When will the AE911 petition finally reach juggernaut strength of 1%?

When will the AE911 petition reach juggernaut strength of 1%?

  • 20 years

    Votes: 3 1.4%
  • 50 years

    Votes: 2 0.9%
  • Never

    Votes: 80 36.4%
  • Who cares?….it's retarded anyway.....

    Votes: 135 61.4%

  • Total voters
    220
AE911T Facebook page lost more than 10,000 likes in one day!

I have been monitoring the development of AE911T's Facebook "likes" closely since early december, and got some numbers going back to August 2012.

During that time, they picked up roughly around 200 "Likes" per day on average (min/max averages for periods between 1 month and 1 year were 164/283). I had previously noted that the increase from day to day has a weird behaviour - sometimes you'd see around, say, +150/day for a week, then suddenly it jumps to around +270 for a few day, then drops to around +190 for days. Last month, they were rather steady in the vicinity of 230 except for three consecutive days when they were >500. This month so far, things generally went slow with around 130-140 per day. Something must be driving this - but I see no correlation to any newsletters, postings or whatever.

Then, yesterday, I noticed that the total number had dropped by -10,456 from the day before (from 266,945 to 256,489). Any ideas how this happens - if it's not a database glitch on Facebook's part? Perhaps FB eliminated thousands of spam/fake accounts in one swoop? I know very little about Facebook and its inner workings, and how it gets abused...

If a user is removed from fb, do their 'likes' disappear? Large scale db cleanups might produce such numbers on fb's huge user base.
 
Then, yesterday, I noticed that the total number had dropped by -10,456 from the day before (from 266,945 to 256,489). Any ideas how this happens - if it's not a database glitch on Facebook's part? Perhaps FB eliminated thousands of spam/fake accounts in one swoop? I know very little about Facebook and its inner workings, and how it gets abused...
An entire industry has spawned around buying & seling Facebook/Twitter likes, most of which are of course a small group of people creating a large number accounts. 5000 likes can be had for ~$96 and most of the sellers will offer a small number of likes (usually around 50) as a free taster.

Facebook/Twitter (and just about everyone else) likes to do large banwaves when dealing with accounts like these, so I'd imagine one just went out over the weekend.
 
I wasn't aware AE911 had a Facebook page. It's obvious they are buying "likes" as KD described above. You can do the same with Youtube as well.

Colour me surprised, a group supposedly searching for the "truth" is caught doing shady things yet again.
 
I wouldn't say yet it's "obvious" and they've "been caught". It's a plausible suspicion for which we don't have sufficient evidence.
 
U.S. Dept of Commerce says that 20.5 m people with at least one science or engineering degree. So I think they can celebrate when they reach 0.1% of their potential audience
 
I wouldn't say yet it's "obvious" and they've "been caught". It's a plausible suspicion for which we don't have sufficient evidence.

Well considering less than a tenth of the people who have supposedly liked the page have also signed their idiotic petition and the fact they have very few people commenting on their wall posts it's obvious to me the number is artificially inflated.

The "like" total juxtaposed against the number of people making comments doesn't wash either. You have 250k+ likes yet 3 or 4 people comment on the updates. Seems fishy to me. And judging by how much they lie, I'd need considerable evidence they are not gaming the system before I'd believe those likes are legitimate.

Add in the fact 10 thousand likes went missing overnight and the only explanation for that would be Facebook security doing yet again another sweep of fake accounts, I that's all the proof I need. More info on the subject can be found here: https://nakedsecurity.sophos.com/20...es-but-the-fans-for-sale-industry-is-booming/

If you'd like to wait for more evidence that's certainly your prerogative. Personally I don't trust the dishonest clowns at AE911and until I get a plausible explanation of why the number of likes doesn't correlate to page activity as well as a reason the numbers took a drastic turn downward in such a short time, I'm going to go with my original assessment of them being shady.
 
Here is a rare insight into the inner workings of AE911Truth!

Retired architect Ronald F. Avery of Seguin, Texas, who was one of the earliest petition signers in June 2007 (so early that he never had his "biography" and "personal 9/11-statement" filled in the form, which later became a requirement) has been removed from the list during the last week. Googling around, I first found this 4-page invitation to a Christopher-Bollyn presentation, dated Jan 26, 2015. It reeks of classical, christian-colored antisemitism:
http://www.lawfulgovernment.com/pastors-911-bollyn.pdf


Then I found his Facebook page where, on January 28, 2015, he dcoumented an interesting exchange of mails with a certain William Jacoby of AE911Truth. Let me quote in full, and in chronological order:



So it looks like AE911T tries to distance itself from over racists - not so much because of rejection of their vile world view but for tactical / PR reasons.

One thing that has me wondering is this William Jacoby fellow: He has not signerd the AE911T petition (neither as A or E nor as "general public"), nor does a search for "Jacoby" on ae911truth.org yield any results.

Ronald Avery's signature is back.
Seems like anti-semites aren't a problem for Gage after all.
 
I watched Avery's presentation. He seems clueless to me about the structure and the collapse and goes to show that an architect can also be stupid.... and I didn't even know about his antisemitism.

Apparently "anti" government position advocacy groups such as AE and other 9/11 truth groups attracts all manner of people who want to get into the spotlight and get credibility from the organization they join and speak on their behalf.

Having racists would be a problem for AE even if they agree with their crazy conspiracy ideas. Perhaps Harrit is not an antisemite... but his wife is and that doesn't seem to be a problem for the truth movement and perhaps it shouldn't be. On the other hand I find it odd that someone would be married to a very "out" antisemite and either agree with their spouse's views or not find them objectionable. Either would be troubling (to me).
 
...Perhaps Harrit is not an antisemite... but his wife is and that doesn't seem to be a problem for the truth movement and perhaps it shouldn't be. On the other hand I find it odd that someone would be married to a very "out" antisemite and either agree with their spouse's views or not find them objectionable. Either would be troubling (to me).

I think a third possibility is more likely: That Harrit doesn't recognize his wife's anti-semitism. For which more than one explanation is possible - rose-tinted glasses, personal confusion about where legitimate criticism toward (Israeli etc.) policies ends and anti-semitism begins, or both, or other...
 
A quarte has ended - time for statistics!


1.) The AE911Truth "Petition"

This 1. Quarter 2015 was their worst ever in both the "Architects & Engineers" (henceforth: AE) and "General Population" (Other Supporters; henceforth: OS) categories:
  • 17 new AE in 3 months beats the previous record low of 19, set in Q3/2012
  • 135 new OS in 3 months beats the previous record low of 139, set in Q4/2007.
It marks the fifth quarter in a row that new AE signatures were below the previous year (that's comparing Q1/2015 with Q1/2014, Q4/2014 with Q4/2013, and so forth):



They have been getting slightly under 0.19 signatures per day from AE:


Expressed as an annual growth rate, that's 3% growth per year, which is equivalent to each "member" convincing another professional to sign once every 33 years.


As for Other Supporters, they signed up 1.5 of those per day, which translates to an annual growth of 2.8%, or 1 new OS per existing OS per 36 years.


Development of the signatures/day pace, month by month:



The current "business year" June-May (I start with June, because the oldest archived petition data is from May 2007, so I start with the first full month I can measure) is on track to being the worst of eight years so far in both categories:




2.) Facebook "Likes"

Interesting development! Remember the >10,000 "Likes" they lost earlier this month? I speculated that Facebook may be cracking down on some "Likes" inflation scheme - and looks like I could be right!

First, here is how the total number developed:



You see the step down on March 14. It's not huge - about -4%.
But now see how the number of Likes per day has dropped, too:



(Note: the the intervals before december 2014 have unequal legths and are thus not fully comparable. Larger ups and downs would average out)

The long-term average typically was 160-180 likes/day (this means: Neither exponential growth - nothing goes viral - nor the slump that is rather typical for fads). Then it increased to around 280 for a couple of months. Actually, it was like 230-240 on most days, with 3 exceptional days.

With the beginning of March, most days only had 120-160 likes/day.
On March 14, 10,456 Likes had gone.
Since then, they had under 100 likes/day on most day and average only 86! That's only 40% of what they had in January and February. I am convinced this is because Facebook stopped some Likes-faking scheme!


3.) Homepage traffic

Since the web design relaunch, there is no traffic counter on the start page www.ae911truth.org, but the legacy page (old layout) at www1.ae911truth.org keeps counting. I don't know if that still captures all content page hits, for the old AND new design, but it seems plausible it does, for the statistics continue a steady trend with no discontinuity in early January when they relaunched the site. The trend is straight down since the annual attention peak in september (anniversary month), losing between 800 and 1100 hits/day every month:



For 12 months in a row, from March 2014 to February 2014, traffic had been higher than the year before. That trend was now broken in March 2015, which had 23% less traffic than March 2014. I sense that the relaunch didn't help at all.

(But all of this depends on what the traffic counter actually counts; if, for example, mobile traffic is not counted, then the analysis is naught.)
 
Your stats are awesome Oystein, keep up the work :)

oh, and I'm cracking up about their facebook "likes" ha!
 
Your stats are awesome Oystein, keep up the work :)

oh, and I'm cracking up about their facebook "likes" ha!

I agree, thanks for these Oystein, I take great pleasure in watching AE911 stats in decline. Pretty soon Dick's gonna have to get a real job.
 
I agree, thanks for these Oystein, I take great pleasure in watching AE911 stats in decline. Pretty soon Dick's gonna have to get a real job.

Don't declare them dead just yet. I did that 2 years ago, and then they rebounded for a relatively strong 2013, when especially the money flow was strong, but the signatures, too
 
Lovely stats, Oystein!

On "like farms":

http://www.abc.net.au/news/2014-11-28/perils-of-buying-facebook-likes-from-india/5925254

"Facebook users warned against buying 'likes' from Indian click farms to boost popularity"

"The social networking site does not allow fake accounts, so those selling fake likes often try to do so discreetly."

"He warns paying for popularity has its downsides because Facebook only posts content out to a certain number of a person's followers. So the more fake friends you have, the fewer real followers see your posts."
 
Now some stats on their "News" articles and their authors:

Since last September 01, almost 8 months ago, there have been 31 news articles - 4 per month on average.

The most prolific writer, with 6 articles, was journalist Craig McKee, a Pentagon no-planer, followed by Frances T. Shure., a psychologist (those are all articles in a series) and Simon Falkner (business student) and Chris Sarns (carpenter) with so far 4 parts of a 6-part series. 2 articles each are credited to Dahlia Mae Lachlan, a kids' book author apparently, and James McDowell who seems to be a musician, sound engineer, and carpenter (if he is the only James McDowell on the petition).
5 articles are credited to AE911Truth Staff, whoever that is.

Only 2 of the 31 articles are written by engineers:
Dick Scar is an aerospace engineer
Mike Bondi is an electronics or electrical engineer


The other writers with 1 article each are
Cheryl Erland - Banking, Freelance writer
Gary Alexander - Journalist, arts critic and former magazine editor
Josef Hanji - Teacher
Robert McGee - Philosophy major, Real estate seller
Russ Baker - ?
Ted Walter - ?
and finally
Richard Gage - Architect
 
Now some stats on their "News" articles and their authors:

Since last September 01, almost 8 months ago, there have been 31 news articles - 4 per month on average.

The most prolific writer, with 6 articles, was journalist Craig McKee, a Pentagon no-planer, followed by Frances T. Shure., a psychologist (those are all articles in a series) and Simon Falkner (business student) and Chris Sarns (carpenter) with so far 4 parts of a 6-part series. 2 articles each are credited to Dahlia Mae Lachlan, a kids' book author apparently, and James McDowell who seems to be a musician, sound engineer, and carpenter (if he is the only James McDowell on the petition).
5 articles are credited to AE911Truth Staff, whoever that is.

Only 2 of the 31 articles are written by engineers:
Dick Scar is an aerospace engineer
Mike Bondi is an electronics or electrical engineer


The other writers with 1 article each are
Cheryl Erland - Banking, Freelance writer
Gary Alexander - Journalist, arts critic and former magazine editor
Josef Hanji - Teacher
Robert McGee - Philosophy major, Real estate seller
Russ Baker - ?
Ted Walter - ?
and finally
Richard Gage - Architect
Thanks for that Oystein. I have, on many occasions, pointed out that despite their loudly touting their contingent of architects and engineers, AE911T has had very little research or papers authored by an engineer or architect. Even fewer authored by such who have relevant qualification and/or experience in large steel structures.

A kid's book author,,,,,,,,:rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
A kid's book author,,,,,,,,:rolleyes:


"The Three Tall Buildings"


Get 'em while they're young:

There was one day that changed everything. Two hijacked planes brought down - not two skyscrapers - but three. Building 7 collapsed in almost perfect free-fall in what appeared to be a classic demolition. This is the story of that day, and how they huffed and puffed and pulled the baby building down (For kids with adult supervision).
 
And how. This woman's bilgebliography kinda makes me sick. What's next? A kid's version of Protocols of the Elders of Zion? Or, Mommy, Why Did the President's Head Snap Backwards?

Disgusting. Shameless.

Perhaps, but lovely rhyming book The People Who Refused to Be Sheeple is available right now. Delivered for the bargin? price of only $9.95 for Amazon Prime members.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom