Great, that's why AA should be paying attention them as well then, they don't know how to help people with varying degrees of problems. Also, I wasn't aware that there were kinds of alcoholism that aren't alcoholism.
I'll let Ali Jaffe, phD addiction researcher, former abstainer explain for context.
Calling ******** on addiction treatment bullies
The "my way or the highway" version of addiction treatment is simply wrong
How many people leave AA, get themselves together and a drink normally for the rest of their lives? A lot. Part of the problem is what is "true alcoholic" and how do you distinguish? A disorder of the reward system, quite a malady, but a complex diagnosis, surely. I've heard that if you can go into the bar, have one drink, and not compulsively continue, you're not an alcoholic. That's literally how it is explained to some people in the program, I don't know how often. This is obviously ********...
Why? If you have a good relationship with them and they are knowledgeable it helps people. The whole "doctors don't understand alcoholism" thing is so 1939. A doctor isn't a support group of fellow abstainers, but they are valuable, not laughable.
Could be true for the people you talked to, doesn't mean they don't work for others with varying degrees of alcoholism or different genetic make-ups or whatever. There was a weight of evidence attached to those numbers...
That's awesome, hearing that success or hearing of birthdays in the program always lifts my heart. It has also helped several members of my family (or so they say

) I've said before, I wouldn't dare to tell them to leave the program. I made my concerns known and surprisingly they agreed that these things were true and it was wacky but they just wanted to stay sober and help others so they put up with it for now, one day at a time.