Oystein
Penultimate Amazing
- Joined
- Dec 9, 2009
- Messages
- 18,948
Cheers. So a negative growth rate for A&E professionals now?
That's a matter of definition and interpretation. Once you allow your petition to grow old, without soliciting any updates of old signatures, you assert that signatures by those who in the meantime are deceased are still valid. These people were, after all, professionals who had that opinion, and their subsequent death does not invalidate the argument from authority any more than its invalidity from the get-go.
The way I see it is that the pool of engineers and architects out there now probably grows faster than Gage's petition. This is supposing that for each professional that retires, a new professional gets his university degree, and for each that dies a new future one is born. So even if you allow the absolute number of signatures to grow and the deceased be counted, the proportion of A&E signers is now shrinking relative to the total number of A&E in America and the world, if you likewise allow those who retired or died since the petition started to be counted.
"We welcome contributions for food and an occasional warm shower along the way."