When will the AE911 petition finally reach juggernaut strength of 1%?

When will the AE911 petition reach juggernaut strength of 1%?

  • 20 years

    Votes: 3 1.4%
  • 50 years

    Votes: 2 0.9%
  • Never

    Votes: 80 36.4%
  • Who cares?….it's retarded anyway.....

    Votes: 135 61.4%

  • Total voters
    220
I had befriended Joe d'Angelo on Facebook, thinking his defection from AE might indicate a relatively saner truther, perhaps on the verge of healing.

I could hardly have been more wrong.
https://www.facebook.com/joe.dangelo.16
He is heavily into chemtrails.
And he is heavily into anything anti-Israel. Now it seems that this stance originates from sympathy for the Palestinian cause, and I believe he has some personal ties with Palestinians, so I can understand a certain degree of rage against Israel.
But today I found he really is an anti-semite - revealing himself as a holocaust denier. He posted a YT video that I YT would not play here in Germany, so I asked him what the content is. He called me a troll, believes I feign not to know what he is talking about... the issue seems to be newspaper articles from before 1938 that mention "6,000,000 Jews". Whatever the argument may be behind this cryptic tag. After his third chat message, he banned me.

9/11 Truth - scum of the earth.

I'm not surprised. As most truthers believe in a lot of CT's out there.
 
Update for the month of january


The number of A&E signatures is the same as one month ago: 2323
They deleted one signer - Mark Kuttner, Marine Engineer from San Francisco (profile on archive.org in April 2008). As usual, I don't know why he was scratched. He had first signed in early 2008.
And added a new signer: Shaun Reinert, Electrical Enginee from Wetumpka, Alabama.
I noticed that they changed about 10 profiles - mostly new city/state, or other changes, so it's not like the team that looks after the database was inactive.

The number of General Public signatures rose from 20,022 to 20,042 - but there was an up and down. I didn't put down exact numbers, but I estimate that the "downs" added up to perhaps 25 signers, and the "ups" to 45, for a net increase of 20.

A net increase of 20 signatures in a month is the worst since the very early days. As a consequence, this eighth year of their petition being on the web at ae911truth.org (I am looking at "business years" from June to May, as June 2007 was the first full month that I have data from) is on course to becoming their worst ever in terms of attracting new signers. However, it seems they have shifted focus away from this anyway.


I have gone back to archives and tabulated Facebool-"Likes" to their page http://www.facebook.com/ae911truth
There is relatively steady growth there:



The slope has averaged around 190 new likes/day for the last 2 1/2 years, and a bit over 270/day this month. They reached a quarter million just after New Year's day, but didn't make much of a fuzz about it.
 
Update for the month of januaryThe number of A&E signatures is the same as one month ago: 2323
They deleted one signer - Mark Kuttner, Marine Engineer from San Francisco (profile on archive.org in April 2008). As usual, I don't know why he was scratched. He had first signed in early 2008.

Now I must know why they deleted Kuttner!
 
Now I must know why they deleted Kuttner!

I think because he may not meet their criteria (weak as it is). Clues in an earlier post by Oystein:

California!!

Most populous state, and home state to Richard Gage. California dominates the AE911Truth roster!

I have identified 90 Petition signers who claim to have a license as Professional Engineer from California. I won't provide a table for these.

Of these, 2 can't be found on the State of CA license lookup page:
ProfileID 998492 Mark Kuttner from San Francisco writes he has a "Coast Guard 2nd engineer's license" - whatever that means, he is not a PE in CA
ProfileID 997265 Richard Thurmond from Cobb, CA, mentions no license - no idea why AE911Truth lists him as licensed.


So we have 88 licensed PEs.
Of these 19 have 2 licenses (often as Structural and Civil Engineer, for example), and 1 has 3 licenses.
For a total of 108 licenses. 88 of which are "clear" (current and active).
56 engineers have a civil or structural PE license or both.


The CA lookup page allows me to search for Last name initial, but returns only 100 names per page, it takes a lot of time, and no download offered. Which makes it hard to guess the numbers on a complete roster. But I can estimate:

CA has issued, and lists, ca. 182,000 PE licenses. That's +/- 5,000 perhaps.
Of these, approx. 6-7% have 2 licenses, and sometimes more. So the number of PEs (persons) schould be roughly 170,000 +/- 5,000.

Of these, by the way, approximately 50% (85,000) are civil or structural engineers, 72% (122,000) are from California, and 62% (105,000) are active. Again, I could be off by a few thousand on all these estimates.


Gage's signers represent:

Licenses: 108 out of 182,000 = 1 in 1,685 = 0.059%
Active licenses: 88 out of 105,000 = 1 in 1,193 = 0.084
Prof. Engineers: 88 out of 170,000 = 1 in 1,932 = 0.052%
Civil + Structural Eng.: 56 out of 85,000 = 1 in 1,518 = 0.066%


So even in his home state of California, Richard Gage has failed to persuade 99.94 of all engineers.
You gotta give him though that active licensees and civil engineers are over-represented.
 
Last edited:
I the no because he may not meet their criteria (weak as it is). Clues in an earlier post by Oystein:

Of these, 2 can't be found on the State of CA license lookup page:
ProfileID 998492 Mark Kuttner from San Francisco writes he has a "Coast Guard 2nd engineer's license" - whatever that means, he is not a PE in CA
ProfileID 997265 Richard Thurmond from Cobb, CA, mentions no license - no idea why AE911Truth lists him as licensed.
Thanks. I suppose the ridicule directed at AE911Truth for their engineering standards has had an effect. Time to delete Thurmond.
 
Gage's organization is in disarray.

In the summer of 2013, they multiplied the number of "teams" listed on this page, which is still the old format:

http://www1.ae911truth.org/en/take-action.html

There are no less than 68 (!) teams, with about 25 different leaders, but 32 of the team leader positions are vacant, and 8 team leader positions are filled in only temporarily.

I looked up the page on archive.org and found that there were plenty of changes between june and september 2013, several more changes until end of june 2014, but zero changes since.

And now I learned that Wayne Coste, leader of three teams, most importantly perhaps the "Congressional Outreach" team, has left AE911Truth several months ago already - he sent out an email to all contacts he had at his email account "[email protected]". Quote:
Wayne Coste said:
You are receiving this because my e-mail records suggest that we have been in correspondence at some point in the past.

  1. Please update my e-mail address to: [email protected] (formerly it was [email protected])
  2. If you send an e-mail to me at the old address:
    a) You will not receive any notification about a problem with my inbox (as it still accepts incoming messages),
    b) I will not be a recipient to anything you send to me.
    c)Therefore I cannot respond.​
  3. I no longer have access to [email protected] -- as I no longer have any responsibilities associated with Architects & Engineers for 9/11 Truth. This way I can focus on a new outreach initiative without encumbrances.
  4. If you wish to know more about the new outreach initiative, please review the materials at http://www.911TruthOutreach.org
Thank you for your understanding

Wayne H. Coste, PE
[email protected]

The highlighted part seems clear enough.

Now, looking at http://www.911TruthOutreach.org, it appears that
  • much of the team structure, particularly the "outreach" teams, was Wayne's baby.
  • a couple of AE team leaders, Carl Seeger Henry and Steve Cohn, may now be on Wayne's group.
Coste and Cohn are electrical engineers. Before them, three more engineers had abandoned team leader positions:
  • John diNatale ("NIST pursuit team")
  • Mike Figa ("Magazine and Newspaper Advertising Outreach team")
  • Eliezer Ihejirika ("Writing team")
and Gage is left with only two engineers in an leading position (assuming they haven't defected, too): Joe Camera ("Military outreach team") and Dan Noel ("Presenter team").

The Board of Directors is currently staffed with architects only:
  • Richard Gage (President)
  • Robert McCoy (Chairman)
  • Tom Spellman (Treasurer)
  • Dan Barnum (Secretary)


When looking at their "ambitious 2015 agenda" one wonders: Which engineers are pursuing this agenda?

Let's see who is doing what:
1a. "Conduct sophisticated computer modeling of World Trade Center Building 7" - we discussed this elsewhere - it is entirely unclear whose initiative this is, as Tony Szamboti, who has in the past been Gage's main research man and who has done a bit of FEA himself has only heard "talk" of it.

1b. "Research, write, and publish monthly technical briefs." - we already know that ex-carpenter Chris Sarns and Simon Falkner, an economics student, is doing that groundbreaking scientific and engineering work.

1c. "Publish and market a book based on psychologist Frances Shure..." - huh? Ambitious agenda for 2322 architect and engineers - finance an esoteric shrink!

2. "Expanded Outreach Initiatives" - tough job, with Coste gone. The following outreach teams are named:
2a. "Presenters" - that's Dan Noel
2b. "Academic engineering community" - Team leader: VACANT
2c. "professional associations and other institutions" - this covers the following teams and their leader...
...Law Enforcement: "John Meaders is team leader, but would be happy to have someone else take on the role" (he has a BS in Criminal Justice)
...Firefighters: Dale Pierce (didn't even sign the AE petition)
...Military: Joe Camera (Mech. Engineer)
...Trades and Professionals: VACANT
...Developer/ Builder Business: VACANT
...Corporate Executives: VACANT
...Small Business Owners: VACANT
...Construction Contractors: VACANT
And the following teams are no longer pursued (appear light gray on the webpage):
...Steel Trades Outreach Team
...Concrete Trades Outreach Team
...Chemist Outreach Team
...Physicist Outreach Team
...Civil Engineering Outreach Team
...Chemical Engineering Outreach Team
...Metallurgists Outreach Team
...Demolition Outreach Team
...Financial Services Industry Outreach Team

3. Legal Strategies
3a. "Sue NIST" - the "NIST pusuit team" has no leader
3b. "Submit a Request for Correction under the Information Quality Act, using the results of the computer modeling of WTC 7 to prove NIST’s errors." - uhm right. The results they don't have yet. The "FOIA Request" and "Legal Skills Support" teams are temporarily led by jack-of-all-trades Gregg Roberts, who has education neither in law nor in engineering, and who has left AE911Truth no less than four times already, according to Joe d'Angelo (quoted upthread). He had his signature removed from the petition at some time before december 2012.
 
...
and Gage is left with only two engineers in an leading position (assuming they haven't defected, too): Joe Camera ("Military outreach team") and Dan Noel ("Presenter team").
...

When looking at their "ambitious 2015 agenda" one wonders: Which engineers are pursuing this agenda?

Let's see who is doing what:
...
2. "Expanded Outreach Initiatives" - tough job, with Coste gone. The following outreach teams are named:
2a. "Presenters" - that's Dan Noel
...

OMG! Dan Noel is now leaning towards "nukes in the basement"! :D

On Facebook, he commented this Veterans Today article two days ago thusly (the comment also shows at the bottom of the article):
Dan Noel said:
More information supporting the WTC nuclear destruction hypothesis! It increasingly looks like 9/11 activists will be able to safely affirm it as a possibility when it has been shown to be coherent with the video record of the destruction.
...
What a douchebag. He believes in every False Flaf CT there ever was and already believe in every one that ever will be. And chemtrails, too.
 
Oy,
This is amazing research on your part and if true very telling. Around the time I left AE's board... I reached out to McCoy and had several email exchanges with him. At the time he was not an AE member but had been an architect who had done high rise steel buildings. We discussed the beam stubs as vulnerable nodes and he told me that he had heard that the large box columns had weld issues / rejections. At the time he definitely was not a truther. But I can see why he might have been recruited... his background. I'd bet he's a bit "out of it" at his age, but slotting him into the board seems like his last grasp for his 15 minutes. I think he was also in ESO.
Wayne Coste showed up at at symposium I attended at the Christian Regenhard Center which included Jim Quintierre and a few other experts on disasters and fire "response". The presenters were critical at how NIST handled their mission comparing it to the way the NTSB does and noting that NIST refused NTSB's assistance. Coste set up a table to pass out AE literature / lobby attendees. I thought that was complete inappropriate... but no one fold up his card table display with literature and CDs. He's definitely a willfully ignorant person who refuses to accept facts and prefers his fantasies. Gage appears to be managing his group to hold on to what amounts to complete control and rubber stamper staff. Any independence and out the door they go. But there are seemingly enough sycophants who will volunteer to do the yes-man work.
 
When looking at their "ambitious 2015 agenda" one wonders: Which engineers are pursuing this agenda?

Let's see who is doing what:
1a. "Conduct sophisticated computer modeling of World Trade Center Building 7" - we discussed this elsewhere - it is entirely unclear whose initiative this is, as Tony Szamboti, who has in the past been Gage's main research man and who has done a bit of FEA himself has only heard "talk" of it.

Guessing from recent activity that this will be the work of "gerrycan".

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/search.php?searchid=2724337&pp=25
 
Back to boosting the petition, and da twoof! They sent out this newsletter at the beginning of the month:

http://us1.campaign-archive2.com/?u=d03bf3ffcac549c7dc7888ef5&id=3957bc9c39

Richard Gage said:
Fellow 9/11 Truth Advocates:

Imagine a small army of experts fanning out across the U.S. and beyond to give dozens of presentations each month, reaching thousands of audiences still unfamiliar with the World Trade Center evidence.

We’re calling it the “Truth-Teller” Project, and it's one of AE911Truth’s key priorities for 2015. Now we’re counting on you to help make it a reality.
...
More About The “Truth-Teller” Project

Over the coming year, the goal of our Truth-Teller Project will be to build a team of a dozen well-trained expert speakers, each of whom will give a minimum of two presentations per month to audiences all over his or her region. All told, we're talking at least six presentations a week—two dozen a month.

As we quadruple the number of presentations AE911Truth gives, we will aim to maximize the impact of those presentations by focusing on key audiences at universities, professional associations, and other relevant organizations. For each presentation, we'll also work to ensure the maximum level of publicity from campus and local media.

As we see it, with 24 presentations a month, the Truth-Teller Project has the potential to draw thousands of new petition signers, influential allies, and positive media exposure. This will add a huge boost to our dissemination of the World Trade Center evidence, bringing us ever closer to the global 9/11 Truth awakening we all seek.
(Emphasise original, highlighting mine)

No information about what the project plans specifically, who is in charge, how to contact them if you are interested to be trained...
My guess is that this is run by electromechanical engineer Dan Noel, leader of the "Presenter Team". I mentioned him the other day - he is leaning toward nukes in the basement.

ETA:
Anyway - "thousands of new petition signers", eh? And here I was, thinking they have de-emphasised the petition! The A&E part has had a net loss of 1 signature in 2015 so far, the Other Supporters a modest gain of 41. Lately they have added 1000 signatures to both lists within about half a year. Are they saying they want add thousands more per... what, year? Silliness.

The rest of the newsletter dutifully asks for money, and then for more money.
 
Last edited:
The latest newsletter, which I received two days ago:
http://us1.campaign-archive2.com/?u=d03bf3ffcac549c7dc7888ef5&id=1c27fd7abd

Interesting statement:
Richard Gage said:
Today, we have close to 1,750 members placing their trust in us and generously giving monthly, quarterly, or annual sustaining donations.
Assuming a typical monthly donation of $5, this means they get over $100,000 per year from such sustaining "members". (The lowest "plan" they describe is called "Supporter" and goes for $2.50/month. $5/month is next and is called "Assiciate". Haha, can I put that titel on my resumé? :D)


Now, I want to say for the record that calling for donations os perfectly okay for any no-profit organisation that is serious about its mission. Of course money is needed to move things, the more the better.
But their stated mission is: "AE911Truth is ... dedicated to researching and disseminating scientific information about the complete destruction of all three World Trade Center skyscrapers". How can that be true if they are selling their information on high-priced DVDs that surely only the already convimced will buy, instead of giving the videos out for free on, say, YouTube?
 
But they are not doing research and they are not even evaluating the non CD research.. for example the ROOSD stuff... If they think it's bunk... why not show why they do? Their real mission is to raise money on the notion that the collapses were CD, false flags and inside jobs... This is more than apparent when you examine "who *they* hang out with / associate with."

The terms conspiracists is a pretty tainted word... at least to the truth guys. It's huge slur and they consider it the way they are put down... and dismissed.

But 9/11 WAS a conspiracy... one of apparently radical Islamists... and that doesn't seem far fetched.

What DOES is that it was a self inflicted false flag.

For sure false flag type things do happen... sting operations, entrapments and other questionably legal activities of the state. It's not even inconceivable to me that the administration was looking for an excuse to go after Saddam. But 9/11 was a very shabby one and most people saw through that ruse. They simply made bold faced lies... WMDs and so on... and that was enough to get the war going. They didn't need to kill 3000 innocent people.
 
The terms conspiracists is a pretty tainted word... at least to the truth guys. It's huge slur and they consider it the way they are put down... and dismissed.

The shoe fits. The terms "conspiracist" or "conspiracy theorist" long predate the Truth movement. They have always meant not just someone who believes in a conspiracy, but rather someone who habitually or instinctively rejects an otherwise widely-held explanation in favor of some secret operation. Even if the widely-held view also involves an actual conspiracy, if you reject it on certain grounds, you can still be a "conspiracy theorist."
 
Richard Gage said:
Fellow 9/11 Truth Advocates:

Imagine a small army of experts fanning out across the U.S. and beyond to give dozens of presentations each month, reaching thousands of audiences still unfamiliar with the World Trade Center evidence.

We’re calling it the “Truth-Teller” Project, and it's one of AE911Truth’s key priorities for 2015. Now we’re counting on you to help make it a reality.
...
More About The “Truth-Teller” Project

Over the coming year, the goal of our Truth-Teller Project will be to build a team of a dozen well-trained expert speakers, each of whom will give a minimum of two presentations per month to audiences all over his or her region. All told, we're talking at least six presentations a week—two dozen a month.

Have they defined what they mean by "Expert?

Being an expert speaker has nothing to do with actually being an expert on the subject matter.

Gage wants to build a bunch of clones.
 
Have they defined what they mean by "Expert?

Being an expert speaker has nothing to do with actually being an expert on the subject matter.

Gage wants to build a bunch of clones.

An "expert", as defined by AE911T, is anyone who 1) is a certified professional or expert in something at least tangentially related to construction (or demolition), and 2) swallows their pack of lies hook, line, and sinker.
 
Interesting new article at ae911truth.org:
60 Structural Engineers Cite Evidence for Controlled Explosive Demolition in Destruction of Three WTC High-Rises on 9/11

A while ago (in 2012 perhaps) I had answered someone's question "how many structural engineers do they have?" with "80", as I estimated ca. 40 US S.E.s and as many from abroad - but I attached several articles of caution, as their profiles are often too vague to say for sure whether some engineer is a structural engineer. Interesting to see I was too generous, and they have only 60 :D

The article quotes the following individual engineers and signers:

Nathan Lomba
Paul Mason
Dennis Kollar
John Watt
Howard Pasternack
Frank Cullinan
David Scott
Anders Björkman
William Rice
Ronald Brookman
Charles Pegelow
Bob Briscoe
David Huebner
Edward Knesl
Graham Inman
Kamal Obeid
Bill Genitsaris
Lynn Affleck
Thomas Lackey
David Topete
Clayton Simmons
Charles Walker
William Acri

23 names. Not bad. I have checked a handful of quotes and it seems they are not directly copy&pasted from their profiles, but I'd have to take closer ook to determine if they merely reworded the "personal statements" in the signatures, or got fresh soundbites from them. The latter would indicate that these guys still believed in the crap.

A courageous claim near the end:
"Then there are those, such as the AE911Truth structural engineers, who have read the entire report"​
Ha! As if!

Another thing to look for would be original work that any of those 23 has done to bring the truth to light - in addition to howling with the choir on an obscure lobby website. Several of their statements clearly give away that they are seriously ignorant of basic facts. On guy for example, Bill Genitsaris, in his profile would expect to have seen core columns standing after the floors had crushed down (the did - "spires"), or columns toppling over in long slabs, damaging far away buildings (they did - see WFC Winter Garrden, Verizon, Deutsche Bank, WTC7, ...). Another, Lynn Affleck, says in the article "It would be my assessment that the flanges on the columns would have to be two inches thick or some equivalent". Well, Mr. Affleck, had you ever liiked at the NIST reports, you'd not say such uninormed things - the perimeter columns were much more flimsy at the crash floors! David Scott complains that the FEMA report (2002) contains errors; hello?? Ever heard of the NIST report 2005? Are you stuck in 2004?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom