DGM
Skeptic not Atheist
All in all, I think they are managing the list quite commendably.
What else do they have to do? Besides that, it's their top marketing tool.
All in all, I think they are managing the list quite commendably.
Richard,
actually...
...they do check the "general" members (what they call "Other Supporters"), at least superficially. First, your email address is checked; you automatically are sent an email with a confirmation link; and you can't use am address twice. Secondly, they seem to read what people write. So if your name is Mickey Mouse, you live on Plantex X or you actually support the official theory in you personal statement, chances are your signature will be rejected. Only about 60-65% of filled-out petition forms make it to the final list
...they do remove signatures. It happens rarely, and I can't tell you for what reasons it happens, but occasionally a signature is deleted. I suspect this is usually due to the member having reconsidered and actively mailing them. No doubt a notable number of members have died in the 5.5 years since the petition began, without anyone noticing.
All in all, I think they are managing the list quite commendably.
Sep 30: 1720End of month / quarter update!
I'll try to keep this brief, as I see indications that Gage's backoffice still had a backlog of unprocessed signatures by the end of september - perhaps on the order of 100, of which the large majority would be "Other Supporters", and only a handful could be architects or engineers.
...
A) Architects and engineers:
Aug 31: 1706
Sep 30: 1720
Sep 30: 15,470B) Other Supporters:
Aug 31: 15,070
Sep 30: 15,470
...
The annual growth rate three and a half times that of the A&E professionals, continuing the trend that amateurs have always been much easier to persuade.
Predictably, after the september mayhem, page hits are again sharply down this month:Page hits:
It interesting to note that, from August 2010 to July 2011, ae911truth.org had 5148 daily page hits on average; from July 2011 to July 2012 that was up to 7042 - and still the number of new signatures dropped greatly in the same intervals (A&E: from 0.77 to 0.49 per day. Other Supporters: from 10.3 to 6.3 per day)
However, August 2012 was down compared to the previous 12 months, while September 2012 was sharply up:
[qimg]http://i1088.photobucket.com/albums/i328/MikeAlfaromeo/AE911T/20120930ae911truthOrgPageHits2010-2012.jpg[/qimg]
This rise in September is almost entirely due to extremetraffic around the 9/11 anniversary:
[qimg]http://i1088.photobucket.com/albums/i328/MikeAlfaromeo/AE911T/20120930ae911truthOrgPageHitsSep2012.jpg[/qimg]
...
This still applies.What's ahead?
Like I said last month already, we will probably see a sharp drop after the september peak, as things return to normal.
But since, as I mentioned at the beginning of this post, their backoffice probably still has to process a number of signatures that came in during september, october might look decent - but november I predict to challange record lows.
Also in november, Gage's IRS statement, form 990 is due, which I expect to show a notable drop in revenues compared to 2010, in keeping with the fading interest in his petition.
C) Fundraisers
Fundraiser #1 National College Outreach
Purpose: "Support AE911Truth's ambitious effort this fall to take our message on a college speaking tour – beginning with APCA.com and NACA.org conference and showcases. Critical youth outreach."
Fundraiser #2 Journey for 9/11 Truth
Purpose: "Support AE011Truth team leaders Pam Senzee & Rena Petty who have embarked on a 3,000 miles bike journey across the country – passing out DVDs and talking to everyone along the way"
He filed for and received an extension. He has until November 15th to file. Last year he filed 2 days before the dead-line (got an extension last year also).I'm not sure of tax law, but perhaps Gage is nearing the crap because he hasn't disclosed his profit from selling his tours, merchandise, dvds etc to the IRS, so he's donating the money back to himself so he can disclose his income as donations?..
Sounds like a conspiracy![]()
Mid-month update:
Sep 30: 1720
Oct 16: 1733
13 new in 15.5 days - looks impressive.
But remember the backlog I mentioned: Of these 13, 9 signed up in september but didn't appear on the webpage before october 1st.
Sep 30: 15,470
Oct 16: 15,650
That's 180 new signatures in 15.5 days, but again, remember the backlog they had at the end of september, which they have cleaned by now. About half of these 180 actually already signed up in september, and the other half in october. So while I logged 400 new signatures for september, october is on a pace towards perhaps 270 - and actually, closer to 490 signed up in september, and october so far has only 180/month. In other words: The september 11th anniversary hype is already over.
Predictably, after the september mayhem, page hits are again sharply down this month:
Aug 2012 - Jul 2012: 7042 hits/day
Aug 2012: 5306 hits/day
Sep 2012: 10779 hits/day
Oct 2012: 6430 hits/day ()through october 16th, lunch time in Europe)
This still applies.
Started: Aug 21, 2012
Scheduled end: Oct 21, 2012 (61 days)
Target: US$ 9,600 ($157/day)
Raised so far (October 09): $ 9,600 (Sep 30: $8,085)
Contributors: 52 (Sep 30: 44)
ENDED, on target
8 contributors in September gave $1,515, that's an average of $189.38 per contributor, $168.33 per day - dominated by a single donation of $1,000. Earlier, there had been three individual donations of $500 each, and one early $5,000 donation in august. This puzzles me a bit - who are the domors of such amounts? So 5 of 52 donations added up to $7,500, the other 47 to just $2,100 (under $45 per donation).
Started: Aug 21, 2012
Scheduled end: Oct 30, 2012 (70 days)
Target: US$ 3,200 ($46/day)
Raised so far (Oct 16): $3,370 (Sep 30: $2,280) - that's 105% of trarget
Contributors: 38 (Sep 30: 32)
$1090 from 6 contributors in october - these break down as 20, 40 and 60 dollars, and then I saw an increase of 970 with 3 donations. I'd there was one big donation of $900 to reach 100% of target, and 2 smaller ones of perhaps 20 and 50 dollars on top of that. All previous contibutions but two had been under $51. There had been one $500-donation in August, and a $150 one in september. So here, again, two individual donations of $900 and $500 totally dominate an otherwise slow fundraiser.
So far in 2012, such fundraisers (there were five, and the better part of a sixth that began in december '11) raised a total of about $25,900.
In 2011, the total was over $38,000 from the same number of fundraisers. In 2010, the total was over 40,000 from seven and a half campaigns. So this sort of income has a downward trend, though not as dramatically as the signatures.
Good point.This appears fairly straightforward to me. It's become formulaic for Gage. He has a clear understanding of how many people he can attract from talking with groups of a given size and how much money he can get - on average. All he has to do is keep up his campaigning and fund raising.
I am not so sure about the "vast numbers". Vast numbers feel strongly about human rights, even vaster numbers about childrens' rights and animal rights and the environment. Online petitions for the benefit of an child care center or even a single dog frequently outpace the current flock of truther petitions by wide margins. There seem to be only a few thousand persons worldwide that are still invested in this issue, feel strongly enough and are connected well enough to just fill out a form on the internet. Only a few dozend part with their money on a given cause.I've been saying for years that the idea the Truth Movement is dead is nonsense. There are vast numbers of people who continue to feel strongly about this. Gage is still able to mobolize gainfully employed people to make videos for him - for example his Psychologists for 9/11 Truth thing. At least some of those people - and I suspect all of them - come from his personal church contacts. $1000? That's not a lot of money. If you really believed in this Truth crap, how many people on the JREF with regular jobs as teachers, engineers, architects, etc could afford this? All of them. Besides, for all I know, it came from Tony Szamboti or David Ray Griffin, who despite their crazy ideas remain gainfully employed.
I disagree somewhat with this. I have predicted, and I stay by that, that his 2011 income will be somewhat down from 2010, and that he already feels a more dramatic decrease of income in 2012. I further said that his organisation will struggle financially to survive 2013....
My guess is Gage can keep on doing this forever. The cash flow situation he has established is guaranteed. The people he is directing his message to don't care about scientific reasoning or the consensus of the engineering community.
Good point.
I am not so sure about the "vast numbers". Vast numbers feel strongly about human rights, even vaster numbers about childrens' rights and animal rights and the environment. Online petitions for the benefit of an child care center or even a single dog frequently outpace the current flock of truther petitions by wide margins. There seem to be only a few thousand persons worldwide that are still invested in this issue, feel strongly enough and are connected well enough to just fill out a form on the internet. Only a few dozens part with their money on a given cause.
Of course these are not all active Truthers. In fact, my guess is that many of them would be African-American. Others would be Democrats who saw Michael Moore's movie, or something like that. I suspect, almost all of them would laugh at Truthers standing on the street corner yelling at people. Almost none of them would be giving money to Truther groups or marching with them in their rallies..The collapse of the World Trade Center was the result of a controlled demolition
These would be people who sign Internet petitions, give money or attend rallies. These would be people who talk about 9/11 Truth with their friends.only a few thousand persons worldwide that are still invested in this issue
The issue to me is the connection between the two groups we pointed to above. Does the latter recruit from the former? I doubt it. 'Invested' Truthers are recruited from the same pool of people who used to join New Age religious groups when I was in my 20s and 30s. Many of the right wing Truthers I know talk openly about their past interest in new age religion. Gage's left wing Truthers are drawn openly from liberal Christian churches and fringe groups like transcendental meditation. Some of his regional contact people for 9/11T are astrologers.Yes, I believe there are a few sustaining members of that "church". There are more who spend their time than their money.
What I want to point out though is that these two latest fundraisers were exceptional, compared to the four previous ones, in that they were dominated by a few very large donations; both had large donations early on, and both reached their targets with a final large donation. How convenient. I can't prove it, of course, but that smells like pimping. Doesn't have to be Gage himself who's doing the pimping - after all, they now took both off the website, before the planned end date. Pimping with his own money would thus have the effect of decreasing income. I think he personally reached out to his sustainers.
This is where I will predict differently. 9/11T does not directly offer, "god's grace, eternal redemption, or elevation of the soul in the hereafter," but it is directly connected to these issues in the same way that creation science has been. It is a political manifestation of these for many American Christians. There is no way it is going anywhere for these people. They will continue to give their time and money and energy to this cause as long as they have breathe. It is a living demonstration of their faith in God on earth.I disagree somewhat with this. I have predicted, and I stay by that, that his 2011 income will be somewhat down from 2010, and that he already feels a more dramatic decrease of income in 2012. I further said that his organisation will struggle financially to survive 2013.
You see, this is not actually a church. It does not offer god's grace, eternal redemption, or elevation of the soul in the hereafter. $1000 won't bring you closer to victory over death.
Well, if a random phone survey asked me if I think Lee Harvey Oswald was part of a conspiracy, I might be inclined to answer "yes", depending on the wording. That's because I know very little about that case beyond what I learned from the Oliver Stone movie. Does that mean a lot? Ask people randomly what they think about any complex issue, say, tax reform, and results won't resemble objective facts but general political allegiance (or political spite). I don't think my behaviour - in elections, for example - changes because of such a single issue. So I'd say it is an insignificant polling result. It informs us less about what people think they know about 9/11 (most people know almost nothing), but more about wide-spread disconnection (which is why I tend not to doubt your suspicion that such beliefs are more wide-spread among African-Americans).Much of this depends on what we mean by a Truther. Are Truthers people willing to endorse Truther-type items on a random phone survey? The most recent surveys point to millions willing to endorse these. Angus-Reid in 2010 found 15% willing to endorse,
Of course these are not all active Truthers. In fact, my guess is that many of them would be African-American. Others would be Democrats who saw Michael Moore's movie, or something like that. I suspect, almost all of them would laugh at Truthers standing on the street corner yelling at people. Almost none of them would be giving money to Truther groups or marching with them in their rallies..
Wow - thanksIn your post, you delineate this further, talking about Truthers who are "invested in the issue." This is a good way to categorize. In fact, this usage of English is so natural and concise, I'm having trouble believing you are not a native English speaker.
I am clearly interested in the latter. Particularly in this thread, I am monitoring the active Truthers: Those that sign petitions and donate money.Yes, this is the term that needs to used. And you would be correct in your estimation of this group's size.
These would be people who sign Internet petitions, give money or attend rallies. These would be people who talk about 9/11 Truth with their friends.
Which of these 2 groups are we talking about? On the JREF, it is clearly the latter.
That's my intuition, too. Recruiting is not mathematically zero, of course, but an insignificant trickle.The issue to me is the connection between the two groups we pointed to above. Does the latter recruit from the former? I doubt it.
I am glad you are saying this! I haven't investigated this in a systematic fashion, but it has been my impression after reading a lot personal statements, and also by occasionally checking which other causes these people support at change.org, that there is a strong faction among Gage's supporters that lean left, and also a strong faction that is sympathetic to esoteric thought. Of course there are also the Ron Paulists. What I haven't seen more often than I would expect is direct references to god or religious beliefs. Sure, you see them, but that is (sorry) America for me...'Invested' Truthers are recruited from the same pool of people who used to join New Age religious groups when I was in my 20s and 30s. Many of the right wing Truthers I know talk openly about their past interest in new age religion. Gage's left wing Truthers are drawn openly from liberal Christian churches and fringe groups like transcendental meditation. Some of his regional contact people for 9/11T are astrologers.
Alright, I am game (hope we don't forgetThis is where I will predict differently. 9/11T does not directly offer, "god's grace, eternal redemption, or elevation of the soul in the hereafter," but it is directly connected to these issues in the same way that creation science has been. It is a political manifestation of these for many American Christians. There is no way it is going anywhere for these people. They will continue to give their time and money and energy to this cause as long as they have breathe. It is a living demonstration of their faith in God on earth.
I'll bet you a beer on this one. In 3 years, AE9/11T will still be touring, drawing in money and paying Gage a salary. I never gamble but this one is worth it. Let's have a pool on this one.
Architects and Engineers for 9/11 truth has 1,734 members according to my last mailing list. 517 fully qualified Structural Engineers, thats almost a 3rd of all our members. Our membership has never reduced in size and we have never received any requests to do so. The membership form is quite detailed so id say pretty impossible for names to be added without consent. We also have 15,673 other members.
if you want to spin your disinfo here, make sure you have evidence.
Thanks Oystein, yeah I didn't doubt the authenticity, however I did call bs on his figures. XLS would be great if it's not too much trouble, don't stress if its not absolutely recent, this is after all just a youtube scuffle, nothing important, but I'm sure many others here on JREF would be interesting in seeing a spread of the members.
So you'll find that, in my judgement, they have approximately 60 structural engineers (STR), plus about 170 civil engineers (CIV). A handful describe themselves as "architectural engineers" (ARC - not to be confused with "Architect"). Those, as well as the "fire protection engineer" (FIR) and perhaps some of the marine, geological or mechanical engineers, possibly can also claim to have relevent professional expertise about steel constructions.
... I bet you one question they dont ask them is do you believe that the towers were brought down by a controlled demolition. ...
So?
I am fairly certain that the vast majority of them do actually believe in CD, or at least consider it significantly likely. That's judging from very many personal statements.