to attend meetings and work steps so he can remove your addiction. It's woo. Plus, the coffee usually sucks.

I don't drink anymore, and used the same one-step method most people use: I quit drinking. It's simple, and unlike AA, there is an exit strategy; and it doesn't require the cognitive dissonance and mental gymnastics necessary to make it through AA.
 
I don't drink anymore, and used the same one-step method most people use: I quit drinking. It's simple, and unlike AA, there is an exit strategy; and it doesn't require the cognitive dissonance and mental gymnastics necessary to make it through AA.

Ah yes, Just Say No. That was a very succesful program as well. I mean as long as you are casting stones.

Your position then is that all addicts should just be able to quit, with your patented one-step program?

Sorry for the snark, but the AA true-believers are no worse than the "just shut up and stop drinking" crowd when it comes to actual solutions. You're interested in winning an internet argument more than actually helping anyone, I think.

Ilsita provided me a link to the SMART program. It looks interesting. But you would disaprove, I guess? Why? Why is outside help not allowed, in your world?

Drugs or alcohol, there are people out there who need help quitting. Saying to them they should just quit is bull.
 
Could anyone for just one minute please forget the OFFICIAL AA POSITION and please focus on the idea that the practice occurs within these groups, under the aegis of AA?

Could anyone manage to do that?

I agree, there is the structure of each group, which varies based upon the members. The official AA is more of the network than the existing groups. But AA itself is an aggregate of separate groups and members.

I have seen wide variation between groups, but groups tend to self select similar attitudes.

My bigger issues with AA have to do with the problems in not vetting sponsors.
 
Yeah, the number of drunks who need help, and are dissuaded from AA by threads like this on forums like this are being hurt, will continue to be hurt, and far exceed the few here and elsewhere who weren't able to graciously accept what was offered, or find alternatives that suited them.

Um really?

People will not be dissuaded by these threads.

To each thier own stinking thinking, if we all said "AA is great place you should try it", it would make no difference.

Seriously AlBell , we are not going to change anyone attending or not attending, they make that choice themselves.

I can say that people should use relapse prevention strategies and try rational recovery if they don't like the god thing, it won't matter.

Addicts avoid accountability until they are ready to take it (I hate teh bottom theory, there is no bottom), if AA and the whole proces of recovery involves accountability, then they will avoid it until they take the first step and make the Big Choice.

Choose not to use.

I met some real scumbags at meetings, arrogant piss asses who sat there and played their pity card and then said how grateful they were to not be pitiful wrecks like the rest of us. That sort of stuff is why people turn away from AA and why I prefer the DFD groups.

But hearing people 'read my mail' and then talk about how they were determined to not use, that is what I needed to nere. So I ignored the ******** and kept going. I went to AA because the NA meetings were even worse.
 
Last edited:
Brutal. Co-ed sponsership? Yeah it's not supposed to happen but, people do look the other way!

You can have co-ed sponsors, but the sponsor better have iron clad boundaries.

And why there is an unofficial rule of recovery:

The first year is for sobriety, no dating, no new relationships. Period.
The second year is to find new friends and new playgrounds, AA is NOT the place to do that.


Most of my issues with AA are the ******** that passes for sponorship, they are the source of so much error.
 
Ah yes, Just Say No.
You can't say no. You have to follwo one simple rule DFD, Don't *********** Drink, whatever it takes, DFD.

Just say no won't do it.

That is also Trimpey's Big Choice.
Ilsita provided me a link to the SMART program.
I like RR and SOS as well, I personally use to use a relapse prevention model.
Drugs or alcohol, there are people out there who need help quitting. Saying to them they should just quit is bull.

It is not just quiting it is more complex, but not using is where it happens. Some people need detox to be safe.

Many need mentors and guidance.
 
Your position then is that all addicts should just be able to quit, with your patented one-step program?

Sorry for the snark, but the AA true-believers are no worse than the "just shut up and stop drinking" crowd when it comes to actual solutions. You're interested in winning an internet argument more than actually helping anyone, I think.

Ilsita provided me a link to the SMART program. It looks interesting. But you would disaprove, I guess? Why? Why is outside help not allowed, in your world?

Drugs or alcohol, there are people out there who need help quitting. Saying to them they should just quit is bull.

So, I just said that I quit on my own, and you extrapolated from that my position on recovery programs, explained it to me, and then told me how I am wrong in thinking it. You were talking about straw man arguments earlier. Well, that is a straw man. Anyway....

First, the topic of the thread is whether or not AA is religious, not to spoon feed you alternative recovery programs. I'm not quite sure why you think I have some sort of obligation to provide you with recovery choices. I'm internet guy, not your addictions counselor.

Having said that, if you think SMART or Rational Recovery or LifeRing or any other program will help you to actualize your quit, then more power to you. You may want to check out the Sinclair Method. Hell, I don't even care if you want to go to AA.

Of course, you are more likely to quit on your own, using my one-step method. I can't link posts yet, but if you add www onto this address, it is a link to the NIAAA site: spectrum.niaaa.nih.gov/features/alcoholism.aspx The idea that someone can't quit drinking on their own is just fiction. Most people do.
 
Great, that's why AA should be paying attention them as well then, they don't know how to help people with varying degrees of problems. Also, I wasn't aware that there were kinds of alcoholism that aren't alcoholism.



I'll let Ali Jaffe, phD addiction researcher, former abstainer explain for context.

Calling ******** on addiction treatment bullies
The "my way or the highway" version of addiction treatment is simply wrong


How many people leave AA, get themselves together and a drink normally for the rest of their lives? A lot. Part of the problem is what is "true alcoholic" and how do you distinguish? A disorder of the reward system, quite a malady, but a complex diagnosis, surely. I've heard that if you can go into the bar, have one drink, and not compulsively continue, you're not an alcoholic. That's literally how it is explained to some people in the program, I don't know how often. This is obviously ********...

Why? If you have a good relationship with them and they are knowledgeable it helps people. The whole "doctors don't understand alcoholism" thing is so 1939. A doctor isn't a support group of fellow abstainers, but they are valuable, not laughable.

Could be true for the people you talked to, doesn't mean they don't work for others with varying degrees of alcoholism or different genetic make-ups or whatever. There was a weight of evidence attached to those numbers...

That's awesome, hearing that success or hearing of birthdays in the program always lifts my heart. It has also helped several members of my family (or so they say ;) ) I've said before, I wouldn't dare to tell them to leave the program. I made my concerns known and surprisingly they agreed that these things were true and it was wacky but they just wanted to stay sober and help others so they put up with it for now, one day at a time.

The question of what constitutes an alcoholic is one I've thought about many times over the years (and probably played a part in me not getting sober sooner than I did). I tried to convince myself time and again over the years that I didn't have a serious drinking problem, I just needed to control it better.

As someone who has been drunk at least 5 000 times in his life and has at one time or another been assoociated with dozens (if not hundreds) of chronic drinkers, I'm not sure if there is much middle ground though I could be wrong.

I'd go into furthur detail but it would be a huge derail. Maybe I'll start a thread in the appropriate sub-forum because I think it would be an interesting discussion and I'd learn quite a bit from it.


Anyway, I'd be interested in exploring the claim you made that alot of people have left AA and resumed drinking "normally" . Do you have any cites for it?
 
Oh yes...the "I've never seen that in all my years." It applies to all things AA: 13th stepping, people being encouraged to stop taking their prescription medication, etc. If in this case you are saying that you have never seen an AA fundie, big book thumper; or you have never seen someone encouraged to use something like an inanimate object, the AA group itself, or some other mystical thing like "the spirit of the universe; as their higher power, I would have to say you are using the patented AA brand of rigorous honesty™.

A simple google search of "group of drunks" or "god of my understanding" will take you to a treasure trove of suggested deities. Tomorrow's post on our blog, Stinkin Thinkin (I'm Ilsita's co-writer) is of someone encouraged to use their Wicca god as their higher power. And as long as we're pretending not to have seen an AA fundamentalist, I'll encourage you to google "back to basics AA," where you'll find more AA nazis than you can shake a stick at.

As for AA "not working for me," it doesn't work for anyone. Faith healing doesn't work (Really). There is no god waiting in the wings as you're getting sloppy drunk, waiting for you to attend meetings and work steps so he can remove your addiction. It's woo. Plus, the coffee usually sucks.

I don't drink anymore, and used the same one-step method most people use: I quit drinking. It's simple, and unlike AA, there is an exit strategy; and it doesn't require the cognitive dissonance and mental gymnastics necessary to make it through AA.

No I've never met a bible thumper "fundie" in AA, if I did and he/she started preaching to me, I'd tell them to get lost.

I've heard many suggestions for a higher power and yes I agree some of them are ridiculous. I think the point of it is to bring our focus elsewhere. Dynamic explained it very well earlier in the thread comparing it to suspending belief, like we do while watching a movie or attending a magic show.

As for the one step method, I tried it hundreds of times, along with 3 psychiatrists, a psychotherapist, a couple of family doctors, group therapy and one-on-one addiction counselling. Unfortunately none of that was successful.
 
So, I just said that I quit on my own, and you extrapolated from that my position on recovery programs, explained it to me, and then told me how I am wrong in thinking it. You were talking about straw man arguments earlier. Well, that is a straw man. Anyway....

First, the topic of the thread is whether or not AA is religious, not to spoon feed you alternative recovery programs. I'm not quite sure why you think I have some sort of obligation to provide you with recovery choices. I'm internet guy, not your addictions counselor.

Having said that, if you think SMART or Rational Recovery or LifeRing or any other program will help you to actualize your quit, then more power to you. You may want to check out the Sinclair Method. Hell, I don't even care if you want to go to AA.

Of course, you are more likely to quit on your own, using my one-step method. I can't link posts yet, but if you add www onto this address, it is a link to the NIAAA site: spectrum.niaaa.nih.gov/features/alcoholism.aspx The idea that someone can't quit drinking on their own is just fiction. Most people do.

I don't put much faith in a study that uses a survey of problem drinkers who are notorious liars as it's focus. I know I filled out at least 10 questionnaires concerning alcohol over the years and lied on every single one of them.

A study where alcoholics were examined in a doctor's office on a regular basis would be much more helpful in my opinion.
 
No I've never met a bible thumper "fundie" in AA, if I did and he/she started preaching to me, I'd tell them to get lost.

1. Then I'd introduce you to my ex, and you'd have met one.
Unfortunately, he's run away from rehab and cannot be found.

2. Attend meetings in the Deep South of the U.S. Wherever you find a large number of Charismatic Evangelical Fundamentalist Christians, you will surely find a correspondingly larger number of alcoholic Charismatic Evangelical Fundamentalist Christians.
 
Nice dodge, care to answer the question?

Well, I definitely don't care to walk into AA's coo-coo bananas hall of mirrors with you, but are you really asking me how people are assessed for alcohol dependence and how a mean is found? Or... wha'd I miss?
 
Last edited:
1. Then I'd introduce you to my ex, and you'd have met one.
Unfortunately, he's run away from rehab and cannot be found.

2. Attend meetings in the Deep South of the U.S. Wherever you find a large number of Charismatic Evangelical Fundamentalist Christians, you will surely find a correspondingly larger number of alcoholic Charismatic Evangelical Fundamentalist Christians.

Yes it seems groups from different areas have a different feel to them.

If I happened to live in a christian belt I fear I'd still be drinking, that nonsense is a real turn off. I wish they'd remove the word god from the Big Book altogether, but for me the good outwieghs the bad..
 
Well, I definitely don't care to walk into AA's coo-coo bananas hall of mirrors with you, but are you really asking me how people are assessed for alcohol dependence and how a mean is found? Or... wha'd I miss?

I've started a thread over here:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=7299160#post7299160

The link you posted pertains to many differing levels of drinking As I stated a few posts ago some of those therapies didn't work for me and I believe the reason why is directed related to the severity of my alcoholism. We can discuss it there if you'd like.
 
Yes it seems groups from different areas have a different feel to them.

If I happened to live in a christian belt I fear I'd still be drinking, that nonsense is a real turn off. I wish they'd remove the word god from the Big Book altogether, but for me the good outwieghs the bad..

I can agree with all you've said. The good tends to outweigh the bad, but I'd prefer god be removed from the Big Book, too.
 
I thought you guys might be interested in this story, about a couple of secular AA groups who were purged from the local AA schedules, because if you take the God out, it's not AA anymore. I posted about it here:

stinkin-thinkin.com/2011/06/04/clowns-to-the-left-of-me/
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom