Merged What's happening in the Middle East?

He's gone. The army is in charge.

http://www.theage.com.au/world/jubi...gns-swiss-freeze-accounts-20110212-1aqv2.html

Jubilation as Mubarak resigns: Swiss freeze accounts

February 12, 2011


Protesters celebrate Mubarak's resignation in the Egyptian city of Alexandria.

Egyptian President Hosni Mubarak has resigned and handed power to the army.
The Swiss government immediately ordered a freeze on any assets belonging to the Egyptian President and his entourage, saying that the three-year freeze was aimed at preventing any risk of embezzlement of Egyptian state property.
....

Nobel Peace laureate Mohammed ElBaradei, whose young suporters were among the organisers of the protest movement, said: ‘‘This is the greatest day of my life."
"The country has been liberated after decades of repression," he said, adding that he expected a "beautiful" transition of power."
Up until yesterday, Mubarak said he would stay until September elections, while handing powers to his vice-president
 
not even close. Hezbollah aren't even fascists.

Then how would you characterize them, Parky? Are they unicorns that fart rainbows? Are they like the Easter Bunny bringing chocolate eggs and candy to children everywhere? Are they brave guardians of Democracy in the Middle East?

What do you think Lebanon will look like if Hezbollah takes over? Do you think they will make it a better place? Safer?
 
Not yet, but they're getting pretty close.

It's way too early to tell. Hezbollah leads a dominant coalition in Parliament, but that coalition includes a number of non-Islamist parties who might not go along with a substantial change in how Lebanon is ruled.

The governmental system there is still pretty new itself, and the product of a number of shaky compromises, so if there's a change in Lebanon, a more likely outcome is a return to the Civil War, not a Hezbollah-ruled "Islamofascist" state.
 
Then how would you characterize them, Parky? Are they unicorns that fart rainbows? Are they like the Easter Bunny bringing chocolate eggs and candy to children everywhere?

yeah, that's it.

good work there Mycroft. You pinned the tail on the donkey.






.......but Muslim extremists is a good descriptor.
 
Last edited:
It's way too early to tell. Hezbollah leads a dominant coalition in Parliament, but that coalition includes a number of non-Islamist parties who might not go along with a substantial change in how Lebanon is ruled.
That would indeed make a difference, if Hizbullah didn't have an army more powerful than the Lebanese government army. Half of which would probably fight for Hizbullah if another civil war broke out.

Lebanon will be a democracy until Hizbullah decides it's time to seize the moment.

eta: IMHO Hizbullah could seize control of Lebanon right now, but doesn't because the status quo is enough to keep Israel from a full blown war against Lebanon. As it is now they have to go through the motions of attacking Hizbullah without attacking the Lebanese army (Lebanon).
 
Last edited:
That would indeed make a difference, if Hizbullah didn't have an army more powerful than the Lebanese government army. Half of which would probably fight for Hizbullah if another civil war broke out.

Lebanon will be a democracy until Hizbullah decides it's time to seize the moment.

eta: IMHO Hizbullah could seize control of Lebanon right now, but doesn't because the status quo is enough to keep Israel from a full blown war against Lebanon. As it is now they have to go through the motions of attacking Hizbullah without attacking the Lebanese army (Lebanon).

Well, yeah. But that was the case before the January coalition change, too. It's not like gaining a barely-majority coalition government will suddenly drive Hezbollah to carry out a coup if they weren't going to do that before.
 
Well, yeah. But that was the case before the January coalition change, too. It's not like gaining a barely-majority coalition government will suddenly drive Hezbollah to carry out a coup if they weren't going to do that before.
The more powerful they are the easier it is to take power in a coup, but Hizbullah can have its cake and eat it too by not taking complete control. They can attack Israel without risking an all-out Israeli attack on the Lebanese government and army. But the more they appear to actually be in control, the more likely they are to get to the point where the line between Hizbullah and the Lebanese government blurs to invisibility.

It's one thing to attack Israel as a terrorist group, quite another when it's an attack by a state.
 
The more powerful they are the easier it is to take power in a coup, but Hizbullah can have its cake and eat it too by not taking complete control. They can attack Israel without risking an all-out Israeli attack on the Lebanese government and army. But the more they appear to actually be in control, the more likely they are to get to the point where the line between Hizbullah and the Lebanese government blurs to invisibility.

They're not really any closer now, though, given the way the coalitions work there. After the next set of elections, maybe, but even that will run into the issue of the confessional distribution of both government positions and parliamentary seats.

EDIT: Not saying that Hezbollah dominance of Lebanon isn't a realistic threat, or that a Hezbollah-dominated Lebanon wouldn't be a threat. Just saying that the risk of both those things is independent of their parliamentary majority...they're the same threat whether they have all the seats they are allowed to get, or no seats at all.
 
Last edited:
No, I'm pretty sure I'm talking to you.

"Brainwashed yankistanis" make their own decisions. I can't remember the last time I asked a brainwashed yankistani to sacrifice a child. I may have eaten one once, but I'm not sure. That may have been a chimpanzee. While I was having a werewolf episode.

If you're talking about military service, you don't know what you're talking about in that sphere either. The truth is, U.S. military personnel don't die much. Not like other folks. During the bloodiest fighting in Iraq, 2003 to 2006, the U.S. military death rate (in Iraq) was 3.92 per 1000, compared to 8.42 per 1000 for a randomly chosen U.S. citizen.

As one Marine Colonel put it, "The safest place in the world is in the middle of a battalion of Marines."

No brag. Just fact.

http://repository.upenn.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1000&context=psc_working_papers



I even read something a while back that revealed, for the particular Division they were looking at at least, even the death rate within the military unit actually dropped once they were deployed to Iraq. In other words being on active duty in a volatile war zone was safer than being back safe and sound at your home base.
 
I even read something a while back that revealed, for the particular Division they were looking at at least, even the death rate within the military unit actually dropped once they were deployed to Iraq. In other words being on active duty in a volatile war zone was safer than being back safe and sound at your home base.
You read somewhere?

Here is the data from the Toontown's link:
The death rate for US men aged 18-39 in 2003 is 1.53 per 1000, about 40% of that of soldiers in Iraq....In Philadelphia, the death rate for black males aged 20-34 in 2002 was 4.37/1000, 11% higher than for troops in Iraq.

So taking the most dangerous place you can find for young men in the US and comparing it to the average risk of a US soldier in Iraq and gee, now you can say young men are not dying needlessly in Iraq.

Why not compare the most dangerous place in each country or the average in each? It would be more honest.
 
I even read something a while back that revealed, for the particular Division they were looking at at least, even the death rate within the military unit actually dropped once they were deployed to Iraq. In other words being on active duty in a volatile war zone was safer than being back safe and sound at your home base.

You read somewhere?

I read something similar somewhere, too. It was because so many troops were killing themselves once they got home, either directly or through risk-taking behaviors such as drug abuse and drink-driving.


ETA: "If deaths associated with high-risk behaviours – including drink-driving and drug overdoses – are taken into account, more soldiers are dying by their own hand than in combat, the report found."

http://www.rawa.org/temp/runews/201...e-exceeds-national-average.html#ixzz1Dk66BUF3
 
Last edited:
You read somewhere?

Yeah it was a newspaper article about a division that was about to come home from Iraq. It was from the early days, so I guess 2004 or something. They were interviewing the Division Commander and he made the observation because it found it quite interesting.



Here is the data from the Toontown's link:

So taking the most dangerous place you can find for young men in the US and comparing it to the average risk of a US soldier in Iraq and gee, now you can say young men are not dying needlessly in Iraq.

Well actually Toontown compared with the overall death rate in the USA, he made no mention of the statistics for young black men in Philadelphia or any other specific statistic. I agree with you that Toontown's representation of the statistics isn't particularly honest, but neither is your representation of his use of the statistics. I'm not entirely sure how useful it is only to look at the US death statistics for 18-39 though either, because the guys serving in Iraq aren't just 18-39 (although a lot of them are).

Anyway...

If you think the Iraq War was needless (which I do), then by definition young men are dying needlessly in Iraq. Whether they're also dying needlessly in the USA (which they most certainly are) is irrelevant.

I wasn't really trying to support Toontown's position. I was merely adding an off-handed comment about an interesting thing I'd read about one particular military unit. The explanations offered in the article (by the Division Commander) for difference was in several parts:

1) Soldiers on operational service are more restricted in their recreation activities, drinking, etc, so less exposed to such accidents that contribute significantly to peace-time death.
2) Soldiers on operational service spend less time in high-intensity training where deadly training accidents can occur
3) Soldiers on operational service know they're in a dangerous place so they're just generally more careful
4) Older officers in the Division who are more likely to die (heart attacks, stroke, blah blah) are less likely to be deployed operationally as they're less fit

There were a bunch of others.



Why not compare the most dangerous place in each country or the average in each? It would be more honest.

He did use the average for each. The problem he didn't account for is that the average total death rate for the USA is skewed by old people who die at higher rates. In Iraq there's less old people.

I think to get a really clear comparison you'd need to be able to breakdown the percentage of people serving in Iraq by age, and then construct an average death rate for the US population using the same weighting by age groups.

I have no idea if that's even possible, to be honest. And since the entire war in Iraq was stupid and pointless in the first place, I don't see much point in even entertaining such an exercise, personally.
 
I read something similar somewhere, too. It was because so many troops were killing themselves once they got home, either directly or through risk-taking behaviors such as drug abuse and drink-driving.


ETA: "If deaths associated with high-risk behaviours – including drink-driving and drug overdoses – are taken into account, more soldiers are dying by their own hand than in combat, the report found."

http://www.rawa.org/temp/runews/201...e-exceeds-national-average.html#ixzz1Dk66BUF3



That's a bit different to what I was reading. In the article I read the Division Commander was comparing pre-deployment deaths with deployment deaths. They were about to come back from Iraq so I don't know how things might have changed once you added post-deployment deaths to the equation.

I think it's pretty safe to say that, relatively speaking, combat in Iraq is quite exceptionally safe for US soldiers. Not that I think this is really a particularly momentous discovery. We established after the Persian Gulf War that modern warfare was reasonable bloodless for modern western armies.

That shouldn't really have any bearing on the validity of the war though, IMHO.

I think a war should either be worth fighting, or it shouldn't. WW2 was worth fighting, and I don't imagine the allies would have packed it in if they'd reached some magic arbitrary death toll that was considered "too much". Once you in, you're in to win, whatever the cost.

Meanwhile if a war's not worth fighting, like Iraq, one death is too many.
 
Reality check: I brought up the very low U.S. military death rate simply to defend myself against Childlike Empress's vicious smear the effect that the children of hapless U.S. mothers are being fed into a meat grinder to satisfy MY supremacist illusions.

I understand it very well. But you're not talking to me, you are talking to brainwashed yankistanis. It's their children who are requested to die and pay for your supremacist illusions after all.

You don't want to face the truth, don't mess with me.
 
Last edited:
I wasn't really trying to support Toontown's position. I was merely adding an off-handed comment about an interesting thing I'd read about one particular military unit. The explanations offered in the article (by the Division Commander) for difference was in several parts:

Hey, dude. Don't be making any off-handed comments around here unless you're prepared to defend yourself for several pages against mult-pronged attacks. These people will attack a bean fart if they suspect the fart of having unwelcome political overtones.
:D
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom