dafydd
Banned
- Joined
- Feb 14, 2008
- Messages
- 35,398
The reality is, Richard Gage is not an island.
He's a peninsula head.
The reality is, Richard Gage is not an island.
Originally Posted by Miragememories
The reality is, Richard Gage is not an island.
You just don't do them anymore because you're caught in some sort of weird Truther identity.
Yes....but!!!!I doubt this is the case with MM. I think he just likes to argue...
Who is making up Gage's organisation? Who contributes actively to his efforts?Yes he is. We have posted this before, but it is clear his 'organization' is not an organization.
You do realize it appears none of the members of AE9/11T, except for him, are signing anyone up. Otherwise the group would be growing much faster than it is. Oystein has documented how it's only been growing a few members a month and the more members it gets, the slower it grows. It's been shown how even Tony Szamboti, who claims to have talked with dozens of engineers who he tells us all agree with him, seems to have failed to signed anyone of them up.
...
I also have Tony Szamboti in a special position. As their most published person with engineering qualification it is easy to see him as either "their best example" or at least an example of the calibre of the best they have. And Gage puts him forward in that role....I am also not counting guys like Tony Szamboti, Steven Jones or Ronald Brookman who surely contribute content, but not as an explicit member of the organisation, and more as members of the general truth movement, and buddies of Dick.
Yes, this deserves to be stressed: "1750 professionals" may sound like a whole lot, and in some way it is, but they are not spreading the message, they are not convincing any of their peers at all. ....
As you will remember I have long held the opinion that Gage made a fundamental strategic error basing his strategy on claims of CD - a false claim that most engineers would see right through. They express concerns about mis/mal/non feasance of the political processes of dealing with 9/11 BUT stand their support on claims of CD at WTC. And proof of no CD is so obvious to any thinking honest and undeluded professional. (OK - for the scientific pedants make that "no proof of CD"...Secondly, the growth rate: So far in 2012, almost 110 architects or engineers have signed on, to add to the 1644 already listed then. This is an annual growth rate of 7.2% - which can be interpreted as every "member" signing up another member once every 14 years! Imagine this: 1644 professionals, convinced they got the facts to prove the crime of the century, and it's within their own professional domain to uncover this, and they are asked to multiply their numbers, and what do they individually accomplish? Nothing in 2012.......
Good example - I couldn't find them till I cheated and looked at the codes....I estimate that about 0.03% (3 in 10,000 - NY state is representative!) of the relevant professionals have signed. Here is how that looks: 10,000 dots. 3 of them are red. Can you find them?...
As you will remember I have long held the opinion that Gage made a fundamental strategic error basing his strategy on claims of CD - a false claim that most engineers would see right through. They express concerns about mis/mal/non feasance of the political processes of dealing with 9/11 BUT stand their support on claims of CD at WTC. And proof of no CD is so obvious to any thinking honest and undeluded professional. (OK - for the scientific pedants make that "no proof of CD")
End of month update!
A) Architects and engineers:
Sep 30: 1720
Oct 31: 1742
B) Other Supporters:B) Other Supporters:
Sep 30: 15,470
Oct 31: 15756
What's ahead?What's ahead?
...
November will be clearly down, but I am not as sure as I was that it will be practically dead (i.e. back to the june/july level)
The 2011 IRS form 990 for AE911Truth is out!
Find it on their own server: http://www2.ae911truth.org/downloads/2011_Form_990.pdf (PDF scan, ca. 30MB)
Some quick observations:
- Contrary to my predictions in this thread, total revenue is somewhat up, not down, from the previous year - $469,362 after $434,526
- Strangely, income from contributions and grants is exactly to the dollar the same as the year before: $288,893
- Gage increased his salary from 80K to 85K
- The Board of Directors is also unchanged from 2010 (Gage, Ryan, Spellman, Keogh, Cole) - by this october, Ryan, Keogh and Cole are out, McCoy, Rika and Barnum in. It's quite unusual for them to have the same Board membership 2 years in a row
- The "Building What" liability, i,e, money they are holding for that stalled advertising campaign, has increased from 66K to 75K
- They have 3 returning large donors: Promethan Genesis (Oregon; $8,000 in 2010 and 2011), Vanguard Charity Endowment (Boston: $10,000 both years) and Robert Jamison (Oregon; 19,500 last year, 16,000 this year). Don't know who these are, and can't find the latter in the petition list.
- Debates with Chris Mohr and Dave Thomas mentioned in the prose on activities
For comparison, here are the forms 990 for the previous years:
2011
2010
2009
2008
It's a private foundation (990 PF) with about 16,000,000 in investments. John and Marilyn Lenahan are the principles along with Robert Reading. PM me your email if you want a copy of the form.Tony Szamboti, when I asked him, said that he doesn't get a penny from these guys. If that's true, he really should be insulted.
Based on a quick google search, Robert Jamison looks to be either a doctor or a meat company executive... He and the Promethean Genesis organization are both in Oregon, and Genesis has been sued by two non-profits - ALS Foundation and GFC Foundation. Wonder what's up with that?
Any subscribers to GuideStar want to see what Promethean Genesis is all about?
...
Based on a quick google search, Robert Jamison looks to be either a doctor or a meat company executive... He and the Promethean Genesis organization are both in Oregon, and Genesis has been sued by two non-profits - ALS Foundation and GFC Foundation. Wonder what's up with that?
Any subscribers to GuideStar want to see what Promethean Genesis is all about?
That's OK, thanks.It's a private foundation (990 PF) with about 16,000,000 in investments. John and Marilyn Lenahan are the principles along with Robert Reading. PM me your email if you want a copy of the form.
Hmm. Why would the Kauai Energy Institute be in Oregon?[*]Total expenses were $5,528,255 - most of that contributions, grants and gifts payed - all of which went to Kauai Energy Institute![]()
Hmm. Why would the Kauai Energy Institute be in Oregon?
/just asking questions
"Each of these listed members is - can you guess what's coming? - a listed member. It's AE911T who lists them. They set themselves up by signing. There is not a bit of information in my spreadsheet that these people haven't provided freely and purposefully themselves."
"Set themselves up for what?
To be found not perfect?"
"To be found gullible, disinformed, deluded, deranged... Not just "not perfect".
If they find themselves on the receiving end of derision, ridicule and mockery, they set themselves up for it by signing this nonsense statement - not I by uploading an excel sheet.
After all, if you google their names and home cities along with a descriptive word like "engineer" or "architect", their ae911truth profile often ranks high in the search results - not my excel sheet, and not this JREF thread."
"b) It allows anyone who cares to analyse who Gage's base ism and what they think. For example, you could find that about 67 of the architects and enhineers mention thermite/thermate in their personal statements as a reason to support Gage. So there are 67 who we know to have based their decision on a false bit of belief, as we know that no thermite has been found (it's paint, as you have been made aware)."
"FALSE.
That is only highly-invested opinion. Being a good scientific mimic is not the same as being a legitimate scientist."
"60 mention have the word "molten" or "melted" in their personal statement - another false premise, supposing this pertains to "molten steel" as a reason to support the woo."
"FALSE
Even the head of the architectural firm collecting debris samples representative of the WTC collapses claimed there was molten steel after he examined the two famous 'meteorite' samples."
"So you are suggesting that we should only rank our respect for their opinions based on their level of engineering education and their familiarity with the sciences related to the collapse of the WTC Towers?"
"Absolutely, yes
If you want to make an argument from authority, you better make sure your authorities are in fact authorities, as evidenced by their having the relevant expertise and education, AND their knowing the actual facts at hand.
Many of Gage's A&E fail on the first criterion: They hail from an irrelevant professional and educational background, such as electrical engineering, land surveying, or interior design.
ALL of them fail on the second criterion: Mislead by Gage's many untruths, they don't know the pertinent facts, and instead consider falsehoods to be fact - as evidenced by many personal statements.
With this, the Argument from Authority fails."
"If so, as a rank amateur, you certainly make a good case for having your opinions on engineering science totally dismissed."
"Strawman.
I am not making an Argument from Authority, as I am not presenting myself as a "mindful professional". Hence, the Argument from Authority can't fail in my case.
Instead, I present pertinent facts, strung together by explicit logic, after having consulted with various experts."
And supposedly your credibility is enhanced by describing these engineering professionals as "gullible, disinformed, deluded, deranged..."?
It is a lie that the red chips extracted from the WTC dust and tested for the Bentham Paper were proven to be non-thermitic primer paint. Your statement of fact is based on a mimicry of scientific research, based primarily on your own amateur interpretation of their published results.
Followed by;
Molten steel was not a false premise. It was observed first hand and reported by a publicized professional with far greater credibility than an anonymous, amateur sleuth staring at an image on a computer screen.
...snip for bollocks