Merged What's happening in the Middle East?

Last edited:
turning ugly.

Al Jazeera reports men on horseback and on camels entering the square, along with men armed with clubs and knives.

A couple of days ago there were already reports of pick-up trucks full of baseball bats coming to supply the pro-gov thugs.

The army is letting them into the square.
Also not a good sign.

ETA:

"The people on horses are pro-Mubarak supporters, they are a very angry crowd looking for anyone working for Al Jazeera and for Americans. They are trying to get on the other side of the army tanks to get to the anti-Mubarak supporters. More and more pro-Mubarak supporters are coming in."

WTF?

Link
 
Last edited:
Wait. The pro-Mubarak forces are anti-American? And after all that tear gas we sold them!
 
And the cliches start coming out.

"I hope they implement a Western Style democracy"

Yeah, because we know best.

Oh wait.
What have Western Style Democracies done for the people of Egypt in the past century? What have all those wonderful western style democracies been doing to the people of Egypt? Oppressing them. The "best political system in the world" seems to treat other peoples like farm fertilizer. Go figure.

here's another good one:

"Mubarak is a tyrant, I'm glad they are getting rid of him!"

Oh really, so you voted for Ron Paul then or Mike Gravel or third party then? Because they were the only ones who ever even came close to suggesting our cozy ties with foreign dictators, and all the money we were giving them was immoral.

those crazy extremists. :rolleyes: Moderate is suggesting it is good to support corrupt dictators with billions upon billions of dollars. Hell, it's something both parties can agree on, and have for decades. What a swell western-style democracy we got!

BUT NOW... oh, NOW... everybody thinks it is shameful we've been propping up Mubarak and his cronies. Just like Obama. NOW Obama is concerned about American foreign policy in Egypt.
Little late for that, isn't it America? Maybe you should have been concerned THIRTY YEARS AGO!

That is because American are useless, cowardly sheep, who ironically think they should be the world's shepherd.

I hope the people of Egypt get a government that gives them equality.
and I hope they exact a terrible justice on the crooks who have been stealing from them, and oppressing them, and casting fear upon them, for decades.


I also hope Americans will closely examine their foreign policy, and who they have been propping up, and who they have been deposing/toppling.

Oh wait, that will never happen. Well maybe one of two ain't bad.

Because 15000 protesters broke a couple of windows in Cairo?

Is that all it is?
You forgot the 30 years of economic and political oppression.
 
Last edited:
baltagy

.....today's appearance of a "pro-Mubarak" crowd has nothing to do with popular support, and everything to do with the regime calling in its thugs. The Egyptian regime has long relied on baltagy, thugs-for-hire, to do their bidding, from quashing overly rambunctious election rallies to breaking up peaceful protests that are regularly seen around various government ministries. Egyptians say that in many cases the baltagy are petty criminals that were released from jail on the condition that they work for the government when needed. Says Higazy, who says he is not a member of any party: "These men are not supporting Mubarak. They are thugs paid to go and injure and kill people peacefully practicing their freedom of speech."

'The Violent Struggle for Cairo's Tahrir Square: An Eyewitness Account'
 
In reality this is a rear guard fight, making anti-western feelings worse when real change inevitable will come. But since this is the future of Europe in 2029 (and in the US already in this decade) change in Egypt will come during the US collapse at the latest, an event that even American Zionists know all too well is coming.

Paul Craig Roberts agrees with me that change in Egypt will most likely come after the collapse of the dollar (and America):

http://globalresearch.ca/index.php?context=va&aid=23029
Because the US dollar is the world reserve currency, the US government has financial dominance and the ability to financially isolate other countries, such as Iran. To break free of America’s grip, one of two things would have to happen. Revolution would have to sweep the Arab world and result in an economic unity that could foster indigenous economic development, or the US dollar has to fail as world currency...

The collapse of the dollar is more likely. Indeed, the policy of the US government to maximize both budget and trade deficits, and the policy of the Federal Reserve to monetize the budget deficit and the fraudulent paper assets of the large banks, have the dollar heading for demise.
 
political theories don't kill people. only people kill people.

and following your logic, "Capitalism" has killed millions of people throughout the world as well.

Presumably slavery counts as a somewhat capitalist endeavour? And it didn't have a great record of letting them out alive.
 
I'm seeing reports that Anderson Cooper was beaten up by a pro-Mubarak mob.

Yes, here's video of the incident.

Sadly, I think that - at some point - violence was inevitable. Seems that the pro-Mubarak folks are getting desperate, and violence is about the only thing left to them at this point.

ETA: Like I said earlier in the thread, I hope this doesn't escalate into a civil war.
 
Last edited:
If you think Egypt is bad, wait until this starts in Syria........It will probably make the Hama Massacre in 1982 look like a picnic.
Assad, like his father, will do anything to stay in power. No way he is going out except via a Tank or a AK 47......
 
Presumably slavery counts as a somewhat capitalist endeavour? And it didn't have a great record of letting them out alive.

Well, the more extreme forms of Socialism does not have a great record either....The Soviet Union under Stalin, China under Mao, Cambodia under Pol Pot.......
 
I'm seeing reports that Anderson Cooper was beaten up by a pro-Mubarak mob.

I suppose every cloud has a silver lining.

In other news, I think we now know where all the police disappeared off to. :mad:

Looks like it. Many of them were carrying very slick banners that looked like they'd just been mass-produced.
 
And the cliches start coming out.

OK...gimme your best cliche shots. I'm ready for you.


Nice start.

What have Western Style Democracies done for the people of Egypt in the past century?

Kept them alive. Hitler really, really wanted that canal. And so did the Soviets. And a Western Style Democracy got them to stop attacking Israel, which was like beating their head against a concrete wall.

What has Egypt done for Western Style Democracies in the past century, besides repeatedly try to destroy one of them? Oh wait I forgot. Mubarak stopped trying to destroy one of them. Because we paid him to stop trying to destroy one of them.

What have all those wonderful western style democracies been doing to the people of Egypt?

Mostly defending themselves. Israel had to fight them off 3 times. After the 3rd failure, the Egyptians gave up and signed a peace treaty. The very generous terms of the treaty has had the U.S. cough up a grand total of @50 billion, resulting in the odiously false cries that the U.S. has been supporting the Egyptian despots.

But they have always been despots in their own right. They've never needed any help for that.

Oppressing them.

No, their leaders have been oppressing them. The U.S. has simply been keeping them from starting more wars.

The "best political system in the world" seems to treat other peoples like farm fertilizer. Go figure.

Go figure what? Why you told that filthy, stinking lie?

I have a better idea. Why don't you just tell us why you told that filthy, stinking lie.

here's another good one:

"Mubarak is a tyrant, I'm glad they are getting rid of him!"

Oh really, so you voted for Ron Paul then or Mike Gravel or third party then? Because they were the only ones who ever even came close to suggesting our cozy ties with foreign dictators, and all the money we were giving them was immoral.

Hmm...

Before giving Egypt all that money, 3 wars started by Egypt.

After giving Egypt all that money, 0 wars.

Hard to argue with reality. In fact, you will go insane if you persistently try to argue with reality. See Ron Paul.

those crazy extremists. :rolleyes: Moderate is suggesting it is good to support corrupt dictators with billions upon billions of dollars. Hell, it's something both parties can agree on, and have for decades. What a swell western-style democracy we got!

Hmm...

Before giving Egypt all that money, 3 wars started by Egypt.

After giving Egypt all that money, 0 wars.

Hard to argue with reality. In fact, you will go insane if you persistently try to argue with reality. See Ron Paul.

BUT NOW... oh, NOW... everybody thinks it is shameful we've been propping up Mubarak and his cronies. Just like Obama. NOW Obama is concerned about American foreign policy in Egypt.
Little late for that, isn't it America? Maybe you should have been concerned THIRTY YEARS AGO!

They were concerned 30 years ago. That's why they pulled Egypt out of Soviet orbit and signed a joint peace treaty.

Look, ma! No more Egypt-Israeli wars! And we owe it all to...UWdooooood!

Oh wait...

That is because American are useless, cowardly sheep, who ironically think they should be the world's shepherd.

Actually, we were hoping the rest of you useful, courageous sheepdogs would step up and be the world's shepherd. That's why we've been doing such a lousy job of it. But you all just keep sitting there on your dead asses, whining and pointing fingers of blame.

I hope the people of Egypt get a government that gives them equality.
and I hope they exact a terrible justice on the crooks who have been stealing from them, and oppressing them, and casting fear upon them, for decades..

Translation: you hope the Egyptians get fooled again, and then get led into a catastrophic war with Israel.

Sorry, I just couldn't come up with another reasonable interpretation of your rant.

I also hope Americans will closely examine their foreign policy, and who they have been propping up, and who they have been deposing/toppling.

And I hope you will closely examine your foreign policy, and who you have been propping up, and who you have been slandering. But we both know that's not going to happen, don't we.

And you hope the U.S. will prop up tyrants like Saddam and the Taliban, but topple tyrants like Mubarak. But we both know that's not going to happen, don't we.

But if all you foreigners, who obviously know best, will just step up and be the sheepdog, there will be peace in the valley some day. But we both know that's not going to happen, don't we.

Oh wait, that will never happen. Well maybe one of two ain't bad.

I already said that.

Is that all it is?
You forgot the 30 years of economic and political oppression.

I didn't forget anything. But you seem to have wandered in here from some parallel universe in which the U.S. has been occupying Egypt for 30 years.

You need to go back to your own universe. You're completely lost in this one.
 
Last edited:
That is because American are useless, cowardly sheep, who ironically think they should be the world's shepherd.
Care to say that to me in person?

You sort of lost the plot there, as I think a couple of your opening points were worth voicing.

What has democracy ever done for Egypt that Egypt should embrace democracy?

That isn't a bad question to ask.
 
Just heard an interesting remark on CNN coverage of the stuff going on in Cairo:

"What this looks like is a government sponsored lynch mob going after the protestors."

Not sure who the reporter is, or his vantage point, but it was an interesting line.

Also not sure how "live" his report was.

Could somebody please toss a Molotov Cocktail at Anderson Cooper? He's getting in the way of the story.
 
Wait....is America supposed to not be Imperialist or is it not supposed to support the protesters? I'm kinda confused on that point because it seems some are advocating both.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom