Wanted: debunking of financial advisors, managers, planners, stock brokers...

I'd just like to add that the "inflation rate" is not a fixed number. It varies from locality to locality and industry to industry. There are many, many different ways of deriving the rate of inflation. You would have to specify exactly which rate of inflation you were talking about.

Good point. Yrreg's hypothetical contract with a money manager would obviously need to define what measure of inflation was being used and what happens during deflation, but I figure that would be fairly easy to work out.

As an example, TIPS are tied to the commonly reported US Consumer Price Index. During periods of deflation, the principal is adjusted downward just like it's adjusted upward during inflation, but if at maturity, the principal would be less than at the start, you still get the original principal.
 
yrreg:

Firstly, I hate to point out that reading a review of a book is not quite the same as reading the book itself. I have read reviews after I have read a book and wondered if the reviewer was writing about the same book which I read.

Taleb's points are rather more complex than your comment would suggest.

Secondly, could you explain what you mean by "mastering the control of chance". By definition, and despite millenia of optimistic gamblers believing otherwise, chance is something you cannot control.
 
Last edited:
Just because it's gotten up my left nostril, I believe the place our friend has missed is an 'abattoir'.
 
Thanks, everyone, for your useful knowledge.

I will have to mull over all the information provided.

Thanks again.



About controlling chance, isn't it what we are all trying to do in life, get a hold over unpredictable vicissitudes; for example there is a chance that crossing the street in the midst of vehicular traffic can get you run over, but you calculate the risk by observing at what time and under what behavioral circumstances of the traffic, to conclude when and how the chance of getting run over by any vehicles would be the least probable, then you cross the street.


Another example, making love to a fertile woman can land you into a paternity suit and support demand from your partner, but you can control that chance by using some mechanical or pharmaceutical assist to pre-empt in a way that chance from ever occurring. That is control of chance, isn't it?

So, there is negative control by evasion or escape, and positive control by prevention, like physically disabling the possibility of the chance event from taking place.


Anyway, I am amenable to be shown that I am erroneous with my idea of what chance is and my idea of controlling chance.



Yrreg
 
Anyway, I am amenable to be shown that I am erroneous with my idea of what chance is and my idea of controlling chance.


You can't be all that amenable because people here have already very clearly explained to you that there are risk-free investments in existence today that earn exactly what you want to earn. Precisely what is left to discuss?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom