When will the AE911 petition finally reach juggernaut strength of 1%?

When will the AE911 petition reach juggernaut strength of 1%?

  • 20 years

    Votes: 3 1.4%
  • 50 years

    Votes: 2 0.9%
  • Never

    Votes: 80 36.4%
  • Who cares?….it's retarded anyway.....

    Votes: 135 61.4%

  • Total voters
    220
End of month update!

End of month update!

A) Architects and engineers:

May 31: 1699
Jun 30: 1701

2 new signatures in 30 days is equivalent to each existing signer convincing one peer once every 69.3 years. Scott Sommers asked a while ago what growth rate would constitute a virtual stand-still. This is it: Signers must be dying at a faster rate than new ones coming in!
...
The list by the way does NOT have 1701 names - it has only 1699 names, but I don't know since when there has been a discrepancy between the official count and the actual number of names.

A) Architects and engineers:

Jun 30: 1701
Jul 31: 1702

But this is misleading.
- They deleted 3 profiles of "members" who had two profiles on the list: Karim Tabbara (since sep 2009), Bryan Evan Westgate (since jan 2010) and Marshall Casey Pfeiffer (since feb 2012). So to compare fairly, I retroactively decreased the numbers per end of month, and for this july, it's

Jun 30: 1698
Jul 31: 1702

But this is still wrong: As I have noticed previously, the "official" count on the front page is too high - the full list (updated today) only has 1699 names -and so AE011T is still wrong to claim they have "1700+ A/Es" :p

Anyway, 4 new signers in 31 days, 0.13 per day or 7.75 days between signatures, is the second worst showing, only last month was worse. 7 of the 10 worst months ever were within the last 9 months. The annual growth rate of 2.8% is equivalent to each existing signer talking one peer into signing once every 35.6 years - the length of a professional career. That is more or less a stall.

B) Other Supporters:

May 31: 14,721
Jun 30: 14,804

83 new signatures in 30 days is equivalent to each existing signer convincing one new "member" once every 14.1 years.
...

B) Other Supporters:

Jun 30: 14,804
Jul 31: 14,886

82 new signatures in 31 days is equivalent to each existing signer convincing one new "member" once every 14.9 years.
The annual growth rate of 6.7% is the second-worst ever (that's ignoring two months in the early days when apparently some housekeeping resulted in negative and zero growth), but it's more than twice that of the A%E professionals, perpetuating the trend that amateurs have always been much easier to persuade.



To put this into visuals:

201010-201207AEOSlineargrowthmonthly.jpg


The Other Supporters seem to have reached a low level. The A&E had single digit signers in 4 of the last 5 months, so it's no wonder the purple line is jumping around more, but on a level dangerously close to zero.



What's ahead?

In most years, the summer months june-august are relatively weak, but september is strong every year, I'd guess coinciding with the 9/11 anniversaries (the month of may was strong only in 2007 and 2008, the february peak may be coincidence).

20120630AEOSAvglineargrowthmonthly.jpg


I'd expect another sad trickle in august, signs of life in september, and near-death in winter.
 
It was seem the correct answer to the polling question is the third option (perhaps the 4th as well :p).

Great work again Oystein
 
It was seem the correct answer to the polling question is the third option (perhaps the 4th as well :p).

Great work again Oystein

Well, since the beginning of this year, their number has grown equivalent to an annual rate of 6.25%

If they could sustain that rate indefinitely,
...after 20 years, they'd increase by a factor of 1.062520 = 3,36
...after 50 years, they'd increase by a factor of 1.062550 = 20,72

We don't know exactly where they stand right now in the USA. I estimate they have about 0.04% of all P.E.s in the USA, so after 50 years, they could reach 0.87% - close to 1%. Assuming of course that they all live those 50 years :D
 
Does it matter if their members die off? A signature is a signature, whether someone is alive or dead, once they've signed something, they've given their approval of that which they have signed.
 
Does it matter if their members die off? A signature is a signature, whether someone is alive or dead, once they've signed something, they've given their approval of that which they have signed.

True, but you'd be comparing signers dead and alive to the total number number of only alive professionals. If the 1700 now are 0.04% of all A&E now, then there are now 4,250,000 A&E total. In 50 years, we can surely expect that another 6 million or so university graduates will add to that number.and so this factor of 2.3 or 2.5 must also apply to the signers.

Past midnight here, I am not explaining well...
 
Good point, Oystein. You would have to compare dead and alive signers with dead and alive non-signers.
 
Well, since the beginning of this year, their number has grown equivalent to an annual rate of 6.25%

If they could sustain that rate indefinitely,
...after 20 years, they'd increase by a factor of 1.062520 = 3,36
...after 50 years, they'd increase by a factor of 1.062550 = 20,72

We don't know exactly where they stand right now in the USA. I estimate they have about 0.04% of all P.E.s in the USA, so after 50 years, they could reach 0.87% - close to 1%. Assuming of course that they all live those 50 years :D

Looks like they're dieing on the vine.
 
True. My problem is that I'm looking at this like a normal petition. A normal petition gets run for a short period of time and submitted, so it wouldn't matter if it's signers died after the fact or what the population will look like in 50 years time. The AE911 petition on the other hand seems destined to never be fully submitted..
 
CJ and Dave,

we have talked about this "submit the petition" issue before, and I think you are wrong to assume that it hasn't been submitted, or ought to be submitted.

In the USA, contrary to what we have in many other countries (I know this now about Germany, Australia and Canada; not sure about the UK), there is no defined single address to submit petitions to. Congress has no standing sub-committee, or a clerk, for petitions. The only, and correct way, to petition Congress seems to be to submit individually to each member.

AE911Truth has been calling on its members to submit the petition and list of signers to their respective and individual reps and senators, and this has been done frequently in the past. They have a team to organize and encourage this, the "Congressional Outreach Team".

I can't find quickly now an article they posted on the occasion of their reaching the 1000 A&E signers mark; it had a number of examples of AE911T activists meeting usually with staff members of representatives to hand them personally the printed-out petition with all 1000 names.
 
True, but you'd be comparing signers dead and alive to the total number number of only alive professionals. If the 1700 now are 0.04% of all A&E now, then there are now 4,250,000 A&E total. In 50 years, we can surely expect that another 6 million or so university graduates will add to that number.and so this factor of 2.3 or 2.5 must also apply to the signers.

Past midnight here, I am not explaining well...

Oystein,

I calculated about 1.8 millions As & Es in the US based on the most recent Bureau of Labor Statistics figures (2008 and 2010), where did you get your numbers from? Are they worldwide or or just US? I agree we also have to figure in those wo've died off. About 0.83& Americans die per year and that would be higher for adults.
 
Last edited:
Oystein,

I calculated about 1.8 millions As & Es in the US based on the most recent Bureau of Labor Statistics figures (2008 and 2010), where did you get your numbers from? Are they worldwide or or just US? I agree we also have to figure in those wo've died off. About 0.83& Americans die per year and that would be higher for adults.

I have gone through the P.E. rosters of several US states and got pretty exact numbers of PE licenses. I extrapolated these to a total number of P.E.s by going from state populations to total population of the USA of something over 300 million. Forgot the number - higher than what I found others saying, about 700,000 I think. This includes retired licensees, and double counts (engineers having more than one license), but these aren't too many.
So I found that 0.04% of all PEs signed the petition (in most states only around 0.02%, but California, the biggest state, is an outlier).

I simply assumed that the same percentage applies to architects, and to the non-licensed engineers. So I calculated 1700 / 0.04% = 4.25 million.

Of course my assumption is unproven. Perhaps architects flock to Gage in larger droves, and perhaps the non-licensed engineers are more easily impressed by woo.



ohhhhhhh and I made a mistake by including the non-US A&E. Should have been 1285 / 0.04% = 3.2 million :o
 
End of month update!

A) Architects and engineers:

...
Jun 30: 1698
Jul 31: 1702

... 4 new signers in 31 days, 0.13 per day or 7.75 days between signatures, ...

B) Other Supporters:

Jun 30: 14,804
Jul 31: 14,886

82 new signatures in 31 days ...

...

What's ahead?

...
I'd expect another sad trickle in august, signs of life in september, and near-death in winter.

Mid-month update:

A) Architects and engineers:

...
Jul 31: 1702
Aug 15: 1703

1 new signers in 15 days, 0.067 per day, is sad indeed. Doing a quick back-of-the-envelop calculation, I think they have more deaths than new signatures now.

(Remember: That number, shown on the front page of their home page, is wrong; the list actually has now 1701 names, that's 2 up from july 31st, so they cracked the 1700 in august; they thought they had it already in june)


B) Other Supporters:

Jul 31: 14,886
Aug 15: 14,959

73 new signatures in 15 days is an improvement over recent months, when they needes almost a full month to get that many.

(Again, this number is wrong, and here it's too low! Their list has 14,999 names as of August 15, 2012 16:01, so they probably reached 15,000 today)
 
Mid-month update:

A) Architects and engineers:

...
Jul 31: 1702
Aug 15: 1703

1 new signers in 15 days, 0.067 per day, is sad indeed. Doing a quick back-of-the-envelop calculation, I think they have more deaths than new signatures now. (Remember: That number, shown on the front page of their home page, is wrong; the list actually has now 1701 names, that's 2 up from july 31st, so they cracked the 1700 in august; they thought they had it already in june)


B) Other Supporters:

Jul 31: 14,886
Aug 15: 14,959

73 new signatures in 15 days is an improvement over recent months, when they needes almost a full month to get that many.

(Again, this number is wrong, and here it's too low! Their list has 14,999 names as of August 15, 2012 16:01, so they probably reached 15,000 today)

I won't embarrass myself by trying to work out how many might have died, but here are stats on the US death rate:

http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/fastats/deaths.htm/
 
I won't embarrass myself by trying to work out how many might have died, but here are stats on the US death rate:

http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/fastats/deaths.htm/

hmmm
794 deaths per 100,000 (per year) means that each person dies once every 126 years :eek:

This includes children. Mortality increases significantly with age, so the number of signers who die this year depends heavily on the age distribution.

Back of the envelope: A&E are usually between 30 and 80 years old. Suppose the 1700 are evenly spread over that span of 50 years. Suppose they die at 80. 1700/50 = 34 of them will then reach 80 and die this year, or 2.8 per month.
 
hmmm
794 deaths per 100,000 (per year) means that each person dies once every 126 years :eek:

This includes children. Mortality increases significantly with age, so the number of signers who die this year depends heavily on the age distribution.

Back of the envelope: A&E are usually between 30 and 80 years old. Suppose the 1700 are evenly spread over that span of 50 years. Suppose they die at 80. 1700/50 = 34 of them will then reach 80 and die this year, or 2.8 per month.

Cheers. So a negative growth rate for A&E professionals now?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom