When will the AE911 petition finally reach juggernaut strength of 1%?

When will the AE911 petition reach juggernaut strength of 1%?

  • 20 years

    Votes: 3 1.4%
  • 50 years

    Votes: 2 0.9%
  • Never

    Votes: 80 36.4%
  • Who cares?….it's retarded anyway.....

    Votes: 135 61.4%

  • Total voters
    220
I uploaded an Excel spreadsheet with all A&E (1,748 as of today) and Other Supporters (15,996 as of a week ago), the former complete with Bios and Personal Statements, to a permanent (bookmarkable) link:

ae911truth_all.xls

For what purpose other than possible harassment of your listed members?

[SNIP]
Edited by kmortis: 
Removed personal comment


MM
 
Last edited by a moderator:
It sounds better than "Need money for 1st-class travel and slick hotels".
Oystein, for what it's worth, when Gage last came to Denver he slept on a mattress on the floor of a host's home office in a 100 year old house. He carries all his own heavy supplies from place to place and people drive him around to save money on rental cars. When in Denver at least, he eats at inexpensive to moderate priced restaurants so his fellow activists (only a few of whom are upper middle class) can afford to join him. They also throw potlucks for him. Sorry to burst your bubble folks but if the Denver stops are any indication, Gage is not living high at all when he travels. You seem to be simultaneously painting a picture of diminishing support for AE911 and Gage living the high life. Which is it? I vote for the "diminishing support" theory.
 
Last edited:
Yes, he did used to stay at much nicer hotels.

Take an architect to lunch!

I'm sure that this money is used for exactly the purpose described. Totally.

1. We offer to bring to the A/E firm our fascinating technical presentation on the destruction of the WTC skyscrapers. (This ensures their presence. )

2. We bring a good lunch and give the noon-hour presentation – sticking to the technical points.

3. We usually get about 100% who agree with us that there are very serious questions about the official story.

4. And we get about 90% who agree with us that the buildings were indeed brought down by controlled demolition.

5. Of those, about 70 to 80% feel comfortable enough joining us by signing our petition "calling upon Congress for a truly independent investigation into the destruction of the 3 WTC skyscrapers". (That's all there is to joining AE911Truth!)

6. This is the process we have used to attract our supporters — and its success is proven because the evidence itself is solid and convincing.

7. All that is ask of you is that you buy a sandwich for an architect or engineer! We'll do the rest! This gives you tremendous leverage to expand the 9/11 Truth Movement with those that will make the most impact — the building professionals!
 
....You seem to be simultaneously painting a picture of diminishing support for AE911 and Gage living the high life. Which is it? I vote for the "diminishing support" theory.
It's not a dichotomy of alternates Chris. They are two separate issues and not tied as alternates.

The first is the fact of diminishing support for AE911 as shown by Oystein's ongoing monitoring.

Ridicule of Gage for "high living" is a separate factor. Whether or not he "lives his delusion" is one aspect. The reality is that he is engaged in an untruthful campaign which deliberately sets out to persuade victims of some untrue claims. Whether Gage is deluded into believing those claims whilst being aware of the rebutting evidence of every one of his common technical claims is a more complex issue.

There is no doubt that he is untruthful. The issue is "Is he a liar?" where the requirement is that he deliberately represents untruth as truth. The deliberation aspect is required to make it a lie and him in consequence a liar. If he is deluded and believes his claims, then, judged as a lay person, he is not deliberately telling untruths. Therefore, judged as a lay person, he counts as "untruthful" but not as "liar".

However as a professional person he does not get away so easy. He is aware that the vast majority of his profession and of the even more relevant professions of engineering and applied physics have rebutted all his technical claims. Yet he still calls on his professional standing to support his false claims without mentioning the opposing majority view. Whether or not that is "lying" it is professionally deceptive conduct which is unethical by the accepted standards of professional conduct.

So, given the very dubious standing of his honesty, it is not surprising that his "rake off" from the scam of AE911 is represented as high living. And that misrepresentation is minor when contrasted with the massive misrepresentations and untruths of his central technical claims.

Personally I would not be able to have much regard for him as a friend if it required me to praise the few things he gets right whilst ignoring the massive effort he puts into deceiving his audiences.
 
Last edited:
"It's not a dichotomy of alternates Chris. They are two separate issues and not tied as alternates.

The first is the fact of diminishing support for AE911 as shown by Oystein's ongoing monitoring.

Ridicule of Gage for "high living" is a separate factor. Whether or not he "lives his delusion" is one aspect. The reality is...
"

The reality is, Richard Gage is not an island.

He represents the beliefs of over 1,600 professionals who have bravely identified themselves in support. Men and women who are willing to have their professional 9/11 truth views fairly scrutinized by the public but risking unfair and harmful public abuse.

Is that not why most people here won't use their real names?

Knowing he is in agreement with the 9/11 observations and conclusions of 1,600 other mindful professionals responding to issues unresolved by the NIST reports, I see no reason why Richard Gage should believe his AE911Truth presentation has been debunked as untruthful.

MM
 
Mindful professionals, bravely identifying themselves, risking unfair and harmful public abuse, supporting the "truth"...

There is a reason that a lot of religions have martyrs. It's a powerful feeling, to know that you are special and that you are willing to take abuse for your cause.
 
For what purpose other than possible harassment of your listed members?

[SNIP]
Edited by kmortis: 
Removed personal comment


MM

Each of these listed members is - can you guess what's coming? - a listed member. It's AE911T who lists them. They set themselves up by signing. There is not a bit of information in my spreadsheet that these people haven't provided freely and purposefully themselves.

So why do I upload this?
a) Because I have been asked more than once
b) It allows anyone who cares to analyse who Gage's base ism and what they think. For example, you could find that about 67 of the architects and enhineers mention thermite/thermate in their personal statements as a reason to support Gage. So there are 67 who we know to have based their decision on a false bit of belief, as we know that no thermite has been found (it's paint, as you have been made aware).
60 mention have the word "molten" or "melted" in their personal statement - another false premise, supposing this pertains to "molten steel" as a reason to support the woo.
Others might be interested in analysing how many of the supporters actually have a background in structural engineering, vs. those "professionals" who, as electrical engineers or landscaoe architects, have no actual expertise to offer.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Oystein, for what it's worth, when Gage last came to Denver he slept on a mattress on the floor of a host's home office in a 100 year old house. He carries all his own heavy supplies from place to place and people drive him around to save money on rental cars. When in Denver at least, he eats at inexpensive to moderate priced restaurants so his fellow activists (only a few of whom are upper middle class) can afford to join him. They also throw potlucks for him. Sorry to burst your bubble folks but if the Denver stops are any indication, Gage is not living high at all when he travels. You seem to be simultaneously painting a picture of diminishing support for AE911 and Gage living the high life. Which is it? I vote for the "diminishing support" theory.

Fair enough, Chris.
Abd yes, I am betting on "diminishing support".

The IRS form 990 os 11 days iverdue :boggled:
 
The reality is, Richard Gage is not an island.

He represents the beliefs of over 1,600 professionals who have bravely identified themselves in support. Men and women who are willing to have their professional 9/11 truth views fairly scrutinized by the public but risking unfair and harmful public abuse.

Is that not why most people here won't use their real names?

Knowing he is in agreement with the 9/11 observations and conclusions of 1,600 other mindful professionals responding to issues unresolved by the NIST reports, I see no reason why Richard Gage should believe his AE911Truth presentation has been debunked as untruthful.

MM

Most people here, like you, dont have any technical qualifications and others would listen to them even less if they knew who they were talking to.

Its a bit why no-one really cares if a professional landscape architect, or an electrical engineer signs a stupid petition. And as you know there is probably less than 2 or 3% active ..say 32 to 48 professionals from electrical engineer to landscape architects and even 5 structural engineers... and lets pretend that all five are active. Woohoo

Go truth .... you know it makes cents!
 
The reality is, Richard Gage is not an island.

He represents the beliefs of over 1,600 professionals who have bravely identified themselves in support...
FALSE claim and a classic "truther lie by innuendo" which we see from those who either are not brave enough to say what they mean or lack the skill of clear thinking and expression. The only "belief" those "over 1,600 professionals" have professed to support is:
AE911Truth Petition said:
We believe there is sufficient doubt about the official story to justify re-opening the 9/11 investigation...
...and even that was only at the time they signed up. It does not even mention support for the central AE911 platform of controlled demolitions. The reference to CD only comes in a round about way - another example of the "lie by innuendo" actually.
AE911Truth Petition said:
...The new investigation must include a full inquiry into the possible use of explosives that might have been the actual cause of the destruction of the World Trade Center Twin Towers and Building 7.
That bit of weasel innuendo is as bi-partisan as you would want. Given that it is conditional on a "new investigation" every "debunker" here would support it. IF (and a big IF) there was a new investigation it would once again show "no CD" so debunkers should insist that IF there was a new investigation it should once again include CD in its scope.

So your comment:
...Men and women who are willing to have their professional 9/11 truth views fairly scrutinized by the public but risking unfair and harmful public abuse...
....is more lies by inference. The only thing those people have expressed as their "professional 9/11 truth views" is that, at the time they signed, they supported a further investigation plus the redundant comment that it should cover CD. So on that issue they were open minded on CD and every person who represents them as supporting CD on the basis of their signing the petition is being dishonest. Including Gage who does it repeatedly.

Knowing he is in agreement with the 9/11 observations and conclusions of 1,600 other mindful professionals responding to issues unresolved by the NIST reports...
FALSE. There is no reference in the petition that they signed to NIST or issues unresolved by the NIST reports.
I see no reason why Richard Gage should believe his AE911Truth presentation has been debunked as untruthful....
The limits on your comprehension are not within my discussion. The reality is that Gage and his close supporters are aware of the relevant facts.

You have posted many times in these threads so you are aware of many of the relevant facts so your claim "I see no reason" is at best mere pretence.
 
Last edited:
The reality is, Richard Gage is not an island. ...
Richard Gage is fraud. Spread lies, takes in > 1,000,000 dollars. He was out of work, and found a fringe movement which pays. How many years can he milk lies, take money from people who don't think for themselves?

He represents the beliefs of over 1,600 professionals who have bravely identified themselves in support. Men and women who are willing to have their professional 9/11 truth views fairly scrutinized by the public but risking unfair and harmful public abuse. ...
1600 who can't figure out 911. Identified, as conspiracy theorists, with real names. Using real names does not make the lies come true. Gage represents fraud and lies, he fooled 1600.
Zero papers from 1600. Zero progress from 1600.

Why can't Gage team with a newspaper and get a Pulitzer Prize for what is the biggest story in 100 years? Because it is a fantasy. Darn, now what will he do - Gage will make more money, the followers will remain in the dark, non-thinking followers, do nothing dolts on 911 issues. Have they done anything? No.

Is that not why most people here won't use their real names? ...
Using real names looks like the mark of not being rational. 1600 real names (some not real) can't figuer out 911, and have fallen for Gage's lies. Using real names does not make the lies come true.

Knowing he is in agreement with the 9/11 observations and conclusions of 1,600 other mindful professionals responding to issues unresolved by the NIST reports, I see no reason why Richard Gage should believe his AE911Truth presentation has been debunked as untruthful. ...
1600 nuts never offered observations or conclusions, they sign a petition of woo and lined up with a nut who makes money off of 911 lies. Nothing Gage said about 911 is true with respect to his conclusions. He plagiarized his entire presentation from failed 911 truth nonsense made up by idiots who can't think rationally when it comes to 911. Big failure, except Gage has made a over a million dollars selling lies. Gage is a success at spreading lies to gain donations which do nothing but supplement Gages presentations begging for more money. It is a do nothing group, which is populated by gullible people who failed to think for themselves on this subject.

Internet videos have more support than Gage's lies - this is the Internet, why does Gage have so few? Real support on the internet would be 800 million visits and 5 million who support; Gage has a few fringe paranoid CTers, 1600, and we know who they are. This is not the old days of newspaper and pony express, the Internet makes it possible for millions to agree, and only 1600 have sat down with Gage to do nothing.
 
Last edited:
...
So your comment:....is more lies by inference. The only thing those people have expressed as their "professional 9/11 truth views" is that, at the time they signed, they supported a further investigation plus the redundant comment that it should cover CD. So on that issue they were open minded on CD and every person who represents them as supporting CD on the basis of their signing the petition is being dishonest. Including Gage who does it repeatedly.
...

Now if you download my spreadsheet, you can scan all the Personal Statements and flag and count them as you like. You will probably find that a majority of the signers included language that indicates they actually do find Gage's claim of CD with explosives or incendiaries credible. I don't think many have revised their opinion significantly since signing.
 
...the 9/11 observations and conclusions of 1,600 other mindful professionals...

You imply that 1600 mindful professionals made observations and formed conclusions.

The vast majority did not. Instead, a great number of them simply believe that the alleged observations presented by Gage are facts, when they aren't; and also believe the conclusions presented by Gage follow logically from facts, when they don't.


  • Many of these "mindful professionals" repeat the assertion that thermite was found. This is not true, and it is not an observation that they made.
  • Many of these "mindful professionals" repeat the assertion that significant quantities of molten steel were observed. This is not true, and it is not an observation that they made.
  • Many of these "mindful professionals" repeat the assertion that all towers fell at almost free-fall acceleration. This is not true, and it is not an observation that they made.
  • Many of these "mindful professionals" repeat the assertion that the speed of collapse violates physical laws, if unassisted by explosives or some such stuff. This is not true, and it is not a conclusion that they drew.
  • Many of these "mindful professionals" repeat the assertion that the towers fell into their foorprints. This is not true, and it is not an observation that they made.
  • Many of these "mindful professionals" repeat the assertion that actual CDed buildings fall into their footprints, and naturally collapsing buildings don't. Neither is true, and they are not observations that they made.
  • Many of these "mindful professionals" repeat the assertion that explosions were heard. This is not an observation that they made.
  • Many of these "mindful professionals" repeat the assertion that all the steel was shipped away without a sufficient forensic examination. This is not true, and it is not an observation that they made.
  • Many of these "mindful professionals" repeat the assertion that the fires that burned in the towers were so limited in expanse, duration and temperature as to be no problem. This is not true, and it is not an observation that they made.

Essentially, a great number of these "mindful professionals" never made any observations themselves, never investigated anything themselves, never formed conclusions of their own. Instead, they ingested the propaganda material handed out by Richard Gage and his cronies, unsceptically, and repeat the many lies contained therein, because they just don't know any better.
 
"I uploaded an Excel spreadsheet with all A&E (1,748 as of today) and Other Supporters (15,996 as of a week ago), the former complete with Bios and Personal Statements, to a permanent (bookmarkable) link:

ae911truth_all.xls"
"For what purpose other than possible harassment of your listed members?"
Edited by LashL: 
Removed quote of moderated content.
"Each of these listed members is - can you guess what's coming? - a listed member. It's AE911T who lists them. They set themselves up by signing. There is not a bit of information in my spreadsheet that these people haven't provided freely and purposefully themselves."

Set themselves up for what?

To be found not perfect?

"So why do I upload this?

a) Because I have been asked more than once


b) It allows anyone who cares to analyse who Gage's base ism and what they think. For example, you could find that about 67 of the architects and enhineers mention thermite/thermate in their personal statements as a reason to support Gage. So there are 67 who we know to have based their decision on a false bit of belief, as we know that no thermite has been found (it's paint, as you have been made aware)."

FALSE.

That is only highly-invested opinion. Being a good scientific mimic is not the same as being a legitimate scientist.

"...60 mention have the word "molten" or "melted" in their personal statement - another false premise, supposing this pertains to "molten steel" as a reason to support the woo...."

FALSE

Even the head of the architectural firm collecting debris samples representative of the WTC collapses claimed there was molten steel after he examined the two famous 'meteorite' samples.

"...Others might be interested in analysing how many of the supporters actually have a background in structural engineering, vs. those "professionals" who, as electrical engineers or landscaoe architects, have no actual expertise to offer."

So you are suggesting that we should only rank our respect for their opinions based on their level of engineering education and their familiarity with the sciences related to the collapse of the WTC Towers?

If so, as a rank amateur, you certainly make a good case for having your opinions on engineering science totally dismissed.

MM
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Set themselves up for what?

To be found not perfect?
To be found gullible, disinformed, deluded, deranged... Not just "not perfect".
If they find themselves on the receiving end of derision, ridicule and mockery, they set themselves up for it by signing this nonsense statement - not I by uploading an excel sheet.
After all, if you google their names and home cities along with a descriptive word like "engineer" or "architect", their ae911truth profile often ranks high in the search results - not my excel sheet, and not this JREF thread.


So you are suggesting that we should only rank our respect for their opinions based on their level of engineering education and their familiarity with the sciences related to the collapse of the WTC Towers?
Absolutely, yes :)
If you want to make an argument from authority, you better make sure your authorities are in fact authorities, as evidenced by their having the relevant expertise and education, AND their knowing the actual facts at hand.

Many of Gage's A&E fail on the first criterion: They hail from an irrelevant professional and educational background, such as electrical engineering, land surveying, or interior design.

ALL of them fail on the second criterion: Mislead by Gage's many untruths, they don't know the pertinent facts, and instead consider falsehoods to be fact - as evidenced by many personal statements.

With this, the Argument from Authority fails.

If so, as a rank amateur, you certainly make a good case for having your opinions on engineering science totally dismissed.
Strawman.

I am not making an Argument from Authority, as I am not presenting myself as a "mindful professional". Hence, the Argument from Authority can't fail in my case.

Instead, I present pertinent facts, strung together by explicit logic, after having consulted with various experts.
 
Now if you download my spreadsheet, you can scan all the Personal Statements and flag and count them as you like. You will probably find that a majority of the signers included language that indicates they actually do find Gage's claim of CD with explosives or incendiaries credible. I don't think many have revised their opinion significantly since signing.
Understood - however my focus on their act of signing a petition was all that I needed to respond to the poorly expressed claims.

If I was presenting my own counter claim I would probably get pedantically accurate in logic. ;)
 
Understood - however my focus on their act of signing a petition was all that I needed to respond to the poorly expressed claims.
...

And a good focus it was.
For what it's worth, I think it's fair to assume that MM has read only a small minority of the profiles, if any at all, and could thus not know if a significant number of them go beyond the wording of the petition and make explicit they already are committed to CD.
 
... Even the head of the architectural firm collecting debris samples representative of the WTC collapses claimed there was molten steel after he examined the two famous 'meteorite' samples.
...
MM
There was paper in the "meteorite", paper. lol,

No melted steel was found in the "meteorite", which makes molten steel a like, and the guy the head of woo. How does partially burned paper exist with molten steel? How can you support nuts like that?

Hearsay is used a lot by 911 truth. Claims? He claims? That is equal to zero evidence. Where is his quote? Where is his evidence? He has nothing. 911 truth believers are gullible.
 
Oystein, for what it's worth, when Gage last came to Denver he slept on a mattress on the floor of a host's home office in a 100 year old house. He carries all his own heavy supplies from place to place and people drive him around to save money on rental cars. When in Denver at least, he eats at inexpensive to moderate priced restaurants so his fellow activists (only a few of whom are upper middle class) can afford to join him. They also throw potlucks for him. Sorry to burst your bubble folks but if the Denver stops are any indication, Gage is not living high at all when he travels. You seem to be simultaneously painting a picture of diminishing support for AE911 and Gage living the high life. Which is it? I vote for the "diminishing support" theory.

I no longer doubt that Gage is sincere in his beliefs and genuinely hopes to convert the world on this one. I don't think there's much of money motive in this and think it's unfair to keep making this claim.

On the other hand, I have read interview research of White Power groups where members and their wives talk about the poverty they have chosen to live in because of their beliefs. You and I may think they're idiots, but I do believe their belief is genuine and they are willing to sacrifice and suffer for it. They are still idiots and, in fact, that they would give up a comfortable life for themselves and their families for these ideas makes them even dumber.

It is not a virtue that Richard Gage is willing to sacrifice for such stupidity.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom