Wanted: debunking of financial advisors, managers, planners, stock brokers...

Thanks, every who goes for the beef and contributes to my education.

I would like to imagine an ideal assets and liabilities manager or credits and debits manager, or in short a money consigliere, who should do the following three acts for me:

1. Keep my money safe.

2. Get me things I want that money can buy, on the criterion of the best pick for the least money.

3. Make my money increase, i.e., return big, easy, quick additional money, and beyond questioning from the law.​

#1 and #2 are easy to achieve by any money adviser, it is #3 that is to my intelligence almost impossible to consistently realize.

This is the arena of winners in stocks like Warren Buffett.


I like to ask the veteran skeptics here, how people like Warren Buffett beat the stock market as to make fabulous fortunes down the years of their stocks activities.

Is there a science and methodology there like there is a science and technology in planting wheat or raising pigs?


If not, how then do they succeed?


There is something uncanny with these people, if they are absolutely honest and are not in the business of anomalously by stealth outsmarting the system or the people in charge of the system.

What is that uncanny factor responsible for their success? Is it what skeptics here like to call chance, spell that luck? so that people like Warren Buffett are just lucky for all the years to the present that they have made massive money from stocks?

What kind of luck? Like the kind skeptics prefer to assign to acupuncturists who effect cures whereas scientific doctors of medicine cannot help, or have given up on patients with ills they find absolutely baffling to their conventional medicine science and therapeutic skills?


Wanted: explanations by skeptics on critical thinking and empirical evidence for the successful careers of people like Warren Buffett who make exorbitant wealth from stocks.



[Disclaimer: I confess myself to be quite ignorant about the inner workings of the stock market; so it is very possible that I don’t know what I am talking about –- in which case I need some beneficent education from the financial cognoscenti and veteran skeptics here.]​



Thanks for any contribution to my education.


Yrreg
 
Stock trading, like planting wheat and raising pigs?

Thanks, Loss Leader, for you kind attention to an inquiring mind.


I asked in above message #21: "Is there a science and methodology there [re: stock trading] like there is a science and technology in planting wheat or raising pigs?"

I mean science and technology in stock trading like in wheat planting and pigs raising, so that there is effectivity and efficiency in stock trading for everyone to make money and get rich tremendously -- like if you do wheat planing and pigs raising, scientifically and technologically, you will produce huge quantity of wheat and pigs, so also in stock trading.

What do the scientists and technocrats among the veteran skeptics here say?

I am just an inquiring mind, I need answers from the experts here. Pleazzzzzz!


Okay, two questions:

1. Is there a science and methodology to stock trading?

2. Where do we go to read about this science and methodology?​

Do you realize that if we do possess a science and technology in stock trading, like we have in planting wheat and raising pigs, all of us will just employ our money in stock trading scientifically and technologically and make a lot of money and all get very very rich. and not only those few like Warren Buffett.


By the way, has Warren Buffett ever said that he does stock trading scientifically and technologically, like he does his gardening -- if he engages in that chore?


Yrreg
 
I asked in above message #21: "Is there a science and methodology there [re: stock trading] like there is a science and technology in planting wheat or raising pigs?"


The answer is that there are many methodologies for investing althout I'm not sure why you're asking here. Any trip to your local bookstore will uncover an entire section devoted to this subject. If you have access to a college library, you'll find hundreds of scholarly texts on investing. There are dozens of different philosophies. The most successful focus on identifying undervalued or overcapitalized businesses and avoiding the belief that one can get rich overnight.

There are a tremendous amount of resources at http://www.investopedia.com/articles/
They're dedicated to teaching investors about the markets with articles, tutorials, virtual portfolios and more. Spend some time there.

By the way, has Warren Buffett ever said that he does stock trading scientifically and technologically, like he does his gardening -- if he engages in that chore?


The links that I provided you gave lots of information about Buffetts own words on his investment strategies and successes. Refer to the links.
 
The basic criterion of non-science and non-technology.

The answer is that there are many methodologies for investing...

Skeptics seem to shun this topic, and I believe it is because they cannot or more correctly they opt to not apply critical thinking and empirical evidence to get to the facts if any of science and technology in stock trading.


There is none, proof of that is the multitudinous guesswork and super verbosity in self-proclaimed masters of stock trading, who at least know that they can make money selling their thoughts on how to beat the stock market.


Why don't skeptics just come out and proclaim that you can be as successful as throwing up coins to get heads or tails in the stock market, so either avoid it totally or just have fun gambling provided it is pure gambling and there is no monkey business from some smart operators behind all the facade of level playing field in the stock market.


Stock trading however is one sacred cow that skeptics don't go into because it is an alien territory to them, they would rather continue to beat the dead horses of the paranormal and the pseudoscientific, and then even in these domains they opt to limit to their convenience the materials they go into, overly dead horses already talked to death in so many skeptics websites.



Yrreg
 
Yrreg - You seem intent on projecting your ignorance of a subject on the rest of mankind. Are you this silly in every domain?

People have given you what you asked for with more patience than you deserve. Read and learn.
 
Why don't skeptics just come out and proclaim that you can be as successful as throwing up coins to get heads or tails in the stock market, so either avoid it totally or just have fun gambling provided it is pure gambling and there is no monkey business from some smart operators behind all the facade of level playing field in the stock market.

Because if you're truly skeptical, that's not how it is. "Pure gambling" implies the odds are equal (or worse) between losing and winning. You're mistaking two things, stock trading to try to outperform the indexes, and long-term investing. Stock trading is where the "throwing coins" analogy comes.

Long-term investing in a broadly diversified portfolio, like a market index fund, has, skeptically speaking, been proven to be more profitable than chance. In other words, over a ten-year period, the odds are that you'll take out more money than you put in. Over longer periods, the odds get even higher.

Actually, one could say that holding onto a dollar bill has generally proven to be a losing proposition. Periods of inflation are more frequent than periods of deflation.

So would you also say that not investing money is a pure gamble? What is safe?
 
Because if you're truly skeptical, that's not how it is. "Pure gambling" implies the odds are equal (or worse) between losing and winning. You're mistaking two things, stock trading to try to outperform the indexes, and long-term investing. Stock trading is where the "throwing coins" analogy comes.

Long-term investing in a broadly diversified portfolio, like a market index fund, has, skeptically speaking, been proven to be more profitable than chance. In other words, over a ten-year period, the odds are that you'll take out more money than you put in. Over longer periods, the odds get even higher.

Actually, one could say that holding onto a dollar bill has generally proven to be a losing proposition. Periods of inflation are more frequent than periods of deflation.

So would you also say that not investing money is a pure gamble? What is safe?

I would make a few clarifications here:

I would say gambling implies a zero expected return, not equal odds. E.g. a gamble is 20% chance of winning $100 and 80% chance of loosing $25.

Also, in addition to our long-term experience of an observed "equity risk premium", this has a logicial thoeretical grounding and is a testable hypothesis (of sorts).
 
I'm really not sure where to start, because you're painting a very large, complex industry with a very broad brush.

There are a lot of different people in the financial industry - some of them are highly technical professionals, some are voodoo men, some are sales people out to make a commission, some are geniuses, some are lucky, and some are morons.

Financial planners, or advisors, are generally responsible for helping an individual or family secure their finances. They advise generally about what investments are appropriate for the client's level of risk tolerance, age, goals, career, income level, etc. Remember that many investment products are somewhat to highly technical in nature, and not everyone understands what is appropriate for them. Financial advisors often charge fixed fees for their services, and generally (if they are at all reputable) do not sell investment products.

They may also offer advice about taxes, insurance, etc. The financial advisor serves to provide general advise about all areas of personal money management. In the US, at least, there is standard certification for financial advisors.

A financial/investment/asset manager, by way of contrast, would imply a more direct control over assets. Rather than simply advising a client, they will actually invest the client's money. Their goal is to provide the client with an acceptable return at a tolerable level of risk, which can vary greatly from client to client. Asset managers may be paid a fixed fee, or they may make a percentage of the amount they manage, depending on the arrangement. A good manager will use various methods of determining what the best investment products are based on past performance, the risk of the underlying investment, etc.

Neither an advisor nor a manager is promising guaranteed results, unless they're an idiot. They don't try to "beat the system" or anything, just to move their client's funds (or advise their clients to move their funds) into investments that are suitable for their needs. Largely, it's about statistical returns. A good manager looks to place the money where it will earn a decent return over time by examining underlying market trends (things like company performance, cash flow, real value, production, business risk, etc.). If the manager has a large amount of capital to work with, they may be able to exert some kind of control over the fund using various macro-level investing strategies.

Also, keep in mind that many fund managers don't do any better than the index funds. A good asset manager isn't going to try to get you rich quick, he or she is going to try to get you a decent level of return by choosing the appropriate investments and moving your money around to protect it from catastrophic down-turns when possible.

Stock brokers, insurance brokers, insurance agents, and their ilk are all sales people. Ultimately, they are trying to get you to buy something. They may advise you as well, but their advice may be colored by their desire to sell a product. A perfect example is the pushing of whole life ("cash value" life insurance) on clients by insurance agents. Generally, it's a horrible, horrible product... but it makes a nice commission for the agent because they get a percentage of first-year premium.

I would like to imagine an ideal assets and liabilities manager or credits and debits manager, or in short a money consigliere, who should do the following three acts for me:

1. Keep my money safe.

Yes, most advisors or managers try to keep your money as safe as possible, given your risk tolerance. There is, however, always some risk involved with investing. The very act of having money involves some risk, albeit very, very little.

2. Get me things I want that money can buy, on the criterion of the best pick for the least money.

You mean advise you on purchases? Probably not. A financial advisor might give you general advice on big ticket items like a home, but that's not really their job. A manager or sales person doesn't give a good god damn what you do with the money you aren't investing with them.


3. Make my money increase, i.e., return big, easy, quick additional money, and beyond questioning from the law

What you say here sounds kind of jumbled.

Generally, the job of an asset manager is to increase your capital, yes, but that doesn't always mean big, quick returns. A good manager is going to try to get you the best return for your risk tolerance level. If you can accept huge risk, you are probably going to get better returns as compensation for this, but you risk losing your money. Similarly, a manager for a financially conservative client is probably going to go for lower-return, lower-risk investments to protect their client's assets.

The idea of fast, easy money is a myth. Sometimes smart investors see trends of undervaluation that will allow them to make some excellent returns for the risk level involved, but that doesn't mean there's a sure-fire way to do it.

The people saying they can get you tons of money fast with no risk and little (or no) startup capital are crooks, not good advisors.

This is the arena of winners in stocks like Warren Buffett.

Buffett was a serious capital investor. He didn't just "win" at stocks, he used leverage on companies to make them more profitable, as well as using various macro strategies to manage funds. He worked with a huge amount of capital, which let him do things your average Joe Schmoe fund manager would have a hard time doing. Like, you know, buying majority shares of companies.

Buffett was a shrewd investor, and few people can do what he did.

I like to ask the veteran skeptics here, how people like Warren Buffett beat the stock market as to make fabulous fortunes down the years of their stocks activities.

He didn't beat it, that's all. A lot of Buffett's investing activity was active and based in active management and capital control. He didn't just pick stocks, he invested in the underlying businesses and improved them so they would make money. To try to reduce what he did to "beating the market" is a bit silly.

There is something uncanny with these people, if they are absolutely honest and are not in the business of anomalously by stealth outsmarting the system or the people in charge of the system.

What is that uncanny factor responsible for their success? Is it what skeptics here like to call chance, spell that luck? so that people like Warren Buffett are just lucky for all the years to the present that they have made massive money from stocks?

Again, Buffett wasn't just a stock investor. Wiki's article should help, and there are various books on him if you're interested.

There was nothing "uncanny" about his success. He was highly intelligent, he understood the economics behind his investments, and he made smart decisions. There was surely some luck involved, but also a lot of foreward thinking and smart planning.

[Disclaimer: I confess myself to be quite ignorant about the inner workings of the stock market; so it is very possible that I don’t know what I am talking about –- in which case I need some beneficent education from the financial cognoscenti and veteran skeptics here.]


Remember that the stock market is only one facet of a very large whole. There is more to investing than simply buying and selling stocks. Remember that those stocks represent the value placed on an underlying product or company by investors.
 
There is none, proof of that is the multitudinous guesswork and super verbosity in self-proclaimed masters of stock trading, who at least know that they can make money selling their thoughts on how to beat the stock market.

Why don't skeptics just come out and proclaim that you can be as successful as throwing up coins to get heads or tails in the stock market, so either avoid it totally or just have fun gambling provided it is pure gambling and there is no monkey business from some smart operators behind all the facade of level playing field in the stock market.


My word, Yrreg, you really just like telling people your conclusions, don't you?

You started asking questions about what methodologies there were to stock trading? You asked if the very successful traders were anything more than lucky.

In response, several people explained the various types of "financial advising" there are and how many different definitions there are of "success." I personally pointed you towards resources outlining Warren Buffet's strategies. Since Buffet actually has strategies and since they actually have worked for him, this would appear to be evidence that there are methodologies that make investing more than just a gamble.

I suspect that you did not read a single word of any of the websites I sent you to. I suspect that you have not gone to the library and checked out a single book on investing.

Just because you haven't educated yourself about the stock market does not mean that the information does not exist. It means that you are ignorant of it. You probably should reserve your opinion until you do some actual research.

As to whether skeptics are "soft" on investing, I have seen no such thing. In fact, I remember at least one thread where an individual claimed a market-beating strategy based on the cycles of the moon. He was roundly criticized. Who are those exposing "boiler rooms" and "pump and dump" scams if not skeptics?

Your opinions not being founded in evidence, they are dismissed.
 
As to whether skeptics are "soft" on investing, I have seen no such thing. In fact, I remember at least one thread where an individual claimed a market-beating strategy based on the cycles of the moon. He was roundly criticized.

Yes, we had a spot of fun with that one. :)
 
I've only just come upon this thread - by accident, as it happens. The date of the last posting suggests that it died a while ago, but nevertheless I think it worth a comment. Perhaps someone is still listening!

Have all of you read Nassim Nicholas Taleb: Fooled by Randomness. ISBN 978-0-141-03148-4. I think it answers the OP.
 
Here is a challenge to all kinds of money making experts.

...

Have all of you read Nassim Nicholas Taleb: Fooled by Randomness. ISBN 978-0-141-03148-4. I think it answers the OP.

I have read reviews about the book.

The author is telling us that everything is up to chance.

And I think he is telling us also and this is more important that we must master the control of chance.



As regards my thread, I have come to this idea about asking anyone expert in making money with other people's material assets, to make money for himself in tendering the service of making money for their clients.

Suppose they just earn for me every year an excess of the previous balance that is 1% over the year end inflation, and they can keep whatever percentage in gain they obtain from managing my material assets, on condition however if they don't succeed in achieving for me that 1% in excess of the year end inflation, then they must pay me from their own pocket so much as to make my year end balance show an excess in gain over the year end inflation.​

Here is my computation:

Present year end inflation
6%

My previous year end balance
$100,000

Present year end balance
$105,000

Money expert must pay me from his own pocket
$7,000


If however my year end balance is
$110,000
then the money expert will keep
$3,000
still leaving me with a balance of
$107,000
which is 1% in excess of the year end inflation.


Do we have any such money experts?



yrreg
 
Suppose they just earn for me every year an excess of the previous balance that is 1% over the year end inflation, and they can keep whatever percentage in gain they obtain from managing my material assets, on condition however if they don't succeed in achieving for me that 1% in excess of the year end inflation, then they must pay me from their own pocket so much as to make my year end balance show an excess in gain [of how much? 1 percentage point?] over the year end inflation.

Okay... But how much excess in gain?


Here is my computation:

Present year end inflation
6%

My previous year end balance
$100,000

Present year end balance
$105,000

Money expert must pay me from his own pocket
$7,000

Inflation plus 1% would be a balance of $107,000, which would mean the money expert would only need to pay you $2,000 to reach that amount. How are you calculating the $7,000?

Do we have any such money experts?

If your example is a mistake, and you mean a money expert who guarantees you a return of inflation plus 1% every year, even if he has to pay you out of his own pocket, um, well, hell yes.

I'd put your money in 20-year U.S. Treasury TIPS, calculated by definition to yield a fixed percentage over the inflation rate. I think the last batch went at 1.807%. No risk, no effort, and I'd pocket 0.807% of your money for twenty years. Sounds like a deal to me.
 
I know some advisors who consistently return much higher than market. They do this because they do the research, understand the research, and put effective plans into place.

Im sure alot of advisors flip a coin, invest in broad managed funds or just follow trends - but theyre the guys you dont want to hire.

With financial advice, the old adage "you get what you pay for" definitely applies.
 
You are correct.

Okay... But how much excess in gain?

....

Quote:

Here is my computation:

Present year end inflation
6%

My previous year end balance
$100,000

Present year end balance
$105,000

Money expert must pay me from his own pocket
$7,000​



Inflation plus 1% would be a balance of $107,000, which would mean the money expert would only need to pay you $2,000 to reach that amount. How are you calculating the $7,000?

.​
Your are correct, my mistake; thanks for pointing that out.


If your example is a mistake, and you mean a money expert who guarantees you a return of inflation plus 1% every year, even if he has to pay you out of his own pocket, um, well, hell yes.

I'd put your money in 20-year U.S. Treasury TIPS, calculated by definition to yield a fixed percentage over the inflation rate. I think the last batch went at 1.807%. No risk, no effort, and I'd pocket 0.807% of your money for twenty years. Sounds like a deal to me.

...calculated by definition to yield a fixed percentage over the inflation rate. I think the last batch went at 1.807%. No risk, no effort...​

If the yield is always more than 1% over inflation, then you deserve the yearly income of the excess over 1% for your knowledge and work.

If the yield is sometimes over sometimes under 1% relative to inflation, then you have to sometimes to pay me from your own pocket.

What is the history of yields in the last 20 years?

And can you just simply pay me every year 1% above the year end inflation? according to this formula:

pb + ir*pb + .01*pb

pb - previous balance
ir - inflation rate​

That amount of .01*pb is what you have to pay me every end of the year, while I still start the new year with a bigger balance than last year's, namely, pb + ir*pb.


I think such a deal will enable me to go into retirement on my accumulated material assets managed by you.


yrreg
 
If the yield is always more than 1% over inflation, then you deserve the yearly income of the excess over 1% for your knowledge and work.

If the yield is sometimes over sometimes under 1% relative to inflation, then you have to sometimes to pay me from your own pocket.

yyreg, the advisor you are looking for is called a "bank". They offer things called "accounts" into which you put your money; the bank offers you a rate of return, called "interest", on any money in these accounts, and this rate of return is usually bit higher than inflation. Unbeknownst to you, the bank actually invests your money elsewhere, with its own teams of managers. Your return, sometimes called "interest", is sometimes paid for by the success of these investments, and in bad times is paid for out of the bank's reserves.

A similar instrument is a Treasury Inflation Protected Security; these will guarantee that the money you put into them comes back ahead of inflation.

There ya go. Super-fancy, up-to-the-minute money management advice.

Of course, you're going to complain that the return rate of all of these "safe" investments is lower than the return rate of, e.g., an index fund, mutual fund, or penny-stock-market-timing-day-trader. No kidding. But that's what you asked for---zero risk.
 
If the yield is always more than 1% over inflation, then you deserve the yearly income of the excess over 1% for your knowledge and work.
Treasury Inflation Protected Security (TIPS) are a common security, introduced quite a few years ago. They require little knowledge and less work, if anyone knows anything at all about stocks and bonds.

The problem is that you asked for a rate of return so low that it can be achieved with virtually no risk and no work. Let's start talking about 4% or 5% above the rate of inflation--that's where financial planners would balk and start muttering about past results being no guarantee of future performance.

What is the history of yields in the last 20 years?

The yield is fixed, compared to inflation. You're told the yield and you can decide whether to purchase. If you purchase, you'll lock in the yield for the life of the bond--always the same percentage above the inflation rate. So right now, you could lock in a guaranteed rate of about 1.8 percentage points above inflation for 20 years. The history of past rates would be irrelevant.

The history of payment, though, is that Treasury securities have always paid what they've guaranteed to pay, so far as I know. It would take the collapse of the U.S. government, or close to it, for the government to withhold payment.

I think such a deal will enable me to go into retirement on my accumulated material assets managed by you.

I wish I was licensed to do it, because honestly, I'd feel like I'd found a sucker. Anyone can buy them though, either directly from the feds or through most any broker, and then you'd get the extra .8% yourself.

You have to pay taxes on the gain each year, so they're useless as a tax shelter unless they're in an IRA or something, but they have the advantage that you never need to pay state taxes on them.
 
I'd just like to add that the "inflation rate" is not a fixed number. It varies from locality to locality and industry to industry. There are many, many different ways of deriving the rate of inflation. You would have to specify exactly which rate of inflation you were talking about.

There is also such a thing as deflation. Prices on some goods (and sometimes all goods) can go down. The technology and agricultural industries have, in recent years, seen sometimes staggering deflation. Your example presupposes a positive inflation rate and breaks down during periods of negative inflation. You would have to be more specific in defining what you were talking about.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom